What was happening in Guantanamo Bay during the Cuban Missile Crisis?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

How do historians approach holy texts, such as the Bible and the Quran?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Connaught Laboratories and biological weapons research during WW2. My uncle worked there in 1942 and was voluntarily injected with something. One Friday he came home and was dead by the next day. Any insights into what may have happened?

From what I've heard Canada was a leader in biological weapons research during WW2. My uncle worked at Connaught Labs which was suppose to be involved in that research. In 1942 while working at the lab he volunteered to be injected with various serums that were kept secret. He died suddenly that same year of something that took his life in 2 days. The death certificate says it was encephalomyelitis. He was buried in a sealed copper coffin never to be opened again. His brother and sister have always thought his death had something to do with what he was doing at Connaught Labs. I'd be interested to know what people here think about that. Or whether they think he probably just died from some bug that caused the encephalitis.

4 Answers 2014-10-18

Was the Peninsular War as brutal as Goya depicted? If so, why?

I've always assumed that among the Napoleonic wars, the Peninsular was singularly vicious. No doubt things like Goya's "Disasters of War" have compounded this assumption - but I've never seen art or literature from the other theaters that quite match the ferocity depicted. To be fair, Goya's a sort of singularly brutal artist, but most of the (admittedly wikipedia) reading I've done on the Peninsular war seems to confirm this. So: is it true that the Peninsular was was particularly violent? And, more importantly, what about Spain made it this way? Sure, guerrilla combat is always exceptionally messy, but why was Spain the place where this really seemed to take place?

Any book recommendations on the peninsular war would also be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Are there any sources criticizing Martin Luther King Jr or questioning his impact on civil rights?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Why is the Battle of Hastings so important? How did it affect the world today?

I keep reading novels that mention it so much and After reading about it, it seems that it was a normal battle involving England. How did this affect the world today?

3 Answers 2014-10-18

What went on in Africa during the height of the roman empire??

2 Answers 2014-10-18

What is the difference between an emperor and a king?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

AMA - Medieval Witchcraft, Heresy, and Inquisition

Welcome inquisitors!

I'm idjet and although I've participated in a few medieval AMAs (and controversial threads) in the last year, this is my first AMA about subjects closest to me: medieval heretics, witchcraft and early inquisition. A little over a year ago I quit my job in North America, sold up and moved to France to enter post-graduate studies to chase this subject full time.

The historiography of the last 30 years has rewritten quite a bit of how we understand heresy, witchcraft, inquisition in medieval society - a lot which still hasn't penetrated popular media's representations. My interest started 20 years ago with medieval manuscripts at college, and in the intervening years I've come to find myself preoccupied with medieval mentalities we call 'heresy'. More importantly, I've been compelled by the works of historians who have cast a critical eye over the received evidence about whether or not heretics or witches existed in any form whatsoever, about how much was 'belief', how much was 'invented by the inquisition', how much was 'dissent'. The debate goes on, often acrimonious, often turning up historiographic hoaxes and forgeries. This is the second reason it's compelling: discerning the 'truth' is ongoing and involves scrutinizing the work of centuries of history writers, both religious and anti-religious even as we search for evidence.

A lot of things can fit under an AMA about 'heresy' and 'witchcraft', for better and for worse (for me!). Everything from theology and scholasticism to folktales; kingship and papacy to the development and rule of law; from the changing ideas of the devil to the massive waves of medieval Christian reform and Apostolicism; from the country monasteries and villages to the new medieval towns; economics to politics. It's why I like these subjects: they cut across many facets of medieval life in unexpected and often confusing ways. And we've inherited a lot of it today in our mentalities even as we think about Hallowe'en in the early 21st century.

I am prepared to answer social, political, economic, and theological/belief systems history around - as well as the historiography of - heresy, witchcraft and inquisition in the middle ages.

For purposes of this AMA and my area of expertise we'll cut off 'medieval' at around 1450 CE. Like any date, it's a bit arbitrary, however we can point to a few reasons why this is important. The first is that by this time the historiographic understanding of 'heresy' transitions into a scheme of functional management by Papacy and monarchies of self-aware dissenters, and the 'witch' in its consolidated modern form (pact with the devil, baby-eating, orgiastic, night flying) is finally established in intellectual and Inquisitional doctrine, best represented by the famous manual Malleus Maleficarum.

