How did the Mexica (aka Aztecs) deal with the umbilical cord after birth? Was there any cultural significance attached to it or was it merely disposed of?

I wanted to do the question for Mesoamerica, but alas our rules say no. And with the recent trend of medical related questions associated with the Mexica I thought I'd add another.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Hypothetically, if the United States hadn't enacted the Marshall Plan, what would Europe look like today?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

At one point, the gospel of Luke refers to Adam as the son of God. Was this ever a cause for concern for Christian scholars?

From antiquity to the modern day, what have theologians said about Mark 3:37? Did anybody believe that it meant Adam and Jesus were of an equal godliness?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Other than Churchill, how frequent was the wearing uniforms by civilian administrators in WW1/WW2?

So I'm in the Honolulu airport and I stop and take a look at a display about the nisei soldiers, when I spy a large photograph captioned as "Gen. Mark Clark, commander of the 5th Army, inspects nisei soldiers with Frank Knox, Secretary of the Navy." The secretary is wearing a khaki shirt, trousers and black shoes and tie, with what I'd call a khaki garrison cap (the folded rectangular headwear). No distinguishing insignia. I'd never seen a civilian head of an armed service wear a uniform like that, other than Churchill. Any ideas what's going on? I'd go get a pic buty flight is about to leave.

EDIT: Got the name of the secretary wrong; should be Frank Knox.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Were the Allies planning to pull significant resources from the European theater in time for the invasion of Japan?

Obviously you don't need tanks or B-17s for occupation duty... were plans being made to use them against Japan prior to Hiroshima?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

In 1066, do we know how many Normans settled in England?

Was it entirely military men who participated in campaign, or did families, farmers, and craftsmen travel as well?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

What are some examples of "False History" that took us a long time to figure out?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Historians, please help a world War 2 time traveler.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Homosexuality in the Muslim world and the Celts

So I've just watched a video that listed "5 gay armies in history". The first three I already knew about: Samurais, Greeks and The French Foreign Legion.

The next two, however, I've never heard of- Islamic warriors(Mamelukes, Janissaries etc.) and Celts. Was there a great number of homosexual acts going in these groups? I know they wouldn't have considered themselves gay, but did they have a lot of gay sex?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Does history support the contention that "a group of small city-states seems to be the best environment for genius"?

"[A] group of small city-states seems to be the best environment for genius. That was the situation in Greece during the Golden Age, in Italy during the Renaissance...."

The quotation is from The Black Flame, a science fiction novel by Stanley G. Weinbaum, written in the early 1930s. Does a broad view of the history of human achievement tend to bear out this contention or is it a fallacious generalization buttressed by cherry-picked examples?

^(PS-Just in case the style of the question makes it sound like an essay question for some test: it's not. I've recently been reading this book, by a largely forgotten writer who died tragically young, and the sentence piqued my interest. Lacking the broad knowledge of history required to properly assess it, I hope that one of the many erudite and well-spoken souls of /r/askhistorians can lend me the benefit of his wisdom.)

^(PPS I suspect my tone in this post is oddly literary or flowery or something in that vein. Just something that happens to me sometimes when I read a book with a distinctive literary style—it tends to infect me. Please forgive any concomitant oddity about my prose.)

3 Answers 2014-10-18

When was the last time that a piece of land on Earth was not claimed by a country?

4 Answers 2014-10-18

What would have happened if the U.S. Air National Guard had intercepted the jets that were doomed to collide into the World Trade Center buildings?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

What legal protections, if any, existed for black slaves in antebellum America?

Obviously slaves were often beaten horrifically, and often to the point of death -- and this was perfectly legal. But were there any laws designed to limit abuse of slaves, or were they truly considered property just the same as furniture and livestock, with the owner granted rights to do literally anything, up to and including wanton destruction?

It's easy to conjure up a hypothetical scenario where some psychopath buys up slaves with the express purpose of murdering them, and I can only imagine this sort of thing would shock even the consciences of antebellum slaveowners. So were there any limits on "excessive" abuse?

