when/why did slavery become entwined with race and skin color?

slavery was a given in the ancient world, yet everything i've read about say, roman slavery has it being a colorblind institution concerned with crime and defeated enemies. but "modern" slavery as was promulgated by the british and french revolved around enslaving only people of african descent. when and why did this occur? when did it become outrageous to enslave a white person and accepted that blacks deserved/benefited from slavery? the institutions name is the same yet somewhere it radically changed. why?

2 Answers 2021-09-27

In early-modern warfare, what were the tradeoffs of using a sword vs a lance for cavalry?

Age of Empires 3 represents polearm-armed garrochista cavalry as being more effective in combat against infantry, where sword-armed Hussar cavalry are more broadly useful. Civilization 5 represents this tradeoff in the opposite way, however. Lancers are a specialized anti-cavalry unit where regular knights are generalists. Which depiction of pre-industrial warfare is more accurate? How did renaissance era tacticians decide how to equip their cavalry? Or did the strategic dimensions of this choice matter little and come down to whatever was popular in the local culture?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Is the American attitude to drinking in modern days a hangover from the Prohibition era.

As a British person, I have only known life through a British perspective, and an attitude to drinking came with that. I remember I was first allowed one bottle of beer on special occasions when I was 14, and by 16 I could pretty much share really whatever my Dad was having in an evening, with how much I could have depending of course on how strong it was and how much he wanted to drink it. But as an adult now, I have spend a considerable time in different parts of America, and the attitude to drinking is completely different. Of course, there’s the legal aspect of Americans needing to be 21 to publicly drink and buy alcohol and us 18, but also how fully grown adults treat it. I was stunned when I heard someone call another an alcoholic after 3 glasses of wine with dinner, when in England you’d still be driving home after that. And it’s made me wonder is this a direct result of Prohibition and alcohol being treated as something evil that has just stuck around through the generations?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

How expensive was it for Rome to sow Carthage with salt?

I thought that salt was expensive in antiquity. Could Rome afford enough salt?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

What Was Really The Plan After Landing on the Moon?

Would it be accurate to characterize the space program principally as a way to garner public support for large investments in ICBM technology/promote American ingenuity abroad vis-a-vis the Soviet Union, or was all this actually done with an eye to extending American dominance in space with something like a moon base colony thereafter? Put simply, did the US urgency to reach space dominance after Sputnik evaporate once both sides had roughly equal missile technology? Certainly more advanced missiles would continue to be developed, so this sudden fall of the space program in national prominence has always been unclear to me. Was a landing on the moon really so symbolically important?

2 Answers 2021-09-27

When did the idealization of the Old West begin?

I feel like Americans tend to idealize the old west as some representation of the American spirit where men were tough risk takers who lived free in the vast western expanse, but I'm generally led to understand that the old west wasn't much like this 20th century pop-culture view of it.

Was this a product of the boom of "Cowboys and Indians" media in the early to mid 20th century? Or was it viewed similarly by easterners contemporaneously?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why was Winston Churchill voted out of office in the 1945 election?

I read somewhere that after World War 2 had ended in Europe, Churchill had a humiliating defeat in the British elections. Why was that? No place I've looked has given me a clear answer, so I've come here to ask. Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-09-27

I want to put on a greek theatre performance with my family. Any recommendations?

I want to perform a scene from a Greek theatre to my family. I need a recommendation on what scene to perform. The actors will be me, my brother, and my sister. I want the play to be no more than 5 minutes long, so please recommend a scene which could be fully understood within 5 minutes.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

The Carpathians are an enormous geographic divide between Transylvania and Wallachia, why did Transylvania end up part of Romania instead of independent of part of Hungary?

I know geography is not the be-all-end-all, but it seems that such a large divide would make Transylvania significantly more culturally aligned with Hungary. Historically, was there much over-mountain trade or contact between the Transylvanians and the Wallachians? I understand that part of the borders are due to treaty concessions, but how did the region end up part of Romania?

e: 'independent or part of Hungary'*

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Did Hitler have a genuine dedicated hatred for other minority groups (LGBTQ, disabled, black people) persecuted, or were they kind of casually lumped in with Jews as also undesirable?

Hitler is known to have had a specific hatred for Jews, quite obviously, that was the focus of the ride of Nazi Germany and the holocaust. We know that many other groups were also persecuted similarly/the same. Were these groups added in as a “let’s throw them in with Jews” situation, or was there also a known dedicated/proportional hatred towards these groups as well?

My apologies if any of the wording is a bit crude.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Could a same-sex couple have realistically lived together, presenting as friends or roommates, in Victorian or early 20th-century England?

Given the tendency of popular history to suggest that two people thought of as “really good friends” may have been romantically involved and the fact that people used to share beds more often, I’m wondering whether this was really a possibility.

Would it be easier or harder if the two people involved were of different social classes? E.g., perhaps an upper-class woman could live with her paid middle-class “companion” without raising eyebrows, but everyone would know what was really going on if two non-related upper-class or two middle-class women lived together.

I’m assuming anything resembling raising a child together or going out and doing contemporary “couple stuff” together (even without an overt romantic component) would be right out.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

How did Britain react to the United States purchasing Alaska?

Were the British ever intent on incorporating it into Canada?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

"Meditations" by Marcus Aurelius and translation in general

I was listening to Meditations and I came across a passage that stuck out.

