To what degree was Louis XIV an absolutist monarch?

I know Louis XIV is typically held up as THE example of an absolute monarchy, sort of setting the standard, but the more I read about his administration, the more it sounds like an Oligarchy or the robe nobility, or more accurately of his advisors.

The writings of Colbert and Louvois seem to suggest that they ran most of the country, making the decisions in their respective fields, and used "His Majesty" as a sort of "get it done ASAP" stamp.

Louis was involved in the affairs of these advisors and attended their meetings, but how much was he an absolute monarch, rather than a powerful centralizing figure who kept the nobility from splintering the country?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

I am the second born son of a 12th Century English noble, how do I join the Knights Templar?

If I want to volunteer, and my father gives the OK, to I just go to the Temple in London? Does my father just sign me up? Are there recruiters who travel the countryside?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Were doctors retaliated at for killing/not saving/experimenting on their patients before modern medicine?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Stain Glass windows on Churches and Cathedrals - Did they get darker over the years, making the churches and cathedrals darker?

Title.

And if they did, did anyone ever try to clear them up and/or replace them so the churches and cathedrals are brighter lit?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Theres a bit in Emperor (2012 film about occupation of japan)where Fumimaro Konoe implies that theres no difference between the Japanese & the British empires, Americans just see one because japan isn’t European. Is that really a viewpoint a prominent Japanese person would plausibly have in the 40s?

3 Answers 2014-10-26

Can you help with identifying these bayonets?

I found these bayonets on the atticks of grandfather of my wife. Can you please help me with identification?

Location is Slovakia. Based on the googling one on the top is probably bayonet with scabbard of Czechoslovakian army from WWII era. But they look very similar from that era, might be vz24 from 1929. But I have read they have mark ČSZ Y on them, and mine has ČSZ U.

Second one is tough one, I havent found it when comparing with images google found. Some shapes looked similar, but they have never been the same. I thought that hole in the end might help with recognition, but that is probably just missing screw or something, because I have found no other bayonet with hole in the end of handle. It is pretty long so I thought WWI at first, but it doesn't look like most bayonets of Austria-Hungary, which was my first guess based on location of find. Oh and handle doesn't seem to be from wood.

Any help is apreciated.

One more question, should I restore them? Or should I display them in current state? I was planing to remove rust first and than polish them, but I am curious what you think about it.

Thanks

1 Answers 2014-10-26

The Varangian Guard and homosexuality

In the game Crusader Kings 2, if you're playing as a Nordic ruler, you can get an event where your son will try to join the Varangian Guard. If you let him join, one of the possible outcomes to the event will be your son returning a few years later, talking about "greek love", and he will gain the "homosexual" trait.

Does this have any basis in history? Did the Varangian Guard have a reputation for it's members being gay? Or is it just some joke the devs added to the game?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Did great military generals and leaders give speeches before battles like you see in the movies? And if so, were only a few able to hear it?

I've always wondered if in movies like, Gladiator or Alexander, the great military leaders gave speeches before battle. And if so, were only a few people able to hear them?

3 Answers 2014-10-26

To what extent can the bible be used as a genuine historical source (New testament only)

2 Answers 2014-10-26

Poland is one of the most Religious countries in Europe, while Lithuania is full of atheists. Why is it so?( Poland and Lithuania was 1 country once too)

3 Answers 2014-10-26

During the Paleolithic, when two groups of humans met, did we fight and war, cooperate and trade, join together?

pre-10,000BCE

As a follow-up, how did we communicate?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

As an English speaking Englishman... how far back in time would I have to go before communication would start to become a serious problem?

2 Answers 2014-10-26

Why did Europeans enslave Africans instead of other Europeans?

For clarification, I'm referring to the Transatlantic slave trade. I'm aware that Europeans did periodically enslave other Europeans throughout their history, and I've heard that some slaves in the Americas were European (I'm going to conflate "European" with "white" and "African" with "black" for the purposes of this post). But the vast majority of slaves in the Americas were black, to my knowledge.

