The Five Civilized Tribes adopted and practiced chattel slavery of blacks in the 18th century. When they were forcibly removed from their homelands in the Trail of Tears, they took their slaves with them to their new reservations. Slavery in the tribes was only abolished at the end of the Civil War as a demand of the victorious Union government.
This begs the question; what happened to the freedmen in these societies? What similarities and differences are there between the experiences of Indian freedmen and the experiences of African Americans, from the period immediately after emancipation up to today?
Lastly, my understanding of post-slavery African American history loosely splits the period into four eras: Reconstruction, Jim Crow, Civil Rights, and Post-Civil Rights. How closely (or not) does the history of Indian freedmen movements follow that of African American movements?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
Looking at the major (historical) ports around the North Sea, almost all of them seem to be some distance inland, at least to my knowledge. London, Antwerp, Rotterdam, Amsterdam (which used to require a detour through the Zuiderzee even), and of course Bremen and Hamburg.
I would expect that dealing with the the fluctuations of a river and the depth limits compared to sea would be challenging for a port, especially when compared to to being able to access the sea directly. Yet, most ports directly on the coast that I know of are either primarily fishing harbours or developed in more recent times (like Scheveningen/The Hague, Esbjerg, Folkestone).
So what gives? Was it easier trade with areas further inland, calmer waters, simply more space to dock, all of those at once, or something else?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
I'm well aware that such a date is arbitrary, but although I'm familiar with some other cut-off dates such as 1453, 1492 or even 1481 (which is perhaps convenient for studying the history of France but not for anything else), I don't remember having see the 1520s mentioned until earlier today when I read the author's note of How to slay a dragon.
1 Answers 2021-10-19
1 Answers 2021-10-19
He always seems to fold his arm like this : https://www.lepoint.fr/images/2015/03/13/adolf-hitler-nazi-allemagne-3089324-jpg_2763435_1250x625.JPG why?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
1 Answers 2021-10-19
After eight months of planning, recording, editing, and polishing, the AskHistorians 2021 Digital Conference is finally here! On behalf of its organizing committee, welcome to this year's event.
In 2020, we hosted our first digital conference right here on reddit, and made history by doing so. This year, reddit is officially sponsoring the AskHistorians Digital Conference. Their generosity, as well as the generosity of our Fundrazr contributors has allowed us to make our entire conference free and accessible to anyone with an internet connection and a computer, tablet, or mobile device.
We are thrilled to be able to share this conference with you all over the next three days.
If you are interested in the history of the AskHistorians conference, its background, rationale, and the details of this year's event (including information about the participants, papers, and panels), please check out our conference program, designed by yours truly.
If you'd like to check out some of last year's panels before diving into this year's offerings, you can find those on our YouTube channel.
Otherwise, keep reading to learn more about today's offerings!
This thread contains an overview of today's events, with direct links added as soon as they go live, and an explanation of how to get involved. If you have any questions, leave them below and we'll address them as soon as possible.
Keynote Address (11 AM EDT): "Ned Christie and the Consequences of Fake News" by Dr. Devon Mihesuah of the University of Kansas
Unfortunately, this post says it all: a widespread internet outage affecting our keynote speaker, Dr. Devon Mihesuah, means that we have had to postpone the talk until tomorrow.
The keynote will now take place at the same time (11AM, EDT) tomorrow, Wednesday 20 October.
If you are already signed up for the keynote, you should have received an email confirming the rescheduled time, and you do not need to reregister. If you haven't received the email confirming this rescheduled time, please let us know. The silver lining in all this is that If you would like to come along at the new time tomorrow and haven't yet registered, you can still do so here.
We understand that not all attendees will be able to make the new time tomorrow, and we share your disappointment. We will be doing our best to get a recording live as soon as possible, so that you can catch up on what promises to be a fantastic, timely talk.
