Do we have records of harem life from members of the Imperial Ottoman harem, and what do they tell us about interpersonal relationships between the women?

More specifically, I'm wondering about the depiction of fierce rivalry and consuming focus on winning the sultan's attention in the Turkish drama Magnificent Century. Are there primary sources that give a real insight into how these women felt about their position and their fellow concubines?

(Due to Empresses in the Palace, I also have an interest in similar information regarding Qing dynasty China.)

3 Answers 2017-01-13

in The Pillars of the Earth (historical novel/TV series set in England in the 1110s/1130s) one of the main characters is stone mason who travels around the countryside with his family, looking for people to employ him. Is that all close to how craftsmen actually lived in the middle ages?

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Pirates in the West Indies in the late 17th and early 18th centuries offered disability benefits to members of their crew. What did these benefits look like? Were they offered maintenance positions on ships such as cooks and maids?

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Was Vlad the Impaler addicted to anything?

Dan Carlin once said that drugs and alcohol are a very overlooked part of history so I was thinking if Vlad the Impaler, one of the most brutal men in history, was possibly addicted to anything.

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Are Cambodian refugees the reason doughnut boxes are pink?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-13

How much influence had Fake News to cause the Spanish–American War of 1898?

Was public pressure (caused by Yellow Journalism) a major factor into the war being declared?

1 Answers 2017-01-13

We just consider you all in one category: hostorians. But what are your specific areas of study? What do you do with your findings? Do you make a lot of money? And is it hard to get a job?

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Did Nestorians, and not Francis Xavier, introduce Christianity to Japan?

This article by the Japan Times claims that the Christianity predates Buddhism in Japan.

Specifically, it was spread by Turkestani refugees looking for religious freedom and Persian Nestorians, both traveling across the Silk Road and leaving their mark on China. There are also supposedly a lot of Christian symbols and rituals mixed into the Buddhist temples and rites, proving that Christianity used to be a major force in Japan.

How accepted is this theory amongst Japanese historians?

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Medieval Warfare, Combat and such.

I was curious, in the Middle Ages in terms of warfare,armies and more. I have a lot of questions, so hope a few people can help!

First off, starting a war. Would Army A send a message saying "We're fighting"to Army B, or simply charge into their lands in a blitz attack to catch their enemy off guard? What were some reasons for war, aside from gold, succession or land(or were those the only ones)?

What percentage of the population would be culled for the armies? Were older veterans ever called in for their experience? Or did they only ever expect and choose young men to fight? Were numbers the main thing that the lords wanted(even if the men were old or young, as numbers were the most important thing for victory)or was training and armour just as important?

Were the population given helmets or even light armour?(Full plate being heavy, things like chainmail or something being lighter)? How about weapons, like footmen provided with spears and swords? Or were they expected to grab up or make their own? What kind of training were they provided with? Were they taught battle maneuvers if they were just commoners, like a shield wall or anything? Or was Army B just telling them "Heres a stick. Stab that fully armoured knight!" Were the commoners expected to come in and train for a few days with someone from their lords castle, or were they trained in the years before, were they just tossed into combat unprepared except for knowing hack and slash?

How many common people would be involved depending on the lands? How many knights? Did the common people or knights ever say "I don't like this cause for your war with the other kingdom Lord A" or "King B, this is a bad reason to fight!" Or "You're evil!" or "I don't want to go!" Would this be treason?

Did the invading army of A ever engage in looting, plundering, murder or rape of commoners from B or vice versa? Was there a reason for it, or was it just cruelty because they had the lord or kings backing and "to the victors go the spoils"? Did the ruling person just turn a blind eye to it because these were their fighters? Or did they punish those who abused their power?

Were battles just about crashing against each other until one side was all(or mostly)dead? Or was it a big tangle of fighting people? Did archers ever shoot into the mass of people(example: "We have reserves"from "Braveheart".) Or did cavalry fight first, then footmen and archers joined in, etc;? How did a leader make commands to all his different men across his army?

Would soldiers ever attempt to capture commanders, knights or people in a position of power from the other side of the battle? Or was it easier to kill them to make Army B lose heart and run away? If common people/footmen surrendered, would the other side take them prisoner? Or execute them because they couldn't handle feeding them?

If one of Army A's lords died and his troops ran away from the battle, would they be considered outlaws or traitors and executed? Or would they join up with another of Army A's lords and fight on his side?

Were mercenaries ever used to fight in armies? Or were they considered untrustworthy or ill trained?

Bonus question!: Were knights only ever made by a king? Who were people who could knight them? Would people ever be knighted even if they hadn't completed being a squire or been a knight in the first place(like for saving their lord, etc;)Was it only lords or a king who could raise them to power?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Historians like Hans Van Wees and Peter Krentz advocate a radically different concept of the hoplite and Classical Greek phalanx. What's the history behind this split from the more established views of historians like Victor Davis Hanson? What evidence supports the newer model?

