I'm a barbarian living on the east/north banks of the Rhine during the 1st century BC. How much contact do I have with those living on the opposite shore living in Roman lands, and is my life totally different from theirs?

And what kind of relations might I have with the Romans? As someone living right next to the Roman Empire, is my tribe engaging in lots of trade with Rome, feel threatened by them, see them as a source of income or opportunity for personal gain as a soldier, see them as potential targets for raids? etc.

I realize there's tons of variation over time, location, and tribe affiliation in Roman-barbarian relations so I chose this particular time and place as a start.

1 Answers 2015-04-08

How many deaths have the Irish Gardaí been responsible for in their history?

I've been seeing a lot of this quote recently: US police killed more people in March than UK did in 20th century; and it made me wonder how many deaths, if any, have been attributed to the Gardaí.

I would also like to ask how accurate the claim that UK police only killed 52 people in the 20th century is?

2 Answers 2015-04-08

Were there any non-monarchic Chinese governments prior to the 20th century?

I'm not talking about a China-wide republic, of course, but (for example) maybe some region during a chaotic period like the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period.

Hypothetical examples of cases I'd be interested in, just to see if this rings any bells:

  • A group of petty warlords unite to form a collective, oligarchic type of government ruled by council, under the threat of a neighboring kingdom that would have conquered them all in detail if they didn't unite. (Something with more institutional permanence than an ad hoc defensive coalition.)

  • A peasant rebellion which theoretically claimed to owe allegiance to a mythical "Celestial Emperor" type figure who would rule as a perfectly just monarch, but in practice govern themselves democratically (or male-only version of democratic, or whatever).

  • Merchant elites in some port city like Shanghai purchase some sort of communal autonomy / self-government type charter from the government.

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Are Indo-Europeans genetically distinct from other European populations (Basques, Uralics, etc)? Is there a certain gene that Indo-Europeans all share in common with each other and nobody else? Or is "Indo-European" simply a description of people who speak languages within that family?

3 Answers 2015-04-08

Politics of the American Revolutionary War

During the time leading up to the independence of the United States, what was the profile of the groups supporting independence, and what was the profile of the groups against it? What was the occupation/identity/location/etc of typical supporters/detractors? How did this profile shift throughout the war or after?
Thanks

1 Answers 2015-04-08

How famous were people like Mozart or Beethoven in their age?

Comparing with actual artists how famous and known they were? Local celebrities? Michael Jackson mega stars? Unknown dudes?

2 Answers 2015-04-08

What was the first military dictatorship?

2 Answers 2015-04-08

Before the rise of nationalism, did the Greek, Armenian, Kurdish, etc. subjects of the Ottoman Empire identify as such? What did the people of the Ottoman Empire call the Ottoman Empire?

2 Answers 2015-04-08

How did banking work in the late middle ages? How did they figure out where all the money was supposed to be?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

What happened to public shaming? Why does the western world no longer use stocks and pillories as punishment.

I was reading a bit about punishment in the 1800s and learned about public shaming.

Just wondering what motivated the movement from public shaming to strictly being jailed.

3 Answers 2015-04-08

Is there any evidence (other than religious texts) of the existence of historical Jesus?

I've read that the academic world's accepted position on Jesus is that he did exist, though his divinity is is not accepted. What records, if any, exist to support the claim that historical Jesus existed, preached, and was crucified?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

How and when did the word "points" become a common term for the thing that is used to quantify a victory?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Why did the Beer Hall Putsch fail despite the Nazis superior numbers?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Why did Americans in the 19th century support the end of slavery, but not racial equality?

This question has always puzzled me. Why, or how, did someone believe in ending slavery, but not in racial equality (since not all who were abolitionists wanted racial equality)? What was the mindset?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

The main plot in the 1984 movie "Footloose" starts when the local minister banned dancing, how prevalent were these type of laws in 1980's America?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Is Machiavelli the "founder" of modern day politics?

I have read and re-read The Prince countless times, as well as having gone through his Discourses on Livy for the second time currently. Each time I read either of these books, I find some interesting new quotes that I missed before (most recent is how he compares Fortune to a woman in chapter XXV). Practically each chapter seems to be put in practice in past and/or contemporary politics. Of course, you must disregard some context in certain areas, like chapter XIV on war tactics. But even that can be applied in different ways other than physical fighting. So, is Machiavelli the 'godfather' of present day politics, or is there another? Also, who in American politics, or otherwise, do you think acts(ed) the most Machiavellian?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Why was population growth in New France so much slower than it was in the Thirteen Colonies?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Greek and Roman sculptures depict figures with hard muscular bodies. How did the individuals modeled develop those bodies without knowledge of proper nutrition and resistance training?

2 Answers 2015-04-08

To what extent did evangelical "Gog and Magog" apocalypticism influence American foreign policy?

I came across this wikipedia article the other day suggesting that U.S. presidents Reagan and Bush (Jr.) believed that a confrontation in defense of Israel was part of biblical end-times prophecy. I've heard this claim asserted a few times before, but I wasn't sure whether this was accurate or made any difference in how the U.S. interacted with the rest of the world. I'd also be interested to hear if this belief was involved in the foreign policy of any previous U.S. administrations prior to the two mentioned above.

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Why was WWI so dependant on trench warfare? Using hindsight, would different tactics, using the technology the had, plus the equipment they had at their disposal, would have made any difference?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Are there any periods or civilizations in human history in which women and men were viewed as equals, or even more valuable/powerful than men?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

Did Hannibal sack and pillage any cities in Rome during the 2nd Punic wars?

If not, why? Surely there must have been many reasons to try and do as much damage as possible?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

How did screws become universally standardized?

Looking at a diagram of screws (http://contrails.free.fr/images/articles/550px-Unified_Thread_Diagram.gif) this seems like a totally unbelievable feet. If any of those numbers are off, the screw won't fit right. How did so many separate industries in separate countries get together and decide on these factors? How long did it take before I could walk into a hardware store, buy a #2-56 screw, and half it fit with a 2-56 nut I bought from a different brand/store?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

How much of our understanding of history has actually changed in the past several decades?

I don't want to come across as disrespectful, but how much of historians' work has changed how we view history? Is our understanding of Ancient Greece or the French Revolution or the Islamic Conquests better today than ten years ago?

What are some of the biggest discoveries for history in the past ten years? What are the biggest breakthroughs?

3 Answers 2015-04-08

America was built on slavery?

Is this an accurate statement? If so how was slavery one of the most integral parts of creating America as we know it today? If not what would you say was one of the most integral things for creating America today as we know it?

What is a good source to read up on so I can educate myself?

1 Answers 2015-04-08

5551 / 7255

Back to start