What were the social & cultural conditions that lead to the First & Second Great Awakening?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Was Germany the only country with a serious plan for exterminating their Jewish population in the 1930's? Or were other countries also planning to solve the 'Jewish problem' in similar ways?

2 Answers 2016-08-28

What was the Roman Empire's reaction to the destruction of Pompeii?

Was it a particularity famous, well-known event? Did the average roman know and/or care about it? Was aid sent?

3 Answers 2016-08-28

How did American Christianity become so 'hostile'?

Hope I can make my question clear also cause I'm not a native speaker but here goes:

When watching television and reading the news it seems to me that some of the main points in American Christianity are anti abortion, anti gay and anti sex education/sex before marriage.

I never hear anything about the 'nicer' parts like turning the other cheek, loving theigh neighbour and treating others like you would like to be treated.

Overall I get a very 'hostile' feeling from Christians in American media, and to be honest I actually thought that that was what Christianity was all about before doing some more research (being raised non religiously I didn't know much about it).

I also researched some 'hardcore Christian' groups like Jehova's Witnesses, but even they seem to focus more on being kind, are for proper sex education and tolerate gays (even though they do say it's wrong).

So my question is when and how was American Christianity shaped into what it is today. When did they let go of the 'be kind' parts and started having a more oppressing type of attitude? Did this even start in America or is it imported?

6 Answers 2016-08-28

Was Europe afraid of African invasion in 1960's?

I was reading Heban by Ryszard Kapuściński (reportages about African countries), and something got my attention. Author wrote that in 1960's (maybe even 1970's), in European countries like France, UK, there was fear about newly indendent African states, would be eager to take revange against former occupants, with a help from Soviet Union. He wrote about even fears of invading Europe. Did this debate were a serious concern in media, or some paranoic clickbait thing?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Did early Muslims know about the Egyptian pyramids?

If not, what did they think about them after the conquest of Egypt?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | August 22, 2016–August 28, 2016

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

4 Answers 2016-08-28

How hard would it be to map the history of the world?

As per the title. Basically everything we know, not just the history of civilizations and the consequences of human actions. Starting from when we were cavemen, the tools we used... The first civilization to appear, the first flamethrower that was used, when paper was invented. How much do we know about everything that has ever happened, and how hard would it be to index (write it down) this?

2 Answers 2016-08-28

After the Beer Hall Putsch, why wasn't Hitler executed for attempting to overthrow the government?

Furthermore, why was he allowed to write and publish a book, was released less after less than a year, and later become chancellor? Wouldn't his actions sort of disqualify him from doing any of these things?

3 Answers 2016-08-28

Why didn't British textile manufacturers' use US slave labor to produce their goods?

In the late 18th and early 19th century British textile mills bought their cotton from the US South, which used slave labor. It seems it would have been cheaper to use slave labor then ship the goods to Europe rather than buy cotton and produce the goods in England.

Why didn't British textile owners set up factories in the US South and utilize slave labor to produce their goods? Would it be because of tariffs? Lack of energy sources in the US South? Were slaves somehow not cheaper than workers in England?

Thanks

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Was the bombing of cities in WWII a war crime for the day?

I've heard that legally speaking, the strategic bombing of cities in WWII wasn't a war crime. Is this true?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Is there any archive or source of historical consumer opinion polls?

Perhaps an odd question, I know. I'm interested in what motivated people to buy various appliances and gadgets, in the context of the 70s or 80s.

1 Answers 2016-08-28

How long did an ancient/ medieval field battle go on until a winner emerged and the losing side began to flee?

Are we talking about minutes, hours, days (in some cases)? I once read that battles during the crusades sometimes went on for hours and some even days - is that accurate?

I always wondered whether battles really played out like in the movies in which the front row of the armies just suicidal/ fanatical ran into the other side hacking everything in sight or if it looked more like police/ violent demonstrators who kind of just pop up on the first line beat or throw something and then retreat back into the line?

Obviously the latter tactics would take much longer than the former.

1 Answers 2016-08-28

In the early Middle Ages the belief in Witchcraft was condemned as "unChristian" by high-ranking churchmen, as well as by Charlemagne. At the same time, both secular and canon law decreed that Witchcraft existed, had power, and deserved punishment. How were these contrary positions resolved?

