Why did the name "Indians" for native Americans stick after they realized the geographic error?

And were there attempts at the time (say 16th, 17th centuries) to change the name? Were there comments on the ridiculousness of using a name derived from a massive geographic misunderstanding?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Is there any evidence of USSR officials reacting to Animal Farm or 1984?

For example, Soldier Nitzkin was arrested, but he was a Russian Citizen.

1 Answers 2014-08-31

How was the American Revolution taught to children in England throughout history?

As an American, I was wondering if the colonists were portrayed as "the villain". As time went by, did the perspective change?

2 Answers 2014-08-31

[US] What Happens to the Physical Copy of Signed Legislation? (US)

When a president signs a new bill into law what happens to the physical copy of the bill?

I asked this is another subreddit but since I'm interested in this from a historical perspectives i.e. legislation signed in the 1700's 1800's etc. Maybe someone here will know.

1 Answers 2014-08-31

What factors enticed the Central Asians, West Africans, and Oceanic peoples to willingly convert to Islam?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Did WWII AA cannons work by throwing shrapnel or concussive force and how were so many fuses constantly changed to follow aircraft

2 Answers 2014-08-31

Slavery

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Why was the Ottoman so behind other European powers technologically?

I'm talking more about the 1700's and the 1800's. I read in a book that there wasn't a printing press in Constantinople until the 1720s, and that the Ottoman army was very far behind other armies in Europe. Why was it so far behind other major powers at the time? I would assume that the progressive heir of Islam combined with a history of using new technology (gunpowder) to great success would help develop the Ottoman Empire into a truly great, progressive power. How did it become the "sick man of Europe" despite having many factors working in its favor?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Is it true that Benjamin Franklin advocated the use of the longbow over the use of the flintlock musket during the American Revolutionary War?

According to this tale, Franklin advocated it's use due to higher rate of fire, better accuracy and the fact that The British had no body armour or shields that could've deflected the arrows. I'm wondering how true this is.

I think this story relies way too much on the often quoted superiority of the longbow over the flintlock musket, which is questionable at best. So i have some doubt that Franklin ever said this, but i could be wrong.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-08-31

What caused the social revolution of the 1960s, with the resultant movement towards more liberal attitudes regarding race, women and sexuality? If it was WW2, why didn't similar things happen after previous major wars?

2 Answers 2014-08-31

Who was the first nation to actually arrive on OZ??

I'm not talking about settlement, I'm talking first boats ever!

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Day of Reflection | August 31, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's installment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

5 Answers 2014-08-31

How likely is it that Plato or Socrates would've heard about or read the Old Testament?

6 Answers 2014-08-31

300 years ago do you think most people in England believed the King had been literally chosen by God to rule?

2 Answers 2014-08-31

Why is Thomas E. Dewey so lost to history and just a name on a newspaper?

Dewey came close to being our president, but my whole life he was only a name on the newspaper. Many also-rans suffer anonymity, but not all - Stephen Douglas, Al Gore, Richard Nixon (v. Kennedy and the first televised debate), George McClellan, Goldwater - but Dewey has never, in my life, been mentioned in any history class. It seems he only has one biography.. And yet his Wikipedia page makes him out to be a fascinating character and the bio calls him the founder of the modern Republican party. Is he remembered in New York? Are there any buildings named after him? What gives? (edit / addition: did he do something wrong? Is his party embarassed by him? It seems he was very progressive for his time)

3 Answers 2014-08-31

Did women shave their armpits in medieval times?

I was just wondering.

1 Answers 2014-08-31

What age were ancient soldiers?

So I made a comment on today's TIL thread about the age of Leonidas, in which I say that ancient soldiers were often older than we think. I'm not a historian and I can trace my impression back only to a couple of faint recollections: (1) a TV documentary about Alexander the Great in which his veterans were described (if I remember well) as being tough old guys in their 50s and 60s, but I can't recall any more specifics, and (2) I also seem to recall reading something about the Roman 'Triarii' units largely consisting of men in their 40s and upwards, despite being one the most powerful units in the Roman army.

One of the comments asked me for sources but I can't recall the details of my original souces or find any on the internet. Is my comment correct or is it nonsense? Were soldiers in ancient times older than our modern idea of the 'normal' age of a soldier?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Are West-Japanese relations from the turn of the 20th century more romanticized than West-Chinese relations from the same time period?

From what I've read it seems both countries were approaching the "opening to the west" in similar fashion although China appears more reluctant. Both isolated the majority of the western trading to single ports/cities (thinking Shanghai concessions and Kobe's quarters), but over the years it seems the movies, fiction etc I consume always seem to show Japan in a much more positive light.

Did the Opium War and Boxer Revolution (list goes on) create a shoddy foundation with China early, from which we've never recovered or have the end of WW2 + Korea + Cold War created a bias in how these countries are portrayed by the west?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Do the Axis have any famous units like the ones recognized on the Allied side like Easy Company or The Rats of Tobruk?

Units during WW2 like Easy Company, The Rats of Tobruk or the British D Company are focused heavily on in the story telling of the war in the media.

Shows like Band of Brothers or The Pacific have only increased the knowledge of these groups.

Did the Axis have any units like these which were famous for their actions during the war?

5 Answers 2014-08-31

Have our ancestors "decrypted" ancient greek like we did with hieropglyph?

Ancient greek grammar seems pretty complex to rebuild with the texts we have from that time; I was wondering if humanity re discovered ancient greek or if scholars, générations after generations, have transmitted it?

2 Answers 2014-08-31

Promotion of junior officeers in the WWI German army

Having read Storm of Steel and making my way through Infantry Attacks, its evident that both Rommel and Junger were competent and successful junior officers, both receiving the Blue Max by the end of the war.

Given their talents and accumulated experience, and given the high turnover in infantry officers in any WWI army, why did they still finish the war as company commanders?

Was promotion especially slow in the German army at the time (and if so how and why) or where there other reasons?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

What caused Viking expansion from 8th century to 11th century?

What's the reason behind the Viking expansion from 8th to 11th century? Was the population growing too quickly and the population density became too large to be accommodated in that peninsula? Or was it an response to the Christian expansion into North Europe?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Could stone-age make garlic bread?

1 Answers 2014-08-31

Why were bootlegs of musicians (Bob Dylan, The Beatles) so popular in the 1960's and 1970's?

I've often read that bootlegs of Bob Dylan or The Beatles were very popular "back in the day." What's the history behind this? How did people get them, and why were they so popular? Were records too expensive?

Thanks in advance (and sorry for how vague the question is).

2 Answers 2014-08-31

Russian historians, can you recommend any books so I can learn more about the Romanovs?

I'm not just interested in books, essays, articles and films are good too! I think they're fascinating and I want to know more about them

1 Answers 2014-08-31

6362 / 7255

Back to start