How did Florida get so much coastline in its panhandle? Did Alabama ever dispute the borders?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

What happened with integration with other professional sport teams or leagues?

At least in America, Jackie Robinson is a household name for when he joined MLB. His number is retired across the league. However, the stories of other baseball teams and other leagues are not taught or as well known. Did Mr. Robinson joining the Dodgers create a wave across baseball and other sports? How long was it from Mr. Robinson joining the Dodgers until the last MLB team integrated, and if possible, the last professional sports team integrated- North American or otherwise?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

In a TIL thread discussing the significance of fire bombing in Japan vs Atomic bombs in WW2, it was claimed that Kyoto was removed from the list of cities to bomb due to the city's cultural significance. Is it true? Why would cultural significance justify not bombing an enemy city at the time?

It's my understanding, from a college US history class a few years ago, that the US was incredibly racist. So much so that we considered the Japanese to be less than human, and placing Japanese Americans in camps was a popular move, which seemed like common sense to the (white) people of the time. Given my understanding of the zeitgeist of that time, it doesn't fit well that the US would have cared about the cultural significance of any Japanese city.

According to other users in that thread, Henry Stimson was the US secretary of war at the time, and it was his decision to remove Kyoto from the list. I'm curious how he justified this decision, and what his reasoning was for making the decision. Was there any common thought, at the time, that an enemy's culture would matter to the US? One user suggested that it was simply because he had taken his honeymoon there. I'm hoping for a less speculative answer, if possible, or at least an answer from someone who is familiar with US history around WW2.

Also, if I've based my understanding on a false premise, or made a poor assumption, I'm happy to be corrected, but I trust this sub to provide a healthy explanation if that's the case.

(PS I love you guys and I've been lurking here for years from my other account, but I think this is my first time posting here, so please let me know if I messed up the rules. I can also add the link for the AMA if anyone is curious about the thread, but I wasn't clear after I checked the rules if that was allowed.)

3 Answers 2021-06-26

Saturday Showcase | June 26, 2021

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2021-06-26

It's a known fact that Robert McNamara was a huge proponent of using mathematical data analysis and computing to influence his decisions as Secretary of Defense. But is it known what calculations he did in particular, what his formulas and models were and to what extent they influenced his strategy?

I want to write an essay on the flaws of McNamara's methods (EDIT: In regards to the Vietnam war) for my history classes but I am finding that concise and accurate metrics in this regard are very difficult to come buy. The best I could find was a paper by historian Donald Fisher Harrison. But this is a professional paper and it is daunting for a novice like me. Are there any fundamental facts or metrics that would make this paper easier to digest?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

What might the singer of Barrett's Privateers future be?

The song itself is fictional, but also highly realistic. For those not familiar with the song, a 17 year old in Canada signs onto a privateering vessel under the British Crown in 1778, going after American shipping. The ship is completely unfit for service and is destroyed by the Americans, with only the singer surviving, but with the loss of his legs, and in 1784 he's a broken man on a Halifax pier in his early 20s. Now what happens to him? Without legs, I presume he can't easily work, especially being an uneducated peasant. I don't know that a privateer could get a pension from the crown. Is there any sort of welfare system at all? Is he relegated to begging? Is there any kind of mobility aid available to him? How does society probably see him?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

In Tokugawa Japan could one travel Japan freely and could a peasant escape from their lord and become a merchant (or artisan)?

Whether it is technically illegal or not doesn’t really matter, more so that it’s enforced — Thanks.

2 Answers 2021-06-26

The name "Arturo" is not uncommon in Spain and Italy, even more than 200 years ago. Was the legend of King Arthur widely known on the European mainland, and if so, how did it spread there?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Looking for names of modern historians working on the history of Ancient Korea, please!

I don't mean texts like the Samguk Sagi/Samgukyusa, but modern historians with books/papers/podcasts etc on the history of the Silla Kingdom. Specifically, around the position of (non-aristocratic) women, as well as the general sociopolitics of King Jinheung, and the history of the Hwarang.

I've tried combing Jstor etc, but haven't come up with much beyond Richard Macbride. Most of the papers seem to deal with the Unified Silla period and later, whereas I'm interested in the earlier Kingdom.

