How common was it to possess a portrait of the reigning monarch in the late 19th and early 20th century?

In the Netflix series Peaky Blinders the main character Thomas buys all of his neighbors portraits of King George V in burns them in the street to send a message. Would most people in Britain actually have the kings portrait in their homes at the time? If so has this custom persisted or has it largely died out? Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Are there any historical objects who are invented for purpose 'A', but were later used for purpose 'B' instead?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Were there any movements to create self sustaining black-only communities in the American South between Abolishment and the civil rights movement?

Did anyone, particularly black people, attempt to create a community separate from whites? Kind of a "screw you guys, we're going to do our own thing" movement.

Additionally, was there any segregation against whites in black owned businesses or venues?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Is there a mainstream explanation for why a lot of ancient mythology coincides with other civilizations?

I'm talking about how multiple large civilizations spread across the world have very similar stories.

For example: the idea that a 'great flood' occurred sometime along with the nephilim or 'giants'.

Or am I asking a stupid question?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Was Hannibal a military genius? or were his acomplishments exagerated by historians?

The reason I'm asking is because I saw a show in History Channel that showed Hannibal as a tactical genius and another show that presented Hannibal as a mediocre strategist whose acomplishments were exagerated by the Romans in order to make themselves look good for defeating a "military genius". So who is telling the truth?

3 Answers 2015-08-22

Is there a reason February still has 28 days?

I feel like there was at least one chance at some point in history where someone could have fixed it.

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Is there any actual textual or oral evidence for the tradition that a prophet would come out of Arabia (I.e. Muhammad)?

So I've constantly read and heard that the Jewish and Christian communities of Arabia had a prophecy stating that a prophet would arise from the region, and this is usually found in Islamic articles and books as support for Muhammad's claim to prophethood.

Is there any verifiable evidence for such a tradition, preferably prior to Muhammad's era?

EDIT: this is getting downvoted but I'm just asking a question, I'm not trying to make a doctrinal statement here. Sheesh.

1 Answers 2015-08-22

What is generally considered the most one sided battle in history based on the number of casualties.

1 Answers 2015-08-22

If Teddy Roosevelt hadn't ran in 1912 for president, is it likely William Taft would have been reelected as president?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

What was food quality like at the beginning of mass production?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Did colonization by Japan help Korea in it's rise as an economic power in Asia?

2 Answers 2015-08-22

Was the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity met with popular resistance?

Were there riots or any other significant resistance? I feel as if the sudden conversion would have angered many dedicated Roman Pagans. Am I correct in assuming it came as a sudden shock or was the conversion a gradual process starting with Emperor Constantine? Edit: By conversion, I am referring to Christianity becoming the state religion.

1 Answers 2015-08-22

When and where did the last battle of America's Civil War take place?

I was taught that the last battle of the Civil War was in Texas: "On May 13, 1865, more than a month after the surrender of Gen. Robert E. Lee, the last land action of the Civil War took place at Palmito Ranch near Brownsville." Source: https://tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/qfp01

I was astonished to find someone on Reddit who argued with me (I know!) who stated that the last battle of the Civil War was in Georgia:
"The last important land battle of the War Between the States was fought here (Georgia) April 16, 1865...." Source: http://lat34north.com/HistoricMarkers/Images/MarkerPic/Pic106-1.jpg

Their argument being "How can the last battle of the Civil War be after the war ended?"

Can AskHistorians settle this?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

As I understand it, the modern historical consensus is that the identity of the sitter in the Mona Lisa is Lisa del Giocondo. How did historians come to this consensus?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

How did the tribes allied with Cortez react to his sacking of Teotihaucan?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

During the French Reign of Terror, did the average person have to worry about getting sent to the guillotine?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

Is it true that more people died in the creation of the Nazi rocket programs than were actually killed from the actual rocket attacks?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

U.N. Security Council

I apologize if this is the wrong place, but for some reason this question has popped into my head. Who determined who makes up the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council?

2 Answers 2015-08-22

How did New World explorers get ships to the Pacific Ocean? Did they have to build them entirely in the Pacific coast?

For example, Fortun Ximenez took a ship from Hernán Cortés' fleet to explore the western coast of North America, eventually landing on Baja California. How did they even get their ships there in the first place?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

In any of the wars of the 20th century, did war photographers from opposing sides ever run into each other? If so, what happened?

As above

1 Answers 2015-08-22

How accurate is this video about the racial history of the United States?

https://www.facebook.com/FilmingCops/videos/899326260102470/

1 Answers 2015-08-22

What is some good reading material on the German Revolution?

I've been working my way through Ian Kershaw's Hitler, and it's sparked an interest in early Weimar history. What are some good academic books that cover that time period, or the German Revolution in particular? I have a particular interest in the Sparticist Uprising/Revolt, but I'm open to suggestions that cover the war or that time period in general.

2 Answers 2015-08-22

How have Chinese perceptions of "the West" evolved throughout history?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

How accurate is Barbara Tuchman's portrayal of WWI military leaders, particularly the field marshals?

I'm about to finish The Guns of August and Tuchman has been pretty critical of French, Moltke, and Joffre. Some of it I could chalk up to the challenges of coordinating gigantic forces without the benefit of modern communications technologies but the picture that she paints is one of leaders who seem almost criminally inept.

Joffre especially comes off poorly as a leader in the first month as he withheld information from the French government and his own commanders, ignored intelligence reports, resisted modernization of the military, and removed any number of officers from their positions for perceived "failings." John French's attitude towards Kitchener and the French commanders seems practically treasonous. Moltke seems to have been put in a tough spot and didn't fare it very well as he vacillated on the implementation of the Schlieffen Plan when confronted by his generals.

My academic background is anthropology and I've been in the US military but this is sort of my first real foray into the nitty gritty of those early 20th century conflicts. I've started reading Meyer's A World Undone and I imagine that will clear up a few things (he was definitely more clear on the state of affairs in the Balkans) but I wanted to know what you all think. Were these guys really as bad at their jobs as it seems or was Mrs. Tuchman being hasty in characterizing them as too headstrong for their own good?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

When Europeans first explored other continents, why did natives suffer more from 'European diseases' and not vice versa?

Native populations in America and the Pacific were devastated by diseases brought by Euroean explorers, but why didn't populations of Europeans in Europe catch these diseases passed on by sailors? And how did colonialists survive initial disease contact at all in the first place?

1 Answers 2015-08-22

5047 / 7255

Back to start