Finally, although I've placed this AMA purposely near Hallowe'en, it's not a history of Hallowe'en AMA. Hopefully the mods here will do a usual history of Hallowe'en megathread near the end of the month.

Let this inquisition begin!

edit: It's 2 am for me, I'm going to sleep for a bit. I'll pick up questions in the morning!

28 Answers 2014-10-18

Saturday Reading and Research | October 18, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

5 Answers 2014-10-18

Is it true that during WW1 airplane pilots were not issued parachutes because that would have hurt their will to fight?

So, as part of the hundredth anniversary of WWI, my town organized three conferences with local scholars about how the war unfolded in our region and what it meant for the people that lived here. Yesterday's conference was about aerial warfare, but one thing the speaker said didn't convince me: he said that working parachutes existed in 1914, and that they were issued to those poor souls that crewed recon baloons so they could bail out as soon as they saw an enemy plane approaching, but that they were not issued to plane pilots and observers as it was believed that having an 'easy' way out of the fight would have made pilots less willing to fight. Is there any truth to this?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Why was mercury used as a remedy to so many illnesses in the past? Did it have a positive effect initially?

1 Answers 2014-10-18

While the Technocracy Movement may have fizzled out, were there any lasting influences from the movement or it's leaders in the political or social spheres?

Thank you all for any interest and answers to this question!

1 Answers 2014-10-18

"Nationalism" as we know it didn't exist in premodern times. But we had "Philip the Arab", who identifies himself with a certain region (not just certain town) in Roman Empire. How did people in the Roman Empire perceive their homeland? Was there something akin to "proud" for living in certain area?

Identifying oneself with a certain town like John of Edessa or Augustine of Hippo seems to be a normal occurrence, but it seems to be different with Philip the "Arab", who identify with a larger area.

Did Philip, or anyone else during the long period of Roman Empire, ever thought of being something akin to "proud" for being born/lived in the place they identify with? Something that extend beyond towns/cities, maybe similar to how today's Southern Italians see themselves as different from Northern Italians, or people in the Bible Belt USA proud of being the part of religious Americans, or people in Central Java sees them as a distinct Javanese, etc.

Something like, "Hey I came from Arab. It's a really nice place and the people there are cool, proud of being a part of them." Regardless how flexible/fixed the boundaries of the said Arab region.

6 Answers 2014-10-18

Given that languages show a strong (borderline universal) trend from being highly synthetic to becoming analytic, and must have started simple, how did ancient languages become so synthetic in the first place? Isn't the current state of language highly unnatural? (Explained in post)

What I'm asking is given that languages tend to lose declensions, inflections, and these sorts of things over time, how did they come to be in the first place, given they ostensibly didn't exist at the beginning of language.

For example, English has over time lost much of the subjunctive, and most languages with this conjugation tend to do so as well; we've lost our declensions, as did Dutch and most romance languages. Languages with the dual case lose them over time; and irregular verbs tend strongly tend to become regular over time (see the evolution of Latin into, say, French).

If this is such a strong trend, it seems to me that the state of ancient languages as being highly synthetic is highly unnatural, and constitutes a grave violation of this trend. Either language popped into being with a high morpheme-to-root ratio, which seems very odd and requires explanation, or there must've once existed a trend to increase morphemes-per-root over time, which is also very odd.

To make an analogy, by my understanding it's like a car on a hill. It is easy for it to roll down (decreasing syntheticness) and it takes energy to push it up. We know that the car was once very high on that hill. How did it get there? Did it pop into being at the top of the hill or did people push it up? Why would they push the car up a hill if it takes energy to do it.

It's really perplexing me and most people that I've asked. Please help.

(X-Post with /r/AskAnthropology)

6 Answers 2014-10-18

Anyone familiar with the term "Mechanics" referenced in a pre-civil war portion of a book about Charleston, SC history?

I recently read A Short History of Charleston and there is a constant reference to a class of people dubbed "Mechanics."

