When people on Reddit discuss criticism of millennials it's often said that older generations have always been very critical of younger generations, is there any historical basis for this?

2 Answers 2014-07-31

Is history truly cyclical, or does it just appear that way from cursory observation and general statistics?

2 Answers 2014-07-31

Is there any evidence for the victor of a war to be tried for war crimes?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Was it better to be black in the USA or aboriginal in the USA prior to the 1900's (or American civil war)?

Just watched the movie 12 years a slave and I found it very eye-opening when I saw the protagonist run into a group of aboriginals. I always thought of the racial issues among black and aboriginals as separate issues and never fully grasped the fact that these two racial issues were/are occurring simultaneously.

2 Answers 2014-07-31

What did Burke Mean in this Section from ROTRIF?

What follows is a tremendous and familiar passage. My simple question is: When Burke refers to "all that was to follow", does he mean the entire revolution or just the assembly? Cheers.

"Judge, Sir, of my surprise, when I found that a very great proportion of the assembly (a majority, I believe, of the members who attended) was composed of practitioners in the law. It was composed, not of distinguished magistrates, who had given pledges to their country of their science, prudence, and integrity; not of leading advocates, the glory of the bar; not of renowned professors in universities- but for the far greater part, as it must in such a number, of the inferior, unlearned, mechanical, merely instrumental members of the profession. There were distinguished exceptions, but the general composition was of obscure provincial advocates, of stewards of petty local jurisdictions, country attorneys, notaries, and the whole train of the ministers of municipal litigation, the fomenters and conductors of the petty war of village vexation. From the moment I read the list, I saw distinctly, and very nearly as it has happened, all that was to follow."

edit: corrected a weird typographical error reflected in the source (lazily c&p'd from http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1791burke.asp )

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Has Import Substitution as an economic policy ever been successful?

Import Substitution being the policy of limiting imports of foreign goods in order to develop the domestic capacity enough to satisfy an internal market.

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Did Soviet trains/airlines have classes of service? If so, what distinguished them/who could access them? How was was such a seemingly-blatant violation of Marxism rationalized?

I can't imagine high party officials traveling in the same train cars with the proletariat. But the irony of "first class," "second class," etc. in what was ostensibly a "worker's paradise" is just too rich.

1 Answers 2014-07-31

If one wants to learn history, where does one begin?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Found: Cannon balls

Hey everyone, this is the first post I've made in here and as a fellow historian I could use some help!

My dad was helping a friend clean out an old barn in Western Maryland when they found several cannon balls. I've attached the only picture he was able to get as they were cleaning everything out but they're 8" and about 70-75 lbs as best he knows. They're too rusted to read/make out any markings unfortunately.

The fact that they're round and don't seem to have a fuse seems to me to indicate possible naval use, and not mortar. Otherwise I have no idea and any additional help dating them would be great! They're going up for auction this Sunday, August 3rd.

Pic: http://i.imgur.com/yeaunnD.jpg

(Also, if this isn't the place for a post like this please feel free to point me in the right direction!)

3 Answers 2014-07-31

What sort of damage would occur from two early 19th-century ships of the line exchanging broadsides directly into each others' hulls?

Let's say third rates, roughly 80 guns. What I am referring to is an exchange of round-shot fire between the two ships' gun decks, at medium range, directly into each others' side hulls. I am NOT referring to raking fire from aft to forward or vice-versa, nor am I referring to shot into the rigging, the crew, etc. I am interested to know how much actual damage would be done by such an exchange, and how many of the cannonballs would simply bounce off harmlessly, or nearly so. Do we have a historical example(s) to look to for evidence of such an exchange, despite it being against most doctrine?

Again, imagine medium range, so no carronades, mortars or the like, and imagine the two ships are essentially equivalent in armament, construction, and design.

1 Answers 2014-07-31

How close has our world come to a nuclear holocaust?

With stories about how close the US and USSR came to launching ICBMs due to incorrect intelligence and warning system data, I wonder how close we have come to a MAD scenario.

I'm not just looking for cold war answers, though I'm sure the bulk will be, but anytime any country legitimately had their thumb on "the button."

*I know it's not a button.

