I often read that police forces were first created in the 19th century. So in the U.S. Bill of Rights, who were the people engaged in searches and seizures that would be limited by the 4th Amendment?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Where did the notion of sacrificing things/people to appease gods come from? When did it fall out of fashion for modern day religions?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

The George Custer film "The Died With Their Boots On" Was Released Two Weeks Before Pearl Harbor Was Attacked. How Did Audiences Respond To A Film Where The US Army Loses?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Questions about cats in ancient Egyptian times: 1) was there punishment for killing or harming cats? 2) did people keep them as pets or did they just sort of wander aeound? 3) did people name them?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Why does Copernicus get the credit for heliocentrism? What about the ancient civilizations that already understood the solar system? Or do we just not have those records?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Looking for Audiobooks or Something Similar about War in the Middle Ages

I am really interested in learning about warfare in the Middle Ages. I want to learn who were the people that fought in these wars.

I understand that the Middle Ages is a broad topic. If I had to narrow it down, I would say I am mostly interested in the Hundred Years War, as this seems to be the most representative of the Middle Ages to a degree.

I want to learn more than just specific battles. I have already watched many of those kinds of videos. I want more of the big picture.

Ideally I want to find audio books or some series of lectures whether It be on YouTube or a podcast or any other media. I want to listen while I commute.

I have searched on YouTube and podcasts and cannot find anything nearly as detailed. I want to spend hours listening to some sort of lecture. The longer the better.

Some topics that I want to learn about are:

Did peasants often fight in wars or did the landowners mostly fight in these wars? What did a typical campaign look like? How often did pitched battles and sieges occur? What did training look like? Who made up the infantry and the missile troops? What did war logistics look like? How were the troops fed? How often did raiding take part in war? Where did mercenaries come from, where they nobles? What did the typical army look like? Was it mostly cavalry? What did the skirmishing phase of a battle look like? How prevalent was the use of missile troops in proportion to the rest of the army? I know the English used longbows but who were these men, how did they become longbow men, did peasants become longbow men? It is my understanding that standing armies were rare, why? Why didn't the Roman standards in the military continue on into the Middle Ages?

Thank you!!!!

TLDR: I am looking for audio books or lectures on war in the Middle Ages, more so than just specific battles but what it was like in general.

1 Answers 2021-07-13

What happened to Australia in 1973, was their really an attempted government overthrow of Australia by the British and Americans and if so why, and why is this never talked about?

So i was going down a rabbit hole through the internet and read this, i tried to do more research but their is surprisingly very little information about it, is this article complete shit, it feels a bit biased, does it have some truth to it, is it all true? What actually happened, why is this not talked about?

2 Answers 2021-07-13

Harry Potter tells us that Ollivanders has been selling wands since 382 BC. What was happening in real life Britain in 382 BC?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Book/Media recommendations: European History from 1700s-1950s

Hey all!

I've been absolutely fascinated by this time period and place since I listened to lectures about it on iTunes U from UC Berkeley. Since then I've watched The Great War series on Youtube, anything from Oversimplified and Extra History, and listened to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History series on WWI a bunch of times. I'm currently reading the Guns of August (love it) and wanted to see if you could recommend some more resources to learn about the different powers and people of the times. Would prefer less dry and more narrative/people driven media, like Ken Burns docs, the PBS Empire series, and Robert Caro biographies.

Would love recommendations on: Maria Theresa, Habsburgs, Otto von Bismarck, Fredrick The Great, European powers leading up to the Napoleonic Wars and after, Carl von Clausewitz, Catherine The Great, World War I, 7 Years War, the French Revolution, etc.

Not as interested but still intrigued: Napoleon and the Napoleonic Wars, British Monarchs (seen a ton of docs on these)

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Was the 4 humors theory of medicine even partially effective, if it lasted so long?

We know that the 4 humors theory of medicine (that lasted ~2000 years) is false and this theory has been completely abbandoned in the 19th century in favour of the germs theory (germs cause diseases and not an unbalance of "humors").

If we know that these theories were false, why did they last so long? Were they even remotely effective to cure symptoms and diseases? What about bloodletting? Didn't people in antiquity notice that this and the other methods for "humor balance" were not effective? (Or maybe I am wrong and they were for a couple cases remotely related to the diseases and they could indeed help with the healing process?)

Was this "classical" theory of medicine (4 humors) of antiquity more effective than, let's say, healing methods of monks?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

How did Native American civilizations mined and valued gold and silver similarly to rest of world despite diverging long before their discovery

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Did Rice become a major part of diet in the Confederate states during the Civil War

One of the paradoxes about the CSA was despite being an agricultural society they had trouble feeding their own population/troops during the war. Food shortages became common as the war went on. One reason is because their agriculture was very heavily focused on cash crops such as cotton and indigo which are obviously not edible.

However, they also produced more than 180 million pounds of rice a year as a cash crop before the war. So did rice which isn't associated with traditional American cooking see increased consumption by southern civilians during the war as they experienced food shortages?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

How can I find more information on a U.S Bomber that crashed in my area?

I have spent many hours trying to search up information about a US Air Force Bomber that crashed on a golf course near where I live but have come up with very little information after hours upon hours of scouring the internet. (and a trip to the library to look for old news cuttings) I am wondering if anybody could give me some advice of the best place to look to try and find any official records of this crash.

