Since blasphemy was a crime punishable by stoning in Biblical times, why wasn't Jesus simply taken out and stoned by the Pharisees?

Why did they let him rise to such power and favor, and why did they bring him to formal trial with the roman governor?

3 Answers 2015-10-04

AskHistorians Booklist is now also available on Goodreads

People have been clamoring for a better Booklist for a long time, and we’ve been listening! We're happy to announce, after a month of tag-team mass data entry, that the Booklist has been copied to Goodreads. Not everyone’s familiar with Goodreads of course, but the basic definition is that it’s a remarkably addictive combo of personal book database and social media platform.

The main thing for us is that with the Goodreads Booklist you can now do two key things people have been asking for: search the list, and easily find books about things other than a specific place and time, for example biographies, political history, women’s history, economic history, etc.

We hope you can now more easily use the 1000+ books recommended by the flairs of AskHistorians!

#Questions?

#Do I need a Goodreads account to use this list?

Nope, our shelves are set to public. If you have an account you will have a slightly better experience though, and of course then you can build your own book lists, and friend us!

#How do find books about a certain subject?

Subject tags are called “shelves” on Goodreads, so just browse our shelves! (full list of shelves is on the left)

#How do I search this book list?

Use the small search bar on our shelves page, just be sure not to use the big search bar by the Goodreads logo. Big search bar searches the entire Goodreads catalog, little search bar searches just our books.

#Can I find books that have been shelved under two subjects, like “Middle Ages” and “Economic History?”

Yes, you can do this, but Goodreads really doesn’t make it obvious:

  1. Click on your first shelf.
  2. Scroll to the bottom of the list of shelves. You will see tiny grey text saying “select multiple.” Click it.
  3. Plus signs appear by the shelves. Click the plus on your second shelf of choice. Or third and fourth!
  4. Books are filtered to your individual requirements.

#Okay I found a book, how do I buy it or get it from the library?

Goodreads makes both of these 1 or 2 click actions, no more copying and pasting to search!

On a book’s specific record there are links to Amazon, Other booksellers, and then Libraries, which goes to Worldcat by default. If you have a Goodreads account you can actually customize these buttons to your preferred bookseller and even your local library catalogs. (And if you have the means, I highly recommend adding in the search buttons for your library, it’s so choice. I’m talking 5 clicks to put a book on your request list.)

#Does this mean you are deleting the wiki list?

Nope. We made a copy on Goodreads for people who asked for a searchable booklist, because this was the easiest way to do it.

#Are documentaries, databases, and all the other non-book things on the Booklist on here?

Unfortunately no, Goodreads only allows for books. Another reason not to retire the wiki list!

#Hey there’s no books about [my favorite thing]!

The Booklist is crowdsourced from the flairs, go sweetly ask your favorite subject expert to give it some books.

7 Answers 2015-10-04

How old is the children's game "hide and seek"?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

When and how did jazz music become jazzy (ie, complicated)?

Jazz, especially early Jazz, was pioneered by African-Americans at a time where blacks weren't given easy access to higher education. But given how musically complicated it can be, how did jazz's "jazziness" come about? Was it more self taught or were early Jazz musicians well versed in music theory? And if they did know a lot of theory, where did they learn it?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Did The Majority Of Atrocities Committed By Communism Happen Under Mao, Stalin, and Pol Pot?

First off to note, I'm not trying to downplay the atrocities that happened under Communism, but I'm just curious about something. The majority of talking points pointing to the large deaths under Communistic regimes often look to The Soviet Union under Stalin, China under Mao, and Cambodia under Pol Pot. However these leaders were not the only Communist dictators that existed. Were killings in other Communist countries or other leaders as numerous or were these three a notable case?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Are there any books you would recommend on the American political realignments in the 1960s (after the New Deal fell apart) forward?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Why did we have the dark ages? After so much forward thinking by the ancient Greeks and technological advances by the Roman Empire- did everyone just forget it? Shun it for some reason? Could we be any more advanced of the dark ages never happened?

2 Answers 2015-10-04

For how long have armies been using the organisational system of Divisions/Brigades/Battalions etc?

I saw a map of the troop placements at the start of a pre-napoleonic battle and the map used four x's to represent each army and then three x's for each corps etc. I also wondered how spatially widespread this system was, for example was it just European/western countries that used it pre-ww2?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Did the Norse colonies of Greenland make contact with any Inuit tribes? If so were there any records of interaction? Conflict? Trade?

I know Erik the Red made contact with Natives in the Americas, I'm just wondering more so if there was a long term relationship between settlements in Greenland and native (sortof, they migrated there) tribes.

Edit: Lief, the son not Erik

3 Answers 2015-10-04

What were the dominant military powers in the 10-15 centuries? (for a video game i'm making)

So I am making a browser-based homage to Age of Empires 2 - game trailer here - and I want for it to be quasi-historically accurate. As a setting, I want to go with the 10-15 centuries, primarily because that was the Feudal era and it falls in line with the theme of the game ("Feudal" Wars). You can view some of the artwork for the different civilizations on the subreddit (r/feudalwars).