Networking Session One (12 PM EDT)
Panel One AMA (1 PM EDT): "The Lie Became the Truth: Locating Trans Narratives in Queer History"
Panel Two AMA (3 PM EDT): "Racism Is So Universal, It's Become Normal: Race, Representation, and Accuracy in Works of Popular Media"
Day Two Panel Livestreams (5 PM EDT)
Panel Three AMA (7 PM EDT): "Players Gonna Play, Play, Play, Play, Play: History in Games, Games in History"
Networking Session Two (9 PM EDT): Trivia with AskHistorians
Watch talks: The central feature of the conference is its collection of recorded talks. These talks have been divided into nine panels of 2–3 speakers, each taking ten minutes to present on their own research before joining in a group discussion with their fellow panelists and an expert moderator. Today's panels were premiered as livestreams yesterday evening and can now be found on our YouTube channel. The recordings will be available indefinitely, so you can always go back and catch up on anything you may have missed!
Ask questions: Each panel will have its own AMA-style Q&A thread where you can ask the speakers anything you'd like to know about their work. These will go live according to the schedule posted above, and will continue as long as the participants feel like answering more questions!
Attend live events: Although our conference panels have all been pre-recorded, they will be premiered at 5 PM EDT as livestreamed talks on YouTube the evening before their associated AMA (hence, Panels One, Two, and Three were livestreamed yesterday evening, and Panels Four, Five, and Six will be livestreamed today at 5 PM EDT). Once they have been premiered, they will be made available indefinitely on the AskHistorians YouTube channel. Additionally, we have a number of live, synchronous events planned for the next three days.
Today's keynote address by Dr. Devon Mihesuah will take place live on Zoom, and you can still register for it here. Don't worry if you're unable to grab tickets though! We'll be releasing a recording of the keynote as soon as possible once it concludes.
As noted above, today's scheduled keynote has been postponed until tomorrow.
Throughout the conference, we will also be hosting live networking sessions for participants and audience members to attend. There will be one networking session focused on talking shop about all things history and one social session focused on chatting and getting to know fellow guests each day.
Today's social session will center around historical trivia! Ever wanted to test your general knowledge against AskHistorians' finest? Come and join us at 9 PM EDT for the first-ever AskHistorians Trivia Night, hosted by u/Starwarsnerd222 and u/Kugelfang52.
Can't make it tonight? There's a rematch scheduled for 8am EDT on Day 2!
You are welcome to register for and attend as many of our networking and social sessions as you like. A full list of these events, and information about registering, can bee found here.
Be a part of the conversation: We'll be treating these daily conference megathreads like our Friday Free-for-Alls: you're welcome to use them to discuss the conference, leave questions or comments, or chat informally about today's papers in this thread. Keep in mind, though, that our rules about civility are still very much in force. You can also follow updates on Twitter via @askhistorians and #AHDC2021. We encourage you to tweet about our conference as well if you'd like. Just remember to tag us and use the #AHDC2021 hashtag!
13 Answers 2021-10-19
I've seen contradicting claims as to the guilt of Gilles de Rais, including on a couple of years old AskHistorians posts so I figure it's worth asking again what the view is on whether or not Gilles de Rais is guilty of what he was acused of.
1 Answers 2021-10-19
When reading into Giolittis reforms I read that Giolitti banned night work in bakeries but there was no reason given and I couldnt think of one?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
Also, First Blood is based on a book published in 1972 right at the end of US involvement in Vietnam. I could not find a similar reference to Agent Orange in the book, but what would have been the understanding of its effects immediately following the Vietnam War?
2 Answers 2021-10-19
By "direct", I mean that they stay in the same ship throughout the whole journey, though they stop at many different ports along the way.
1 Answers 2021-10-19
I've been reading the Commentaries for the first time, and I find it pretty amazing that we have the "voice" of not only a person from so far back, but one of the most important people in Roman history. I've heard that there's a consensus that Caesar himself wrote most of the Commentaries, with Hirtius writing the last book. However, as far as I know, we don't exactly have other written works by Caesar. How, then, did historians come to the conclusion that the text was written by Caesar himself, especially considering that it only refers to him in the third person?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
Did peasants mostly wear woven fabric? (this is my assumption. i dont know much about textiles tho)
Did peasants weave their own fabric? If not, who did? Local village weavers? Or was fabric traded over longer distances from cities?
What fibres? Mostly wool and linen? Any cotton?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
So basically, as the title says, read different sources telling that the carriers won importance after the IS was forced to rely on them after losing some of their ships at Pearl Harbor, and also that they were the primary target of the Japanese. Could someone clarify the situation to me? Thanks in advance
1 Answers 2021-10-19
Pretty much the title. I'm wondering if the first Norse raiders knew where they were going or if they kicked off the Viking Age by accident.