I get the feeling that the answer here is probably -- "in theory, yes; in practice, no." But I'm curious.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

What are some good sources for US involvement in the drug trade?

I had a conversation with my daughter yesterday about hypocrisy and propaganda, and I realized I couldn't discuss the US government's position on drugs without sounding like a crazy person. I'm not entirely sure where I've learned the "facts" that I kinda sorta know.

I have no patience for conspiracy theorists, so I'm not sure where to begin. Much as I love documentaries, I would prefer to have written works for reference. Help?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

In the years around the Revolutionary War in the US, what were the major languages spoken in the area that was becoming the United States, and what were their geographic distributions?

English is obviously the major one, but I've heard German was spoken by a significant number of people in Pennsylvania, for example. If there isn't a lot of variation, I'd be interested to hear about regional dialects of English that we know about from that time, or important Native American languages, if their distribution is interesting. Really I'd be happy to hear information about any time from 1760-1800.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Dividing Byzantine from Roman

I am wondering about the dividing line historians generally place between when the Eastern Roman Empire can be thought of as more "Byzantine" than classically "Roman". Obviously there would be some debate regarding this as the distinction is more so academic than anything else.

Where do most historians put the break? Is there a majority opinion on this? Are there dissenters? Thanks in advance for your time!

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Why is India's history poorly documented compared with the Graeco-Roman world or China?

This question was inspired by the thread on r/badhistory talking about Rome, India, and China's economies in the 1st century.

It seems to me that we have quite a lot of historical texts from classical antiquity (e.g. Herodotus, Polybius, Tacitus), and we also know quite a bit about Warring States and Han Dynasty China (e.g. Sima Qian, Spring and Autumn, Book of Han). By comparison, the same period in Indian history seems very poorly documented - we don't really have much from the Maurya dynasty or the Kushan Empire, for example.

Am I missing something here? Are there some sources I'm not aware of, or did Indians just not see a need to write or preserve the annals of that period? Or was the lack of a unified Indian state the issue?

4 Answers 2014-10-18

When did japanese (or the language ancestral to it) become the most widely spoken language in Japan?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Early airplane crashes

Not knowing much about aviation history, I'm defining "early airplanes" very broadly, as being any wooden-framed propeller plane. Historians, please correct my definition, in your replies.

What altitudes and speeds were these planes used at? What for? What were the most common causes of crashes? How often did the plane survive? How often did the pilot survive? What did the crash sites look like?

It's a broad topic, I know - please feel free to narrow it, based on your expertise.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Do you think it's plausible that ancient Polynesians reached the Americas? If so what do you think contact would have been like?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

How were letters delivered in early medieval Europe?

I am assuming that wealthy nobles might hire someone to take the letter there, but how would they get there? How would they know where to go? Would the person give a messenger extra money for tolls/transportation/etc.? Say the Frankish King sending a letter to Rome

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Why were monarchies and the notion of the divine right of kings such a dominant idea throughout different societies?

I'm referring to why they were independently similar: I'm wondering if there are interesting similarities in the justification for such ideas amongst different, separate societies. E.g. Chinese emperors, Roman emperors, Egyptian pharoahs, rulers of Maya/Inca, rulers in South East Asia

2 Answers 2014-10-18

What purpose did assuming additional titles by rulers serve?

This sounds like a very broad question, and I am curious about different time eras and countries. But mostly, I wanted to ask question after finding a reference to Royal Titles Act of 1876, which added the title "Empress of India" to the list of Victoria's titles.

What was it done for? Did it change anything, did it have any de-jure implications? Or was it just PR?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Did Vietnam Veterans have an impact on the role of drugs and/or guns in Outlaw Biker culture?

I'm considering choosing this as a project but am unsure if it was the case. It seems like it may be relevant given how many veterans sought the brotherhood/companionship present MCs after the Vietnam war in the USA.

I understand it's a strange question but I would appreciate any insight.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

When did cotton replace linen and wool as main fabric for making clothes?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

6195 / 7255

Back to start