Mutinous Roman legions?

I want to know about the riots in the imperial Roman legions. Not in the auxiliary troops, but in the legion. For example, Rhine mutiny. (AD 14) Are there any other examples like this?

1 Answers 2021-05-28

What made Agrippa so different from contemporary Roman military leaders?

I've been looking into decline of the Roman Republic, and something that's confusing me is the nature of Agrippa and his relationship with Octavian. Most Roman military leaders are glory hounds- they fight wars for the spoils and the prestige; a triumph is the greatest honor possible for a general. A lot of accounts about Octavian seem to paint he picture that he was failing upwards- he wasn't a very good military commander, wasn't very interested in warfare, and if it weren't for Agrippa generally kicking ass, he probably wouldn't have accomplished any of "his" military victories. The two of them seemed to offset each other's weaknesses quite well, but that Roman trait of seeking glory doesn't seem to be very prominent with Agrippa.

So why was Agrippa willing to stay Octavian's "underling?" I know they were childhood friends, but most Roman leaders seemed to chafe under the glory of their peers. Why was Agrippa so willing to back Octavian, to the point of forgoing his own triumph following Octavian's failed ambush of Sicily? Did Agrippa just not have any interest in glory and politics?

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Friday Free-for-All | May 28, 2021

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

11 Answers 2021-05-28

When did the identity of Han become a meaningful self-identity in the mass general consciousness in China?

Years ago in college I read an essay by Nietzsche, "On the Use and Abuse of History for Life" as part of an introduction to Foucault. One of my take aways from that was how the past serves as a warehouse of stories and that what most people think of as "history" is often a selective curation of the past to legitimize something politically in the present. Lately I've been studying the history of the Italian unification because through some peculiar italian interpretation of jure sanguinis I was able to become a dual citizen. I really enjoyed this quote by Massimo d'Azeglio, Prime Minister of Sardinia who said "L'Italia è fatta. Restano da fare gli italiani", translated as "We have made Italy. Now we must make Italians." I found it interesting to realize that my American identity was actually older than the Italian identity. In my studies I noticed how romantic italian nationalist invoked Battle of Legnano and how the fascists saw themselves as heirs of Rome all as parts of trying to construct and influence italianness.

This made me wonder to what extent is Chinese "history" a selective curation as part of CCP efforts to legitimize their political vision? When did Han chinese start calling themselves Han, and when did that actually become a meaningful identity to an average Han person?

2 Answers 2021-05-28

Why most former colonies, especially Brazil, are less advanced compare to Australia, USA, Canada etc? Despite the fact that Australia and Canada have hazardous climate, or geography.

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Books about complete Roman history

I am looking for a good modern history book that spans complete history of Rome. I loved Rubicon from Holland and SPQR from Mary Beard. Gibbon is great but I would like something more new.

So a books that will have wars with Italics, Punic wars, Gracchi brothers, Caesar, Octavian, Hadrian, Trajan until 475.

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Were the Anzacs and Turks friendly with each other at times during the battle of Gallipoli?

So I’m Australian and I’ve recently been watching this TV series about Gallipoli during WW1 and it shows that at times like during the momentary ceasefire to collect bodies (which I’m 90% sure did actually happen but correct me if I’m wrong) the Turks and Anzacs we’re quite friendly with each other despite the language barrier, I’ve heard things like this happened in the western front like with England and Germany and the famous Christmas soccer match and was just wondering if stuff like that also happened at Gallipoli

1 Answers 2021-05-28

I have read that the Royal Navy would traditionally serve sailors a daily ration of a GALLON of beer or a full pint of hard liquor. That seems like an insane amount of alcohol to be consuming every day. Were sailors just constantly drunk?

1 Answers 2021-05-28

How did Adolf Hitler become such an extreme antisemite?

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Any book recommendations covering pre-colonial Africa?

Emphasis on "pre-colonial". Looking for any material detailing the social/political/economic orders, laws, norms, values etc.

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Why did it take until 1799 for British Royal Navy frigates to be equipped with bow and stern chasers when Great Britain had over 100 years of naval supremacy to come up with the idea? And what other ship classes did (and did not) have bow and stern chasers between 1700 and 1799?

The Wikipedia page I got this info from

After reading, I get the impression that no European navy in the 18th century outfitted their ships with bow and stern chasers, is this assumption correct?

If the best navy in the world operating at its height between 1700-1799 didn’t equip their ships with stern and bow chasers, I can assume no other European navies (and even the Continental navy) tried to either?

What was the reason for this? And why did it take so long to come up with the idea?

Also, if this was the case, then what is this front most cannon on this sixth-rate frigate in this painting dating to 1758? It looks an awful lot like a bow chaser, unless I’m mistaken.

Follow-up: did pirates and privateers equip their ships with stern and bow chasers?

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Other examples of texts similar to The Travels of Marco Polo

Hello there. I am looking for examples of texts similar to The Travels of Marco Polo, specifically: texts detailing someone's first-hand accounts of traveling to "far-way" lands, and the fantastic things they experience there. I have a feeling Marco Polo can't be the only one. Any texts supposedly detailing fantastic things or impossibilities would also be helpful. The project I'm working on requires examples of times where people have reported impossibilities as if they were true, to demonstrate their untrustworthiness. Thanks for any help.

2 Answers 2021-05-28

Did the Rothschild familyv(or at least a part of it) willingly financed Hitler ?

My mother claim so, and i would want to know if they did.

Since they are a family of jewish descent, i initially dismissed the idea, but i don't want to be a fool.

