Telephone Bills in the Early Days of Telephones

How were telephone bills calculated in the early days of the telephone (late 1800s- early 1900s)? I'm thinking in particular of the days when you still had to talk to an operator and ask her to connect you to your other party. Did somebody at the telephone company sit there with a stopwatch to time your call, or was telephone service offered for a flat fee? Also, how much did a local telephone call cost in the late 1800s (say one Manhattan residence to another Manhattan residence)?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Were there any recorded UFO sighting prior to the early 1900s?

4 Answers 2014-07-19

How apt would a common colonist be to survive in case of crop failure?

I'm specifically wondering about the situation in which there are no native settlements around that could trade food or information about the land. How did they act? Were they left to completely fend for themselves or could they expect to have supplies regularly brought to them? Would knowledge about fauna and flora from back home help devise survival techniques or would colonist be afraid of interacting with their surroundings?

The question applies to anywhere around the world. North and South Americas, Africa, Oceania, some island in the middle of the ocean, etc.

Finally, is there any known and well described case that I could read about?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Any environmental historians around here?

Maybe this question doesn't belong here, as it is not specifically a question about a historical event, so feel free moderators, to remove my post if you deem it necessary. Anyways, are there any environmental historians around here? I just made my first foray into environmental history via the book The Mortal Sea: Fishing the Atlantic in the Age of Sail by W. Jeffrey Bolster (teaches history at the Uni. of New Hampshire) and found it to be both enlightening and refreshing. I haven't always understood the significance of the role that environment plays into the human story, but I am learning that perhaps humans and the environment are inextricably intertwined in a way that's difficult to really academically grasp. Are any of you familiar with Bolster's work? Is this idea of the connection between humanity and nature the fundamental thesis explaining the justification for studying environmental history?

2 Answers 2014-07-19

A few questions after reading C. S. Forester's Hornblower saga.

I have been rereading Hornblower saga. I have a few questions, although I am sorry if they are stupid or too vague. I woul be happy if you answer even only one question!

  1. How highly service in the navy was regarded at that time? To where would a young man from a rich aristocratic family more likely to be sent: in the navy or army? Why would they go in the navy at all, because to me very bad food, cramped living conditions and salt water every living moment sounds like its own kind of hell.

  2. How high on the social ladder were captains? If such a captain was not from a rich and influential family, with whom he could hope to befriend on the shore: a priest, or a judge, or someone from gentry?

  3. Could a retired captain live on a half salary? Where did all those captains go after being discharged at the end of the war?

  4. By marrying Hornblower did Barbara Wellesley commit a major faux pas? A daughter of an earl married a son of a vilage doctor, yes, a captain, yes, recently knighted and probably a national hero, but son of a doctor non the less. It is one thing for Mr. Rochester to marry his daughter's governess, it is another thing if the roles would be reversed.

  5. What was the difference between being knighted and given Order of the Bath and being made baron? To me they all belong to nobility.

  6. Was there a tight, interconnected and intermarried officer class with several generations of those who served in the navy like it was with lots of professions in civil sector?

  7. I know that the character of Hornblower was based on many real life examples, but aside from Nelson and Coghlan I could not find anyone that did not come from aristocratic family or gentry. Was it that hard to make such career for a boy with no background?

  8. If a captain from the early 19 century was magically transported to a modern ship like the newly built HMS Queen Elizabeth, would anything be familiar to him aside from rank names? Any traditions, customs or rules?

Thank you!

2 Answers 2014-07-19

AMA - Modern Israel and the Israeli-Arab Conflict

Hi!

I'm going to be hosting today's AMA and answering all your burning questions on the history of Modern Israel and Palestine! Some guidelines, before we get down to business:

  • I am fully prepared to talk about anything from the beginnings of modern Zionism (roughly the 1880s) to the Oslo I Accords (early 1990s). However, I will not include the Oslo I Accords, as they are far too political and it would be difficult to talk about them without breaking the 20 year rule.

