Was Rurik of Rus buried by the Slavic or Scandinavian tradition? At what point Rurikids and thier retinue have become indistinguishable from Slavs in terms of religion?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

What's a good example of well written Historical Fiction?

Inspired by this post on 'big history'.

The discussion about big history, and 'why its bad' (yes, I know, I'm making the same broad brush assumption that replies to that post warn against) got me thinking that often what I want isn't an in-depth study of a time and place, but something that conjures up a 'spirit of place' (thank you Durrell). Something that, whilst obviously taking some artistic license for the sake of the story, still manages to create a feel for a place isn't at odds with what historians understand to be accurate.

So go on then, who would you rate as being good at this, from a professional historians point of view?

I mean, I'm a big fan of both Bernard Cornwell (Sharpe and others) and Patrick O'Brian (Aubrey / Maturin) and from what I understand they both base what they write in the best historical understanding available to them at the time. I've also heard several authors here wax lyrical about Ken Follet (Pillars of the Earth et. al.).

So which fictional authors / books get your seal of approval as being a. as historically accurate as is reasonable for the grounds of narrative and b. creating a sense of a time that 'rings true' (in as much as one ever can)?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

The FBI and CIA

Recently I delved into American history and got myself interested into inner machinations of said government-insitutes.
Pls can somebody direct me into some books about the topic especially about J. Edgar Hoover.
TY.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Why the Nazis didn't use gas in the Normandy invasion?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Everyone talks about how the Roman Empire continued under the Byzantines, but what were relations like between the Byzantines and post-Roman Italy?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

How did prehistoric hunter gatherers survive long fasting periods without replenishing their electrolytes?

One of the many arguments proposed in favor of fasting is that it's our "default mode". Only in the last century have we all transitioned to a 3 meal a day paradigm, and only in the last 50 years we started to heavily snack as we do today, going up to 5.7 meals per day.

Various books like "The Obesity Code" and "The Fasting Method" mention how our hunter gatherer ancestors would sometimes go days or weeks without food. But now I just realized this - how did they manage without electrolytes?

I really doubt pleistocene hunters would gather salt to make caveman keto juice when they went on long periods without any successful hunting. So how did they manage it? 2 days of water fasting without electrolytes make me miserable, so how did they do it?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

How widely spoken did Hellenic languages become in the Seleucid Empire?

I know that the ruling families spoke Greek, but how deep into society did Greek (or other Hellenic languages) reach into society? How did it vary from Egypt to the Levant to Persia to Central Asia?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

I need help finding info on King John 1 of Portugal, can anyone here point me in the right direction?

I am trying to study Iberia in the late fourteenth century I a running into roadblocks.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

What would a new US marine have experienced in 1959?

My mom passed last year and I've been going through her old photos. I found a framed picture of a marine in uniform, and the newspaper clipping stating his name and hometown and that he was shipping off to Parris Island (I do not have the exact text in front of me). I believe he was likely just someone she went to high school with, and they would have graduated in 1959, this is not a "hunting down a relative" situation.

I'd love to track down the family and get them the picture, but I think that's beyond the scope of my efforts (I've already read up on how, if you're not next of kin, you have to put in a request for records and so on...). But it's still got me curious what this young man's experience might have been like? What was going on that year, would he likely have gone straight into battle, or would he have been able to do his time without that? I find myself wondering if he lived a long and happy life or a tragically short one.

Neither the clipping nor the picture have a date, but my mom was born in 1940 and the other yearbook pictures she saved, with various notes and signatures on the back, all say 1959. There is no mention of any unit or any other structural information about who this soldier was with, just the Parris Island reference in the newspaper clipping. We are all from Massachusetts, if that provides any useful info or context.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Were abortions legal in the 13 US colonies? What about in the early United States? When and why did abortions start to be banned?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Were WW2 German uniforms bad uniforms?

My sister and I were talking the other day, and she said that German uniforms in world war 2 were made of poor quality materials, fit poorly, fell apart easily, and were all around not functional pieces of clothing, but were instead designed for their look, not their function. She’s said this a couple times now, but hasn’t given any sources for it. While I’m nowhere near an expert, I feel like I’ve got a pretty decent grasp on WW2 military history, and I haven’t heard of this before. I did a quick google search and couldn’t really find much. I find it kinda hard to believe, but is this true?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Social rights and obligations in viking expeditions

I'm setting up a tabletop RPG campaign set in a viking-esque fantasy society, and I'm trying to get a basic idea of the social structure, taking my limited knowledge and filling in the gaps with whatever sounds good, but I'm getting stuck on the title topic. I don't know anything about it and I'm not sure how to even formulate a google or scholarly search to get what I'm looking for. More specifically:

  1. Were viking expeditions (to raid, trade, or whatever else) organized by lords or independently by freemen, or both?
  2. If by lords, was participation voluntary or compulsory?
  3. If independent, how much say did the relevant liege(s) have, could he just veto the whole thing?
  4. Who went on expeditions? Was it just vassals of the organizing lord, or broader than that? Were thralls ever pressed into expeditions? To fight or just as labor?
  5. Are any of these questions not-even-wrong or based on completely incorrect understanding?
  6. Anything else on this general subject you want to volunteer would be much appreciated, of course.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

best resource to read an original doc from the 1740's?

