Looking for a citation: Intellectuals in Victorian England loved to classify/categorize EVERYTHING

I'm writing an essay on Victorian England, and at the root of it is the claim that the Victorians had a fascination for classification.

Ideas that emerged mostly in the Victorian era:

  • Evolution
  • Sexology
  • Psychoanalysis

I've even found sources that say the rooms within the home would ideally only be used for one specific function. So, you could ONLY sleep in a bedroom, cook in a kitchen, read in a library, etc (though this tended not to apply to lower class families for obvious reasons).

Could anyone help me to simply find a source that agrees with the fact that the Victorians liked to classify things? i.e., they were unusually keen on/pioneered that sort of mindset.

And, of course, if anyone wants to smack my essay in the face, please let me know if I'm completely wrong about this assertion.

2 Answers 2016-04-27

How were miners and other non-skilled, non-agricultural labourers paid in medieval Europe?

Hello,

I have a question about medieval working conditions: There are a lot of medieval mineshafts under the city I live in, and I was wondering how miners made their living under the feudal system where land was key. Obviously, farmers would grow what they needed and sell the rest/give it to their lord as tribute. Miners couldn't eat silver or gold etc, so how did they get paid? Did they sell the coal themselves, or did it belong to their lord?

I'm also interested in other non-agricultural but non-skilled jobs at the time and how they worked.

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Why was the Eagle the symbol of the Roman Legion if their mythological animal was the Capitoline Wolf?

Asked this question a few months ago, never got an answer, still interested in knowing.

2 Answers 2016-04-27

There was a building at the east end of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool between the pool and the Washington Monument. Can anyone help me find more info on this building? I have two images in the text.

http://imgur.com/bBie2hA https://www.flickr.com/photos/rock_creek/4016109667

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Please help me understand what role the longsword actually played on the medieval battlefield. Was it ever a primary weapon? I am speaking of the European hand-and-a-half or "bastard" sword, the typical longsword, not an arming sword from an earlier age of sword and shield

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Please could somebody help me understand the rise (and fall) of 'politeness' in England? (c.1680-1820)

Who wanted to be polite? Why? When? What ideas replaced this?

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Why exactly did different armies/cultures/peoples use different weapons?

I've contemplated asking this for a while now.

This may stem from my lack of knowledge, but in my eyes certain weapons are associated with certain cultures/people. Axes and the like with Vikings or Germanic peoples, and Egypt (or whatever the region would have been known as) and things like the Kopesh.

Does this arise for a practical purpose? Did they design these weapons specifically to overcome some problem? Or did they appropriate the weapon from tools they've used. Was it something cultural?

It seems like there should be a reason that certain regions used certain weapons provided I'm correct that they did in the first place, for all i know this could be a pop-history understanding that plays out in popular culture but is in no way historically accurate.

I'm not particularly sure what time period specifically I'd like an answer for, but I imagine the Viking age and what ever age the Kopesh was used is what I had in mind, and explanations as to why they were used as weapons.

1 Answers 2016-04-27

[META] "Check the FAQ" and Other Non-responses

I'm interested in hearing if other people have a similar take on this or not. There's seems to have been some discussion on it in a popular thread today, but those comments were deleted in accordance with the subs rules. Not complaining about that in any way.

To me, this is the correct way to refer someone to a previous answer. It provided the link, but also the information OP was looking for. It also led to further discussion.

There are plenty of examples of people being less than tactful in pointing to the FAQ. And even more examples of people being tactful, yet still killing all discussion. That's probably not intentional as they are pointing OP in the right direction, but it still happens.

I understand that "use the search tool" and "RTFM" are time-honored staples of Internet forums, but I'm wondering if just utilizing PMs is a better way to accomplish this.

Most of the flaIred users probably wouldn't be discouraged from adding to the thread anyway, but some non-flaired users with the requisite knowledge might.

The other thing I seem to be noticing more are responses along the lines of, "This is a very broad question."

Again, I've seen this done in a way that gets OP information and fosters discussion.

I don't know that a new rule is necessary because there are great answers in the FAQ that people might not otherwise see. Just wondering if I'm alone in feeling like it's cutting off what could be good dialogue.

It also just struck me that for some reason I think meta threads need to be approved. Is that the case? Hopefully I didn't just type that all for no reason.

1 Answers 2016-04-27

What stopped the Ottomans from expanding into Iran?

