What does historians do in their everyday work?

2 Answers 2015-12-05

Origins of the concept of "time", and the role it plays today

Though I'm fairly ignorant on the topic itself, it seems like time is an essential element of our daily lives, and as necessary to our modern lives as money, electricity, and coffee. Perhaps more so, some might argue.

At what point in history did we become obsessed with it, and has it changed much in the last few centuries? Additionally, have there been any efforts to change how we keep or view time (aside from Daylight Savings Time, etc.)? Or does it fall into the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" caveat?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Was there ever a historical "Great Depression" that had the same impact as the more recent one in the 1930s?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Is sarcasm modern?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Is there any evidence that Linda Lovelace was forced to act in the pornographic film Deep Throat by being threatened with a gun?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Are there negative accounts of Richard III that don't stem from Tudor sources (Shakespeare/Thomas More)?

This is my second Ricardian post in as many days - sorry, it's becoming a minor obsession!

A common refrain in defence of Richard III is that the unflattering accounts of his reign - his tyranny, bloodlust, child-killing etc - stem from a Tudor bias, specifically the double-barrelled hate-machine that is William Shakespeare and Thomas More, both men with a good reason to underscore a "Bad Richard/Good Henry" narrative.

But is this accurate? What other critical sources do historians draw upon in order to present Ricky 3 as a less than ideal monarch?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Was there any public opprobrium in regards to Johnny Cash playing prison concerts at Folsom and San Quentin in the 1960s? Is he unique in these performances?

I've looked into this myself before posting, but can't find any information on it. It just strikes me that if a modern darling of the music industry were to perform in front of a crowd of violent convicts there'd be a backlash against them. I've always wondered whether Cash faced criticism for doing so.

3 Answers 2015-12-05

Research advice for life in the middle ages?

See, I'm confused because I read that the term and concept of "feudalism" is fabricated and false so I've lost my entire basis for the time period really. I need to get rid of the misconceptions about Medieval society and to get an accurate, if general knowledge of life in the middle ages, economically, military, socially, the whole deal.

So where should I start researching? I'm a student so I can't really throw money around at more expensive books. If it's any help I really just need to know about Western Europe.

Edit: Specifically the High Middle Ages

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Was Gandhi sexist, racist, uncaring about the plight of Untouchables?

Just read an article about the flaws of Gandhi and wondering whether the article is a fair representation of the views of the man or not: https://broadly.vice.com/en_us/article/gandhi-was-a-racist-who-forced-young-girls-to-sleep-in-bed-with-him

From a historian's perspective, are these claims legitimate?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Why did Medieval kings ever feel the need to pay attention to religious figures? Could the Pope actually command real political authority?

2 Answers 2015-12-05

Why didn't France fortify its border with Belgium?

Leading up to WW1, France had a formidable defensive line along its border with Germany but surely someone high up in the French military could surmise that Germany would try to go through Belgium in event of a war. Happened again with the construction of the Maginot line in the lead up to WW2. Relations with Belgium aside, seems like they didn't make a full hearted effort in the defense against Germany.

2 Answers 2015-12-05

Have classical music composers ever been accused of plagiarism?

2 Answers 2015-12-05

What is the link between the modern Russian Coat of Arms and the Habsburg Coat of Arms?

If you look, the Coat of Arms of the Habsburg family is very similar to the modern-day Russian Coat of Arms.

Habsburg Coat of Arms:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/32/Greater_Coat_of_Arms_of_Leopold_II_and_Francis_II%2C_Holy_Roman_Emperors.svg

Russia's Coat of Arms:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f2/Coat_of_Arms_of_the_Russian_Federation.svg

Two eagles (or some other bird), facing opposite ways, underneath a crown. The right eagle holding a globular crown with a cross (what is this item?), the left eagle holding a scepter of some kind.

Obviously, these two coats are quite similar. What is the linkage between the two, and why are they so similar?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Would WW2 tactics be plausible in WW1?

2 Answers 2015-12-05

What is the origin of the nickname "Jim Crows" for members of England's home-guard during WW2?