1 Answers 2014-07-31

What was it like in German cities when the concentration camps were liberated? Were the citizens horrified? Did the prisoners just go back to their homes?

I've always been taught that many German citizens were unaware of what was going on while the concentration camps were in use, but I am curious as to what their reactions were AFTER the camps were liberated. Surely they were faced to deal with the reality when the emaciated survivors left the camps. I guess my question is what was this like, and did the survivors actually make their way back to their original homes or did they go elsewhere?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Do we have any idea what the most common causes of death during the Middle Ages were?

I'm fairly sure most people died of illness or "old age" but do we know if any specific illnesses killed more than others? Was it mostly infections that did people in or were factors such as heart disease also of significance? If infections were the main culprits, do we know if they were respiratory or circulatory?

Also, were plagues common and widespread enough to be a significantly common cause of death (with the exception of the Black Death?

2 Answers 2014-07-31

How were disabled veterans treated in Medieval society?

If they lost a leg or an arm, what would happen to them? Assuming they survived the injury, what would they do when they returned home? Would they get money from the king honoring their service? Or were they left to fend for themselves? What jobs could they do?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Suppose I created a wormhole (or time machine) and transported all seven of the Harry Potter books back to the court of King Henry VIII. Would they be able to recognize it as English and if so how much of it would they understand?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

How and when did the concept (and term) "civil war" develop?

What war was it first used to reference? Does the term mean the same thing now that it did when it was first coined?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Gender and Naming During The Late Bronze Age in Europe and Africa

I was wondering if anyone could point me to some sources on human naming traditions during the late Bronze Age. Was there much information on what common people would tend to be named as opposed to their gods or monarchs? And just to make it even more specialized, are there records on the naming of women during this time? Any sources regarding the prominent civilizations during the time would be welcome. Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-07-31

What kind of dishes and recipes do we eat today that come from ancient times?

For example: Stew, meat pies. Etc

1 Answers 2014-07-31

How did Byzantine Emperor Alexios I Komnenos afford his currency reforms?

/u/Ambarenya gave an awesome overview of Alexios's reforms [here] (http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2b1qq9/what_did_alexios_i_komnenos_do_differently_to_his/cj1dup2). Where did the specie for his new coins come from? How exactly could Alexios afford to increase the specie in each coin? Specie from recycled coins and donated Church valuables was used, but was that enough? Did Alexios have to implement additional taxes?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Why did the US enter WWI?

At the time, the US was not heavily involved in old world European politics, and had little to gain militarily from joining a side in the war. In addition, it was an exceptionally sanguinary conflict when the US entered late, and there was no particular reason, moral, political or otherwise, why the US would join one side versus the other. So why did the US enter WWI?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

How did the modern day hiring process of application + resume, then interview, become commonplace?

I've been looking for a job recently, and yesterday it dawned on me how specific the process seems to be. Look for a job, turn in a resume and application, have an interview, cross your fingers. But it couldn't have always been that way.

I assume that manual labor jobs, like farming, probably hired whoever could do the work. But when did jobs like grocers and bankers start asking for applications? Was there any historical precedent for an application or resume?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

Is the lack of smoking in Downton Abbey realistic?

I was asking myself of the noble families of the early nineteen hundreds didn't smoke a lot, because of the lack of smoking in serie as Downton Abbey or that it is just that smoking on the television isn't cool anymore.

2 Answers 2014-07-31

How much has the Magyar history affected Hungary historical make up and is it relevant to there culture today?

I am doing some dissertation work, and I need to look into Hungarian history briefly and find how there past events affect there identity today. If anyone can give me brief understanding of the major points in the Magyar/Hungarian history or if anyone knows a good documentary or book would be god.

1 Answers 2014-07-31

What did Mexico use for sewage management 100's of years ago?

I'm doing a paper on the Sewage systems of Great Britain, Mexico, and the USA. Currently I am stuck as I can't find any information pertaining to Mexico's history of sewage. I know that England would throw it's waste in the streets but what did Mexico do?

1 Answers 2014-07-31

What are some good books about the American Revolution?

I'm looking for some good, detailed, historical books on both the political and military aspects of the Revolution. Also, any book recommendations on the French & Indian War would be appreciated. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-07-31

6465 / 7255

Back to start