I knew that Charlemagne had famously ordered the execution of any person that killed another on charges of witchcraft, and I believe that even a Pope condemned the belief. I assumed that the church changed its opinion in the new millennium, possibly due to Reformist tendencies, but was confused by the number of clashing decrees, penitentials, and synods that occurred around the same time which had strongly contrary arguments.

Condemnations of the belief in Witchcraft as unChristian, pagan, and heretical:

  • Council of Paderborn (785)

  • Saint Boniface (d. 754)

  • Saint Agobard (d. 840

  • Canon Episcopi (before the 11th century)

Condemnations of Witchcraft, which implicitly suggest its existence and power:

  • Synod of Tours (813)

  • Synod of Paris (829)

  • Regino, Abbot of Prum (d. 915)

How were these different writers, bishops, and kings able to reconcile these points? Was the belief in witchcraft another internal conflict for the early church as what Orthodoxy really meant?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

I'd like to know about the economy in Victorian England

What did the socio-economic hierarchy look like? How many groups were there and how much did they make? Was the barrier between the groups permeable, or was ones life station fixed?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

What did ancient Greek battlefield trophies consist of and how long, if at all,were they maintained?

A lot of descriptions of Greek battles end with one side or another erecting a trophy but I've never read anything on what exactly these looked like or whether there was any upkeep of them. Would they have been maintained as a reminder of the victorious side's power or was it just a very temporary arrangement? Note I'm talking about battlefield trophies, not victory monuments set up later,e.g. at Delphi.

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Why is it that the Spanish and the Portuguese were more successful in spreading the Christian faith than the English and the Dutch? Was it because the English and the Dutch did not proselytize, or the Spanish and the Portuguese were simply more successful?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

What is the best way to vet an author or book?

If you're a historian focused on a subject, let's say the Roman Empire, and find a interesting book on a subject you know little of, like feudal Japan, what do you do to try and estimate the credibility of the book?

What are the steps you take to ensure the book your reading is not bunk if a simple "author x book y historically accurate?" google search doesn't work?

3 Answers 2016-08-28

The popular conception of the popular-music landscape in the 1920s-40s is pretty much wall-to-wall jazz. But is that accurate? Suppose I'm an American in the second quarter or so of the 20th century (i.e., 1926-1950 or so) who doesn't care for Jazz-- what am I probably listening to instead?

6 Answers 2016-08-28

What is this battle called?

When I was in middle school, we read a story in history class about two submarines who I think were surfaced while they were battling. So, I don't think that torpedoes were used. During the battle one of the submarines thought they had won the battle for whatever reason, I think they thought the other submarine surrendered. So, they started leaving the battle since they thought they had won. The other submarine saw that the other submarine was leaving so then they thought that the other submarine had surrendered, so they thought that they had won. Both submarines thought they had won when neither of them won.

2 Answers 2016-08-28

When did the Christian objection to abortion begin and at what point did abortion become a political issue?

Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2016-08-28

Is the claim that King James was black new?

I'm seeing some afrocentrics and "hebrew israelites" claiming "King James was black" (as in the KJV's King James), and although I know this is obviously false, it's one false claim I started seeing more commonly recently than before, so I got curious: Is the claim that KJ was black old in these BHI or afrocentric circles, meaning did anyone of significance in these movements ever say this before (as in the time period this subredit accepts questions about)? And on another note, I can even understand saying ancient egypcians, jews etc were black (at least they live somewhat close to large black populations, and it's harder to know how very ancient people looked like), but why King James? Is there any old folk legend about him being black or something or is this just arbitrary? I mean really, just google "king james black" and there are even books about it!

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Before smoking was proven to cause lung cancer did people at least know that smoking was "bad" for them.

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-08-28

Is there an actual history of Jewish people living inside tree holes and underground burrows to hide themselves within various ancient Kingdoms? (not anti-Semitic!)

I tried asking this question elsewhere and I suppose it sounds so strange and possibly controversial that I'm having a difficult time getting approval. Was this a real thing? I've noticed multiple comedy films, satire, where the Jewish characters often live down inside tree stumps and burrows and one has to have a password to get through. Was this an actual historic thing, like people lived this way to escape persecution, or is this just comedic nonsense?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

I need some information about unit 731

So I'm in the pre planning stages of a comic idea with various historical settings and I wanna tell a story about Unit 731 (The Japanese chemical and biological weapon experimentation facility from WWII) and I need to know what happened to the scientists who worked there and some of the more horrifying experiments conducted there. Can you help me?

1 Answers 2016-08-28

⯇ 4007 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start