Was there any pre WW1 war doctrine on Trench warfare?

1 Answers 2016-04-06

What caused Scandinavian countries to develop such liberal and socialist policies?

3 Answers 2016-04-06

Aviation and American history buffs, would you please help me identify a World War 2 plane?

Here's the best picture I could find.

http://i.imgur.com/bwcByiEh.jpg

Could you please help me identify the plane behind my girlfriend's grandfather right here? This is a World War 2 picture by the way.

And any other additional information would be greatly appreciated as well.

4 Answers 2016-04-06

How did Stalin decide who got purged?

I know that Stalin was extremely paranoid and he had a ton of people shot for really tenuous reasons, but it seems to me that a lot of times it was completely random. People like Bukharin and Tuchachevesky never were a threat to Stalins power, but they were killed anyway. Same with Rykov.

1 Answers 2016-04-06

In his new book "The Silk Roads," Peter Frankopan asserts that food shortages were a direct cause of the Holocaust - how widely accepted is this theory?

Specifically, he states that it was caused by the failure of newly conquered lands in Russia, Ukraine, and the western steppes to generate wheat in sufficient quantities to meet Germany's needs. "Faced with chronic problems in Russia, this casual attitude now hardened into something more formal and more ruthless as it dawned on Nazi planners that the fact that Jews had been gathered in camps meant that mass murder could be accomplished with little difficulty.” (this after previously having intended to simply deport them all to a new homeland somewhere)

While obviously not absolving the Nazis in any way, this is a very different spin on the Holocaust than I'm accustomed to hearing - motivated by callousness and a lack of resources rather than pure malevolence - so I'm curious to know whether it's something with widespread support.

2 Answers 2016-04-06

Did ancients scribes ever make typos? If so, what was done to correct them?

Was it thrown out and started over? Was it acknowledged at all or simply just "crossed out"?

1 Answers 2016-04-06

How did Tourism within the Eastern Bloc operate?

I read Michael David Fox's book Showcasing the Great Experiment about western travellers visiting the Soviet Union in the 1930s, and it got me wondering about how travel worked between eastern bloc countries (once the Eastern Bloc existed- 1950s-1980s). Does anyone know if there were tour operators? Was free (unimpeded) travel and circulation within other Communist nations permitted? Did Poles/Romanians etc. travel into the USSR? And were travel posters and campaigns encouraging tourism possible in Communist countries? Someone needs to write the history of communist tourism, if such a book does not yet exist. If it does, I will read the heck out of it.

2 Answers 2016-04-06

How prevalent was cannabis use in literary and artistic culture in modernist England?

We know that many American authors and artists around the turn of the 20th century could have used cannabis, and some did, but was it remotely the same in English culture? For example, if Virginia Woolf wanted to blaze dank kush could she have?

1 Answers 2016-04-06

Could it be said that the British effectively ended global slavery?

Thanks so much for reading.

I recently was involved in this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/4diurv/cmv_essentially_every_culture_on_earth/

It's my understanding that for all intents and purposes all humanity throughout recorded (and surely before) history everyone was involved in slavery to varying degrees.

The British ended slavery legally within the 1/3 of the earth they controlled and actively suppressed it elsewhere, so can't we say that at least ostensibly "white people participated in and even expanded slavery, but they also eventually enforced the end of it"?

Thanks so much for reading and any potential responses!

1 Answers 2016-04-06

How did English evolve such that we have C, K, Q, Ch, Kh, and ck to give the same hard consonant sound?

tried to be clever with the dashes on either side of the letter to show that it could be only in front of the word, behind the word, or sometimes in between, hope you understood that!

1 Answers 2016-04-06

For how long has there been a sentiment of New York City not being "Real America"?

The last few decades of politics have driven home that a lot of people in the United States feel like New Yorkers aren't real Americans. References are made to this earlier in things like Annie Hall. But I was surprised to see some mention of this in Ron Chernow's biography of Alexander Hamilton as well, which got me thinking - how long has this sentiment been around in a meaningful way, how has it been exploited, and what are some notable examples?

