Where did/does 'Beethoven' lie?

The last name "van Beethoven" as in Ludwig van Beethoven means "from Beethoven" in dutch. But where does, or did, Beethoven lie?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

How could so few military men hold huge regions if not countries?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

When did the term "revolution" start being used to describe radical changes in a certain society?

And how?
Sources would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-11-08

What was the hate crime percentage against African-Americans before civil rights?

I know the title makes it sounds like I want an answer to a homework question, but I want to compare the "current" percentage (48.5 percent in 2012) to percentages from a long time ago, preferably before the Civil Rights Movement. I cannot find anything through Google, however. Did they not take note of these things back then? What is the farthest back the records go?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

Historians of Reddit, what schools do you recommend for someone looking to study the Ancient World?

6 Answers 2014-11-08

Where and when did the concept of bloodlines originate?

I hope this is not too vague of a question and that it actually makes sense in my phrasing...

I know that plenty of ancient civilizations had leaders - and I understand the idea of the strongest in the civilization being the leader. But when did people begin treating the leadership position as a hereditary position? Does it have to do with religion and many rulers being considered to have been chosen by god?

I just find it interesting that even though different civilizations developed at the same time in different corners of the world, they all came up with similar concepts about leadership.

1 Answers 2014-11-08

What is the ideological origin of the Wahhabi movement in Islam? More importantly, how has it risen to prominence?

2 Answers 2014-11-08

Would interpretation of Egyptian hieroglyphs be at all possible without the Rosetta stone?

2 Answers 2014-11-08

What was the Church's attitude towards Dante's Inferno when it first came out?

Dante went in to great detail into explaining what he saw as the afterlife heaven,purgatory,and hell. How the did the clergyman of the time feel towards the book? Did they consider it heretical?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

During the Hundred Years War, how old would the oldest knights have been?

Assuming that they otherwise survived intact, how old would knights have been when they 'retired' from active warfare?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

Did the mandingo/slave fighting depicted in Django Unchained actually happened?

Was this a real thing? Would owners have slaves fight to the death? Were there any laws against slave fighting? Thanks.

3 Answers 2014-11-08

[META] The Annals of Askhistorians: the Inauguration of New Mods!

AH 2014: In this year the mods of Askhistorians were assailed on all sides by one-line comments, bigotry, plagiarism and soapboxing, so that they were nearly overwhelmed by the magnitude of these offenses. Then, as all hope seemed lost, three gallant new mods appeared beyond the din of battle with shining ban-hammers raised high, and made such depredations upon the rule-breakers that they were scattered to the default subs, and the users of Askhistorians raised shouts of triumph! Sic quod Domino placuit.

Now, these were the names of those new mods, so worthy of welcome and praise:

  • /u/cephalopodie: a most noble person, perfectly schooled in the subjects of gays and lesbians in the USA and the AIDS crisis.
  • /u/anthropology_nerd: a hard and heroic historian, expert in demographics and disease in the New World.
  • /u/keyilan: a valiant warrior, vanquisher of misconceptions regarding Chinese historical linguistics, their are of expertise.

The mods of Askhistorians exhorted their users to welcome these most capable and noble newcomers, whence this quatrain was sung:

Bring me my harp

so that I may make music on it,

on account of the ushering in of Cephalopodie,

Keyilan and Anthropology_Nerd!

16 Answers 2014-11-08

Did common German soldiers question the atrocities in the East?

My understanding is that the organized killing of Soviet POWs and certain Soviet civilians started early on during the war in the East. Forgive me if this seems like a stupid question or if it has been covered before, but it seems to me that some German soldiers (who came from ordinary villages and ordinary families) must have thought something along the lines of "Gee whiz, should we really be murdering large numbers of unarmed soldiers and noncombatants? Isn't this kind of a bad thing, even in war?"

I'm not asking if there was any organized opposition, or if people tasked with actual killing refused to do it, or if anyone really kicked up a fuss. I was just wondering if there is any testimony that anyone bothered to even suggest informally that what was happening was wrong or should not be happening, even if were in an offhand or embarrassed way ("Wow, they just mowed down all those guys. Is that OK? Did I miss a meeting? Because that seems kind of wrong.")

3 Answers 2014-11-08

Saturday Reading and Research | November 08, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

1 Answers 2014-11-08

How well connected were disparate Jewish communities in Europe in the Middle Ages and how did they communicate with each other?

2 Answers 2014-11-08

Did Vikings have gay lovers?

