Was spying hyped up to hide the breaking of enigma?

Since 1973 we've known about the breaking of enigma but how did people explain the intelligence before hand?

Was post war stories about spies and resistance movements hyped up in their scale/importance/effectiveness at gather intelligence? Not that I'm saying these weren't important activities but were they given the credit for things we now know was Ultra?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

What motivated the Apportionment Act of 1911?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

Have we discovered stone age archaeological sites underwater (where old coasts existed before sea level rise)? If so, what have we learned? Are efforts ongoing?

In geology the other day we were discussing how much the coastlines have retreated due to sea rise from the melting glaciers. We also talked about how around 50% of the world population lives near a coast. I was wondering, since humans tend to live near coasts, there were probably many stone age settlements that are now underwater. It kills me to think that there's potentially a good chunk of our past is underwater. Have any underwater sites from this era been discovered? Have there been or are there any ongoing attempts to explore the former coasts for human archaeological sites? If so, what have we learned so far?

ETA: Thank you for all of your responses and resources so far... it's all incredibly interesting to me.

4 Answers 2016-04-12

Were there any examples of armor being "proofed" by spears, arrows, ect. before the invention of gunpowder weapons?

For instance a 16th century breastplate might be shot by a pistol to show it was "pistol-proof". Are there any examples of armor from the early middle ages being "spear-proofed" or "axe-proofed".

1 Answers 2016-04-12

After the Glorious Revolution, William and Mary ruled as co-monarchs. How was power shared between the two? Why didn't Mary rule alone?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

In light of today's "Marilyn Moment" scandal in the UK, I'm looking for a historical moment in India...

I know I saw references to it in the Mehrangh Fort in Jodhpur, India but I can't find anything online. Here is what I remember (quite fuzzy):

  • When a royal woman of the ruling clan of Jodhpur state visited England, the public was fascinated that she maintained purda and was carried about in an upright litter. At some point, someone got a photo of her ankle and published it in the paper. The royal woman's people went and bought every copy to protect her privacy.

Anyone got any sources on this? I appreciate it.

1 Answers 2016-04-12

What would the armies at the Battle of Tours (733) look like?

To clarify, I'm interested in what type of weapons and armor the Franks and Muslims would be using.

2 Answers 2016-04-12

Martha Washington's Looks

Is there much evidence beyond what is in [this] (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/02/01/AR2009020102023.html?sid=ST2009020201419) article to support Martha Washington looking like [this] (http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/04/71/35/1283939/3/920x920.jpg) in her younger years?

The article itself addresses this being revisionist. Is it?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

What was the large island Diodorus mentions the Phoenicians visited west of Africa?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-04-12

By the end of the Qing Dynasty, how "Manchu" were the Qings and the Ruling Classes?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

How was the Summer of Love financed?

I've been watching some documentaries on the 60s, and I'm a little confused about the day-to-day functioning of hippie movement, especially during the Summer of Love.

It seems like few, if any, in the movement were working or making money. There were "free shops", offering goods for no cost, and there were a lot of communal activities like free meals. But who was supplying these basic goods if no one was actually making any money? Where was the money coming from?

Was the movement supported by outside money (e.g., trust funds, parental allowances, savings)? Did the hippies go into debt to support their lifestyle?

Some of their events must have cost a significant amount of money to host, but contributions from the community had to have been minimal - money has to be coming from somewhere! Were they supported by "hippie tourism"?

Thanks guys!

2 Answers 2016-04-12

Hinduism and Islam have coexisted for more than 700 years. How have they influenced each other in South and Southeast Asia?

2 Answers 2016-04-12

How did the price of a horse in the UK change from just before WW1 to just before WW2?

I know that the world horse population peaked just before WW1 and that horses died at a staggering pace all over the continent during the war. Dying from poor conditions, overwork, lack of food, and even being blown up by artillery.

However, I also know that the industrialized world was moving towards more reliance on the automobile/tractor than the horse during the same period. Also that horses were being phased out of military use in the UK at this time.

There's multiple kinds of horses, so one suited to pulling a plow or a carriage will suffice.

1 Answers 2016-04-12

Did the US government make a conscious decision to support highway over railway infrastructure after seeing damage inflicted to rail operations in Europe during WWII?

