Concerning Fascist Historiography

I’ll try to keep this as concise as I can: studied history as an undergrad, and specialized in Nazi Germany. Recently I have been expanding my reading into the literature on fascism more generally and not just Nazism, which has led me to the works of A. J. Gregor

I was wondering how I should approach reading him—from what I understand his interpretation of fascism is a little peculiar, contending that it emerges almost directly from Marxism (which I’m wary of due to the whole “nazis were socialists etc etc” talking point). I haven’t seen him cited in the other literature I’ve read, such as Paxton, Payne, or Griffin. But I also understand that he’s something of a big deal where Mussolini is concerned

2 Answers 2021-12-21

"The safest general characterization of the European philosophical tradition is that it consists of a series of footnotes to Plato." Who, therefore, would fill the place of the Plato of the Chinese philosophical tradition?

1 Answers 2021-12-21

Were the people who danced during the Dancing Plague of 1518 sane? What happened when other people tried to talk to them?

were they possesed? what happened to those who survived, what did they say afterwards?

this is a historical event that I just don’t understand.

1 Answers 2021-12-21

Why did small cities like Ft. Wayne, Rochester and Rock Island get early pro sports franchises?

The NFL famously was founded in an auto dealership in Canton, Ohio, home of one of the original teams. Other early franchises included big burgs like Dayton, Duluth, Muncie and Tonawanda. The NBA’s history includes metropolises such as Rochester, Syracuse, Fort Wayne and even lovely Moline, Illinois.

It’s not surprising that, except for Green Bay, most of the teams in tiny towns either relocated or went bust. But why were they included in the first place? How could owners expect to draw enough attendance, in the era before TV rights, to survive?

1 Answers 2021-12-21

I’ve often heard it said that Italy lacked major heavy industry at the start of WWII. Is this true? If so why did Italy struggle to develop such industry?

1 Answers 2021-12-21

What did learning to fight in the medieval ages actually look like?

1 Answers 2021-12-21

Did Abdel Nasser pay Canal Shareholders when Nationalizing the Suez?

According to the Suez Canal Authority, Nasser did pay off 800,000 shares of the canal. I'm not 100% sure this is accurate as I cannot find the source they cited. Would anyone have a corroborating source to verify the claim of the Egyptian government that during the nationalization, Nasser paid off all shareholders?

1 Answers 2021-12-21

Despite having the technology and self-loading pistols at the time of WW1, why were semi-automatic self-loading rifles not standard use for infantry?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Were there dissenters in the south during the American civil war?

Northern loyalists, you might say?

2 Answers 2021-12-20

What caused the decline of Blaxploitation films after the early 1980s?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Why did the US “island hop” during WWII? I can envision the benefits of destroying naval vessels but why not bypass small islands and instead focus on Japan?

2 Answers 2021-12-20

How far back in time would I have to go in London to hear easily understandable English? What about the English countryside?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

How likely is it that Tibetan shirpas could have climbed Mount Everest centuries ago and it just didn't get recorded?

3 Answers 2021-12-20

Do we know where the playwright Aeschylus is buried specifically?

I know he was buried in Gela, on the isle of Sicily, and that we have the transcript of his epitaph, but does his tombstone still exist or is his final resting spot known to any more specific degree than that? Even just a general side of town or ancient graveyard stemming from that era?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Pre-WW1 Fighting Vehicles

I am currently doing research in preparing to write an essay on fighting vehicles prior to WW1 (War Wagons, Chariots etc.) and came across "A History of Mechanical Engineering" by Ce Zhang. In it he states

"In the 6th century, China was already able to build huge war wagons as high as several meters with 20 wheels "

The source given is: 'Bu, Y. (2018). Vehicles in ancient times. In Encyclopedia of China (3rd ed., electronic edition). Beijing: Encyclopedia of China Publishing House (in Chinese).' I am having incredible difficulty in tracking this down, and automated Chinese to English translation is iffy at best. The Encyclopedia of China is also claimed to be quite nationalistic in it's portrayal of History. I cannot find a similar claim in other literature that does not reference this source

Is there any validity/evidence/supporting archaeology to this claim of Goliath War Wagons or is this purely historical fantasy? Is anyone able to track down the reference in question?