So... why didn't Europeans just enslave other Europeans and ship them overseas instead of enslaving Africans? I've read one explanation from Frank Wilderson, professor at UC Irvine, from "Red, White & Black: Cinema and Structure of U.S. Antagonisms", that:

"[Europeans] could easily have provided 50,000 [white slaves] a year [to the New World] without serious disruption to either international peace or existing social institutions that generated and supervised these potential European victims" and that "the costs of enslavement would have been driven down exponentially had Europeans taken white slaves directly to America [...] shipping costs... composed by far the greater part of the price." He continues that "not only would European civil society have been able to absorb the social consequences of these losses (i.e. class warfare would have been unlikely even at this rate of enslavement), but civil society 'would [also] have enjoyed lower labor costs, a faster development of the Americas, and higher exports and income levels on both sides of the Atlantic."

He concludes that "what Whites would have gained in economic value, they would have lost in symbolic value". Basically, Wilderson's explanation seems to be that white Europeans are simply driven by an evil obsession with dominating and subjugating people based on skin color (that there isn't really an economic or practical reason why they do this - in fact, they do this despite strong economic incentives not to), because Whiteness/White Culture is based on exploitation and violence.

Is this actually the case? Did Europeans have no real reason to pick blacks for slavery other than not liking dark-skinned people? One of the traditional explanations I've heard for the origins of racism against blacks amongst whites is that, because of the strong commercial incentives to get cheap labor for the Americas, White European colonialists enslaved Africans because labor shortages meant the costly practice makes economic sense. However, European liberalism seemed to imply that enslaving your fellow man was wrong, so Europeans had to come up with an ideological justification why the principles of liberalism (human rights, agency, freedom, etc.) would not apply to slaves, thus originates the racist theory that blacks are categorically different than whites in moral character. In other words, modern racism has its origins as an ex post facto justification for an economically motivated practice (instead of just being an irrational superstition that white people made up so they could be sadistic). But I'm not sure if this "squaring liberalism's circle" argument makes a whole lot of sense.

Anyone?

6 Answers 2014-10-26

Did Kaiser Wilhelm II ever try to regain his throne after WWI?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Why did the Anatolian peninsula become the core of the Byzantine Empire but not Greece?

I have always read that the Byzantine Empire was mainly a greek speaking empire and had a greek character to it. So why did the Anatolian peninsula become more important to the empire but not greece itself?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Was there ever a warrior who could kill tens of opponents single handedly in close combat like we often see in movies?

3 Answers 2014-10-26

How did the practices and terminology of French cuisine become a culinary standard?

I've noticed that cookbooks are filled with terms like "saute," "julienne," and so on and so forth, even in "eastern" recipes that don't appear to have been influenced by "western" cuisine. Is there any particularly interesting historical reason why details of the French culinary tradition have become so widespread?

2 Answers 2014-10-26

How would an aspiring conquistador acquire martial skills?

Considering that the conquistadores were often semi-private adventurers with little to no prior military service, where and how would they have learned how to fight?

Where and how would they have acquired the sword / crossbow / arquebus / martial skills they would need when it came time to fight the outraged native warriors?

How would, say, a desperate Extremaduran peasant or a Sevillian immigrant come to the New World or to the Philippines have learned how to fight with arms and armour?

2 Answers 2014-10-26

Why does Edward the Confessor appear to be angry at Harold Godwinson in the Bayeux Tapestry after returning from Normandy?

Norman sources suggest that he was sent to Normandy to promise the Kingdom to him upon Edward's death, then why is he angry in the tapestry if Harold succeeded?

Edit: I'm referring to this scene http://imgur.com/fC8oUOJ

1 Answers 2014-10-26

How did viking raiders/settlers communicate with the inhabitants of places like Ireland and Scotland?

I've heard that OE may have been mutually intelligible with Old Norse but how would a viking communicate with a Gaelic, Pictish or even Frankish speaker?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Did the German Empire have a realistic chance of winning WWI?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Could you argue that WW1 and WW2 were the same war with a 20 year pause?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

How did Hitler financed the World War 2?

If the treaty of Versailles left Germany with a broken economy, hyperinflation, unemployment and limited military resources, then how did the Germans manage gather the resources to build a massive army to fight wars on two fronts.

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Who were the "old greek" or the "old romans" to the old Greeks or old Romans we are referring to when we Talk about ancient history?

Did they have Peoples they were referring to as what we now call ancient?

1 Answers 2014-10-26

Day of Reflection | October 20, 2014–October 26, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2014-10-26

6169 / 7255

Back to start