1 Answers 2021-10-19
Did Alexander the Great ever try or suggested conquering Rome or was he never interested in the italian peninsula?
1 Answers 2021-10-19
I know that the Baltic nations were briefly part of the HRE, but not for long, and that would have been a long time before this image was made. So why would the author have seen the Baltic nations as Germanic? Was this a common belief?
1 Answers 2021-10-18
I’ve been reading lately on the involvement of women in the Soviet armed forces during WWII. Not only were they present in the workforce and as nurses, but they also participated heavily (compared to other armies) in the actual combat.
I remember from my WWII class there was a massive ransacking of Germany including a mass rape of German women following the Allies’ victory. IIRC all powers participated but none to the extent of the Soviet troops.
My question is what was the role of female Soviet troops while this was happening? I’d think there had to be some witnesses given they were everywhere from tench ware fare to sniper posts.
Were they complicit? Or were they participants? Were they not present at all? We can speculate all day but are there any resources that actually investigate the phenomenon?
1 Answers 2021-10-18
Reading the IMDB info about the movie, it says that college students in the 1980s would run around campus trying to hunt and shoot each other with paintball weapons. Universities would even promote these activities under various club names. I can't seem to find anything about this on the internet. Does anyone have any resources on this fad?
1 Answers 2021-10-18
This period just seemed really slow compared to timeframes before and after. Most timelines on technology advancement I look at just skip through most of these years as there wasn’t much to tell. I know they’re called the dark ages but just curious what caused this decline or lack of notable innovation for over 1000 years and where would society be now if things were different
1 Answers 2021-10-18
1 Answers 2021-10-18
As a spanish man who never trusted the black legend of the Empire, I have faced serious troubles when trying to write a book about the "revolution of 1820". And since i have critical thinking and i don't want to address the topic from a flawed perspective, i do no longer know which words should i use to describe certain events.
First of all, genocide. This word is problematic in my opinion to describe the early relationships between the conquerors and the natives because as far as i know, there was never a will from the public institutions to kill civilians and most of the deaths that occurred after the arrival were caused by diseases. Nonetheless... Colón. That happened. And i cannot simply ignore it. So... Is it a genocide when a public authority acts against the will of the government (in this case the monarchs) to commit a massacre even tho he was punished because of it? Can i really talk seriously about genocide on this regard?
Second of all, everything related with the word colonial. If natives had the same legal status as those who were born in the metropoli, and those who went there had childs with the natives, is it possible to talk about colonial population? And if the territories spent within their soil most of the resources that were extracted from there, can i really talk about colonies? Being fair, the virreinatos were not even considered different countries, and they did not have more differences among them back then than the ones that Spanish historic nationalities had among themselves.
Third of all... The word in spanish is expolio. I don't know how to say that in english but it means something like robbery or so. And linking it with the last question, in which i claimed that most of the resources were spent there, is it possible to speak about expolio when most of the resources that were subtracted from them were stolen due to corruption of peninsular authorities? This is specially hard to gasp for me because even tho most latin american countries claim that there was indeed, robbery, Catalonians say the same about the central government of Spain nowadays. Even those who live in the capital claim that Spain is stealing their money. So... When everyone is spanish but everyone thinks that the spanish people are stealing their money, can i really talk about robbery?
1 Answers 2021-10-18
Hello everyone!
Tomorrow officially kicks off Day One of the AskHistorians 2021 Digital Conference! We have an amazing slate of content lined up over the next three days, and we want to make sure everyone gets to experience it all. With that in mind, we're rolling out the panel videos for Day One this evening. Each panel offers in exciting look at history, and will be accompanied by a live AMA right here on AskHistorians tomorrow. Be sure not to miss them at the noted time!
AskHistorians 2021 Digital Conference Chair's Welcome and Land Acknowledgement
1 PM ET: The Lie Became the Truth: Locating Trans Narratives in Queer History!
7 PM ET: Players Gonna Play, Play, Play, Play, Play: History in Games, Games in History!
In addition, it isn't too late to register for our keynote address, "Ned Christie and the Consequences of Fake News" by Dr. Devon Mihesuah of the University of Kansas, which is live at 11 AM ET.
6 Answers 2021-10-18