#1

sculptors; he will see a kind of bloom and fresh beauty in an old woman or an old man; and he will be able to look with sober eyes on the seductive charm of his own slave boys. Book 3.2 (Penguin Classics edition; Translated with Notes by MARTIN HAMMOND)

I bolded the part that stood out to me. The translator provided a footnote for that part, referencing a different part of the book, which provided a degree of context. Out of curiosity, I looked up other translations of the book. These are the first few results from Google

#2

So will he be able to perceive the proper ripeness and beauty of old age, whether in man or woman: and whatsoever else it is that is beautiful and alluring in whatsoever is, with chaste and continent eyes he will soon find out and discern. ( Gutenberg.org version, Translator: Meric Casaubon)

#3

He’ll look calmly at the distinct beauty of old age in men, women, and at the loveliness of children. And other things like that will call out to him constantly—things unnoticed by others (Modern Library edition, A New Translation, with an Introduction, by Gregory Hays)

#4

With like pleasure will his chaste eyes behold <77> the maturity and grace of old age in man or woman, and the inviting charms of youth. (Liberty Fund. Translated by Francis Hutcheson and James Moor Edited and with an Introduction by James Moore and Michael Silverthorne )

#5

and in an old woman and an old man he will be able to see a certain maturity and comeliness; and the attractive loveliness of young persons he will be able to look on with chaste eyes; and many such things will present themselves, not pleasing to every man, but to him only who has become truly familiar with nature and her works. (MIT Classics Translated by George Long )

All of these version present, at least to a lay person, a VERY different interpretation of the passage. #1, #4 and #5 all make the attractiveness to youth seem sexual in nature, and #1 makes it the most explicit; #3 reads to me more paternalistic; and #2 makes no mention of young people at all, only the old! Additionally, #1 is the only one to mention the word "slave" which completely alters the perception for a modern reader.

So my question is two fold

  • Which is more accurate? Do we know what he is trying to say
  • How can, as I layperson, have confidence in an arbitrary translation of an ancient work, when translations vary so widely? Or how can pick a translation?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why was the west able to build a prosperous Japan and West Germany, but unable to do so with Afghanistan and Iraq?

I have been watching a history YouTube channel lately and he has been going into detail about how how the west -- particularly the USA -- succeeded in rebuilding West Germany and Japan into the economic powerhouses they are to this day. Why did "nation building" succeed in these cases, but fail catastrophically as in the cases of Afghanistan and Iraq? What did the US do differently in the former than with the latter?

I have heard the argument proposed that the reason Iraq and Afghanistan failed was because of Islam and culture incongruity, but that seems weird given how different Japan was from the west.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2021-09-27

In the Royal British Navy, during the age of sail, there were hundreds of ships of various sizes manned by volunteers, "drunk" volunteers abs presses men. Without a computer system, how did the navy keep track of its members, how much pay was needed, who got promoted, or even who was a deserter?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

War movies often show military personnel travelling to a house to inform a dead soldier's relatives of the soldier's death. When did this become standard practice? Before official adoption by militaries, did a dead soldier's comrades often perform this task on their own initiative?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why did/does America hate communism so much?

America cites “fighting communism” as the main reason behind political interference, such as in Vietnam or Italian politics after 1949. But why does America hate communism so much that they’d spend billions of dollars to make sure no other country adopts it?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

What were the largest African empires and what are some interesting facts about them?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

I just finished reading Walden by Henry David Thoreau, and I noticed HUNDREDS of references to ancient mythology, the Classics, and the Bible peppered throughout the pages. Was this practice common for 19th century American intellectuals to do so? (see description)

- Or was this common for Transcendentalists like him, seeing how much of mythology goes against the mainstream churches, and their philosophy does not depend on seeking the church for wisdom?

- Or is he just showing off, seeing that he "flexed" on those who were ignorant to the Classics at one point in one of the chapters.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why is the woman in “Liberty Leading the People” topless?

So I’m not sure if this is the right place to ask this, but is there a reason for her breasts to be exposed other than “haha sexy woman with big boobs”

2 Answers 2021-09-27

Ancient Rome is famous for its massive public projects, particularly focused on leisure and entertainment, such as public stadiums, baths, theaters, etc. Did the contemporaneous Han Dynasty in China have anything similar?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why are all Europeans referred to as Caucasians

I've been wondering this for a while now. Caucasians seem to refer to the caucuses who's origin can be traced to Slavic peoples. They may have a relation to indo-european ancestry through their language but even that is not completely known to be true. So why did this term expand to cover all of western Europe regardless of ancestry or origin?

2 Answers 2021-09-27

Who is a fascist? Nowadays political opponents call each other "fascists" all the time but I have no actual idea what this means.

In the political talking nowadays you will see a lot of people throwing around the allegation that this or that political opponent is "fascist".

I think it was Orwell who said - sometimes after WW2 - that the word fascist has become so devoid of meaning that it has come to mean just someone you don't like.

However, in the beginning of fascism, probably the word had some actual meaning and was associated with some set of understanding as to how a country should be run. From what I have been taught at school, I can say for sure that the governments of Mussolini, Hitler, and Franco were fascist. I just do not know what makes them fascist and how the label "fascist" makes them different from other non-leftist dictators.

I have also heard the word casually thrown around for other dictators like Pinochet, the Japanese government during WW2, and Chinese republican leader Chiang Kai-shek, as well as (surprisingly for me) Israeli leader Menachem Begin.

2 Answers 2021-09-27

why was Venice built in the first place? why did the early settlers build a city in the middle of a lagoon?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why did the Germans side with the Nazis instead of the Communists after WW1?

Didn't both parties claim to represent the impoverished German masses against the decadent bourgeois elite?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

518 / 7255

Back to start