Edit: Especially amateur aviation and whatever else produced nice crashes.
Thanks.
1 Answers 2014-10-30
The 2006 movie The Lives of Others claims that in 1977, the GDR stopped counting suicides when East Germany had the second-highest suicide rate in Europe, second only to Hungary.
My question is: How true is this claim? Is there any evidence that the GDR actually stopped counting suicides in 1977? Did they have a secret count but simply ban the publication of any statistics?
I've been trying to Google around for answers but nothing is forthcoming, and the only source I've found that might directly addresses the subject is a) behind a paywall and b) in German (which I do not read).
1 Answers 2014-10-30
How come it took so long for humans to develop card, electronics etc?
Is it just the compounding of technologies build on previous technologies over thousands of years?
Everything has to start with a natural resource doesn't it?
2 Answers 2014-10-30
So a while ago i read a post of reddit about an Arabic sailor who went to America long before Christopher Columbus or the other famous "discoverers of America" who was captured by Indians on the west coast and was only released after an Arabic speaking Indian told his tribe that they were not a threat. Do you have any more information or knowledge about this incident?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
I'm a student studying religion and culture and I'm interested in the development of formations of credit/debt/and damnation in medieval theology. Unfortunately, while I have a decent background in medieval theology, I don't have a great one in medieval history. I'm convinced, though, that it's mostly fruitless to study the development of concepts without linking them to the practices they render intelligible. Where should I start?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
What is the basis for calling it hellenistic? As far as I know there were no kingdoms named Hellenopolis or anything like that.
2 Answers 2014-10-30
Could a Syrian seaman expect to see Alexandria, Constantinople, and Marseille? Could a sailor from Antwerp expect to see Seville and Birka in his lifetime?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
(Horrible title, sorry - I just can't think of a better way to word it.)
Over in this thread, /u/historiagrephour was answering a fascinating question regarding beliefs about women on ships during the Age of Sail when this came up (quoting from /u/historiagrephour):
This effect of female nudity over nature was recorded by Pliny in his encyclopedic Natural History (Book 28, Ch 2) where he wrote that a menstruating woman who uncovers her body has the ability to scare away hailstorms, whirlwinds and lightning. If she walks naked around the field, caterpillars, worms, and beetles will fall off the ears of corn. And, even when not menstruating, a woman can still lull a storm out at sea by stripping down to nothing.
Historically, there are a lot of beliefs surrounding menstruation that contemporary people would charitably call "unusual," but there's usually some trail you can follow to a logical conclusion. The Biblical concept of uncleanliness during menstruation, for instance - I can understand how someone could "logic" that out.
Take another snippet from the comment made by /u/historiagrephour:
...a number of ships' figureheads were bare-breasted female figures. It was thought that her open eyes would lead the ship to her destination while her bare breasts would shame the sea gods into calm.
This, too, is from Pliny's Natural History - and I can "logic" this one out. I probably wouldn't have gotten there on my own, but I can see how someone could think for a bit and arrive at the idea that a bare-breasted figurehead would keep the sea shamed into calm.
That first one baffles me, though. Pliny basically describes bare-chested women on their period as a subdued version of Storm from the X-Men, plus some Orkin pest control powers. Surely - surely - there was not empirical evidence to indicate that menstruating women held the power of death over corn pests.
How in the world did this belief take hold so firmly as to make it into Pliny's Natural History as apparent fact? I sort of think of Tecumseh's Eclipse when I ask this question - was there some sort of event that led to this particular belief about the power of menstruation? Maybe a menstruating Roman woman of whom I'm currently unaware once stepped onto her balcony as a hailstorm coincidentally retreated and ... beetle season ended? How the heck did people of the time come to believe this?
2 Answers 2014-10-30
I understand there were protests against the various taxes imposed by the British; however, once the taxes were repealed, what drove plantation owners, merchants, shopkeepers, artisans, and small-time farmers to join up and start a full-on revolution? Where did the "we hate central authority" ideology come from? and how did Sam Adams organize all of the different parts of colonial society around that ideology?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
I've always wondered something; Wouldn't many people in earlier history (medieval times, colonial era, etc.) have been born with fetal alcohol syndrome or other complications, due to alcoholic beverages being one of the few safe things to drink?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
In Adam Curtis power of nightmares documentary, it is suggested that today's radical Islam was more or less born in alignment to the rise of the neo conservartism
Do reddit historians agree with his narrative, and if not , whats your perspective on the matter ?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
I've been curious about WWI for a while so I decided to research it, but I've been conflicted between George Norris's views and Wilson's views.
