Memoirs after the fact: Primary or secondary sources?

Would the personal memoirs of an individual written decades after an event be considered a primary source for that event? How do historians view such sources?

1 Answers 2014-06-03

Where did the practice of thanking people come from? Is there a rough equivalent to "thank you" and "you're welcome" in most languages or are there other practices? In periods with a more formalized class structure, would one in an elevated social class have thanked someone in a lower class?

3 Answers 2014-06-03

Where does the concept of a "state" come from, and when did it begin?

I've read that medieval cities and townships didn't ever conceive of themselves as say "french" in any real sense, even though when we look back at the history we often refer to things like "the nation of France". The ancient Greeks had the concept of the polis. And of course history is littered with empires. But where did the "nation state" come from? When did it start? When did the actual people, not just the monarchs, consider themselves to be living in a nation and that they were the same as the village a hundred miles away, because they were all "french", and not a collection of villages that viewed their neighboring villages as foreign?

Obviously I don't mean to limit this to France. I'm just using that as an example.

1 Answers 2014-06-03

Georgian:Was the seven years war technically the first world war, rather than the great war of 1914-18?

Was the seven years war technically the first real world war? I read somewhere that Churchill argued this historical point, he argued that because the seven years war had conflict and belligerents on every continent it was technically the world's first world war, therefore meaning that the great war of 1914-18 (abiding by the same factors) was actually the worlds second world war; rather than first.

As well as this what are the criteria for a world war? and are there any more debates over potential non-named / credited world wars?

2 Answers 2014-06-03

To what extent might it be true that Scandinavian women are relatively attractive because Vikings brought back attractive women from raids?

Inspired by that meme.

1 Answers 2014-06-03

What was the Medieval concept of Europe?

In the Fourteenth century, Petrarch claimed that what we now consider the Middle Ages was a period of intellectual decline, which he titled the "Dark Ages." In what he referred to as Europe, he said that classical learning declined greatly. I understand this, while seeing the medieval renaissances as disproving this, but what was the medieval concept of the European continent? As far as I'm concerned, in the Selecluid and Sassanian Empires, classical thought was greatly preserved, and this was transferred to the Abbassid Caliphates. Did the coming of Islam create a divide between what we see as Europe, or did the average medieval person not think of continental borders?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

Was speculative literature on the future common before the 20th century?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

If Rome were put into the 21st century, and their relative level of power and wealth compared to the rest of the world at the time were put into today's society, what would their city, army, and economy be like?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

In shows like Game of Thrones, characters wear their armor almost everywhere. How accurate is this portrayal?

In the most recent episode of GOT, there is a character who wears heavy plate armor in the middle of an almost impenetrable castle. Would knights or lords do this at all? Armor is heavy and took assistance in many cases to put on and take off, making it seem unlikely that people would wear it unless they were going to war or traveling.

4 Answers 2014-06-02

How would the world have turned out if America had sided with Germany in World War 1?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

What are the "ancestors" of Judaism?

What came before it? How did people come up with the idea of one god and all the stories in The Bible and such?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

What are some good books for looking into the Battle of Camaron.

Sorry if this falls under the polls rule, I didn't see anything about book recommendations. I am specifically looking for good material on the Battle of Camaron, but general French Foreign Legion history is of interest to me as well.

1 Answers 2014-06-02

How was knighthood during the Victorian Era?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

How did the "Real Madrid" futbol club became one of the most known and famous clubs in the world?

A long with a few selected teams, this is one of the most famous futbol teams even over seas. Im wondering how did it happen: too many won cup? good financial choices? good publicity?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

Why did it take so long for rolling luggage to be invented and even longer for it to catch on?

From this this article, I learned that rolling luggage was invented in 1970, and the "Rollaboard" design with the telescoping handle wasn't invented until 1987. Why did it take so long to develop rolling luggage?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

What were Hitlers plans after winning ww2? What was he planning to do with his Italian and Japanese allies?