A good example of what I'm talking about would be the Chigi Vase. A student of Hanson claimed the soldiers carrying the spears over their heads showed that hoplites fought with their spear overhand instead of an under grip and that this was the earliest representation of a hoplite phalanx (Source: Hoplites: The Classical Greek Battle Experience).

Conversely, advocates of the Van Wees/Krentz model caution that the Chigi Vase shouldn't be taken so literally and the overhead spears are actually javelins, with no evidence for a phalanx (even though the warriors have an aspis??). No source for this one, it was a discussion on Roman Army Talk, iirc.

Chigi Vase:

http://sites.psu.edu/thehopliteexperience/wp-content/uploads/sites/10736/2014/03/Hoplite-battle-Chigi-Vase.jpg

1 Answers 2017-01-13

Were any President/VP teams in history as close as Obama/Biden?

After watching President Obama present VP Biden with the medal today, I got to wondering if any other VPs enjoyed both influence and warm personal relations with their president?

I can think of some who had influence but not much personal warmth (Cheney/Bush), and others who were close personally but didn't have great influence (Bush/Reagan), but did anyone have the two as Biden does?

Bonus question: who were the most influential VPs?

Thanks to anyone who answers!

1 Answers 2017-01-12

We all know that Hitler was a real areshole, but did he have any good leadership qualities or noble pursuits, traits, and the like?

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Why did Kings fight in battles, and when did this practice end?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Roman countercultures?

Were there any Roman countercultures? I know about the circus factions, but outside of that, was there anything as far out as the 60's American countercultures?

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Why do all the former British territories have such varying accents ?

For example America and Canada have very different accents to those of England where as Australia sounds very similar

1 Answers 2017-01-12

In The Art of War, Sun Tzu states, "There are not more than five musical notes, yet the combination of these five give rise to more melodies than can ever be heard." How does this fit in with the modern octet? Was music theory in Ancient China very different?

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Were there any countries that weren't involved in WW2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Before 1800, would the average person have any irrational fears of things?

For instance, i have arachnophobia (fear of spiders). Would they have this? Or would they be used to traveling through spider webs, having spiders in their homes, perhaps even eating spiders? What about water? Some people fear water they can not see the bottom of, or just drowning. But would these people be used to much more dangerous things and not care about a little water?

My question boils down to this: Have people become cowards?

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Did any British Soldiers ("redcoats") defect during the American Revolutionary War, or stay to join the new nation after Britain's defeat?

1 Answers 2017-01-12

How prevalent was homosexuality in Ancient Greek militaries?

I know of the Sacred Band of Thebes and I'm curious how it was in other armies, if it was institutionalized at all.

2 Answers 2017-01-12

How much power or authority did the federal German states have over their own affairs after unification?

I had always assumed that it became state controlled, but the book I am reading refers to Prussia as a political entity up to 1891 at least. Sorry if this has an obvious answer or has been asked before.

1 Answers 2017-01-12

Did Henry Ford say this quote, and what did he mean by it?

After a few google searches, I haven't been able to locate anything that points to him actually saying this. Most of the links that appear seem to be conspiracy-esque sites.

The quote in question:

"It is well enough that people of the nation do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning."

1 Answers 2017-01-12

What are some good supplemental reading materials to go along with the "History of Rome" podcast?

I've just started listening to The History of Rome, a podcast by Mike Duncan. The podcast is incredibly informative, but I learn better through reading than listening, and Roman names especially can be easy to forget. So, I am looking for some good books on Rome that closely mirror the content of the podcast. Any suggestions are welcome!

1 Answers 2017-01-12

How was the draft, conscientious objectors and draft dodgers viewed during World War 2?

We know a lot about the draft and the public's reaction to it and how the troops felt about it during Vietnam, but the draft in WWII seems to get swept under the rug. There doesn't really seem to be much in the way of information on how the public felt about it or what effects it had on troops who were drafted.

1 Answers 2017-01-12

I found a speech by Gamal Abdel Nasser in which he mentions the head of the Muslim brotherhood asking him to require all women in Egypt to wear the Hijab, provoking laughter in the audience. What was the general attitude in the middle east to the hijab at the time, and how has it changed since?

This is the video in question. Among other things, such as someone in the audience yelling "Let him wear it!" in reference to the head of the Muslim Brotherhood, the general attitude of both Nasser and his audience seemed to be that making the Hijab mandatory was a dumb idea. Nowadays, Hijabs are worn commonly by Muslim women all over the world. What caused this shift in attitude?

4 Answers 2017-01-12

⯇ 3682 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start