In case anyone is curious, here is what I have researched so far: I had an old friend who told me when he was a kid he witnessed a B-17 Bomber crash land onto a golf course in Churston, England, recalling how loads of oranges that the plane was carrying had scattered onto the course. It took me hours of entering different combinations of words into google to eventually find a reference in a list of serial numbers about a B-17 with the serial number 42-5250 that ran out of fuel during a flight from Morocco and crash landed North-East of the town of Brixham (Where Churston is) on January 12th, 1943. Going off that, I eventually found another reference in a B-17 Master Log Book briefly mentioning the same crash, but also naming a crew member called Lt. A.F. Burch. I eventually found this out to be a man called Armand F Burch but I'm not sure what part of the air force he was in at the time, having found references to both the 12th Air Force and the 8th Air Force. This is the last new info I have found and have now hit a road block after spending ages on google trying to find more with the information I have found. Which is why I am here.

Any help will be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

1 Answers 2021-07-13

So many JFK conspiracy theories

Since the assassination of John F. Kennedy in Dallas Texas on November 22, 1963 there have been a plethora of theories and beliefs about conspiracies surrounding the event that go contrary to The official story.Why are there so many?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

In 1864, the Confederate States secretly offered to abolish slavery in exchange for diplomatic recognition and support from the UK and France. Why?

It is by now common knowledge that the underlying cause of Confederate secession was the South's wish to preserve slavery. But from the very start of the Civil War, slavery was one of the main obstacles to the Confederacy's efforts to secure diplomatic recognition from European powers.

In 1864, as defeat was becoming more and more likely, Confederate President Jefferson Davis and Secretary of State Judah P. Benjamin agreed to send Duncan F. Kenner to Europe, to negotiate diplomatic recognition and material support from the UK and France in exchange for the abolition of slavery. Kenner's mission failed, partly because by the time he got to Europe the Confederacy's military situation had become truly hopeless (source).

Now for the question: if the Confederates had seceded in order to preserve slavery in the first place, why would they agree to abolish it to prevent their reabsorption into the Union? I haven't found any sources directly addressing this.

Here are some hypotheses I have thought of:

  1. They feared that abolition on Northern terms would be less favourable than on their own terms (i.e. compensated vs uncompensated emancipation);
  2. They were afraid of Northern reconstruction (maybe they were fine with abolishing slavery but not with granting African Americans civil rights);
  3. Maybe they were concerned about personal (criminal) consequences for themselves;
  4. Maybe their stubbornness and sense of pride led them to take desperate measures to avoid defeat at all costs.

But these are all conjectures of mine. Does anyone have a documented reason for why the Confederacy would abandon the very cause of its existence to secure its continued existence?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

What were early chivalric perceptions of firearms in 16th century Europe?

How was the adoption of firearms perceived by the rulers of these states?

Was their use perceived as ‘unfair’ or ‘cowardly’ and what was the average soldiers attitude toward adoption of the arquebus?

Were there any groups that felt disenfranchised with its adoption?

Any response is greatly appreciated, Thank you,

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Were public hangings common in the “Old West?”

A popular trope in westerns is that of the public hanging, often as a setup for the protagonist to either rescue a compatriot or themselves be rescued.

Is there any basis in fact for public hangings in the early frontier communities of the old west? Or were they mostly carried out in private?

My understanding is that most hangings would have involved trees or wagons since the “trapdoor” method wasn’t common until the 1870s.

Likewise, are there any examples of a person being rescued from a hanging?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

What are the best books to read more about King Arthur?

I’m interested in learning more about the mythology of King Arthur. Knowing that the most well-known stories come from the days of Middle English and before, are there any modern translations or retellings that give a reliable overview of the mythology as it was in that period? All the modern versions I could find were, like other fairy tales, retold and transformed in some way for the writer’s intended audience/purpose. Even a general overview would be great! I’d just love to do more reading besides Wikipedia.

If an older, but still understandable text for contemporary readers exists, that’s fine too.

If my question is already asked, feel free to send me to a previous post! Thanks to anyone who can answer :)

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Why did Indian powers fail to keep pace with military innovations in Europe during the 15th-18th centuries?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

Why have more people moved to Phoenix than Palm Springs if they are both desert cities with lots of affordable land for suburban homes, but the latter is more popular culturally?

Both Phoenix and Palm Springs are desert cities with lots of space to build suburbs, and they both seem to have cheap land. Why did Phoenix end up growing more at a greater pace than Palm Springs, especially if Palm Springs is more popular culturally?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

In my political science module, we learned the Democratic Peace Theory, which says no mature liber democracy has ever gone to war with another. Is this true?

Additionally, are there examples of countries which became mature liberal democracies, and never went to war since?

(Update: Thanks for all the in-depth responses! It adds some new angles to how I see DPT!)

2 Answers 2021-07-13

Why are buttons placed on different sides for men's and women's shirts?

A quick Google search suggests it might have to do with upper class women traditionally having servants to dress them whereas men generally dressed themselves. However, I couldn't find any articles that cited sources so I was wondering if this answer actually holds up.

1 Answers 2021-07-13

1) Did private detectives like Sherlock Holmes, a person without police background, actually exist and 2) would police have ever called them in to help with tricky cases?

1 Answers 2021-07-13

I am Vasco de Gama in 1492 and I have just landed in Calicut, how do I communicate with the Zamorin king?

I've read many history books about European interactions with Asian kings. But I've always wanted to know how the English, French, Spanish etc communicated with the local kings, especially when they've just landed in a new location, for the first time.

1 Answers 2021-07-13

How was slavery viewed in Ancient Rome, and what type of resistance existed towards it?

What I want to know is how people interacted with slaves especially in the late republican/ early imperial era. This may be impossible to actually find out, but I’d like to know how free farmers/workers saw slaves. Did they see them as competition or as potential allies, or something else. Perhaps more answerable how did elites view slavery? We’re they as with modern American slave owners in near constant fear of slave uprisings? On the topic of uprisings, do we know how common or how widespread these were?

2 Answers 2021-07-13

614 / 7255

Back to start