What mistakes did the British make to lose the US War of Independence, and could they have won it?

From Crown to Colonials.

6 Answers 2016-04-13

Why did the US stop at the Canadian border when it was establishing what belonged to them?

2 Answers 2016-04-13

Some book recommendations on the prehistory and dark ages of Northern (Scandinavian) Europe.

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-04-13

So how exactly did the Holy Roman Empire work

Was it named because it wasn't an empire wasn't Roman and wasn't holy

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Why were Late Antique bishops so often hostile to itinerant monks and "holy men"?

To add a little context, I'm familiar with St. Augustine more than other bishops; I'm specifically thinking of works such as his "On the work of monks", where he contrasts the virtues of a monastic lifestyle with what he portrays as greedy travelling ascetics; was this a widely held attitude or a prejudice that was quite specific to him?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

How did the Christian view of the end times change? Did some loose faith when the apocalypse never happened?

I think i saw a thread on this, but no matter what i search i cannot find it.

From what i understand many early christians (thinking mostly about romans, but also medieval) believed that the end times was something that was not far off? When nothing happened after century after century was there any change in christian canon?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

How credible are theories that native Americans were responsible for the extinction of many new world mega fauna?

How were these theories developed and propagated? We're there any bias to accuse native Americans to paint in a light as irresponsible? After hearing theories of cataclysmic events as a potential cause for the extinction of fauna such as; Saber tooth tiger, wooly mammoth, wooly camels, etc... Is there any evidence to disprove one or the other?

2 Answers 2016-04-13

Has a communist state ever achieved stability & success without mass deaths/ending with dictatorships?

Hey /r/AskHistoarians

Recently, the whole 'resist capitalism' movement has taken steam & a lot of pro-communist supporters are joining in & pushing their ideology. Which is fine, I believe we should have more options on the table then just capitalism. However, as a man who knows a thing or two about history, I can not recall state communism ever working. I also know that history repeats itself. And in this case, a lot.

Stalin, Mao, Lenin, Castro, The Kim Dynasty, Pol Pot, Minh & Khrushchev have at least over 100 million deaths in their collective hands combined. From famine, political assassinations, death from forced labor, proxy wars with the west, even more famine, mass murder and other unspeakable atrocities. As I see it, communism only works in theory but fails horribly in practice.

So, has there ever been a state that was successful without millions of civilians dying? Also, did I get anything wrong in what I posted above? Thank you in advance!

2 Answers 2016-04-13

why is the invasion of Poland considered the start of ww2 and not the second Sino-Japanese war

2 Answers 2016-04-13

What movies/books do you recommend on the IRA and Irish Independence?

I'll be visiting Ireland soon and I've always been interested in knowing more about the IRA and Ireland's history. I'd like to watch a series of documentaries and read some books, preferably in chronological order of the events taking place so I can frame each more recent event in light of the previous events.

Currently on my list is this one: https://www.reddit.com/r/Documentaries/comments/4crofy/1916_the_irish_rebellion_2016_narrated_by_liam/

I'd like to have a good understanding of how far back the IRA's history goes and how it transformed over the years of it's existence.

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Where trenches from WWI in Europe used at all in WWII?

I ask this question because of a post in r/pics showing a picture of a trench from WWI taken in the last few years. It was suprising to see how well you could it even today.

2 Answers 2016-04-13

Aside from baseball, was soccer one of the most popular professional sports of 1920s America?

I've read that professional soccer (football for most non-Americans) was popular in the 1920s in the United States, competing with football as the second most popular sport in the country aside from . Was soccer really that popular? And if so, why did it lose popularity?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Why were there so many famous pitched battles in ancient history?

It seems to me like it required a lot of organisation and expense to arrange a mass battle on the field. From what I've heard, most battles were skirmishes, sieges or raids for pillaging, because that's what generally won a war.

Why then, were there pitched battles? What examples can be drawn up for why this was, at times, necessary?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Why does every school teach the French Revolution?

At least it was taught in my highschool.

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Modern firearms have safeties. When did safeties develop? Would crossbows during the Crusades have safeties? What about Chinese crossbows from the Warring States Period and repeating crossbows?

2 Answers 2016-04-13

Is there any really good novel that revolves around the events of the Wars of the Roses?

I am really interested in learning more about the Wars of the Roses (for many reasons, not the least of which being that they are allegedly what George R.R. Martin based his novels on)? Everything I have read has been very dry, complex and frankly, boring. Is there any novel that really places you into the lives of the people involved in this conflict as opposed to being a history textbook?

2 Answers 2016-04-13

How close was Douglas MacArthur to actually nuking North Korea.

I have heard that the reason Douglas MacArthur lost command during the Korean War was his insistence on using nuclear weapons on China and North Korea. How close were we to actually nuking them and what would have happened if we did?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Battle of the Bulge bring-backs

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Despite a millenia-long tradition, Sun Tzu's Art of War is the only work of Chinese literature that most Westerners can identify. Why is this?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

I've heard a theory that Christianity caused the downfall of the Roman Empire, what exactly do they mean by that, and how true is such a claim?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

How did people keep leftovers before refrigeration?

Suppose someone in the 18th or 19th century made too much soup or had leftover roast from dinner. How would they keep something like that to safely eat the next day?

1 Answers 2016-04-13

Can you recommend a good American history podcast. Details inside.

I am an American living in the UK and they completely gloss over any US history. While I have a history degree, my children are missing a big part of their history. My wife doesn't really like it when I go on and on about history with my kids, so I am hoping for something that I can play for them in the car or the like.

1 Answers 2016-04-13

How did the symbol for the dollar($) come about?

Whats's the origin of the dollar symbol and has it been used to represent money/ other currencies prior to its use as the representation of the Dollar?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

Why is there a historical consensus among scholars/historians that the historical figure of Jesus existed?

Generally speaking there is a consensus that Jesus, as a historical figure, existed, and that the Christ Myth Theory is wrong. I cannot find many arguments on the internet supporting the existence of a historical Jesus however, whilst CM Theory is readily available. How is it that the disbelief in a historical Jesus is such a rejected concept among scholars and historians?

4 Answers 2016-04-12

Why didn't Norway join the European Union?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

4357 / 7255

Back to start