As far as I know, Hitlers goal was to create an arian-only world where all other races would have been eradicated or enslaved. And I assume that the reason he teamed up with the Japanese, Italians etc. is because he figured that extra soldiers fighting for germany would be useful.

But was Hitler planning another war betwene say Japan and Germany after the Allies would be defeated? Is this mentioned anywhere? Did Tojo or Mussolini know about the inevitable war betwene them and Germany? Did Hitler view the Japanese as "untemench" or as "pretty cool guys that can stick around after we conquer the world" ?

Basicly, what I want to know is. Did Germany actually like its allies or did they just tolerate them because they needed them?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

How accurate was the HBO television film 'The Normal Heart' in retelling the AIDS crisis between 1981-83?

Not only government response, but also mannerisms of gay men living in the era. As a gay man myself I found the differences quite shocking (e.g. a massive emphasis on sexuality in relationships as 'liberating').

1 Answers 2014-06-02

Human trafficking in the Roman Empire

How common was illegal human trafficking in the Empire? I guess more specifically how common was it for a group of people to have the explicit intent of kidnapping a person / group of people for the intent of illegally selling them into sexual slavery, forced labor, or forced marriage. Were there any 'hot spots' for risk of being taken by these groups, if it was ever that serious?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

How much did the Triangular Slave Trade impact the British Industrial Revolution?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

Was trial by combat ever a "thing"

It seems such an illogical way to determine guilt, yet it is often referenced in books and tv-shows set in a medieval stage (namely Game of Thrones). Did people actually do this, or is it just an easy way to introduce a fight into a tv-show?

2 Answers 2014-06-02

Some questions about the Spanish Revolution

What would it be like to be a worker in an anarchist stronghold during the Spanish Revolution? What was an average day like? How did this compare to a worker's life in the Soviet Union? How does this compare to modern America? How does this compare to life before the revolution and in Francoist Spain?

For the record, I'm referring to this one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_revolution

1 Answers 2014-06-02

Why was Rhodesia much more prosperous than many other African states and what events led to its downfall?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

How is Peter the Great, a man John Merriman once called a "Peasant Tsar", regarded in Russia today? Why?

I thought it was interesting that Peter the Great is often called an absolutist ruler, frequently compared to Louis XIV, but acted very differently to him and often sympathised greatly with the common people to a huge extent. How is he regarded today?

1 Answers 2014-06-02

In the US, what role did comic books play in perceptions of black Americans during and following the Black-American Civil Rights Movement?

I've read that comic books were fairly racist during and following World War II (mostly towards Asian peoples), but I'm confused about the ways in which comic books presented black Americans.

Were they more racist or progressive? Were they focused on integration into white America or black empowerment? Were these perceptions dependent upon different publishers?

Aside from All-Negro Comics (a one-off series in 1947), I can't find much information on black people appearing in comic books until the 60's with characters such as Gabriel Jones in Nick Fury's Howling Commandos or Black Panther who appeared in Fantastic Four in 1966 and got his own series in 1973.

Additionally, how heavily were comic publishers decisions on race dependent upon the bottom line, financially speaking? When black people were eventually incorporated into comics (and eventually had their own series), was the decision to do so based on predominantly financial or socially progressive reasons?

Lastly, what academic literature can I read on the subject to further my knowledge on the issue? (/u/Bufus)

2 Answers 2014-06-02

Who were the Indo-Europeans, how their language became the mother of a huge part of today's languages and how come a European (a French, let's say) looks so different from a Indian today?

Really, it's mind-blowing to me how Portuguese and Hindi could be related and that a Portuguese and a Indian might have come from the same people.

I mean, I know, if we go back at the beginning of human race, we all come from the same place. But isn't that TOO broad? If there's a Indo-European people/language branch it must mean there's another groups, right?

How come? How were these split?

2 Answers 2014-06-02

6668 / 7255

Back to start