Is the "Golden Age of Islam" an achievement of Islam or the "tolerated" Persian culture?

Several famous scientists and philosopher (Avicenna, Al Razi, Al Biruni etc.) are said to be muslims. However, some historians and scholars claim that these scientific accomplishments were solely possible due to the tolerant Abassid caliphs, who have not aligned their regime to Sharia yet.

  • Has "Islam", as we know it today, just not accelerated enough back then but eventually ended in a "decline" since 1200 AD?

  • Are the scientific achievements accountable to Islam or the occupied culture?

  • Has religion in general been an obstacle for science or are there any examples in history, which show that religion might foster science?

2 Answers 2016-10-07

How literate were Judaeans in Roman Times?

In the Talmud, education in Hebrew is very strongly encouraged, as is the public reading of sacred texts. Were Jews in Judaea substantially more literate than other Roman communities?

1 Answers 2016-10-07

A history teacher I worked with once suggested that medeival antisemitism was the blueprint for colonial racism. How well supported is this position?

1 Answers 2016-10-07

How many people would be in a castle at any given time?

So I was watching a YouTube video, I believe it was one by Lindybeige? Might have been someone different - but either way the claim was given that a castle where court was not being held would generally only have 5-10 people garrisoning it at any given time, while even when court was being held the total population wouldn't exceed about 50.

Is there any truth to these claims, or would castles have much larger garrisons/populations at any given time than this?

1 Answers 2016-10-07

Did Europeans ever try to establish colonies in Japan?

Specifically, I'm referring to the Age of Exploration in which European countries started to become establish colonies and become worldwide empires around the 15th-18th centuries. Did any European power ever try to take over Japan? If not, why didn't anyone try?

4 Answers 2016-10-07

How is it that the Hapsburg House ruled over countries ranging from England, France, Germany, Holy Roman Empire, Hungary, etc... without any of these ever becoming unified empires? And how did a single house expand to cover such different regions of Europe?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-10-07

Could I get more information about these soldiers in this photo? Battle of the Bulge

This is the photo

Mainly I'm curious about their rank and role in their respective armies. I'm noticing the German soldier doesn't have a helmet. Does that mean he's part of a tank crew? I'm doing a project and just trying to find more information about these people. Any info would be wonderful! Thank you :)

1 Answers 2016-10-07

Did the citizens of the Byzantine Empire refer to themselves as Romans?

Ik they're named for Byzantium on which Constantinople was built, but what did they call themselves?

1 Answers 2016-10-07

On average, how religious were the American founders, compared to average Americans?

I don't know how "founding fathers" usually gets defined... members of the Continental Congress? Signers of the Declaration of Independence? I also realize that religiosity is a complicated beast, too--behavioral religiosity? Acceptance of values? Personal belief?--but I'm hoping someone somewhere has taken the plunge, operationally defined these things, and tried to inform this question.

I guess my overall question is: was the USA founded by people who were more religious than, less religious than, or about as religious as other Americans at the time?

1 Answers 2016-10-07

There is a scene within the movie Gangs Of The York where newly arrived Irishman straight off the boat are directly recruited (much to dismay of 1 family) into the Union Army to fight in the Civil War. Is this scene acurate or simply a minor drama plot in a film?

Gangs Of New York

3 Answers 2016-10-07

What are your thoughts on Ibn Khaldun's 'Muqaddimah' (1377), sometimes also called his 'Prolegomena to the Book of Lessons'?

A recent recommendation from another thread has seen me reading Kim Stanley Robinson's Years of Rice and Salt (2002) of late, and Ibn Khaldun's historiographical ideas -- especially about the purported cycle of dynasties and the limits of civilizations -- play an important role in this often fanciful but still amazingly moving alt-history novel. I am probably going to have much more to ask about things related to this book (Robinson's, that is) in the days to come, as it has thoroughly unsettled my otherwise serenely modern, Western mind, but the matter of Ibn Khaldun seems the most pressing.

Where does he stand in modern historiography -- especially where the East is concerned? How were his ideas received during his own life and that of his works? Is there a widely-accepted translation of the Muqaddimah that you'd recommend? I've been working off the Princeton one so far, and it's been absolutely spellbinding (if very obviously -- and occasionally satisfyingly -- medieval).

