Did the UNSC remove Andrew del Rio for making the same decision at the Battle of Requiem that Lord Hood made at the Battle of Earth?

Both del Rio and Hood made the conservative play, and both even justified their decision by suggesting that Cortana was unreliable. The nature of their relationship with John 117 was very different, but fundamentally both decided to let the SPARTAN-II soldier confront an existential threat to humanity essentially unaided.

Obviously both the UNSC and history have treated these men very differently for what are essentially the same actions. Am I missing something?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

How did the Nazis get the massive manpower to build their base on the Moon?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Ook ook ook, ook ook. Ook?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

How accurate is this diagram?

My friend posted this to his ForceBook Wall, and something just doesn't seem right about it to me. But I don't know enough about Galactic History to argue with him...

3 Answers 2015-03-31

If the Soviet Union collapsed how could "Space Soviets" from the 23rd century travel to mid-'80s earth seeking intel on contemporary US nuclear wessels?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Aircraft Insignia Help

I was asked the other day by my (naval) flight instructor about the history/story/significance of the USAF/USN Roundel. and can't seem to find anything on the internet. Any ideas?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

can someone explain the series of events that led to WWI?

I've been listening to a podcast about it and I am getting more and more confused. Can someone explain the alliances and events in a simple way?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Do we have any proof that Scar actually assassinated King Mufasa? Or was this just a propaganda story created by the Simba Regime to legitimatize Simba's transition back to Lion Apartheid over a racially intergrated kingdom of lions and hyenas (under scar)?

Was this "lion king" story made to depict a lion dominated kingdom look better than a racially mixed kingdom? Are there any sources that prove otherwise?

14 Answers 2015-03-31

Could the Muggle adaptation of traditional wizarding quidditch be considered cultural appropriation?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

Why are there no cyclopean historical sources?

As far as I know, the only sources we have on Cyclopes are from Greek accounts, which are inherently going to be biased due to the nature of their encounter. Do we have any accounts from the Cyclopean side of the conflict that help to provide a more balanced view?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Were Jedi ever known to use death sticks or other illicit substances?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

How faithful to the Way of the Light were the Children of the Light, or Whitecloaks, as they were known?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

What were the long-term effects of Queen Elsa's ice entitlement in Arendelle?

Aside from ideological debates over the morality of creating this entitlement, didn't it distort the ice market? By creating a limitless supply of cheap ice, didn't Elsa encourage the growth of ice-dependent industries which would collapse upon her death - or at least rely on an ice-harvesting guild which had suffered extreme losses in numbers and training during Elsa's long reign?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

We've always been at war with Eastasia. Why did the conflict start in the first place?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

Was Sauron justified in blaming a lot of Middle Earth's problem on the domination of the Elves.

It's so easy to paint Sauron as the bad guy but the Elves were a secretive group that kept a lot of power to themselves. Perhaps if they were more open and integrated into the rest of society Sauron would have never needed to wage a war against them.

1 Answers 2015-03-31

How many witches were convicted by the duck test?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

What was the theological influence of the Ayatollah of Rock 'n' Rolla on the Twelver Shia faith?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

After Hal Jordan's Decimation of the Green Lantern Corps, What Where Some of the Local Effects in Sectors That Lost their Appointed Green Lantern?

Tried googling and reading a few old textbooks but I can't find anything. All the info I've come across relates to the effect on the Sector 2814 and nothing else.

1 Answers 2015-03-31

What was the USSR's long-term plan against the West? A combination of military conquest and political subversion?

In TV miniseries such as 'The Game', and movies like 'Red Dawn' the Soviet Union has had plans to either conquer the West or to take over pieces of it with political subversion. What evidence is there that there were plans for the USSR's long-term plans against the West?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Why, in the 23rd century, were transporter technology applications so rudimentary/heavily restricted? Were humans in the 23rd century suffering from some collective form of mental disability?

If we remember transporters in the 23rd century (the age of Picard, Riker, etc), we may recall that numerous accidents occurred that, if reliably reproduced and exploited, may have certainly had great benefits to the Federation and its allies.

First, I mention Transporter Cloning - on more than one occasion a transporter accident led to a simultaneously co-existing 'copy' of a crewmember. Why didn't the Federation harness this phenomenon to clone an army of "Data" androids. It seems a missed opportunity to gain a potentially infinite quantity of loyal, benevolent, and hyper intelligent supermen.

Secondly, on more than one occasion a transporter beam was used to "reset" an ill crewmember's illness to a less chronic state. Why was this practice only used in isolated incidents when it could have been broadened into general use? The potential applications are endless - removal of any disease or condition, reversing aging, etc?

Lastly, why all the monkey business of 'not being able to transport' into / out of uninhabited caves and other assorted intervening obstacles (which led to all sorts of lethal complications in away missions) when they could easily have transported the intervening material away? This could have been done much more quickly than hoofing it, and would have been much safer.

Is there something I'm not seeing here, or were humans in the 23rd century simply mentally deficient?

2 Answers 2015-03-31

Was King Joffery Baratheon the Bold a good king?

Sure his atrocities, and the rumours about rumours regarding his heritage are fresh in our memories, but Aegon the Conqueror killed thousands in his conquest, and was married to his sisters, and he is remembered as a great king, because of his overall accomplishment of conquering most of Westeroes. So if we forget all the minor torture and terrible acts he committed, we see that during his tenure as king, he quelled several rebellions as a boy, before he was tragically assassinated at his own wedding, but is this enough to make him a good king?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

Why are there no known records of transgender people in the Federation?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

What led to the split between the People's Front of Judea and the Judean People's Front in the first century?

I was watching this documentary the other day and they passed over this point without explaining much. I'm curious as to the ideological split between these groups. Thanks!

11 Answers 2015-03-31

Is there any hard evidence to suggest that the USS Enterprise (NCC-1701D) could stand up to the might of a Star Destroyer?

I've seen a lot of speculation recently that the exploration-focused Enterprise would wither under the might of a military-focused cruiser like a Star Destroyer. Is there any truth to this?

3 Answers 2015-03-31

If Seldon's psychohistory is only accurate for large groups of people (billions), how was he able to predict the behavior and effects of a Foundation of only a hundred thousand at first?

1 Answers 2015-03-31

5601 / 7255

Back to start