As a possible follow-up: Have other American cities (other than San Francisco and Los Angeles) been subjected to the same widespread "not one of us" denigration?

1 Answers 2016-04-06

What caused the percentage of white incarceration to decrease so much since the early 1900's and the blacks to increase?

2 Answers 2016-04-06

To what extent were Soviet nuclear engineers aware of the flaws inherent in Chernobyl's design at the time it was constructed?

In reading up on the Chernobyl nuclear disaster, I came across an article in the Los Angeles Times from August 1986 which reports that flawed reactor design was a major factor in the catastrophe (a claim which is now known to be true). Relevant excerpt here:

These analysts say that Soviet authorities appear to recognize that operator errors at the Chernobyl plant on the night of April 25-26 were not the sole cause of the accident, and that technical flaws in the reactor's design contributed to the worst accident in the 44-year history of nuclear energy.

In particular, they said, a distinctive feature of the Chernobyl design, which sets it apart from conventional nuclear power plants in most of the world, is its tendency to generate a sudden and uncontrollable burst of power if large steam bubbles, or "voids," are allowed to form in the reactor core, as they did before the accident.

My question is: did the Soviet engineers or the Soviet government know the of the flaws inherent to Chernobyl's reactor design when construction began in 1972? If so, how serious did the engineers or government consider these flaws to be?

2 Answers 2016-04-06

How was the orientation of maps determined (North on top, South on bottom)?

I was looking at the upside Florida map posted earlier in /r/mildlyinteresting and realized that the way our maps are oriented (North on top, South on bottom) must have been chosen at some point in history. I mean we could have maps with Antarctica on the top if this was how early topographers decided to orient their maps. Is there any explanation as to how this was determined? I tried looking this up but only got articles for Kim Kardashian and how she chose North as her baby's name.

1 Answers 2016-04-06

I visited a ruined monastery in the Norfolk Broads today. One of the info points said that peasants broke in a burnt all the church records during the revolt in 1381. Why would they do that? weren't most/all English peasants Catholic at the time?

Wouldn't they have been worried about facing damnation for attacking a monastery?

1 Answers 2016-04-06

Book on America's various regional subcultures?

I am looking at Woodard's American Nations and Garreau's The Nine Nations of Noth America. I'm limited on funds, and I don't have the time to fact check what I read, so I was wondering if someone here can recommend one as more historically credible. Or any third option if you have one. Thanks

1 Answers 2016-04-06

Can anyone direct me to a website or book on the Tlingit civilizations symbols and meaning?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-04-06

How would the super rich of the late 19th century have spent their money?

Today we hear about the super rich buying expensive yachts, mansions, cars, house around the world and more and more outrageous things. But how would the richest people of the 19th century have spent their money?

1 Answers 2016-04-05

How come settlers didn't contract diseases from native and aboriginal peoples but were still able to spread them?

1 Answers 2016-04-05

AMA The British History Podcast: The Challenges of Communicating History and Covering Britain from Pre-History to the Ninth Century CE.

Hello, I'm Jamie Jeffers, the creator and host of The British History Podcast. The BHP is a chronological telling of the history of Britain and has been running for the last five years. Currently, we are right on the eve of the establishment of Danelaw. The show itself takes a multi-disciplinary approach and attempts to create a three dimensional picture of the past by looking not only at the written record and the accounts of kings, but also at cultural history, archaeology, geography, and virtually every other piece of data I can get my hands on. We also try to make it very clear to the audience when something is unknown (which is quite common in the Middle Ages) and we encourage the listeners to practice their critical thinking skills when weighing a historical account. So beyond merely popularizing a long neglected area of history, we also hope to encourage people to learn where our knowledge of history comes from and, through that, hopefully value (and fund) the study of history.

You can find the show at http://www.thebritishhistorypodcast.com. To date there are just under 200 freely available episodes, and a nearly 300 episodes in total.

I have a Juris Doctorate and my co-producer is currently completing her PhD at the LSE. My lack of a PhD in History is why I make it very clear that I am not a historian, but rather I'm a history communicator. I research the story, I read endless charters and articles related to them, and then I try to find the story there and communicate that to my audience. The way I see it, my role is to distill the record and do my best to return a sense of humanity to the stories that have been buried in rather dry documents. But when it comes down to it, I am standing on the shoulders of giants like Barbara Yorke and D.P. Kirby.

