Whatever happened to "Bong Sunbin"? Joseon Korea's lesbian royal consort?

I realize I may be asking the unanswerable, but I'll take a shot.

Daniel Tudor's Korea: The Impossible Country lists this fascinating tidbit in the chapter on homosexuality:

King Sejong the Great himself was advised by ministers to disown his daughter-in-law for the crime of having sexual relations with maidservants. This case has the rare distinction of being recorded in royal documents. We can probably infer that the scarcity of such tales in official records is more of a result of the aversion and taboo that had by then developed than an indication of the absence of homosexual practices.

I started researching to figure out more about this lesbian consort. Initially finding this on Wikipedia, clearly written by someone less than versed in English:

After Royal Noble Consort Hwi of the Andong Kim clan lost her position, Royal Noble Consort Sun of the Ha-eum Bong clan (순빈 봉씨) became crowned prince's second wife. However, she was so lonely that she loved one of the made [sic] named So-ssang (소쌍). Also she relied on alcohol too much and at that time period, woman drinking too much alcohol was unacceptable. She lost her position because the king found out that she was a lesbian.

A little bit more and I found this article which focuses on Munjong's marriages (prior to becoming King). The relevant portion below:

Prince Munjong second wife's surname was Pong.'' But the situation did not improve on the front of bearing sons for the royal family, a serious problem for Munjong's father, King Sejong. King Sejong hoped his son would have a boy baby who could continue the throne, but the night affairs between Munjong and his new wife were not fruitful. To resolve the issue, King Sejong brought in three young ladies to put a spin on the troubled marriage life of Munjong. King Sejong's intervention no doubt displeased Pong, but there was nothing she could do except suppress her overwhelming anxiety and jealousy. Unfortunately, one of the three ladies, Kwon Sung-hui, got pregnant after a nightly visit by Munjong. Desperate to secure her position, Pong spread false rumors including a lie that she herself was pregnant. The false news reached unsuspecting court officials and King Sejong. Filled with joy, King Sejong even asked his daughter-in-law to move into an inner court room to keep her from any possible harm. One month later, Pong said she suffered a miscarriage, in her continuing effort to hoodwink the king and others. Pong's weird acts went out of control in the wake of the mock pregnancy scandal. She was caught looking through the cracks of a restroom wall to peak at men outside of the palace. In addition, she forced her servants to sing songs about love affairs. Even more shocking was that Pong was believed to be a lesbian.'' According to the Annals articles, Pong loved her female servant named So-ssang.'' Since Pong showed a particularly strong affection, So-ssang was deeply troubled. So-ssang later testified that she was forced to sleep with Pong. Last year, Crown Princess called me and asked me to stay at her room that night. I declined, but she screamed so much so that I obliged. When I was half- naked and entered the room, she took away my clothes and forced me to assume a position as if having sex with a man,'' So-ssang said. When King Sejong called Pong to ask her about the incident, she gave a different story. Pong argued that So-ssang was in love with another servant girl and that she had never slept with So-ssang. But, the truth finally came out, and Pong was expelled from the palace, her royal title canceled.

The website gives a strong impression that this comes from the Sillok Royal Annals, so I hope I'm not barking up the wrong tree if I ask if this is what the Annals recorded?

And otherwise, what happened to Bong Sun? She was stripped of her Royal title, but what did that mean for early Joseon? Was she a commoner? Was she still a noble lady? Would she have returned home to her clan to be married off to a less prestigious husband? Would she suddenly be an outcast, on the level of Gisaeng and bandits?

1 Answers 2016-07-11

Why did the double envelopment work at Cannae but not at Dertosa?

From what little I know of Dertosa, Hasdrubal tried the same thing Hannibal used at Cannae but he failed where his brother succeeded. Why was this, was it because of better soldiers, luck, differences in generalship skill, or a combination of factors?

Also, I want clarification on a sub-topic of each battle: As far as I'm aware, both carthage generals had their centers collapse, how did hannibal go on to win the battle despite this while Hasdrubal ended up losing?

1 Answers 2016-07-11

During the Roman Empire, what was the status of the amphora? Might one be proudly displayed during a formal meal, a bit like showing off an expensive bottle of wine today; or might a secondary vessel be used to present the wine to guests and the amphora be on par with an empty Coke bottle?

1 Answers 2016-07-11

Why have the Baha'i been persecuted in Iran more heavily than other religious minorities? Is there any evidence to the claims that the Baha'i are (especially likely to be) spies?

Here's Wikipedia on persecution of Baha'i people.

Jews, Christians, and Zoroastrians have official recognition in Iran, and (on paper) do not face much persecution, as far as I can tell from Wikipedia. The Baha'i situation is very different, with institutionalized hostility stretching back at least to 1906.

Has the official rationale for persecution changed much over time? Is there evidence that foreign players (e.g., the CIA or the KGB or IIS) used Baha'i discontent as a platform for their operations?

In accordance with the 20-year rule, let's keep the discussion pre-1997. There's plenty to work with there.

1 Answers 2016-07-11

What would a merchant and his 8-year-old kid do in a ship for three months in the 14th century?

Besides talking, is there anything else they could do? (Already checked the FAQ)

1 Answers 2016-07-11

Why did the Allies need D-Day? Couldn't they have fought their way in from Italy?

They already had a foothold in Europe no? Why not just re enforce and push through from the south?

2 Answers 2016-07-11

Was secession the immediate response to Lincoln's election, or were there serious alternatives proposed?

Since there was no legal mechanism for secession, surely some people foresaw its potential consequences. Did any politicians or personalities (of either the South or North) propose some other radical change to the Union, such as calling a constitutional convention?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

When did the Flavian Amphitheater become colloquially referred to as the Colosseum?

