Why did Celtic culture survive the Roman occupation in Cornwall and Wales so much better than in England?

2 Answers 2014-04-23

Why did Spain decline in the 1600s-1700s

Correct me if I'm wrong, but Spain had a huge empire and were extremely rich in the age of discovery (16th-early 17th century I think). Yet, after the Napoleonic wars they weren't even included in the concert of Europe-What led,to this decline in power? Was it something to do with the 30 years' war??

2 Answers 2014-04-23

Books to learn more about carthage?

Does anyone have to recommend to learn more about carthage

3 Answers 2014-04-23

Before the globalization of the food market, was it possible for people who live in a cold climate to get fruits in winter?

Nowadays, we have all the fruit we want, whenever we want it, in the supermarket. But did people eat fruits in winter, in countries where it was frequently freezing?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

What was the difference between The Nazi Schutzstaffel and Wehrmacht?

My understanding of their difference is limited as the SS was party's private army while Wehrmacht was national army. Was there any difference in equipment, doctrine, recruitment, ideology etc. besides the "SS was more elite" and the SS marched alongside Wehrmacht during the war?

Thanks.

2 Answers 2014-04-23

The North Korean narrative regarding the Korean War is that the conflict was begun when South Korean and American forces invaded the North, and that they merely defended themselves. Was this the same narrative that was taught throughout the Communist world?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

How was the recipe for concrete lost when the Roman Empire fell? Why was it not known in the Eastern Roman Empire?

I don't know all that much on the topic so I might be confused as to how exactly the recipe was 'lost' and maybe I don't correctly understand the interaction between the West and Eastern empires. Thanks for taking the time to read this.

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Could the Nazis have won on the Eastern Front, had they pushed for Moscow instead of Stalingrad?

3 Answers 2014-04-23

Why is it that a man who was born in Palestine and died in Turkey is the patron saint of England?

Everybody in England loves St. George and he is a source of great patriotism but from what I can see, he shouldn't have anything to do with my country? Please explain, I'm befuddled.

Thankyou!

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Many Russian historians do not except the widespread rape of German women by the Red army, despite western consensus . Many Turkish historians do not accept the Armenian genocide happened, despite western consensus. What events do western historians not accept - despite non-western consensus?

Oh man embarrassing grammar in the title - can't work out how to change..

edit:

I know I gave example of atrocities in the thread title so this is what most people are replying about: I am also interested in any historical issue where there is a consensus amongst non western countries not accepted by the west. I also don't want this topic just to be about scenarios where historical events aren't accepted on nationalist grounds.

I feel western historians probably all have certain things in common. They have centuries of similar intellectual traditions; from capitalism, liberalism, christianity, the greek/roman canon, philosophical ideas, scientific ideas, etc etc...features which no doubt inform their thought, even subconsciously . Western historians come from countries which have dominated economically, have (or have had) dominant relations with the rest of the world ( i.e. colonialism/empire etc). I am interested in how these events have shaped western historians views, and whether non-western intellectual traditions/experiences have shaped different views of events.

I would expect differences in social and economic history particularly..

edit2: Sorry mods for all the work..

6 Answers 2014-04-23

To which extent atrocities attributed to Stalin is true?

I was reading this article which claimed:

The most commonly-made claims used to denounce Stalin and the USSR under his leadership are that Stalin built up a cult of personality around himself, that Stalin suppressed democracy and eliminated anyone who disagreed with him, that the bureaucracy which emerged in the USSR was largely Stalin’s doing, and that the USSR under Stalin was ultimately “state capitalism.” All of these claims are either false or thoroughly misleading. The first two assertions are simply not backed up by any credible evidence. Surely, there is a great deal of literature expounding upon Stalin’s supposed crimes and abuses of power, but these accounts are almost entirely based on hearsay and rumor, something even bourgeois historians occasionally admit.

There was a comment on /r/socialism citing this article in defense of how the lack of democracy in Stalinist era wasn't (entirely) Stalin's fault.

But I'm specially interested in the "eliminated anyone who disagreed with him" bit; the author attributes the purges to Ezhov, which is then called "part of a Rightist conspiracy" (which Ezhov confessed under torture). My understanding is that Ezhov was useful to advance Stalin's goals into consolidation of power, and that he was later discarded for some reason.