I know that during the time of ancient Greece and Roman Empire it was pretty common for men to have lovers of the same sex, but what about the people that lived in Germanic tribes or other cultures during the same time period? Were gay lovers something normal or looked down upon?

2 Answers 2014-11-08

Was the Red Army a good army?

During WWII a lot of soldiers from the USSR died because of the incompetence of Red Army's generals. They sent lots of soldiers to die just like cannon fodder. Also in the Winter War against Finland the Red Army lost lots of men against a much inferior enemy numerically.

Yes, they certainly won against the best and biggest side of the Wehrmacht but I've always thought it was because Red Army sent hordes of soldiers.

Was the Red Army a good army or just a bunch of useless generals sending to die lots of people?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

Why did Chedder become the ubiquitous cheese of modern America?

There are so many types of cheese in the world and yet in most grocery stores in America the block of chedder is the mainstay while other cheeses are shuffled off as specialty foods. Why?

2 Answers 2014-11-08

To what extent were the British-Indian armies split and separated? Would a Hindu be in the same theater as a Muslim?

*Meant this for World War 1 and 2, sorry for any confusion

1 Answers 2014-11-08

Why did the warlords disappear after the Communists won the Chinese Civil War?

They had existed in force since the fall of the Qing Dynasty if not sooner but someway somehow, they all seem to disappear after 1949. What happened to them? Did they turn communist? Flee with the KMT? Were they eradicated by the PLA?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

How would a young man in the "Age of Sail" go about becoming a pirate?

I just got finished taking a "Haunted History" tour around the French Quarter in New Orleans and one of the ghost stories really got me thinking. Basically, a young man living in New Orleans in the 18th century decided he wanted to be a pirate, so he broke into a home and stole an expensive piece of jewelry that he then took to a bar that was a known pirate meeting place and tried to show it off in the hope that someone would be impressed with his thieving skills and offer him a job on a pirate ship. Unfortunately for the young man, one of the pirates recognized the jewelry as a gift he had given a family member and the young man was made a ghost.

So my question is what were the common career paths (so to speak) that men took to become pirates? Did they commonly set out with the goal of become a pirate, or was it something that people fell into? I'm assuming that this could vary greatly depending on where or when the person lived, so what places were pirates usually recruited from?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-11-08

When did conspiracy theories accusing groups like the Illuminati and Freemasons of secretly controlling the world first emerge?

1 Answers 2014-11-08

Who Was Diana Lucifera in Roman Mythology?

Many Roman coins would show a god or goddess on the backside, and a description of their role. I found there are denarius and antoninianus coins that feature "Diana Lucifera" on the reverse, predominantly in the 2nd and 3rd Century AD.

Lucifer didn't have sinister overtones and just meant "light bringer", right? The correlation with Christianity's devil is hard to miss, but I wouldn't expect to have anything to do with Diana's role in pagan mythology.

So my questions:

  1. She holds a lamp or candle (EDIT: or torch), and it's always on a pole. Was she acting as a lamplighter? Or perhaps a pathfinder or nighttime guide?

  2. When Christianity was attracting Roman converts and eventually becoming the Roman state religion, was there any synthesis between the Jewish devil and Diana?

EDIT: Here's the highest detail example I could find of such a reverse.

1 Answers 2014-11-08

The Soviets by 1945 had learned from and employed many of the best of the German tactics of offensive warfare, is there any record that they seriously considered continuing the war against the Allies onto 1946?

At the end of the war in Europe with the US concentrated on Japan, did the Soviets think this to be an opportunity against a force divided? Possible their own Blitz,continuing on through Germany to France. Any secret records that they may have contemplated? Any personal opinions or memoirs from their great generals like zhukov? Highly speculative I know, but it seems in reading that many of the Allies generals and leaders (Churchill, Parton.. had the feeling that a future war w/ was inevitable . And no I'm asking would they have been successful but rather if they had a contingency plan in place as an option One final note: I'm thinking before Hiroshima and Nagasaki , where Nuclear Deterrent would weigh heavily for not attacking

1 Answers 2014-11-08

How did education theory affect West Point?

I am curious about the styles of education at West Point. Was it contemporary? ahead of its time? Was it influenced by examples such as Tuskegee, Dewey, or European styles of education? Where did it draw its curriculum or styles of education.

Im asking about the period from the origin of West Point till WWI.

1 Answers 2014-11-08

6126 / 7255

Back to start