It was suggested that I post this in advance to give you a chance to submit questions. So here we are. I'll be back at 9am PST on April 6th to start answering questions.

Ask me anything about podcasting, or anything about British history through to the mid-ninth century. No questions are too basic. And while I'm sure some questions are too complex, I'll do my best.

Edit at 9:00am PST Wow, there are already a bunch of great questions. This is going to be fun. I'll answer your questions as quick as I can. Lets get started!

Edit at 2:15pm PST Thanks for having me on, this was a lot of fun. If you have any questions, feel free to post them here and I'll check in for the next several days. Otherwise, you can always contact me at my site (http://www.thebritishhistorypodcast.com), at https://twitter.com/BritishPodcast, and on http://www.facebook.com/BritishHistory

41 Answers 2016-04-05

How were empires such as Byzantium and the Ottomans able to field armies in the tens of thousands (or even 100,000) while western armies a fraction that size had issues with starvation? What were the respective logistical networks like?

1 Answers 2016-04-05

Were the USSR largely responsible for the victory against the Nazis and were the rest of the Allies mostly a glorified mop up crew?

I know the title seems provocative, but I think it describes my question in the best way.

I found this video especially enlightening, which graphically illustrates the deaths during the second world war (most of the following numbers are from this video).

The US lost about 400k soldiers (deaths), the UK also about 400k soldiers and France 200k soldiers. The Nazis lost 600k soldiers fighting in the Western Theater.

The Nazis lost 600k soldiers in Stalingrad alone. So in one single and decisive battle, the Nazis lost as many men as fighting the US, the UK and France in the entirety of the war. 1.2 million soviet soldiers lost their lives in Stalingrad alone.

Overall, the soviets killed 2.3 million Nazi soldiers and lost about 10 million soldiers. Again, the soviets managed to kill roughly 4 times as many Nazi soldiers than the rest of the Allies. And this does not include the civilian lives the USSR lost in the war (about 10 million).

I have the feeling that in the West the predominant sentiment seems to be that the US and the UK saved Europe. But faced with these numbers, this sentiment seems entirely misguided. Isn't it a fair assessment to say that the USSR was the responsible force by a large margin in defeating the Nazis?

It seems to me that we do history a disservice by painting the US as the big liberator. Perhaps this misremembering is due to the cold war. On D-Day 120k US soldiers lost their lives and about the same number of Nazi soldiers. How come D-Day seems more present in our memory than Stalingrad, where more than 10 times as many solders lost their lives?

Perhaps I'm misjudging the strategic impact the rest of the Allies had on the war. But faced with these death tolls, I can only wonder if the USSR broke the neck of the Nazi Reich, and the rest of the Allies were just a glorified mop up crew.

1 Answers 2016-04-05

In light of the recent death of Winston Moseley, has there been any follow up with the witnesses to Kitty Genovese's death?

I am especially curious about Karl Ross, the infamous "I didn't want to get involved" guy. I haven't been able to find anything about anyone though, such as thoughts, beliefs, etc. about what happened. I don't know if there just hasn't been any effort, or if I'm just not searching correctly.

1 Answers 2016-04-05

Help with finding very nitty-gritty sources on the Chinese Civil War (1927-37)!

I'm writing my undergrad thesis on the Chinese Civil War from 1927-37, and I'm specifically looking at why Mao and Chiang teamed up against the Japanese. One of the theories that I'm working with hypothesizes that actors with weaker military forces are more likely to enter into coalitions than those who have stronger military forces. In order to show a correlation, I have to find data on number of enlisted soldiers and number of military hardware (tanks, guns, planes, etc.) that the National Revolutionary Army, the Red Army, and the Imperial Japanese Army had. I can't find this data anywhere, and I was wondering if you guys could help!

1 Answers 2016-04-05

Why did the Japanese flag change after WW2 and how did it go over with people?

1 Answers 2016-04-05

4376 / 7255

Back to start