  • I am prepared to answer any question about Israeli or Palestinian perspectives. I have studied the historians and political beliefs of both sides of this conflict, and can answer questions about them.

  • Please don't come in with preconceptions, and please be respectful. This is a charged topic, especially with ongoing political events, so I hope we can have a minimum of trolling and the like!

Finally, I'd like to note that I do have a pro-Israel bias, and I'd like to be upfront about that. However, my political beliefs do not (I believe) apply to which information I present. I have always, especially on this sub, attempted to provide both perspectives to the best of my ability, or intermingle them and acknowledge the differences of opinion, as I did here. I will attempt to cite all my references/sources, so please feel free to ask, and check out what I say as well :)!

Ask away!

Edit: Taking a brief lunch/dinner (linner? dunch?) break, will return shortly to continue! Keep asking questions, I'll still get to them!

Edit 2: In case it wasn't clear, I'm back!

Edit 3: Forgot to mention, anyone interested in following and learning more after the AMA can follow my blog or ask questions there, it's http://tayaravaknin.wordpress.com. I only recently set it up, and will be adding to it over time, so please feel free to take a look!

Edit 4: Well, with me needing sleep finally after 14 hours, I'm closing up the AMA. It was enjoyable to host, and I'm hopeful that everyone enjoyed! If I promised you a PM, it will arrive sometime tomorrow: I have not forgotten! Anyone with more questions can still post in the thread or post as a separate thread (probably better to post separately) in /r/AskHistorians :). Good night everyone!

39 Answers 2014-07-19

Are we on the verge of a new "World War" ? Compared to the unfolding of WWI and II, what recent events (<15 years) COULD be seen as antecedents for it ? What elements are speaking against the likelihood of such a scenario happening ? Which nations would be involved and what alliances formed ?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Why did English speakers not predominantly use the terms Islam and Muslim until the mid-20th century?

I always see Islam referred to as "Mohammedism" and Muslims referred to as "Mohammedans" or similar terms in older texts. When and why did the shift toward using more directly Arabic terms occur?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

When did humans start becoming interested in history?

At what point did humans really start to research and be intrigued by their ancestors lives?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

How might the Romans of Virgil's time have pictured the ancient Trojans/Phoenicians, and do we know what they actually looked like?

I am currently reading Virgil's Aeneid and just finished the story of Aeneas and Dido, and it occurred to me that my image of the characters comes from later paintings I've seen of them, which seem to portray them as Caucasian. I would like my own mental picture of them to be as accurate as possible (not that how they looked if they existed really matters; I'm just curious), but I'm also interested in how Virgil and people of his time might have seen them.

1 Answers 2014-07-19

What are the different effects of environment on food production in the Eastern and Western hemispheres?

I've started to read Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs, and Steel, which is such an interesting book in itself. One of its main focal points is how agriculture is a huge factor in how civilizations develop. And since starting to read this book, I've been wondering how food production differed between the Eastern and Western hemispheres as a result of the different environments.

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Were the bows of steppe archers harder to pull back than those of an English longbowman?

In an episode of Dan Carlin's Hardcore History (I think it was "Steppe Stories"), he mentioned that the bow of a steppe horse archer (I don't remember which tribe) was harder to pull back than that of an English longbowman. Is there any truth to this?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Ronin in the Sengoku period?

In the Edo period, at least to my knowledge, ronin would often become mercenaries or get involved in petty crime, among other things. How was this different prior to the Tokugawa Shogunate, i.e. in the Sengoku period?

What kind of possessions would a ronin, Sengoku or Edo, have? Would he have owned a horse or a suit of armour (in the Sengoku period)?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Who decides/when is it decided to give someone an epithet?

