Not everyone always agrees on what trivia is. Partially for that reason, the moderators of /r/askhistorians have changed the wording of the rule against "trivia-seeking questions."
We've often struggled with the wording of this rule (it used to be called "throughout history"), but while the name of the rule has changed, the meaning of it hasn't.
Because we have a limited number of moderators and a limited slate of moderation tools, we have to forbid questions that generate large numbers of low-quality answers. Without such a prohibition, we'd spend an extraordinary amount of time on a handful of questions, and the rest of the subreddit would suffer.
So please, keep your questions as narrowly focused as possible. If your question can be summarized as "tell me random stuff about X" or "tell me about X in several centuries around the world," you're better off asking it in /r/history.
5 Answers 2016-07-06
I was just reading about Hieronymus of Cardia and his History of the Successors.
I was wondering, how was it that primary sources from this era (that were well known enough for us to know they existed) totally disappeared, and how possible is it that an archeological dig could still turn up these lost works?
1 Answers 2016-07-06
I guess I should also expand it to how do all executioners get paid? I mean....that must have been a part-time job, where he was an aspiring chef and then chops some heads off on a weekend or two a month right? Or was he a full time executioner because there was just that many heads to needs chopping?
Hope this answers your question as well Jeremy!
2 Answers 2016-07-06
I google searched first world war grenades and found similar examples, but the ridging is different. Dad's grenade
2 Answers 2016-07-06
I know that various cultures obviously interacted with each other and likely spread stories, but how did these creatures come to be so prominent in the cultures that they're found in?
To be clear, I'm referring to European dragons, Chinese dragons, Quetzalcoatl, The Leviathan, and so on.
2 Answers 2016-07-06
How is that Vercingetorix could lead thousands against Caesar?
1 Answers 2016-07-06
I was looking through this website and reading the info on golden age of piracy weapons. For the long rifles, it reads...
Long rifles, although they are black powder weapons, were much more stable. Used both by pirates and marines, these were the assault weapons of the period. When fixed with a bayonet, the barrel of the gun is plugged, but the weapon retains functionality as a boarding pike. In the period, some of the French buccaneers were renowned hunters and their accuracy with a long rifle, whether killing a boar or a man, was the stuff of legend. It is interesting to note that although the British and French were known to use long rifles from the rigging (or more accurately from the fighting tops), the Spanish never did -- their Admiralty believed that the risk of fire in the rigging far outweighed the benefits of guns. Even as late as the 1700's, the Spanish used bows and crossbows in their fighting tops.
Also, is fighting tops the correct term used for those platforms on the masts? Would "crow's nest" be a term just coined by fictitious stuff on pirates/sailing ships?
1 Answers 2016-07-06
2 Answers 2016-07-06
For example, could a wealthy businessman travel from New York to London for matters of important business? Or did you in some way need to be connected to the war effort to be able to travel?
2 Answers 2016-07-06
Basically if Germans, Scythians etc are said to have a temple to Zeus is that name just being used analogically to refer to "the deity considered king of the gods" or was it more literal and taken to mean that the people in question would have the same myths and stories about this god as the Greeks and Romans did?
1 Answers 2016-07-06
The question often comes up as to if there has ever been a society ruled by women rather than men, and the answer is always "the Amazons." However, not once have I learned anything more detailed than merely their name in school and college. A few questions come to mind:
-To what extent were they real?
-Was it a society only of women or of women and men as equals?
-If they are to some extent mythological, are there well-known myths?
-Is there some dispute to their history?
1 Answers 2016-07-06
I'm not sure if this question is too broad, but I'm curious to know if there were distinguishing differences between the various knights and men-at-arms of the major Kingdoms of Europe during the High and Late Middle Ages, particularly around the time of the Hundred Years' War.
For instance, aside from language and basic cultural differences that would come with any different region, were there major variations in the doctrine or codes of conduct expected of knights and men-at-arms from France, England and the various Kingdoms of the Holy Roman Empire around the time if the Hundred Years' War? Did they, for instance, favor different tactics in battle to any notable degree or have distinguishing characteristics that generally set then apart from the knights of other places in Western Europe?
Did French, English, "German" or other knights of the time vary significantly in their preferred arms and/or armor? Did any of the Kingdoms specifically put more focus on one aspect of warfare (Heavy armored cavalry, light cavalry, infantry, missile/archers, etc...) above the others?
Did any of the major powers and their fighting knights and men-at-arms of the time excel at any specific type of warfare over the others? For instance, did some Kingdoms notably produce better or more successful cavalry or pikemen or tacticians than others?
And were there any major differences in how the Knights from France, England and the HRE Kingdoms were trained for combat, insofar as having distinct styles of sword fighting (I've heard there were various different European schools of swordsmanship. Was this around during the High middle ages? If so, what were the notable differences between the major schools?) or with a larger focus on different weaponry?