The portion of the book that refers to Mechanics covers pre-civil war Charleston but doesn't specifically define the class of people. The lines are somewhat blurred between artisan slaves who paid their own cost to their owners to have a semblance of freedom and immigrants with no social standing.

I thought I'd post here before I go back and try re-reading the book to figure this out as Google hasn't provided much other than the game mechanics of Civilization V's slavery.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

In an 1830s, rural Virginia setting, in what manner did a typical family decorate their Christmas tree?

A small group of 12 year old girls have been asked to make decorations for, and decorate, a Christmas tree to be displayed in a small manor in southern Virginia. They were thinking of stringing popcorn and making paper chains, but is there anything else to keep in mind? Were feathers, fruit or foil decorations used? Were small presents hung from the tree? We do realize that this typical family's Christmas would have been quite humble.

For additional information, this manor was built in the 1790s, but is currently furnished in the 1830s period.

Thank you, greatly, for your expertise.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Is it problematic to use out of copyright maps (older than 200 years) in a publication

Background is as follows:

A coworker has been invited to publish her dissertation, however central to the work are some maps that were gathered from an archive holding the primary sources.

The applicable copyright law is 70 years after the authors death, 70 years after creation of the map if the author is unknown, all of the used works are well outside this timeframe and therefore should be within the public domain.

The archive however demands royalties for gathered works in the event of a formal publication.

Can this be safely ignored since they are not in any way copyright holders or are there complications.

I Imagine that this problem has occurred to some professionals here so i formally ask for some clarification or advice.

Thanks in advance.

2 Answers 2014-10-18

I have heard that horses used in cavalry charges in the 1200s were far bigger than modern horses, how much truth is there in this?

3 Answers 2014-10-18

Timeline of who has inhabited Palestine throughout history?

Dear Historians, looking for a agreed upon, evidence supported timeline of who has inhabited Palestine from as far back as possible. Were there any non-jews there before? Trying to get my head around the modern day conflict. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

Did the germans make full use of the french industry and resources in WWII?

Seems like the germans didn't really invade the Soviet Union with much more tanks. planes, trucks etc than they did France. I would think after capturing France that production and resources would nearly double.

2 Answers 2014-10-18

What would a Lancastrian Army in the war of the roses have looked like? How would it have been broken down? Where would the men have come from?

Hello. I'm a big nerd and like painting model soldiers. Soon I'm getting some mounted men at arms and some footsoldier models which are based on War of the Roses era English troops.

Since I'm from Manchester I thought I'd paint then up as Lancastrians.

I'm really keen to make them fairly authentic, so I'd like some information on how an army of that era, specifically a Lancastrian one, would have looked.

Would there have been a uniform of sorts? Or would each man have brought his own equipment? If so, would they have tried to wear the right sort of colours for their army?

Would a unit of troops have been led by a lord they were affiliated with? If so, how many or few troops would a lord lead? Would he go mounted with his fellow upper crust guys, or join his foot soldiers in battle? Were the soldiers professionals, or were they drawn from local populations by an indebted lord?

I would also love to hear about any particularly famous lord type leaders of the Lancastrians as I would like to paint models to represent these also.

Finally. What would the army have looked like? Are there any paintings or such which give an idea? Or any first hand descriptions of how the armies of the time were outfitted visually.

I realise it seems like I have a lot of questions here, but really it boils down to; How would a Lancastrian army in the war of the roses have looked, been led, and been organised.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-10-18

During the period of personal union between Hannover and Great Britain, was there ever any efforts to incorporate Hannover into Great Britain?

Or did anyone ever advocate it or suggest it?

2 Answers 2014-10-18

Were there any inventions or tools Europeans have adopted from Native Americans?

10 Answers 2014-10-18

What caused the Renaissance to start when it did?

Was there a steady progression of technological development (such as metallurgy) that had to be completed in order for other key inventions (such as the movable type printing press) to be created?

Was it more a matter of no nations of the medieval era having the time and resources to spend on things other than survival and warfare?

I know the arrival of Byzantine scholars in western Europe following the fall of Constantinople to the Ottomans played a role, but I get the impression that their contribution was to bring in their library classical knowledge, which could (hypothetically) have been done at any time had the circumstances warranted it.

1 Answers 2014-10-18

6196 / 7255

Back to start