The Ottomans fought several wars against various Iranian dynasties throughout their reign. Why did they focus their territorial conquests north and west, instead of aiming to control this constant threat?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

What did Native Americans think of tornadoes before (or during) colonial times?

I don't need a specific tribe or time period, any information on how they handled, survived through, and what they thought of more extreme weather hazards would be awesome!

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Has a non-presumptive Presidential candidate ever named a running mate like Cruz just name Fiorina?

Ted Cruz is naming Carly Fiorina as his running mate. Naming a running mate was generally something a nominee did at Convention. While last cycle Mitt Romney named Paul Ryan his running mate before the convention he was, at that time, the presumptive nominee.

Ted Cruz is decidedly not the presumptive nominee of the Republican Party. Are there any other examples of Presidential candidates naming their running mate when the outcome of the primary was still in question/not looking to go their way?

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Why did the Qin dynasty use the color black to represent the Water element, and not blue?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Why was the Russian Revolution of 1917 Successful While the Revolution in 1905 Wasn't?

Also, weren't there more troops mobolized at the time of the revolution in 1917 so shouldn't it of been easier to put down?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Where did we get the 'classic' depiction of a vampire from?

No facial hair, thick eastern european accent, and other characterizations that seem to fit the mold of the iconic figures in cinematic horror.

2 Answers 2016-04-27

When the Ottoman Empire conquered the Byzantine Empire, why did they allow the Christian Armenians to remain in communities in the population ultimately resulting in the Armenian Genocide?

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Before Greek independence, what was the geographical extent of "Greece", as a region?

I read that before Greek independence, Anatolia was also referred to as Greece.

Before the Greek War of Independence, when someone educated spoke of "Greece" in the Modern Sense, how far did that area encompass?

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Is genocide a relatively modern invention?

Are there examples of genocide in the ancient or classical world? The first thing that came to my head was Rome's destruction of Carthage, but they were destroying a city, and not a people, so would this count?

2 Answers 2016-04-27

The 4 types of "eaters" (wheat, corn, rice, and...?)

So the other day, my Latin American history professor mentioned the idea of the "wheat eaters" and "corn eaters". He said repeatedly that there was 4, and after I looked it up I could only find 3, the other being "rice eaters" (obviously from east Asia). However, I could not find out what the fourth one is. I would assume it's something about Africa since Europeans, Native Americans, and east Asians are covered already.

Thank you!

4 Answers 2016-04-27

What would happen to a white person during segregation who intentionally used "colored" facilities as a form of protest?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

When learning about U.S. History, it seems that the narrative is that of the executive office. What historians have done the most admirable work documenting Congressional History?

I would love to learn about the most pivotal and powerful floor speeches. What are considered the most important votes that have changed the tide of history? Greatest filibusters? How have the rules of the Senate and the House evolved over time? What were the most powerful congresses and what were the weakest?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

In general, how accurate do you find the CaspianReport's 'History of Islam' series?

Link (~100 minutes in total, for those interested)

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Can you recommend some good "layperson" books on the 1920s?

I'm looking for non-fiction books. Can be topic specific, but would appreciate a few broad overview. I find the era so fascinating. Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-04-27

Can anyone recommend a reputable book on the election of 1860?

Due to the current republican primary contest the history of contentious american presidential elections has caught my eye, and the election of 1860 has caught my eye in particular. I've been trying to find good books on the subject but am having some difficulty determining which books are by reputable historians.

Can anyone please suggest a good book by a reputable historian on the topic of the election of 1860, or other contentious american elections?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

How did people in the middle ages light candles?

did they always have a fire going somewhere and transfer? or was it flint and steel?

1 Answers 2016-04-27

Why are American Indians stereotypically humorless?

We aren't.

EDIT:

"There is scarcely anything so exasperating to me as the idea that the natives of this country have no sense of humor and no faculty for mirth. This phase of their character is well understood by those whose fortune or misfortune it has been to live among them day in and day out at their homes. I don't believe I ever heard a real hearty laugh away from the Indians' fireside. I have often spent an entire evening in laughing with them until I could laugh no more. There are evenings when the recognized wit or story-teller of the village gives a free entertainment which keeps the rest of the community in a convulsive state until he leaves them. However, Indian humor consists as much in the gestures and inflections of the voice as in words, and is really untranslatable."

1 Answers 2016-04-27

4320 / 7255

Back to start