How did the Royal Navy from 1997 compare to its glorious and legendary predecesor from the napoleonic era? Would it still have been safe to say that britannia ruled the seas?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

How does England's navy today compare to the prestigious and renown navy they had during the Napoleonic era? Are they still the king at sea, how does the quality of their navy compare to other countries today?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

What was happening in Washington DC in summer of 1968?

My mom said she was there on a field trip between June and August of 1968 and said there were protesters between the washington monument and the lincoln memorial. She's always been curious about what was happening that summer.

2 Answers 2017-03-18

How did French Classical Drama [Racine, etc.] Become THE Standard of Literature for the Eighteenth-Century?

In the early eighteenth century, Italian and French literati were embroiled in a debate over the relative merits of their national dramatic products (I'm mostly interested in opera at this point). The French stance in this debate makes total sense: "Italian drama and poetry is really dumb, French drama is so much better!" But what doesn't make sense to me is the Italian response. I would expect a response like "nuh, uh! We aren't dumb... YOU'RE dumb!" But instead, the response appears to be "Yeah, you're right, but what if we model our opera libretti on Racine, would you like us then?"

That is, after people like Bouhours and Boileau trash Italianate literature, early eighteenth century opera reformers (Muratori, Zeno, Metastasio, etc.) were using French writers like Racine and Corneille as models, in part because to imitate these writers appeared to pretty much universally assure that your dramatic product would be shielded from criticism.

This seems to me to say something interesting about the status of French drama at this time. Not only could the French use their authors as an "objectively good" yard stick to beat up on Italians, but the Italian Academies in Rome and Bologna seem to roll over and accept that judgment. They adopt the rhetoric of "good taste" that their French writers advance, and use their principles to reformulate their own theatrical practices.

So my question is what are the circumstances that lead to the prestige of French Drama at this time? Beyond the actual aesthetic merits of Racine and others, how did these authors come to acquire the status of objectively good models that were impervious to criticism? Unlike, say, Petrarch (who Italian authors clung to in a "see? We don't all suck!" way), who had centuries of reputation built up around him by this point, the bodies of Moliere and Corneile were still warm when this debate raged, and Racine was still kicking. So their international reputation seems to have been established at a particularly rapid pace. How did this happen? What is their reception history outside of France?

I suspect that there might be political reasons behind tied up in this. Many of these Italian writers are also advocates of "Unification" plans around this time (such as Muratori), and my thoughts were that the glories of the Absolutist state under Louis XIV might have been an important source of inspiration for these guys in a political sense ("man, why can't Italy get its shit together like France? Look how powerful and glorious Versailles is!"), and therefore trying to recast their own drama via French models could have been part of a larger attempt to try to inject a degree of solidarity into their culture by making it "objectively" in good taste. I also wonder if Jansenist / Jesuit debates might be playing into this.

This doesn't seem like a focused question. But I guess at the end of the day, I'm just interested in why French literary culture was seen to be the objective standard by which other countries could measure their own products. Why was their drama accepted in this fashion, rather than resisted in favor of local traditions?

Some sources I've been reading:

  • Minor, Vernon Hyde. The Death of the Baroque and the Rhetoric of Good Taste. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

  • Strohm, Reinhard. "Apostolo Zeno's Teuzzone and its French Models." In Dramma per Musica: Italian Opera Seria of the Eighteenth Century, 121-33. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

What did Hitler's first 6 months in power look like?

When Hitler came to power there was a strong nationalistic sentiment after WWI and there was a massive economic depression in Germany. What were Hitler's first actions and what did he do that garnered him such heavy popular support? He also worked to stifle his dissenters, what form did that take in the early part of his power? I'm sure there was a period where he wasn't able to have people outright assassinated right away, right?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Was Ancient Rome better off as a republic or an empire?

By "better off", I mean in terms of quality of life for the average citizen, defensive/military capabilities, and frequency of internal unrest (ie. riots, protests, etc.).

2 Answers 2017-03-18

Just bought this old Indian document from some unknown years ago from an antique shop. Anyone know what this is?

http://imgur.com/a/FJv4i

I bought this painting while on a trip in Rajasthan, India. It looks like a miniature painting drawn over an old official document of some sort. Can anyone identify the language and what the document is?

Thanks

1 Answers 2017-03-18

How long did it take for Christopher Columbus to realize he had not found India?

Was it immediate, were there a few round trips?

Also European Colonialists in general

1 Answers 2017-03-18

What did the Japanese know about what hit them in August, 1945?

