What are the theories regarding the origins of Qur'an ?

Muslims claim that Qur'an is a direct revelation of the God. I don't think historians take this as it is. So, what theories have historians developed in order to explain the origins/compilation of the Qur'an ?

2 Answers 2016-06-09

[AMA] Hamilton and his Time: The Stories Behind the Musical

American historians can "look around, look around, and think of how lucky we are to be alive right now" thanks to the smash success of Lin-Manuel Miranda's Hamilton: The Musical. This play, nominated for sixteen Tony awards, has turned the nation's and the world's attention to the American Revolution and the early Republic in ways that professional historians have often dreamed of but seldom achieved. As such, people have been asking an amazing number and variety of questions about Hamilton, and some of us here at /r/Askhistorians will take our best shot (heh) at answering them.

Among today's panelists are:

and myself,

  • /u/TRB1783, who will focus on the War of American Independence, Hamilton's military career, Loyalists, and, drawing from his time as a tour guide at their Albany mansion, will try to werk his way through questions about the Schuyler family.

We have a few other flaired users checking in throughout the day, so don't worry if you don't see your specific area of interest addressed by us three.

We look forward to answering your questions!

EDIT: Whew, what a day! Sorry if we didn't get to your question yet, but we'll be back tomorrow and through the weekend. Thank you all for your excellent questions.

86 Answers 2016-06-09

Pre-Civil War, did groups of freed slaves ever try to free other slaves through economic means?

The history of American slavery is a history of slaves trying to escape the institution. We know some were successful, either by buying their own freedom or merely running away.

Were there ever any schemes for these former slaves to pool their money and free even more people?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

How were Black slaves in the USA converted so successfully to Christianity?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in June 09 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2016-06-09

A question about Augustus' name.

I read that Augustus' full name at death was Imperator Caesar Divi Filvis Augustus. But he is commonly referred to as Caesar Augustus and Augustus Caesar, between the two is one more correct than the other? Or does it not matter in what order the name is said?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Why was French food (and culture) so popular in Russia during Napoleon's invasion? Why wasn't there a backlash?

Hello

I'm working on a Russian/Ukrainian cookbook which includes a bit of history. I understand how Western (and specifically French) food and culture came to be popular in Russia in the 18th and 19th centuries.

My question is why there wasn't a backlash against it given the political situation, specifically Napoleon invading Russia in 1812. Or was there? I know there were slavophile movements but they seem more of a protest against Westernization in general.

I'm just having a hard time writing, like, "French food was all the rage. Then Napoleon invaded and everyone hated him. But French food remained popular regardless." Or is that really all there was to it?

Hope my question makes sense. Thank you!

1 Answers 2016-06-09

What books can you recommend about the Yugoslav war in the 90's?

I have recently watch the miniseries Death of Yugoslavia. It was extremely fascinating to hear all of the major players give their take on what had happened, considering this was before any war crimes had been prosecuted and the conflict still wouldn't be over for another 6 years. Now that the series is 21 years old, I would like a good book to compare what was known during the conflict to what is known now. What would you guys recommend?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Do we know the exact route Hannibal took through the Alps?

Just a curiousity that came up recently for me, but do we know the exact route Hannibal and his army took and if so, have we found any evidence left behind?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

A stereotypical form of address in Communist countries is "comrade". Did any tropes exist in fascist or other authoritarian governments?

E.g. as "comrade" is thought to have Iberian influences, did Francoist Spain have a similar address?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Do we know when exactly the worship of the Norse gods (Asatru) began in Scandinavia?

I'm Danish myself, and a casual history buff who loves to have a well organized timeline in my head chronicling when various historical events happened in relation to other historical events.

But one of the things I'm surprised I've been unable to find specific, readily available information on is the timeline of Norse Mythology. I know most of what we know about it comes from the 13th century Icelandic sources, so it can be difficult to extrapolate an exact timeline from those, but do Historians have any idea when organized belief in Norse Gods - as we know them (Odin, Thor, Loki, Baldr Freya etc.) - began?

I've always been under the impression it started sometime after the fall of the Western Roman Empire, but could it have begun earlier, concurrently with Christianity perhaps?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Fiction makes such a big deal of British, US and Soviet spies. In the end, how important were they really in ending (or surviving) the Cold War?

Were secret agents and espionage in any way the decisive margin for who won the Cold War?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

How did the obscenely rich ancient Romans store their wealth?

According to this wiki page:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wealthiest_historical_figures#Antiquity

Marcus Crassus was at one point worth 170 million sesterces, which I understand is a coin. How was this wealth held? I assume this includes assets to, but he would still surely hold a large sum of it in spendable cash. Did he just have a big vault of coins somewhere? Or was it converted and held in an expensive form like gold? Or did banks hold it and record it on a ledger? If so, did the banks just have big vaults of coins/gold, or was a lot of the money non-physical like it is today?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wealthiest_historical_figures#Antiquity

2 Answers 2016-06-09

Were there Germans that voted for the NSDAP as some form of protest and not because they agreed with their ideology?