Someone who is an aide in a high school history classroom told me she heard this from a teacher in class. It sounds plausible but I wonder if it's true.

2 Answers 2016-04-12

What do we know about water rights and tenure in Imperial Rome? Was all water public or could water be private property?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

Tuesday Trivia | Famous and Not-so-Famous Historical Firsts

Previous weeks' Tuesday Trivias and the complete upcoming schedule.

Happy Russian Cosmonaut Day! In the spirit of the first human in space, here’s an open space to talk about other famous firsts. You can take this any way you like, it can be first-person-who-did-x, or it can be first examples of something, like the first email or telephone call, or anything else you can think up. Or you can do a little mythbusting about historical firsts!

Next week on Tuesday Trivia: April is National Poetry Month, as we all know. So we’ll share our favorite poems from history!

And you may notice if you click the schedule that my trivia bag is a dangerously low on prompts, so if you have any cool ideas, please send them in!

3 Answers 2016-04-12

Where there a lot of people in 17th, 18th century Europe that opposed their country colonizing the New World?

(i.e. English, French, Spanish citizens) You hear a lot about the motivation provided by the governments in the form of promise of "God, Gold, and Glory", but just like in any political issue, were there people who openly opposed it?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

Why did Napoleon fail to create a lasting French empire?

I just finished Napoleon: A Life by Andrew Roberts. I highly recommend it.

Napoleon seemed to be superior to all of his contemporaries at waging war. As a result, he greatly expanded France's territories and influence.

Yet despite his superiority, Napoleon lost his empire. How is it that a man of such superiority to his enemies couldn't convert his successes into long-lasting accomplishments?

Some issues spring to mind. Why couldn't Napoleon stay out of war? Why did everyone in Europe team up against him, and could he have prevented them from doing so? Why did he make the mistake of invading Russia? Why did he make so many mistakes during the Waterloo campaign? Etc.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-04-12

"Second class citizens" in the pre-WW1 European empires? (Especially Austria-Hungary)

I'v heard from a youtube video (link at the end) that there were practically no high rank personnel who was of south slavic descent(Croats, Serbs, etc..) in Austro-Hungarian army, with very few exceptions of course. So why was that, did Austrians view them as second class citizens? or was there any serious discrimination of that kind in any other european power of that period?

thanks and sorry if i made english mistakes. video: /watch?v=Efaq1_yc61A&list=UUUcyEsEjhPEDf69RRVhRh4A

1 Answers 2016-04-12

The Kurds were split apart after the fall of the Ottoman Empire after WWI. How did the Kurds feel about this and is their separate "autonomy" enough to keep them satisfied?

I am specifically interested in knowing more about their revolts in the 1920s and 1960s. Who stopped them from becoming a country and why?

Did/do they have a large amount of oil in their defined borders?

Is there anything specific besides land that Iraq, Iran, Syria, and Turkey stand to lose by a separate Kurdish state?

2 Answers 2016-04-12

How much did the average person in a medieval village or town know about the surrounding geography?

I've always taken it for granted that I know the general layout of the entire planet, and certainly the layout of my country and my continent. But how much would someone in the distant past know about that?

For example, would someone living in some small town or village in the middle ages (or earlier) know where the capital of their country is? Or the rough shape and size of their nation? If they didn't, how would they go about finding it out? Were there maps they could access at a library?

2 Answers 2016-04-12

I am an average Christian in the 2nd century AD. Do I take the story of Genesis literally?

I.E, do I accept that the world was created in six days.

For clarity's sake, let's say I live somewhere in the Roman Empire.

2 Answers 2016-04-12

What do we know of the Publicani? A 12th century heretical sect from England which viewed procreation as a sin.

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-12

How did the "last meal" become a part of the death penalty ritual in the US and where did it originate?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

During history, many languages were first written in one script and are now written in another. Why and how did these changes from one way of writing to another happen?

(This is a bit of an obscure example but this is the most prominent one I've read about since I'm a Pakistani.) For example, the language Punjabi was first written in the Gurmukhi script, but during the later years of the mughals it started to get written in Arabic script and that's how it's still written today. Why and how did changes like these happen?

1 Answers 2016-04-12

4359 / 7255

Back to start