If they did, how much it was ? And please, give informations for books, give the french titles of the books and authors if possible (i am french) i could share the informations with her and know if she was saying non-sense or the truth.

1 Answers 2021-05-28

How much of Jesus was fact and fiction? Did he live at all? If he did, was he crucified like described in the Bible? Did he claim to be a son of God? What historical records on him do we still have access to except the religious texts?

There are so, so many different opinions on who Jesus was within and beyond the Christian faith, and so I wanted to see an objective, historical perspective on this. Beyond my introductory questions in the title, please expand into Jesus's life and the aftermath of his death as much as you can. Thanks.

1 Answers 2021-05-28

Ben Franklin suggested the outgunned Continental Army fight the British with bows and arrows. How sensible was his idea?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

[META] Why is the sub's portrait based on (I assume) Justinian?

Justinian the Great was a Roman/Byzantine Emperor from 527 to 565, one of the most famous Roman Emperors and probably the most well-known Eastern Roman Emperor. His well-earned reputation is due to his eventful life, richly described in Procopius' accounts, and his famous portrait mosaic in the Basilica of San Vitale, Ravenna.

His rule was marked my many momentous events, like the Nika riots, the making of the Corpus Juris Civilis (the basis for Civil Law applied in continental Europe and beyond), the reconquest of North Africa (meaning modern Tunisia, eastern Algeria and western Libya aka Tripolitania), the Gothic wars that devastated Italy, the seeding of the Lombardic control of that same peninsula, the Battle of Dara, the Sack of Antioch in 540 and, perhaps more important, but completely beyond his control, the Justinianic Plague, the first pandemic of Yersinia pestis.

As huge Byzaboo/Byzantophile, I'm glad he's been chosen to represent this sub, but I have to ask why, among all the other historical figures, has he been chosen?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

What was non-Latin language learning like in the Roman Empire? What would the process be for a Roman citizen who wants to learn, say, Gaulish or Greek?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

How much autonomy did a woman have in late 18th Century American Taverns?

I’ve been trying to find some concrete information but maybe I’m looking in the wrong places: would it be acceptable for a woman to socialize in an 18th century American tavern? Specifically around 1790? I’m under the impression that some taverns were owned by women and that the “Tavern” was much more of a central social nexus than a bar or brothel or something like that. Would it be unreasonable for a woman to go to a tavern alone? Would it depend on social economic status? Race? Etc!

Thanks all!

1 Answers 2021-05-27

What proportion of the "English" population (in the land which would be England) continued to speak Celtic languages by the time of the Norman Conquest?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

Is Noam Chomsky's claim that all postwar US presidents would be guilty of war crimes under the Nuremberg principles accurate?

Here's a clip of him summarising each president but there are plenty other sources where he goes into more depth.

I'm aware the 20 year rule would prevent any comment on recent presidents, but I would love to know about the rest.

2 Answers 2021-05-27

What were Muslim Egyptian rulers opinions and views on the pyramids, given how they were built with what would be considered pagan intentions?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

What caused the de-radicalization of the LGBTQ rights movement and the shift away from gay liberation towards more mainstream goals and attitudes?

I was recently reading a lot of historical resources on the LGBTQ rights movement to learn more about the history of my identity in activism, and one thing that struck me was just how radical the major gay rights organizations were in the 1960s and 1970s in comparison to those of the 1990s and into the present.

The Gay Liberation Front, the Combahee River Collective, other organizations, etc. were almost all explicitly anti-capitalist, very left wing, and in many cases rejected the nuclear family and marriage itself, far from desiring to earn marriage rights as the modern gay marriage movement sought. Many of these organizations main goals revolved around restructuring society itself rather than law changes within the already extant structures of society.

By the 1990s however, much of the modern movement, like the Human Rights Campaign, had become highly integrated with a capitalist and centrist (Democratic) political party and their demands were generally centered around law changes and in particular gay marriage.

What caused this shift? Were COINTELPRO or similar government programs utilized to disrupt the gay liberation movement in the same way as they were on the Black Power movement? Was the AIDS crises influential in killing the previous generation of radical leadership? Was the incorporation of the movement into the non-profit structure and government/business funding sources a reason for the rightward shift (I.e. Gay Inc. book)? The question particularity interests me as a gay leftist who draws a lot of inspiration from the early gay liberation groups.

Any explanation or even sources for reading are appreciated. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2021-05-27

AskHistorians Podcast Minisode - Causes of the Great War

A new AskHistorians Podcast Minisode is live!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!

The aim of these minisodes is to feature recent answers or contributions on the sub, giving some background, going into a bit more detail, and covering further aspects.

This Minisode:

Morgan Lewin ( /u/aquatermain ) talks to Avan ( /u/Starwarsnerd222 ) about the geopolitical causes of the First World War.

1 Answers 2021-05-27

The Korean War created a massive influx of refugees from the North who fled South. How were they integrated into society considering they had lost their homes, jobs, and families?

I am curious how south Korea’s government dealt with the massive influx of refugees and how they were integrated into society. Were there any programs in place to help them? Also were there any who wanted to return north?

1 Answers 2021-05-27

I’m rewatching Game of Thrones. Did everyone just have PTSD and was everyone a Psychopath in Medieval times?

From just what I know of history, it seems like every day, every year, was like the WWI trenches.

You have 5 kids and bury 3. You watch your kids starve. Raiders rape and steal. I imagine it was punctuated with just waiting for something to happen.

You have a bumper crop after 5 years of drought, then everyone gets measles and dies.

1 Answers 2021-05-27

686 / 7255

Back to start