So, I'm in /r/badhistory a lot, and I notice that they are constantly on about the "Jesus don't real" bit, disputing people saying that Jesus never existed. So, since Easter is just around the corner, I figured I would be the person brave (or stupid) enough to ask the question.
What first hand evidence is there that he existed? From my understanding (which may be horribly flawed, which is why I'm asking here) there is no actual first hand account of his life. The Gospel Of Mark is supposed to be, but from what I understand it also references things that happened after Mark died, meaning he couldn't have been the author. I know about the Dead Sea Scrolls and the recent "Jesus Wife" scroll, but aren't they both dated hundreds of years after he was crucified? I know I could be very wrong about all this, so I would really appreciate some expert information. Thanks in advance!
2 Answers 2014-04-18
1 Answers 2014-04-18
I have read (sorry, don't have reference) that Judea was a minor province, and Pontius Pilate was Equestrian, not Patrician. Both of these meant that Pilate did not have the rank to have had any actual Legionaries under his command. His soldiers were therefore actually Auxiliaries (possibly Samaritans, which could have interesting consequences as garrison soldiers of a Jewish province). The nearest Legions were in Damascus under the command of the Legate of Syria.
This sounds intriguing, but implausible: the Bible is of course very specific about there being a Centurion at the crucifixion. Might Auxiliaries have had a Centurion as commander? Or is it just more likely that Pilate had a detachment of Legionaries given to him from Damascus? Thoughts from the Historians?
3 Answers 2014-04-18
1 Answers 2014-04-18
Question on the Reformation. Need some blanks filled on regarding a radical sect that came up during the reformation.
I remember hearing about a sect that grew out of the reformation (most likely anabaptists) who took to some pretty radical ideas such as collectivisation and what we would call free love, liberal interpretation of marriage (if it was thought of at all) and developed the doctrine of Sin is good because what is important about the Christian experience is that forgiveness, so go sin so you can be forgiven again.
I know the anabaptists were persecuted by both Catholic and Protestants and I think/assume these guys were too. I vaguely remember hearing that the town that this heresy developed in was simply destroyed or at least everyone in it was killed because of the danger of the heresy.
Can anyone point me in the right direction or clarify any of this? Or am I thinking of something that never happened.
1 Answers 2014-04-18
As the Roman empire was slowly collapsing, did any significant remnant of the empire remain while Medieval Kings were the primary power in Europe? Did they ever meet? If so, what was the relationship like?
3 Answers 2014-04-18
The Jews were targeted in the Crusades, the pogroms in Russia in the early 1900s, and the Holocaust - not to mention dozens of other massacres, and the hate crimes that continue to this day.
Why have the Jews been targeted so many times throughout history? Did any particular event set it off? When did it start, and why?
1 Answers 2014-04-18
It just strikes me as odd that the war against Germany is seen as a necessary (and righteous) response to its expansionism, whereas the USSR was ignored and then treated as an ally of convenience. Did the Soviet Union as the lesser of two evils, or was a war against both considered infeasible, or what?
2 Answers 2014-04-18
2 Answers 2014-04-18
1 Answers 2014-04-18
1 Answers 2014-04-18
If it wasn't for the French's substantial assistance during the War for Independence, there may be no America. The United States' help in WW1 and WW2 returned the favor for France.
Many Americans ridicule the French for being cowardly and pretentious snobs while many French think Americans are devoid of culture, inferior, brutish and crass.
2 Answers 2014-04-18
I'm seriously wondering , what happened during the time America was colonised that made it that they didn't take what is now Canada aswell?
From my European perspective and if you don't consider the French community in Quebec, they seem like very similar countries and culture and they share more or less the same land. What made the split between these countries?
Thanks !
1 Answers 2014-04-18
I looked through /u/bemonk's big AMA and some of his later posts, so sorry if I missed an obvious answer.
1 Answers 2014-04-18
I've found plenty of information on the various calendars used by the Romans. The thing I'm lookng for, though, is where was the start of the calendar was. I'm trying to date something in roman years and I cant.
1 Answers 2014-04-18
Is it a post-colonial thing or does it have a longer precedent?
1 Answers 2014-04-18
Do you only come here to read about a particular topic, and don't want to have to wade through the sub to find posts about it? Are you aspiring to join our panel of historians, but are struggling to find questions in your specialty? Hopefully, your life is about to become a lot easier, thanks to IFTTT!
IFTTT (which stands for If This Then That) is a service that uses simple "recipes" to automate functions. In our case, we've set up a "recipe" that will send you an email (or other alert method of your choosing) whenever someone posts a question that contains any number of keywords you select. To set it up, create an account at IFTTT and activate the reddit channel (to do this you'll need to give IFTTT permission to access your reddit account – don't worry, you can revoke this at any time in your reddit preferences). You can then use the following shared recipe as a template for setting up your own custom alerts:
For this recipe you'll need to specify your own keywords to find questions you're interested in. Alternatively, you can use an existing set of keywords in recipes shared by other users. You can also configure it to alert you however you want--it could send you a text, call you, put answering it in your to-do list, put it on facebook, or really anything you could imagine (except send a PM, unfortunately).
Alternatively, you can use google alerts, which doesn't use reddit's search function directly. You can see directions for setting both up here. IFTTT is really optimized for exactly this, though, and it's user-friendly and configurable.
The Panel of Historians have been using IFTTT alerts for about a month now, and as far as I'm aware it has been working wonderfully; personally, I haven't missed a post with the system.
Anyway, it's very easy to set up, and is very useful. If you're having trouble setting it up, comment below and we'll see if we can help.
4 Answers 2014-04-18
2 Answers 2014-04-18
Was he the rightful heir or was this just a way to get out of paying the French homage or both?
1 Answers 2014-04-18
Today:
You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.
As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.
21 Answers 2014-04-18
In another thread, /u/fubus2 linked to this list of Roman consuls. 375BC to 371BC are listed as "anarchy years" which is something I've never heard of before. I'm sure this is a simple factual question, but I can't find anything through googling. Wikipedia doesn't say there was anything eventful happening in Rome in 376BC or 375BC. Why did Rome not have a consul for these years?
1 Answers 2014-04-18
5 claims they make:
10 Answers 2014-04-18