I remember that Alexander of Macedon was called "the Great" while he was still living, that Augustus was a title given to Octavius, but who gets to decide that someone gets an epithet? How does someone get "the Terrible", "the Conqueror", "the Magnificent", and is it something that happens posthumously or not?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Why weren't the Persians able to use archers and mounted archers to defeat the Greek and Macedonian hoplites?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

What were some of the cultural, social, and political differences between the Austrian and Hungarian regions of Austria-Hungary during the events leading up to the first world war?

Hey /r/AskHistorians! I am currently reading a book about the first world war and I am trying to better understand how the government Austria-Hungary worked during this time. I know that Austria-Hungary was divided mainly into two sections (Austria & Hungary) and they had two centers of government in Vienna and Budapest (I know there are much more factors than that because Austria-Hungary was a heavily culturally divided place, I would like info about that as well). I was wondering if you could tell me how the differences in the political/cultural/social aspects of these two regions affected how Austria-Hungary reacted after the assassination of Franz Ferdinand?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

How true is it that Prescott Bush was involved in an attempt to overthrow the Roosevelt government and install a fascist regime?

Wikipedia, particularly the article concerning the Business Plot, has been scrubbed of all mention of Prescott Bush's (Yes, GWB's grandfather) involvement in the Business Plot.

I was wondering if it was removed because it is not true, or if the Bush family has paid someone to scrub it, or if all of it is fringe conspiracy nonsense that conspiracy theorist embellished with their own rewritten version of history.

1 Answers 2014-07-19

What is the first country that has its Independence Day / fought Independence War?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

What is known about the true origins the Quran and whether it has evolved over time?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Where any ''concept weapons'' made?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Saturday Reading and Research | July 19, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

5 Answers 2014-07-19

History of Germany that focuses on 1929-1934?

I have the audio version of Shirer's The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. I've listened repeatedly to the coverage of this important period, when the Nazis went from relative obscurity to power and consolidation of that power.

I think it's fascinating. The way Shirer paints it, things had to fall just right for Hitler. The machinations of von Schleicher, von Papen, the various parties, President and Oskar Hindenburg all worked in a intricate dance to bring Hitler to power.

Then, consolidation of that power with the Röhm-Putsch in 1934.

Is there a really good book on this specific period?

1 Answers 2014-07-19

How do I find out if my house was used in the Underground Railroad?

We bought an 1857 Victorian home located on the bluff in Quincy, IL two blocks from the Mississippi river with Missouri on the other side. There are a few homes in town that have been proven to be part of the Underground Railroad, but I have no idea how they proved it.

When we bought the house, the previous owners pointed out an area in the basement (which is almost entirely original, with brick floors and all) that appears to have been a fairly good sized tunnel at some point. But that doesn't necessarily mean much, because Quincy has had lots of tunnels for lots of reasons. There used to be several breweries with tunnels that went all over town, for instance; and we had at least one prohibition bootlegger with his own system of tunnels. We know that the original owner of the home was the first banker in town, so he may have had his own reasons for having a tunnel. If it was a tunnel at all.

4 Answers 2014-07-19

If I recall correctly, there were pacifists against going to war with Japan and Germany after Pearl Harbor. In addition, there were pacifists post RMS Lusitania sinking. Can R/AskHistorians cover this some?

Societal impact, influence on public opinion etc.

I admit, I'm more of a financial legal historian focused on the 1800s. Some light shed on post-RMS Lusitania and post-Pearl Harbor pacifism would be neat. This is of course thinking of recent events in Ukraine. Still working on PhD I will note I do follow the notion that history never repeats itself, but eh..those that specialize in this area it would be interesting to hear from you. Maybe next financial crisis I can add to questions pertaining to financial legal history..maybe..it seems my PhD is making me more introverted as the weeks, months...pass by.

1 Answers 2014-07-19

Were there professional musicians in the era of Romantic music? (mid-late 1800's) and if so, what were their lives like? Was it possible to make a living playing music during this time period?

I hope the title is pretty self explanatory.

Thank you!

2 Answers 2014-07-19

6509 / 7255

Back to start