Please let me know! Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Question about improvised artillery in the Chinese Civil War

i was watching a segment about a film set during the chinese civil war. the segment shows a battle between nationalist and communist forces. whil i was watching i noticed that the communist forces were using a very unusual form of artillery. for some reason, they were using metal barrels dug into the earth at an angle and filled with potato sacks that contained some sort of explosive. they then fired the barrels using a rope fuse. they reminded me of early gunpowder cannons. im not sure why they did this. are there any cases of this happening in real life, and if so why? are the soldiers in this particular engagement simply short of artillery pieces?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Why Mali Empire fleets failed to voyage to the West but European voyager later success ? Were voyage technologies are the main reason ?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Did the Romans have square-format books like we do? Or did they only have scrolls?

So I've been reading about the Villa of the Papyri and they only mention scrolls.

Since Romans were quite sophisticated in other matters, did they also make bound books with pages?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

How did early medieval armies tell which side a soldier or force was on?

What did they use before heraldry was widespread?

2 Answers 2021-06-26

Why did China develop economically so much faster than India in the late 20th century?

They both achieved independence and India even had a more developed infrastructure at the time. I don’t believe that any ideology or system is inherently better than others so what’s the deal?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Poland somehow avoided the Black Plague. Do we have any evidence or credible theories as to why when the rest of Europe and Asia suffered?

I was listening to a lecture by Robert Garland and he mentioned that Poland was spared from the Black Plague for unknown reasons. Is there any new evidence or hypothesis as to why?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

How did the Republicans go from being the progressive northern party to being the conservative southern party?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Today, our imagination of schizophrenic delusions involves government surveillance. But what did people we would consider schizophrenics today have delusions about before the advent of mass surveillance?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Why didn't the same (one) language preponderate over China, Korea, and Japan?

https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/q/40301

1 Answers 2021-06-26

What was the US populace's reaction to the establishment of the NHS and other universal healthcare systems in Europe during the 20th century?

American citizens at the time must have been aware to some extent. Did they demand that the US do the same? If they did, they obviously failed. So what what was the reasoning given by politicians at the time for the US not needing to establish a universal healthcare system similar to the England's?

Lyndon B. Johnson signed Medicare & Medicaid into law in 1965. Did he get pushback for it not being universal?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

When did ear protection become standard when using firearms in military situations?

Small arms are loud, cannonry and artillery etc. are louder. I was watching a popular world war two movie and wondered how much hearing damage these people had due to battle conditions.

When was hearing protection standardized due these problems?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Is it true that during medieval times people were constantly disease ridden and that it was normal to have people walk around with lumps and rashes all over?

To elaborate, was it common to see people have lumps and rashes on their bodies and that is wasn’t a big deal like “everyone has it” like was having these diseases so common it was normal to see that everyone had it?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

What did slave-owners in the United States do to slaves who were disabled, or who lived long enough to become too old to do any work?

1 Answers 2021-06-26

Nordic religious/mythological equivalent to South Asian "spiritual" works like Upanisads, Ramayana, Bhagavadgita, etc.?

So I know this is quite an odd question, but I am wondering if anyone can point me towards some sources or general understanding of the development of Nordic religion/mythology. My background is in SA religion, and so I am specifically wondering if we see a kind of specifically "spiritual" literature develop in Nordic religion as we do in South Asia? And by spiritual I mean some kind of conscious meta-awareness of existential problems as such. We don't *really* see this in the Vedas proper or the Puranas, and it isn't until around 600 BCE ish that we see the development of these more philosophically reflective works that seem to take existential questions of humanity or being itself as a self-conscious object of inquiry. I know I could be said to be a bit guilty of overly teleological thinking with regards to the development of religion here, but I nonetheless do believe certain broad patterns, often corresponding to large sociological changes, can be observed in the development of religious ideas. Anyways, any thoughts/source would be much appreciated!

1 Answers 2021-06-25

Were civilian spectators at the first Battle of Bull Run in Manassas, Virginia?

Is it true that northeners were so sure of the Union army that the battle was treated as a spectacle, with families setting up picnics?

1 Answers 2021-06-25

I love you guys. I've learned so much from you guys over the years.

People here are examples of GOOD NERDS. Yall nerd out on history and every time I come back here I learn something new. I am not a historian (I'm a layman), but my field of work frequently requires quick historical answers. You guys give me some information, and then I'm able to find very reputable sources from your info. Thanks all you historians! I freaking love you!

8 Answers 2021-06-25

640 / 7255

Back to start