Napoleon famously considered torture as close to useless for the acquisition of intelligence, was this position informed by personal experience in anyway?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Which Roman emperor do we know the least about, which emperor is spoken about the least in primary sources?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Was there instances of pagan missionaries? Why did Christianity spread so far but not the various pagan religions?

5 Answers 2016-07-05

[ww2] How did tank crews get permission to paint their own tanks?

We've all seen tanks with names and images painted on them. What is the process to getting this done? Does the tank crew have to get permission from someone first? Was it pretty unregulated? I've hit google and gotten nothing at all on this topic.

1 Answers 2016-07-05

What tactics were used by the various "barbarian hordes" fighting the Romans around the 4th century AD?

Between the Franks, the Saxons, and the various Germanic tribes, it seems like Roman tactics had stopped giving the Roman Empire the tactical superiority that had helped the empire expand as much as it did.

Did the various tribes use Roman tactics, thus negating a Roman advantage? Were the barbarians so numerically superior that Roman tactics were no longer useful?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

What were American soldiers that happened to be named Charlie referred to by in Vietnam?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Rules Roundtable no. 14- Make your own META post

Welcome to another installment Rules Roundtable, our biweekly thread where we demystify the rules of the subreddit. In this post, I will explain what META posts are (and what they are not), what purpose they serve, and how they are moderated. As always, these roundtables are here to get feedback from you, the readers.

What is [META] for?

META posts are for discussing the /r/AskHistorians subreddit. They might take the form of open letters to the moderators suggesting changes in rules or moderator policy, or requesting additional features for the subreddit, or complaints about specific moderation incidents. Moderators will often announce changes to rules, or issue gentle public reminders about the existing rules, in META posts. The Rules Roundtable that you are reading right now is technically a META post.

However, Moderators aren't the only people who can make META posts. Any user can make a META post. If you are interested in making one, please begin the title of your post with [META] with the brackets, to make it clear that the topic of your post is not to ask a question about the past, but to discuss the subreddit.

META posts are automatically given orange flair, so that they further stand out from regular posts. If you have submitted a META post and it does not display orange flair after several minutes, message the mods and we will add the flair.

Am I using the [META] tag correctly?

Sometimes, users don't want to ask questions about a specific historical event, person, or era; instead they wish to ask questions about historical theory , or practice, or terminology.

Those sorts of questions are welcome in AskHistorians. However, we ask that you do not use the [META] tag for those types of questions. The [META] tag is intended to denote that the post will be for introspection about the /r/AskHistorians subreddit.

How are META threads moderated?

META posts and the comment threads within will often be moderated more lightly than other threads. For instance, threads announcing a fresh round of moderators have historically gotten quite jokey.

As stated above, sometimes users will create a META post to point out what they feel has been an instance of unfair moderation.^1 In those cases, the policy of the mod team is to give people the opportunity to state their grievance. Thus, we are extremely cautious about removing comments in those types of META posts.

On the other hand, our rules about civil behavior still apply in META posts. There is a difference between registering a complaint, and being a jerk. If your comment includes name-calling or insults against members of the community, including users, flairs or the mod team, then it will be removed and you may be warned or banned.

Also, comments that express bigotry, or provide personal information about other users will be removed and the commenter banned.


  1. Alternatively, you can always message the mods to discuss specific instances of moderation.

1 Answers 2016-07-05

How would I get into battle during Operation Barbarossa?

If I was a member of a standard Heer Infanterie-Division, not a mechanized one, how much of my movement would be done on foot?

If I was not currently in an active part of the front, would I be moving by train? Wagon? Horseback? Or would the entirety of my advance through the Soviet Union during Operation Barbarossa consist of walking?

As a less important curiosity, what about my Soviet counterpart?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Were hangmen paid per hanging?

In the movie The Hateful Eight the character John Ruth says: "I don't like cheating the hangman. He's got to make a living too."
 
Is this true? Were hangmen paid per hanging? Did this not create a possible conflict of interest?

2 Answers 2016-07-05

What was the relationship between the Mayan and Aztec Empire?

This probably has been answered before but because the two civilizations are close to each other. So how did they interact and view each other's peoples/civilizations?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Did the 18th century use holsters for their pistols? If not, how were they carried?

We hear examples of men carrying multiple pistols into battle (particularly in the navy). How would these have been carried? Are depictions of holsters and shoulder holsters accurate or a movie creation?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Were the "Barbarian Invasions" of ancient Rome really invasions, or were they migrations? Or both?

I've been wondering whether the Barbarian "Invasions" are a bit of a misnomer, and I'd like to know more. What were the circumstances of the migration period in ancient Rome? Were people really invading, or were they simply migrating because they had nowhere else to go? What spurred the migrations? How did Rome deal with the migrants? Did the Romans give any of them citizenship, or some other legal status? Might some of the migrants be considered refugees by modern standards? How did the migrations affect Roman attitudes toward multiculturalism? Also, if you know of any, I'd love to hear recommendations of sources for further reading on this topic!

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Russian military hat?

Greetings my fellow redditors!

My friend and I bought this hat a few years ago but we've never really figured out what it is, where it came from etc. The seller were not an expert on these things but he told us vaguely it was russian.

Basically we'd like more information about what this hat is.

Here is the hat in question: http://imgur.com/Cx5cvJT

1 Answers 2016-07-05

According to historical evidence, who appeared first as a people, the Egyptians or the Jews? And who developed a religion first?

Adding the question posted by TheRetardedGoat:

"Adding to the question, did the Israelites and Egyptians share any cultural/religious traditions?"

2 Answers 2016-07-05

Hernando De Soto encountered the Mississippi River in 1541. Marquette and Jolliet first explored most of its length in 1673, more than 130 years later. Why did a massive river go unexplored for so long?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

When and how did the Evangelicals tie themselves with the Conservative Party?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

How historically accurate is the 'Historia Brittonum'?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

When did humans become aware of previously extinct species such as dinosaurs?

Hi Historians! I'm in my first year of studying History in University and it's a question one of my teachers brought up today but left sort of unanswered and I've been curious about the answer since. Would the societies of ancient History such as Romans or Egyptians have known of the existence of extinct species? When were they first known of? Are there sources or information that suggest they did know about them?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

What was the reaction of european nations when Napoleon III became president of France and then Emperor?

Was Europe afraid of a return to the napoleonic era?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

What were the motivating factors fueling the gold v silver debate in the second half of the 19th century in the US?

I've heard that it was a very controversial and contentious issue at that time, but have never really understood why it mattered all that much which was chosen. As I understand it different sections of the population favored one or the other. What were the rationale behind these positions?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Would it have been better (trade-wise) if the afsluitdijk was never built?

Would Amsterdams harbor be larger than Rotterdams harbor is now?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Why didn't Jordan and/or Egypt give Palestinians independence or autonomy?

2 Answers 2016-07-05

What did the fertile crescent look like when it was, well, fertile?

Was it wast farmlands, grassland or desert or dry lands like now? When did it change? why did it change?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

Why did Hitler not invade Switzerland?

2 Answers 2016-07-05

What was law school like back in the 1700 and 1800s?

Was just reading a post on the front page that had facts about US presidents and many were lawyers. Did they go to law school as we know it today? Did students read a bunch of case law and take bar exam?

1 Answers 2016-07-05

⯇ 4140 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start