1 Answers 2014-10-30
So according to Biblical texts, the Amalakites were possibly a real historic tribe that living in the area of modern day Israel. The question might be moot depending on historical verification of this group.
Malachite is a green stone, likely used originally for ornamental purposes, but later contributed heavily to the growth of the Copper Age. The name of the stone probably derives from ancient Greek.
So the copper age probably began around 5000 BCE, and biblical stories in Genesis where Amalak (The Amalakites namesake) is written of may have originated as early as 3000 BCE.
Could the name of one have contributed the name of the other? I'm picturing the nomadic Amalakites raiding villages with Copper weapons and taking any Malachite stone they could find. Obviously, that's purely imagination, but could there be some connection?
1 Answers 2014-10-30
1 Answers 2014-10-29
2 Answers 2014-10-29
Obviously Hannibal's campaign was a hugely significant and should be well-remembered. And the imagery of taking a bunch of elephants across a mountain range captures imaginations. But the notoriety of this event still seems to be out of whack compared to other exceptional events of the classical era. Has it always been so prominent?
2 Answers 2014-10-29
2 Answers 2014-10-29
I'm not entirely sure how a collection of unruly tribesmen united to be such a force that it would manage to annihilate most empires and armies at the time. The Mongols managed to many things that were almost impossible at the time, but how? How did the Mongolians create an empire from Korea to the borders of Austria?
1 Answers 2014-10-29
Obviously people didn't have D-Dayesque landing craft in the 18th and 19th centuries, so how would a force attacking from the sea come ashore? In lots of small boats? How many of these boats would a typical ship carry/tow/whatever? In a similar vein, how were large numbers of troops transported across large distances? Aboard ships of the line or on separate transport vessels or what? Did 'transport ships' follow a main fleet closely but skedaddle away when enemy sails appeared, or were they well-armed enough to take part in naval action?
How much did the appearance of steamships alter these methods of troop transportation and landing?
Is there anything else I should look into to try and give a realistic representation of a late-Age of Sail amphibious assault?
Thanks.
1 Answers 2014-10-29
My husband can trace his American ancestry back to John Maxfield of Maine. Maxfield was one of the first Europeans to go to Maine and not run away. He can also trace back to a different (probably father) John Maxfield in England. Then it goes a bit further back. Which all makes sense and is traceable via tax, church, legal records. It gets weird when it starts being traced back to Normans, Welsh, Vikings (Norse), and a Roman in about 350 AD. How do the people who trace these things figure this stuff out? It is all official, so not one of those "buy a family tree" scams.
My poor family is impossible to trace. 1700s on my mother's side and 1850 on my dad's side.
2 Answers 2014-10-29
This image of a mother and child being executed is very well known, but I could not find any information on it. Is it known who any of the people in it are, or when it was taken? Why would the Nazis allow such a photo, which could not possibly show their actions in a positive light, to be taken?
2 Answers 2014-10-29
In Europe there's a Eurocentric kind of history teaching and American history only starts at 1492 with Columbus. Who wants to summarize American history (north and/or south) from the first record of human activity until 1492? Or does American history in America also start in 1492? What looks American history teaching like in America? (by America I mean the whole continent, by the way)
Thank you!
3 Answers 2014-10-29
It might be a quite specific question, but I have to do a paper on local (fun) fairs, parties, markets, balls ... in Antwerp (Belgium) in the 1890s. I wonder whether there are good books or essays on comparable events in other western cities at that time, so I can read in a little on urban events all over the western world. I prefer English, French, German or Dutch texts because if I want to quote an author in another language, I have translate it. But if you have a good read in another language, that would be great anyway!
Thanks for helping, I love you. :)
1 Answers 2014-10-29
If a soldier were injured terminally on the battlefield and asked to be put out of his misery how was that handled?
Was it allowed or disallowed? If so how often did this happen often?
Just something I've always wondered, feel free to post an answer for any side of WWII not just US.
1 Answers 2014-10-29