I ask this because of an odd passage I've found in my reading of Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray. The passage in question is located in chapter XI and reads as follows: "Where, the huge velarium that Nero had stretchered across the Colosseum at Rome" (115). Yet, the Flavian Amphitheater was built after the reign of Nero. Wilde was apparently a brilliant classicist, so I find it a bit difficult to believe he made such a silly error (not to mention if this was a mistake, my Norton critical edition also failed to catch it).

Thus, I wonder if he's referring to something else? When did the Flavian Amphitheater become referred to as the Colosseum in English? Did the "Colosseum" refer to some other than the Flavian Amphitheater in Victorian English? Or, did "Nero" perhaps referring to someone else besides the last of the Julio-Claudians in Victorian speech?

I'm reading the Second Norton Critical Edition published in 2007 for reference.

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Is there any historical evidence of Buddha's existence?

I was just wondering how historical scholarship at large views the Buddha. Regardless of whether he had supernatural abilities, is there evidence that such a man existed? Is it reasonable to think he was real? Or, would the objective position simply be that we have no idea if there is any truth behind the stories of Buddha's life?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Which beer hall did the Munich putsch happen in?

Is it still around?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Why were ethnic tensions higher in Bosnia compared to Croatia in the Yugoslav Independence Wars?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Can we guess about Saxon Helmets?

Despite only having found four Early Saxon Helmets, can we guess what the others looked like? -Coppergate -Benty Grange -Sutton Hoo -Staffordshire

How often were face-plates like Sutton Hoo?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

What is some compelling evidence for/against the theory that Anastasia Romanov survived her family's assassination?

Throughout the last century, there have been multiple rumors and conspiracy theories that Anastasia survived the shooting of her entire family by the Bolsheviks. What evidence supports or opposes this theory?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Why did service in the us military lose importance as a social status symbol?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

In "Kagemusha," the European-backed Japanese lord wears plate armor to battle. Did some Japanese warriors wear plate armor in real life? If so, was it more effective than Japanese armor?

2 Answers 2016-07-10

What were LBJ's true motivations for passing the landmark civil rights/race discrimination bills of the 1960s?

As LBJ was known to be a blatant racist, did he truly believe in the civil rights cause, or were his efforts to pass civil rights legislation largely a part of party politics and public image with the African American population?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

I keep hearing that the 2016 election will be the first election in American history in which a third party candidate (Gary Johnson) will be on the ballot in all 50 states. Is this true for all of American history?

I realize the statement itself is about current events, but my question is for all of American history, so I hope this is allowed. Right off the top of my head, I can think of George Wallace in 1968, Teddy Roosevelt in the Progressive Party, and the 1800 election in which Jefferson and Aaron Burr tied for first and Adams came in third. Do these examples not disprove the claim about the current election? Are there any other examples that disprove the claim?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Why are there so many conspiracy theories about the Rothschilds?

Every now and then you will find a conspiracy guy on YouTube, your Facebook feed or here on reddit. When they aren't talking about Chemtrails or whatever, they always point fingers at that family. What's up with that? I know that they are very rich and somewhat powerful (?) but why are there so many conspiracy theories surrounding them still? How did they develop?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Before air conditioning what did the wealthy do?

So I recently saw posted a link to a story about how before the advent of AC people would sleep in Central Park and on fire escapes to escape the heat. My question is, was there any other option which might of been too expensive for most people?

2 Answers 2016-07-10

How did ancient civilizations use their crops to maximum effect without them spoiling?

I have fruit trees and I used to have a large garden and what I have noticed, is that they don't seem to give me long term yields. Mostly it's about a week of ripeness, before they go bad, or the birds eat them. And the problem is that if I pick them all before they go bad, they usually don't last long in my kitchen. How would ancient people's maximize the effectiveness of their crops? How could fruits and vegetables stay edible to last them through the winter?

2 Answers 2016-07-10

Did Western medieval theologians ever assume a role somewhat akin to that of modern "public intellectuals"?

I'm aware that the notion of "public intellectuals" (or even of a "public" space) is very modern. I guess what I'm interested in is how much theologians (and medieval philosophers in general) were involved in more "temporal" issues and debates.

I don't know if I should specify a time period, but let's say from the 11th-12th centuries onward, when the first universities were established.

2 Answers 2016-07-10

If I am a male Native American prior to European arrival, how often was I going into battle with other tribes?

Was it monthly, yearly, once or twice a lifetime?

I know there is no single answer, each tribe was vastly different in war practices. But hopefully there is some literature on numbers for differing tribes.

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Who are the Macrobians of Herotodus? Were they ancestral Somalis or other Cushitic? Nilo-Saharan? Or just a made-up legend?

Herotodus mentions a nation of pastoral herders who challenged Cambyses and whom he described as youthful and living to very venerable age and of great stature. The area he describes them as living is very confusing as well and I find it hard to pin point a general area of sub-Saharan Africa which he seemingly describes.

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Why is so little classic English literature and folklore set in Anglo-Saxon England?

Celtic Britain appears plenty of times (King Arthur, King Lear, Old King Cole, Brut, etc.), and there are classic works set during the Anglo-Saxon period, in neighboring countries (Beowulf, MacBeth, Hamlet)—but Anglo-Saxon England itself seems to have dropped out of the national consciousness. One would expect that if nothing else, the repulsion of the invading Vikings by Alfred the Great would have given rise to an English epic.

Was the subject actively suppressed by the Normans?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

Was there an ancient Rome equivalent to modern rock bands--a group of people with a fandom that are consistently putting on concerts and performing for events?

1 Answers 2016-07-10

⯇ 4128 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start