2 Answers 2016-10-07

What are the Castles/Static Defenses of the Classical Age?

I enjoy reading about European and Middle-eastern castles and siegecraft but most of my research I have yet to stumble across a good definitive look at the defenses of ancient cities?

How were the walls of Greek and Roman cities laid out? Were there actually fortified castles as such, or other major fortifications? What about in Phoenician or Persian areas?

Thank you in advance

1 Answers 2016-10-07

During the Vietnam war, did any Vietmanese-Americans receive any discrimination?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

Are the Mongols the only empire to invade russia

i'm writing a paper on the Mongolian Empire and i was wondering if they were the only ones to successfully invade russia?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

How did the Communists in China manage to defeat Chang Kai Shek?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

(WWII) Did the UK become self-sufficient following the Battle of Britain?

After having crippled the Luftwaffe over Southern England, could Britain still have been starved into submission by the German Navy/Airforce, or did they become self sufficient by this time? (In terms of food, mostly.)

1 Answers 2016-10-06

In medieval and early-modern Europe, when a ruler died without an heir, it was common for a foreign ruler to inherit the lands or to be in a personal union with those lands. When is something inherited, rather than being in personal union?

For example, after the death of Karloman, Karl inherited Middle Francia and it directly joined his empire, but Brandenburg was in personal union with Prussia after the Prussian duke died. What is the difference that causes a realm to be integrated upon foreign leadership versus a realm keeping its own laws?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

Why was so much of America's industrial capacity centered around the Great Lakes?

Nowadays, it seems like people want to locate in more temperate, coastal regions like California, Texas, and Florida.

1 Answers 2016-10-06

What do we know about the Polynesian ancestors that sailed all the way into the middle of the Pacific 3000 years ago?

I'm fascinated that they were able to achieve such maritime achievements thousands of years before the discovery of the New World.

1 Answers 2016-10-06

Why didn't Japan attack the Sovie Union during World War 2 to prevent the SU from regrouping their forces from the east front to the German front?

Why didn't Hitler ask them to do this, to help them?

Were those islands really that important?

Would the US have joined to WW2 if Japan hadn't attacked?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

Why were the Ottoman Turks fixated with Anatolia as a place for conquering and later as the center of the empire?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-10-06

What was life like in the Soviet Union for a musicians and artists?

And please point me to some good sources on this.

Edit: It looks like this got flagged for Visual Art. I meant artists of all mediums (music, dance, visual, etc.) But if that is too broad, please give me the answer for musicians. I messed up the post title too. Sorry. I originally wrote it for "a musician," and added artists, and forgot to delete the a...

Edit 2: This question is extraordinarily broad. But if it helps, I'm primarily interested in the economic situation and daily life of musicians/artists, and any hierarchy that may exist from hobbyists to famous musicians/artists (which ones were paid for their work full time, if any?).

1 Answers 2016-10-06

Wars that ended in Genocide.

I am writing a paper examining the relationship between war and genocide. I am going to be focusing on first the definition both UN and other scholars definitions of it (i.e. Lemkin, Chalk and Jonassohn, and even the UN's definition) however I first need to know about any wars that could have ended in potential genocides. I am going to start in Ancient warfare and a few notable examples I have thus far are the Athens destruction of Melos, the Spartans to the Trojans, The battle of Carthage.

However I am reminded that genocide wasn't common practice in Ancient times because slavery and colonization were more practice but it was used as more of a display of power, I am hoping this does not speak for a majority of battles/wars.

Essentially what I need is a database or other post pointing me in the right direction of (important/worth mentioning) wars that ended in Genocide. Any form of genocide as well, (i.e Physical, Cultural, Biological,) but the important thing is that a war or battle was fought.

2 Answers 2016-10-06

We're Carthaginians black or white?

1 Answers 2016-10-06

How do we know 6 million jews were killed during the holocaust?

I AM NOT QUESTIONING WHETHER THE HOLOCAUST HAPPENED OR NOT!!! It happened, one of the worst moments in human history.

I just want to know how we got this figure! What was the methodology?

2 Answers 2016-10-06

⯇ 3910 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start