I've recently read Eagle Against the Sun by Ronald Spector. Good book, and I fully accept that it's not the most complete, but for a layman like myself it did quite well to explain the war. He mentions that, after the Hiroshima bombing but before the Nagasaki, there may have been a couple of Japanese officials who thought the Americans may only have had a single bomb to drop, and thus they already used their trump card (a justification to draw out a bloody fight on the main islands as I understand it).

I wasn't able to find a copy of the source for this, but I'm interested in the broader question. What did Japan know about the Atomic bomb after it had been dropped? Did they really think there may have only been one? Did they properly comprehend the devastation, or did some officials think that, though a major bomb, it was something they could fight through?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2017-03-18

During the Battle of Berlin, was there really a battle for the Reichstag leading up to the famous flag photo?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

In his book on the Russian Revolution, Trostky claims there was disagreement between historians about the existence of a Fuedal system in Russia. Is this true? If so why was it unclear? If not why does he say there is?

This book is, I imagine, pretty heavily biased to some side or the other, considering the author and when it was written.

Here's the relevant passage:

"The existence of feudal relations in Russia, denied by former historians, may be considered unconditionally established by later investigations. Furthermore, the fundamental elements of Russian feudalism were the same as in the West."

It seems like he's implying Russia had been treated unfairly by the West. But he isn't kind either. Also says that the lack of evidence "testifies to the incompleteness of Russian feudalism, its formlessness, its poverty of cultural monuments."

Is any of that true, or related to the first question?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Is there any way to know whether composers in history had perfect pitch?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Biographies of Cecil Rhodes

Looking for good biographies of Cecil Rhodes -- detailed, comprehensive, unbiased. Doesn't matter how old they are as long as the information is still valid. Any suggestions?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

Saturday Reading and Research | March 18, 2017

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

10 Answers 2017-03-18

Why did printing only revolutionize Europe but not China, the middle east, or other places in the world?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

During the Korean war, foreign intervention came largely from the contributions of the US, China and the Soviet Union. When the war was being prolonged at the 38th parallel, what was the Soviet's role in this prolonging?

In researching the reasons for the prolonging of the Korean war, most sources point toward the defensive tactics of the Chinese which matched the aggression from US/UN forces. But apart from providing indirect (air support, supply contributions) support, how did the Soviet Union contribute to the stalemate?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

When did St. Patrick's day become so popular?

So basically the question above

1 Answers 2017-03-18

What do Aztec and Mayan houses and commercial buildings look like? We always hear of their large cities, why do we only see pyramids?

Obviously they can't live or do business in the existing stone pyramid ruins we always see.

When I hear of Mayan and Aztec cities like Chichen Itza, Palenque and the largest city Tenochtitlan, I imagine cities like ancient Roman ones with lots of markets, stores, bath houses, temples, entertainment center, houses but it seems that we seem to only see stone pyramids or what's left.

What will a Mayan or an Aztec city look like with all of its buildings and residential houses present at the time of their height?

5 Answers 2017-03-18

During World War 2, were the military of any other European countries considered equal in Quality (not size) to the Soviet, British German and US military.

It seems like whenever another country is mentioned; in books I read or documentaries that I watch, like Italy, France or Romania, it is mostly unfavorably.

1 Answers 2017-03-18

During WW2, Japan had decisively conquered the resources rich Southeast Asia, securing ample resources to fuel their war against China and the US. Given this, why did the Japanese further commit to an invasion of India in July 1944?

What were they seeking to accomplish, given that their main priority in WW2 was the war against China, and the largest opposition to this goal was the US?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

What was early gunpowder warfare like (14th-16th centuries) and how did it change how battles were fought?

What was the immediate reaction to gunpowder warfare? At what point did people think, "oh this is a big deal and very effective, everybody should have gunpowder weapons..."? At what point did cannons become naval weapons? When did archers become "obsolete"? What kind of psychological impact did seeing things go boom and shooting things at speeds that the human eye could not accurately detect have on soldiers?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

Where are the Oldowan tools held?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-03-18

How did people know where to mine in the middle ages?

How did people know where to mine in the middle ages? Or even before then? How did they know what they would pulled out of those mines would be suitable for weapons?

1 Answers 2017-03-18

In the 1800s and early 1900s, how did banks identify patrons when they wanted to withdraw money?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-03-18

When depicting two sword combatants running at each other to engage, Cinema often shows them running with their sword out front, sheathed until the split second before contact. Is there any evidence that this practice was normal and if so what advantage did it provide?

2 Answers 2017-03-18

⯇ 3536 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start