3 Answers 2016-07-06
1 Answers 2016-07-05
Saw the story of Count Von Shilssengourg in a Ripley's Museum. He was 6' 11.5" tall and was sentenced to 20 years to spend in a 4 feet cell because his trousers split as he was following protocol by bending down to kiss the hand of the Petite Empress Anne.
Could not find any articles of what happened to him. Can anybody provide some information.
1 Answers 2016-07-05
[deleted]
1 Answers 2016-07-05
Rodrigo Borgia was vice chancellor of the church before becoming pope. What exactly did this job entail and how powerful was it
2 Answers 2016-07-05
I've been reading a lot of contradictory accounts of the Ismailis, in Montefiore's "Jerusalem: a Biography," on their own official website, on Wikipedia and in various other places. Some sources present the Ismailis as an extremist splitoff sect from the Twelver Shi'as, while others portray them as a reasonable sort of protest group who've endured centuries of persecution.
Does either of these portrayals fit more closely with the historical records? Do they each have their own validity?
1 Answers 2016-07-05
I've tried to read up on clothing as a part of human culture and its implication on our views of the civilized vs the uncivilized. Whilst doing some own research i found sources claiming that people started wearing clothes between 100.000 to 500.000 years ago and that modern humans / Homo Sapiens has been around for around 200.000 years
Does this mean that clothing might have existed longer than our own species and if so, who were the first to wear clothes? Is it even known?
1 Answers 2016-07-05
I'm currently reading through Jonathon D. Spence's The Search for Modern China. In chapter 4, under the section entitled "The Center and Channels of Power," Spence discusses how Yongzheng was able to use newly consolidated power to better coordinate his forces against both the Zunghars and the Miao. Why were the Miao subdued while the Zunghars were able to achieve victory against the Chinese forces and were only defeated during Qianlong? Any clarification and additional details on these events would be much appreciated.
1 Answers 2016-07-05
I'm a relative of Jesse Fearson, who was a American Privateer during the Am. Rev. and american- French Quasi-War. Not sure if he retired to Baltimore from privateering before the war of 1812. (Also his sister-in-law was Mary Pickersgill who made the 'Star Spangled Banner which flew over Ft. McHenry.).
Anyway, I found three ships that he commanded as an American Privateer, the sloop-of-war, Buccaneer, a cutter(?), William and another cutter the Eagle. Also found a mention of one of his schooners being captured by Spanish Privateers working for France..
My father and I thought it would be cool to be able to find the plans for one of these ships (especially the Buccaneer) and to be able to make a model from them. Anyone have any resources where I can find out more about these ships, or if there are any drawings or images of what they would look like?
1 Answers 2016-07-05
The way I most often hear about WWI, whether in high school and college classes or in places like Dan Carlin's hardcore history or The Great War youtube series is as a calamitous and avoidable series of mistakes that resolved nothing and set the stage for WWII.
Are there any alternative views, whether by modern historians or by politicians immediately after the war trying to justify it, portraying it as a fight of liberal democracies against monarchical empires, or questioning the directness of the connection to WWII (Italy, for instance, was a winner in WWI yet also the root of fascism), or considering it a calamitous and avoidable mistake but for different-than-usual reasons?
1 Answers 2016-07-05
Between the Confederate offensives into Maryland and Pennsylvania, and the battles which took place in the Midwestern border states, I can imagine that Union forces may have requisitioned food, supplies, horses, and shelter from civilians without their enthusiastic consent.
Did any people sue the Federal government after the war for violation of the Third Amendment?
1 Answers 2016-07-05
Hello,
I've been reading about the Winter War and the events leading up to it. Can anyone tell me which language was spoken during the various talks and negotiations between Finland and Russia in the interwar period?
As I've been thinking about this, I realize that I have a host of related questions as well:
Thanks!
2 Answers 2016-07-05
Marvel Comics and Brooklyn's (NY, USA) Prospect Park have just announced a forthcoming historical monument: a 4-meter-tall statue of that great American patriot...Steve Rogers. The monument's epigraph: "I'm just a kid from Brooklyn."
There's a (probably unsurprising) massive amount of scholarship on Captain America as a mirror of America or American ideals, evolving from the famous cover illustration of him punching Hitler in the face to his ambivalent role in the student protest movements of the 1960s to his (comics) death in the (real world) post-9/11, height of the Iraq War era.
The unveiling of the plans for the statue raises new questions. How does a fictional character become remembered like one who actually lived? Or do we simply fictionalize "real" heroes (Joan of Arc) until they become narrative creations? What is the relationship between Captain America and figures we associate clearly with propaganda, like Uncle Sam or Marianne?
Since I can apparently only think of examples from the USA and France, help me diversify! What are some of history's greatest fictional or fictionalized symbols of patriotism--and what kind of patriotism do they stand for?
Next Week: Prepare to feel like you've entered the world of Honey, I Shrunk The Historians as we ponder the roles of REALLY BIG THINGS throughout history.
3 Answers 2016-07-05