I'm not exactly a history buff so I wanted to pick your brains as to what the setting of the game should be like. If you haven't played age of empires (what my game will be like), you essentially start out as a civilization of your choice and you can make buildings, armies with the artwork of the buildings/armies matching the style of the civilization. For example, here is our spanish barracks: http://i.imgur.com/DuA4eD2.png And here is our english barracks: http://i.imgur.com/s5t9AXj.png

One of the problems I'm confronted with is determining which civilizations the game should have. I want to start out with English and Spanish but Spain of course didn't exist from 10-15 and was more divided into kingdoms like Corsica and Leon (right?). I certainly wouldn't mind calling the civ Corsica Castile instead of Spanish and I could use the castilian coat of arms (since that's public domain) but is that historically accurate?

If you had to list the dominant united military powers from 10-15, what would they be? Again, I'm not looking for exact historical accuracy - I just want to portray a "rounded off" version of history. What civilizations would you put in the game and how would you name them? I'm looking for kingdom name and people name (e.g. England / English). I'm also looking to portray civs with distinct architectural styles. For example, 1 of the reasons we chose English and Spanish starting out was because of the distinct architectural styles of the two in the latter middle ages. I'm going to want to have middle eastern and far east civs (Japanese obviously) as well.

I'd appreciate any advice!

5 Answers 2015-10-04

I survived the German Holocaust of WW2, what do my next ten years look like?

Should I stay in germany?

4 Answers 2015-10-04

Why renaissance-men were appreciated throughout history whereas people attracted by different life paths struggle nowadays?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Darkened plate armor in late Medieval/early Modern warfare?

I have read different things about darkened darkened plate armor in warfare. I've heard that darkened armor was for knights who couldn't afford a squire or someone to help them polish their armor, so the darkened color helped prevent rust. I've also seen darkened armor for kings and high military figures (e.g. King Henry VIII's field armor). What is the truth to black/darkened plate armor? Is it a fashion, or is it for practicality? Both?

2 Answers 2015-10-04

Any body have some good sources pertaining to Women and Consumerism during the war years? Specifically 1945.

Currently doing a research project and looking for some secondary sources. It revolves around advertisements aimed at women during the years of World War II. Im trying to prove that this was an uprecedented time not only for women in the work force, but also for women as consumers.

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Were India and China aware/knowledgeable of the other before imperialism?

I'm curious as to if, or how much interaction or contact occurred between India and China before they were imperialized (any time before then. Ancient China and Ancient India, the Qing and the Mughals, etc.). Other than Buddhism being invented in India and spreading to China, I'm not aware of any contact between them.

2 Answers 2015-10-04

Did Ancient Rome have anything like the popular music culture we now enjoy? Were there singers or composers that most people were likely to have heard of? Were there concerts?

Obviously the lack of an ability to preserve recordings of music would have had a huge impact on all of this, but what sort of musical culture existed in spite of this?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

What happened to the families of Romans who were compelled to fall on their swords?

I assume that the forced suicide generally came as a result of some catastrophic cack-up on the part of the individual. Did that shame pass on to their family?

I'm also curious about Japan, same question. Dude gives himself the old harakiri, what happens to his family?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

How bloodless was the Glorious Revolution really?

All the time you hear about how peaceful and devoid of conflict the Glorious Revolution was, but it seems to me unlikely that there wasn't even a bit of unrest, so my question is were there any instances of violence when the revolution occurred or was it really as peaceful as they say?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Looking for literature on British government policy (under Thatcher) regarding the 'football hooliganism' problem

For a dissertation. I'm struggling to find secondary literature that studies government attempts to tackle the phenomenon. Any assistance would be greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Was Rommel a Member of the Nazi Party?

Did Rommel ever actually join the Nazi party officially? There's a lot of confused information on the web about this so proper citations would be appreciated.

EDIT: A lot is riding on this question since I have a bet with my friend. Whoever loses has to buy and read a book of the other person's choosing. And based on the experience of previous similar bets, there's an understanding that an abysmal piece of rubbish of a book will be picked.

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Did the Americans and French really commit attrocities surpassing Hitler in WW2?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2015-10-04

Why were buildings taxed by their width?

Apparently, Houses in several different places (such as Amsterdam during the 17th century for example) were at some period in time taxed by their width. House styles in such places seem to have evolved into very long and thin houses in order to minimize taxation.

I have come across this idea in several European and Japanese cities, mostly in regional trade hubs and harbor towns so I believe there must be an economic reason that made several places choose this form of taxes independently of one another. But what is that reason?

Was it the inability to reliably measure the square area of a building? Was access to the road the actual basis for taxes and by having merchants minimize their roadside exposure, more merchants could trade on the main roads thus generating more revenue for the city?

1 Answers 2015-10-04

Has a language ever been purposely phased out over several generations in favor of a different language?

2 Answers 2015-10-04

What is the furthest city in the East that Alexander the Great conquered?

2 Answers 2015-10-04

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | September 28, 2015–October 04, 2015

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2015-10-04

4920 / 7255

Back to start