I am a citizen of a Greek city state in the 5th/6th Century BC. How likely am I to be familiar with Homer?

I am active in civic life and statistically, I am probably illiterate. Have I heard Homer being recited? Do I know the story and the characters? Is it likely that I or my friends can recite passages from memory? How often am I exposed to the material?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Why didn't France devolve into a bunch of small states during the medieval ages like Germany did?

France and Germany were both former parts of the Carolingian Empire, but only the latter devolved into a bunch of small states while the former stayed intact. Why?

3 Answers 2017-02-27

Was there any significant changes in religious attitudes of Europeans due to the rise of sugar, quinine, or tea trade?

This question relates to a hypothesis my wife is researching, and together we are finding information and sources difficult to aquire. Specifically, she is interested in how attitudes may have changed, for better or worse, after the rise of trade regarding these commodities.

2 Answers 2017-02-27

Does anyone recognize this artists initials/signature? Found at Goodwill for a buck. Rome Oct 10, 1923

http://imgur.com/rOkq47h http://imgur.com/UDVRCSH

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How and why was Western musical notation standardized in the 17th century?

2 Answers 2017-02-27

Are there any major debates about Ken Burns' documentary The Civil War?

Saw that it was re-released on Netflix. Were there any disagreements about the facts presented at the original release? Have there been advances in knowledge or changes in views in the past 27 years such that portions of it are no longer held to be accurate?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Are there any Chinese or Middle Eastern sources on the Mongols?

Both of these areas had developed writing, but I never saw a contemporary source from these regions on the Mongol invasion. Are there any to look at?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

When did "Jesus Christ" start being used as a way to indicate frustration?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How did the Videla-regime in Argentina affect society in ways of happiness among the people?

Let me clarify this: I know the people weren't happy at all with Isabel Perón's way of ruling (economic crisis, Triple A) and that the newspapers were writing about an upcoming coup d'etat. So when this did finally happen, was it a relief for the nation? I'm writing a thesis on the Argentine junta 1976-1983, and specifically the influence the junta had on social happiness, but I can't find data about the social happiness in this period. Can someone tell me more about this? Who can help me with sources that provide the information that I'm looking for? (Graphs, numbers, stories of people who lived during that time (less preferred), or maybe someone just knows in what way the coup affected society)

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Is there any historic reasoning for why so many holy books condemn homosexuality?

3 Answers 2017-02-27

use of term "Italy" and the italian identity since the fall of Roman Empire up until the unification

My questions is was the term Italy and Italian people used in the medival kingdoms of Europe and among the city states and duchys of the italian peninsula or were there clear separations between Venice,Genoa,Ferrara,Napels, Papal State etc. Did they have a sense of common identity?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How long was full plate armor as seen in fantasy books used on the European battlefields?

Just focusing on Europe here. Ill probably ask about other regions in future questions. I am trying to avoid a question that is too vague.

I need to be careful to focus my question and provide context for he experts on here. I know the romans used plates for their body armor, but it was a long way from being full body. I am referring to the full body plate armor that we see in stereotypical movies/fantasy books. I also know alot of the armor is wrong and anachronistic. Such as great helms used by knoghts in full body armor. My understanding is that the great helm was absolete by several hundred years by the time full body plate armor was used.

My knowledge comes from some youtube channels. They are fun to watch, but I dont know how accurate they are. To name a few metatron, lindybeige, knighterrant, scholargladiaria. There are others.

Those channels mention full body plate armor started after 1420. My understanding is that fire arms started being used heavily on battlefields by the end of the 15th century. That would tell me that the full body plate armor was nit used on the battlefield that long. I think I read that soldiers often used chest plates during the 30 years was in the 1600 hundreds, but that is a long way from full body plate armor.

I am trying to narrow and clarify my question. I understand the people on here are experts and I am trying to avoid asking something that is vague unfocused.

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Say I'm an officer in the military of the German Democratic Republic and the 1990 reunification just happened. Am I out of a job? Is my pension gone? What happens to me?

2 Answers 2017-02-27

What is the 'corn' Caesar refers to in his Commentaries on the Gallic War?

My understanding is that corn, or maize, existed solely on the American continents up until the 15th century and the arrival of European explorers. But Caesar refers constantly to securing a supply of "corn" for his troops. Does the word have another meaning in this context, perhaps just a generic term for food? What food is he referring to? What would his army have been eating as they moved around Gaul throughout the seasons?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Embalming became a major industry during the American Civil War, as families wanted to bury fallen soldiers at home. How did the embalmer get paid? How did they know which of the rapidly decaying corpses would be connected to a family who could pay? Did soldiers buy some form of burial insurance?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

In the show Taboo, the British East India Company denied trading slaves. Did they actually deny this, and if yes, why?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How did people light candles before lighters and matches?