I'm currently reading the book "Alone" which is part of Winston Churchill's series on World War II. At one point Winston mentions that spotters looking for - and giving warning of - German air raids were eventually known as "Jim Crows. How did this come about? Was this a common nickname?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

I have a question about WWI in general

Okay, so I'm not sure if this is the right sub, but I'm really interested to learn more about the causes and motives behind WWI. I was wondering if you guys could point me in the direction of some books or articles where I could read about this. Or, if you could point me in the direction of the right subreddit I would appreciate that. Thanks guys !

1 Answers 2015-12-05

When did early Christians develop the idea of the Church Fathers and how did the Early Fathers see themselves and thier role in the development of Christianity?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Did the Waffen SS ever try having a sea or air component, or were they strictly a ground fighting force?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

A question about Rommel.

I'm currently watching a bbc documentary called Tankies: Tank Heroes of World War II. In it there's a short clip of Rommel going over plans in the desert and he appears to have a black eye and cut lip!

Has there ever been a reason given for it?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Your best book about the Ottoman Empire ?

I've discovered that it's a civilization I don't know a lot about and would like some suggestions for a good general, easy to find lecture about the Ottomans.

Thanks a lot

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Question about Martin Luther King Jr.

One of my professors mentioned something about MLK getting caught for plagiarism in regards to his doctoral thesis. Is there any real evidence of this?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Were there any army leaders who thought the pike was still relevant in an 18th century field of muskets and cannons?

1 Answers 2015-12-05

What did Roman legionnaires actually do with the land they got after their tour of duty, and could it actually sustain their owners?

Since I was a kid I read about how Roman legionnaires, after finishing their tour of duty, would get some money and a piece of land to settle down on, as a reward. Lately it occurred to me that I never really thought about if that was actually a good deal; just checked if off as "oh, that's nice, guess they'll become farmers then." back then, naively picturing vast rows of neat rectangular plots covering the land.

So my question(s) is/are: Was the piece of land a legionnaire got actually enough to sustain him? Sustain a whole family? (by sustain I mean feed the people and provide enough excess products/materials to be traded for other necessities).

Expanding upon that two other questions:

1.) What did Legionnaires actually do with their land? Really just go their, build a house, start becoming a farmer? It must be more complicated, especially for people that have been professional solders half their life.

2.) How did those lots of land for legionnaires fit into the larger economic picture? Were they mostly isolated, sustaining their owners. Or did they play a larger role, maybe as provider for the military? Did they organize themselves, etc.?

Edit: I am aware of the broad socio-political reasons why Rome would want to settle their veterans in newly conquered lands; by all means feel free to explicate those aspects. The main focus of my question however are the micro- and macro-economic aspects of this topic.

1 Answers 2015-12-05

Why was Japan able to successfully modernize during the late 19th century (early 20th century) while China was not?

I am aware of the fact Japan essentially modernized because of the Meiji restoration, however I am confused as to why the Japanese people were so accepting of this new way of life. I don't get why there weren't any hiccups so to say.

Also China had the opportunity to undergo the same process because during the late 19th century they had their own strengthening movement. The Qing dynasty elite recognized that they had to adopt western technology to better defend themselves, which they did. They built ships and even sent some Chinese students to study in the US. So why did their modernization efforts end there?

I apologize if this post does not abide by this subreddit's rules, I did my best. Also apologies if any of the above information is incorrect please feel free to correct me, thanks!

1 Answers 2015-12-05

During the advent of mass, public education, were reading and math seen as highly specialized skills that most people would never be able to handle?

There's a lot of chatter about programming becoming the third literacy. While there's a large movement to make coding much more popular, there's also a reactionary movement that contends that the average person is not capable of that kind of reasoning and ultimately the effort is futile.

Were reading and math education seen with similar pessimism in the 19th century in this United States? If so, was it common, and how did this attitude change?

EDIT: Someone noticed that I did not mention which country I am referring to.

1 Answers 2015-12-05

4743 / 7255

Back to start