Hello!

I'm not sure if the question in the title makes an awful lot of sense in the way I phrased it so maybe an example will make it clearer.

Currently, around 75% of the votes the German AfD got in elections were votes people cast out of protest against Merkel's refugee policies. All the other ideas that party stands for were apparently irrelevant to those 75%.

Did something similar happen in the Weimar Republic? Like, did people vote the NSDAP because they were fed up with the economy crisis but didn't really subscribe to any other of the NSDAP's ideas?

I can't imagine it being a lot but then again I also can't imagine voting for them at all even out of protest so what do I know...

2 Answers 2016-06-09

What is the historical significance of the Taiping Rebellion and how is it perceived in China today?

The first part of the question is basically, would the Opium Wars or Chinese history in general be any different if the rebellion didn't happen?

The second part would be, is it perceived as a part of the general foreign Western incursion into 19. century China or a separated event?

Also because the wikipedia article mentions a nationalistic anti-Manchu/anti-Qing element as being one of the driving forces of the rebellion, is there any sort of positive interpretation of this rebellion in modern China despite it being Christian, considering how negatively the Qing dynasty is viewed?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

In HBO's "Rome" (set during Caesar's civil war), there is a scene in which one character has never heard of the Gracchi or Gaius Marius. Would this have been at all possible?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

How good is Christopher Matthew's scholarship?

This book came up for me in my Amazon feed today, and it has me wondering whether or not it's worth buying this book. From the very little I've been able to gather on the internet, Matthews apparently accepts the idea of a two piece pike, which I thought was largely agreed to be a misinterpretation of the archaeological find, and apparently some of his methodology in A Storm of Spears was flawed. I'm also uneasy about his application of Alan William's energy values for penetration of mild steel to bronze which, while in the same range of hardness, could well have different mechanical properties that alters the energy requirements for penetration.

This leaves me wondering: just how good is Christopher Matthew's scholarship, and is it worth buying the book? Are there any authors who examine the subject better or in more detail?

4 Answers 2016-06-09

What Cleopatra *really* a degenerate drug addict?

In HBOs Rome series, Cleopatra is frequently portrayed as a highly drug addled, hedonistic individual. She is mainly shown smoking heroin and cannabis.

Yet, many modern histories of Ancient Rome prioritise her political role, whilst sections on her personality is focused on her talent for seduction and/or political intrigue.

Is there any evidence or "reliable" historical accounts of Cleopatra's relationship with drugs? Any answers or recommended reading would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2016-06-09

Why was the art of sword fighting kept alive only in Japan?

In the latest Dan Carlin podcast on Persians, he mentions in passing that historians try to reimagine sword fighting as those skills are lost in time in most of the world except in some places like Japan. Considering that swords are so common in popular entertainment, I never realized that what is shown is probably not how it actually happened.

When did sword fighting disappear in different regions? I guess that the Samurai kept the art of sword fighting alive till the Meiji restoration, which may explain why it was passed down to our times. However, why did it disappear in other places?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

What is the history of religion in China like?

Obviously when people think of Asia, they think of buddhism, but is there a more in-depth and diverse history of Religion in China?

1 Answers 2016-06-09

What are some good books on military tactics and war strategies used by cultures over the generations?

I wasn't sure where to take this question so figured I'd just ask a historian. I'm writing a war film and need as much info on how war is conducted as possible.

4 Answers 2016-06-09

What is the earliest year we could go back to with relative certainty that there is nothing that the US government is still classifying?

Not sure if I phrased this question correctly. What I mean by this is, I think pretty much every "government secret" before WWII has been declassified to the best of our knowledge? I'm wondering if there is an exact year we can go to where everything that happened before that has been fully declassified to the best of the government's ability.

2 Answers 2016-06-09

How common was the knowledge that the Earth was round in Antiquity to the Middle Ages?

I know that the 'Christopher Columbus proved Europe wrong about the Earth being flat!' thing is blatantly false, I also know that Greek scientists discovered it many, many years before and it was the commonly accepted model among scientists for many centuries after that, but what about the common people? I know the Printing Press existed for about 50 years after Columbus 'proved' it was round, but before then when books weren't as widely published or available, would the common people (Of any variety--Roman citizens, Peasants, etc. Basically, people who weren't scientists and philosophers) have known that the Earth was round?

3 Answers 2016-06-09

The nutcracker. Ballet and its lasting impact.

I understand how music can be written and passed throughout generations, with sheet music and a mathematical reason. I don't however understand how dance can be transcribed and made official. Any insight on this would be greatly appreciated.

2 Answers 2016-06-09

What was the population of Athens during the Peloponnesian War?

I was reading this article and it said Athens was ruled by "the 400" during the time. What was the population then?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athenian_coup_of_411_BC

1 Answers 2016-06-09

4204 / 7255

Back to start