Many thanks in advance

2 Answers 2021-12-20

Did rennaissance people struggle to read their handwrittem texts the way do today?

I sometimes come across notes written by Galileo, Copernicus and other people from centuries ago and find their handwriting extremely difficult to read. Sometimes, book authors leave notes saying that some texts are yet to be deciphered. Is it a problem associated with the ink and paper degradation through time? Modern physicians are sometimes regarded as writing with unreadable calligraphy as if it was part of some sort of "physician culture/style". Was it the same case? Did they feel compelled to write in a calligraphy that was hard to read because it was what everyone else did? Was it an attempt to hide their ideas from others? Or is it just an anachronistic impression by someone who's born centuries later?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

To what extent is the European attitude towards gun an outgrowth of a feudal mindset (Lord/government has a duty to protect you) vs the American attitude being an outgrowth of people settling a new land (no one to protect you but you)?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Why was there a trend for Australian-themed things around the 1980s?

It might just be my Millennial nostalgia playing tricks on me, but it seems to me that there was something of a fad for all things Australian around the 1980s, at least from my perspective as a kid in the US. Here are some of the events/cultural products I was aware of as a kid that made me think of this pattern:

What was going on in--or with--Australia that prompted all this Australiana that reached me all the way in Kentucky? Or am I just imagining a pattern that isn't there?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Were floor length dresses common throughout history?

It just wouldn't seem practical to have floor length gowns dragging on the ground and getting frayed and dirty. Yet in most historical dramas (from medieval times onwards) people seem to have gowns that fall to the floor.

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Why did the 19th century Russian Czars use exile as punishment with revolutionaries instead of execution?

Very often in Russian history we see revolutionaries (nationalists and socialists both) attempt and succeed at assassinations and revolts. The czar often imprisoned these people, then exiled them for several years in Siberia. For example this happened to Lenin. Where they were then able to come back and cause more trouble for the Czars later. Sometimes escaping before their exile was “finished”. Was this seen as a permanent solution? Why not hang them, which was otherwise common at the time.

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Why would the nobles of Bohemia elect Vladislav II Jagiellon, a foreigner, as King of Bohemia?

Following the death of the Hussite George Podebrady, the Bohemian nobles elected Vladislav II as King of Bohemia. In some cases (e.g. Hungary electing Vladislav III as protection against ottomans) it makes sense, but I don't seem to understand why the Bohemians would do this.

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Is the Medieval Water Myth unique to European/Eurocentric history?

The inimitable /u/DanKensington has some great posts debunking the myth that "medieval people mostly drank alcohol because of water contamination". I pretty much always see this referenced to Europe, especially western Europe, and sometimes colonial America (despite being definitely non-medieval...). Is this myth exclusive to popular misconceptions of European history, or do laypeople in other parts of the world also have similar myths about their own history?

Also, where did the myth originate? Is there a particular author or historian to whom we can attribute the original idea?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Books recommendation

Hi! Can someone recommend me some books of US History of 20th century?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

Other than Engelbert Dollfuss, were there other fascists that opposed Nazi Germany and Hitler?

Other than Engelbert Dollfuss, were there other fascists that opposed Nazi Germany and Hitler?

Was there anyone else during WW2?

1 Answers 2021-12-20

How Did Roman Officers Learn to be Officers?

Was there an equivalent of a military academy? Was there some kind of apprenticeship program? Officer training school? Were there books on strategy? Was it purely figure-it-out-as-you-go, on-the-job training?

I have been listening to the History of Rome podcast and it seems like so many rich or well-connected guys just show up and are given command of troops. If I were a teenager from a patrician family looking to have a military career (during say, the time from Augustus to Trajan), do I start as a legionnaire or am I given command of any soldiers? Would I be expected to have gone through any military education process?

2 Answers 2021-12-20

420 / 7255

Back to start