I've come into possession of what appears to be (from the date on its face) an old mortgage document from the mid-1700's.

It's in rough shape, so a lot of it is tough to read. It's probably not worth restoring, but I am curious enough about it to that I would like read what it says. It is in english, though faded in multiple spots and tough to read the handwriting in others. I don't even know who I would take this to .. any suggestions?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

1 in 4 military-age American Jewish males served in WW2; did the military do anything to accommodate the large number of Jews entering the service?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

The Munsters and its "rival" series The Addams Family (1964) both debuted within a week of one another in September 1964. What lead to this unique sitcom phenomenon?

At the end of that year's TV season, this show ranked #18 in the Nielsens, with a rating of 24.7, while The Addams Family came in at #23, with a 23.9 rating. At the time, Nielsens indicated what percentage of American TV households tuned in to any given program. By the end of the following year, both series were cancelled.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

How were mercenaries hired during medieval times?

I understand that during large wars and campaigns many kingdoms hired out mercenaries to bolster their forces alongside trained knights and conscripted peasants, but how were those mercenaries hired or selected to fight in those wars? Were they already know to kingdoms through some sort of guild registration? Did someone from the kingdom go around asking for mercenary companies looking for work? In various video games and fantasy novels, there is usually a Adventurer's Guild where adventurers/heros for hire/mercenaries can register for quests, was it something like this?

1 Answers 2021-09-27

Is anything known about the historical population growth of New Amsterdam before it became New York?

Or the population growth of any settlement that became a major population center over time.

1 Answers 2021-09-27

The only surviving record of Columbus's journals is a transcription done by Bartolomé de las Casas decades after Columbus's journey. How trustworthy is this as a source?

The transcription is purported to be an exact copy, a fact we can't verify for certain. Additionally, de las Casas held a bias in favor of the Native Americans (unusual for his time), which could have affected exactly what he wrote or excluded. I'm also aware us English-speaking folk are precluded from reading the transcription verbatim, and have to rely on translations of (presumably) varying fidelity.

1 Answers 2021-09-26

[Empires] Who decides who gets to be an empire?

It seems like a simple question but it's been bugging me for a while; when does a kingdom become an empire?

2 Answers 2021-09-26

What did people do with their nails before the "invention" of clippers?

Did we just let it grow indefinitely?

1 Answers 2021-09-26

Are there less strict subs that r/askhistorians?

It seems like lots of questions go unanswered here (or have their answers deleted). Is there a sub with less strict rules where these questions could get answered? I understand the mods desire to keep the discussions on target, but seeing a great post with nothing but deleted comments is pretty annoying. How about a quarantine section or a related sub?

6 Answers 2021-09-26

When did exact dates started getting common?

What I mean by that is when did people start saying "he was born on October 13th". This has been bugging me for a while now, additionally, how did people keep track of dates back in the day? Thanks for your help :)

1 Answers 2021-09-26

What exactly happened to Japan after WWII?

I was watching something that mentioned the 2011 Tohoku earthquake, so I looked it up on Wikipedia. That led me to the 1923 Kanto Earthquake. In the opening blurb I see "Kanto Massacre". Which leads me to a page about the fact that, in the weeks following the earthquake, the Japanese just started slaughtering Koreans that lived in the Kanto region. Under the See Also, there's the "Gando Massacre", which was more of the same. Then there's WWII, and while I may not know too much about the things Japan did, there is definitely a very long list of war crimes and general crimes against humanity.

The only thing I know of separating that morally black regime that treated other humans as things to be slaughtered or experimented on and the country that many westerners associate with anime, video games, culture, and generally pleasant things is the occupation of the country by America after WWII. What exactly happened in those years that led to what I can only describe as such a drastic transformation in an entire nation?

1 Answers 2021-09-26

Where I can work if I’ll get historian degree?

Im really interested in history and have best grades in it so i want to apply to university for historian, but I have one question why I still not sure, is it possible to earn normal money as historian? If yes where(kind of job) P.S im in 9th grade/11, so if I will i should start preparing.

1 Answers 2021-09-26

Did medieval people considered being literate meaning being able to understand and read latin?

In one of Shadiversity's videos that he states that many people in the middle ages not just clergymen and nobles could read, but they're were not considered literate because they can't read and write latin and only read and write in their local langauge.

How true is his statement? Was a person in the middle ages considered literate, if they can read and write latin? And would they considered a person iliterate if they can only read and write in their own native tongue?

1 Answers 2021-09-26

519 / 7255

Back to start