I assume it was too impractical to keep a fire perpetually burning in your home to transfer flame. How was a simple candle lit hundreds of years ago?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

I’ll try ask this question again. How were warships in the early 18th century French navy named and classified?

I posted the same question a few days ago but I didn’t get any responses.

But, I decided to do a little background research this time, but the only sources I could find were on Wikipedia, so I can’t trust it with 100% historical accuracy (here and here) so I’d like to see if anybody here can share more of what they know about what I found.

More specifically, from these two sources I’m keeping my focus on ship ranks in the first decade of 1700’s (more specifically 1707 - 1713). So, with what I found out from the links and listed below, corresponds to the ships that were launched between the 1690’s and the early years of the 1700’s (00’s).

  • Vaisseaux de Premier Rang (First rank ships) - 3-decked vessels with around 80 to 100 guns

  • Vaisseaux de Deuxième Rang (Second rank ships) - most were two-decked vessels with around 64 - 74 guns

  • Vaisseaux de Troisième Rang (Third rank ships) - two-decked vessels with 64 or less

  • Vaisseaux de Quatrième Rang (Fourth rank ships) - two-decked frégates (frigates) with around 40 - 44 guns

  • vaisseaux de Cinquième Rang (Fifth rank ships) - two-decked frégates (frigates) with around 36 - 40 guns

  • Frégates légères (light frigates, unranked vessels) - single-decked vessels with 20 - 24 guns

I think I have general understanding of how the French would’ve ranked their ships in the first decade of the 1700’s, but the big question I have is; did what I find is accurate?

Follow-up questions: were all unranked vessels with even the smallest number of guns classed as frégates légères? (I would find it odd classifying a 12-gun vessel as a frigate)

Would it be historically accurate for a sailor in, say, 1710 to see one of these ships on the high seas and say something like “Look, it’s a Vaisseaux de Troisième Rang!”

1 Answers 2017-02-27

At the Battle of Quebec, why did Benedict Arnold & Montgomery attack the walled city in a snowstorm with undersupplied troops wearing torn rags instead of taking the time to gather their strength and wait for reinforcements?

According to W.J. Wood, Benedict Arnold & Montgomery attacked the walls of Québec City in late December 1775, in a snowstorm, with undersupplied troops wearing torn rags. Why did they attack at that time and in those circumstances instead of taking the time to gather their strength and wait for reinforcements?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

Any Information On My Great Grandfather's Rank/Unit?

Hey, I hope this is the right sub but I was recently given this old photo of my great grandfather from East Prussia and was wondering if the fine folks here could give me more info on his position in the military such as rank, unit, specialty, etc.

http://imgur.com/a/PfYUt

Would love to get more details! Thanks

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How and why did the pistol duel become common?

Hard to word this right so I'm going to rattle off a bunch of sub-questions to give an idea of what I mean. I'm not interested in the common reasons for a duel (protecting honour etc), more in how the format became popular when it seems like a death sentence for both parties. I'm guessing a lot of this will come down to misconceptions about the format.

How often did both parties get shot? How was cheating policed? (in my head, it seems tough to stop participants turning earlier than allowed, like a false start in racing, and if a fatal shot is fired, there's no second go). Did duelists see it as a skillful pursuit, and is there evidence to suggest that top duelists existed, rather than owners of hair-trigger guns that got lucky a few times?

Finally, the inspiration for the thought, was Alexander Hamilton a total fool to think that firing in the sky could be spotted and reacted to before Burr fired? I read on Wikipedia that duelists sometimes fired at the ground to show courage, was that a common end result and could it possibly happen without a gentlemen's agreement beforehand?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

In school we read an article that said "The Turkish dynasties became identified with Sunni Islam and with the Hanefi school of Jurisprudence, the one least restrictive of the ruler's discretion and the most accommodating to custom." What does this mean, what in Hanefi doctrine makes this so?

The exact quote is: "In the long run, most Turkish dynasties did become identified with Sunni Islam and with the Hanefi school of Jurisprudence, the one least restrictive of the ruler's discretion and the most accommodating to custom." It's taken from Carter V. Findley's Turks in World History. To clarify on the question, what exactly in the Hanefi school makes it more accommodating to customs and and least restrictive of the leaders discretion than, say, the Shafi school or even Shia Islam altogether?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

When did everyday Romans realize their civilization was collapsing?

Asking specifically about Romans in the Western part of the empire, not the Constantinople/Byzantine/Eastern part. When did people realize that their way of life was going away?

1 Answers 2017-02-27

How and when and why did monogamous marriage become a thing?

I have been cursed to do a lot of work in the bridal industry, which has me wondering what we know about when, how and why monogamous marriage became the standard (in societies where it is the standard)

1 Answers 2017-02-27

D-day invasion

Why weren't French involved in the first wave at Normandy beach, on D-day?

2 Answers 2017-02-27

⯇ 3577 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start