Anyway, the article gave me the motivation to ask this here but the question goes beyond it: is the common view that Stalin was directly responsible for many Soviet atrocities true? Did he order torture and murder of his political opponents?

4 Answers 2014-04-23

If I was a slave paddler on a large ship, what would my life be like?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

How did the Russians colonize the steppe? What where their tactics?

Did they have different tactics before Peter the great? I'm really interested in Russian colonization, because so often we only look at the Europeans form of colonization but it's not commonly known that the Russians colonized as well

1 Answers 2014-04-23

ancient Roman nobles are often portrayed in the movies or TV with by actors with posh British accents. what would the proper representation of them?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Would the Allies have won WWI without U.S. military involvement?

Is there any evidence showing that the Central Powers could have been successful if the U.S. hadn't gotten involved.

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Early Christianity, Paul and Jesus

Just read this article, and piqued some questions I was wondering if anyone cared to elaborate on.

First, I saw another comment briefly mention Paul's 'ministry' as a cult which later merged to become what we know as Christianity today, and I was wondering if there is any historical evidence for that.

Similarly, how did Christianity become a global religion itself? I understand the Roman adoption of it as a state religion greatly helped, but why did the Roman Imperium adopt it in the first place?

2 Answers 2014-04-23

Were There Any Particularly Popular Artistic Depictions Of Jesus Before We "Forgot" That He Was From The Middle East?

Living in the modern world, the only depictions of Jesus I see are of some white guy or pictures explicitly meant as a reminder that he didn't actually look like that. Are there any surviving renditions from before he was white-washed?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Why does India have so many languages while next door China which is much bigger in size not so many?

Thank you all for the responses. But my query was more India centric in the sense that what conditions led to so much fragmentation in the Indian subcontinent in terms of language, culture etc. (this is my first post on reddit so pls excuse me if I'm not doing it right)

5 Answers 2014-04-23

what explains the differences in ideological certainty between different parts of the world?

In particular, the Middle East

2 Answers 2014-04-23

What was Austria like during the Cold War

I've heard that it was divided into British, French, American, and Soviet zones, much like Germany, but not much else. Could someone give me some more details about the economic, political, and social history of Austria after WW2?

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Has Russia always had a rocky relationship with the West? If so, why?

I've been doing some reading on here and it seems that at various points in history, Russia was allied with many different western European countries. When did it start becoming more distant with the West? It seems it started happening before WW2, but I know that wasn't the first time Russia had friction with Western powers.

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Are there any notable accounts of kings/leaders fighting hand to hand combat in battles along side their soldiers?

I always see in movies where the generals/kings/leaders are along side their army, in the thick of the action fighting along side their soldiers. Now I know to take movies with a grain of salt in terms of historical value, but did this actually happen? I just can't seem to picture kings getting in the action of the battles. Are there any accounts of very highly ranked individuals, even royalty fighting with their army?

2 Answers 2014-04-23

In the 19th century why did foreign heads of state (like the emperor of Japan or the king of thailand for instance) start adopting European dress?

It's not like they didn't have contact with us before that, and it's not like you need to wear a neck tie to use a revolver or build a steam engine

1 Answers 2014-04-23

Can anyone help my grandfather find a castle he was near during WWII? He was in the 22nd Infantry Regiment of the 4th Infantry Division.

I have tried for a few years now to find a photo of a castle my grandfather was stationed near during WWII with no success. He is getting older and I am running out of options, it would mean the world to him. He was in the 22nd Infantry Regiment of the 4th Infantry Division. He remembers being near this castle but not allowed to visit it. He believes it was in Germany and near a rail line, there was also a creek/stream at the foot of the hill it sat on. I thought it was Altenberg Castle near Bamberg, Germany but he claims this isn't it. Does anyone know the path that this regiment took through the war and what castle(s) it could potentially be?

2 Answers 2014-04-23

Most 20th century history classes go into depth discussing WWII, skim the Korean War, and then focus on Vietnam and the Cold War. Why so little attention to Korea?

The Korean Conflict is still very much going on, yet most people can’t tell you squat about North Korea. Except that their Leader looks like the guy from Gangnam Style. Why do most classes not discuss The Korean conflict and the implications that it has caused.

2 Answers 2014-04-23

6831 / 7255

Back to start