What makes major world religions survive longer than others?

According to wiki we have at least Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism among the biggest fours, on other hand we no longer see Roman paganism, Gnosticism, etc, what makes them survive?

2 Answers 2014-03-15

Was the Paris Commune (1871) a form of communist government? Did the rebels/revolutionaries adhere to a specific ideology? Request for book suggestion as well.

I have a general interest in reading 19th century European history. Yesterday, while checking on my blog-feed, I came across a blog entry by a historical fiction author. While bantering about his novel, he mentioned the Paris Commune and implied that it was a precursor of the communist state. Is that true? Did the rebels/revolutionaries adhere to an ideology, and did they pass any laws to indicate that.

As well, I'd like to read about the subject, from a rather unbiased viewpoint. The author/blogger had referenced "Fall of Paris" by Alistair Horne (and another socialist source) as the source of his info. However, on checking the book I found that it's big and a major part of it discussed the Prussian siege of Paris. I'm more interested in reading about the Commune itself.

Thank you.

P.S. For those wanting to check on the blog-entry mentioned above, check here: http://maxconnelly.blogspot.ro/2014/03/on-writing-next-big-thing-torn-between.html

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Saturday Reading and Research | March 15, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

6 Answers 2014-03-15

How did the early British settlers in Australia cope with the heat and weather, and still manage to engage in work like building roads and clearing land for farming?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What was the view Nazi Germany held of the Greeks and Greece?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What was the public reaction and consequences of Princess Diana's divorce from Prince Charles?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

How did compulsory military service affect the number of victims, the destruction and the outcome in general of civil wars in those countries?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

My thesis topic: I turn to you for help with a question I have.

Greetings all, I am a currently a double major as an undergrad in History and English. To prevent the need to write two separate thesis papers I have gotten approval to write a longer thesis paper that can satisfy both departmental requirements. I became very interested in the fear of new science and technology when reading colonial literature from the outbreak of smallpox in Massachusetts during the American Revolution (fear of inoculations) and especially after reading Shelley's Frankenstein.

I already got signed off from the English department about this topic, however I am struggling to find the "historical controversy" which exists to write about. Is there something that historians still debate, or a controversy which exists within this context which I can further research? If not I have to decide if I like this topic enough to write a separate thesis for History, or it's back to the drawing board to find a different topic that can encompass both fields. Thanks!

5 Answers 2014-03-15

British Navy vs Napoleon's Navy circa 1798 - Egypt invasion - Timing & Communication question

I am reading "Black Count" by Tom Reiss currently and he has a great little bit about the near miss of Admiral Nelson leaving Alexandria 3 hours before the arrival of Napoleon's fleet. My question is this: had Nelson actually encounter The French Armada how long would it have taken word to get back to the UK for reinforcements, and how long would the have taken to arrive? Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What were some of the stranger innovations of war in WWII?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

If chickens were first domesticated in Southeast Asia, how did it spread throughout Europe, Africa, and the Americas?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Were opinions towards mercenaries as negative historically as they are today?

I'm especially interested in the opinions people held towards free companies in the Middle Ages and Renaissance.

1 Answers 2014-03-15

How Important was Lenin's reintroduction to Russia during World War 1 on the February Revolution

From what I know Lenins reintroduction into Russia was a "turning point" in the revolutionary movement at the time. But the Krensky had proven himself a fine leader to the Bolsheviks. Wouldn't he have eventually led them to revolution.

2 Answers 2014-03-15

What are some good electronic sources that delve into the topic of German nationalism in the 19th Century?

I'm currently taking a course on European Nationalism in the 19th Century history and I have had a very hard time finding decent additional sources to read about. Most of the books recommended by people, such as the German History, 1770-1866 by James Sheehan from the /r/AskHistorians book list are only available in print. I live in Hong Kong and most of these books aren't available here, unless I order them internationally. Are there any good sources for Germanic Nationalism that any of you would've known of that are currently available to buy as an electronic version?

2 Answers 2014-03-15

What other countries had the capacity, resources and technology to have developed the atomic bomb at the time instead if the United States never had?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Concerning History and Analytics

http://www.nytimes.com/2003/07/06/books/chapters/0713-1st-hedges.html

This New York Times paper suggest that you can estimate the amount of deaths due to war. Could their be a sector of computer analytics that collects historical data for the better understanding of historical or present situations. I believe culture and traditions have heavy impacts on our lives that we do not notice. There might be a lot of hidden details that we can discover.

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Historical explanations or mentions of static electricity?

I can't help but wonder what people before the understanding of electricity thought of it? Especially the bright blue flashes of static electricity that can be produced with nothing more than blankets.

Any odd or interesting mentions?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What are some jobs people had in ancient times that would be simply unheard of in today's world?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What is the history of the occult / esotericism like for Africa?

I see a lot of references to Western traditions of the occult in media (demons, alchemy, tarot, and all that), a few references to Eastern esotericism, and even some references to Native American mysticism (though not much beyond spirit animals/quests, sadly), but the only depictions of the occult in Africa I can think of involve just communing with the spirits of your ancestors. I'd look up more about it myself, but I really don't even know what to look for. So what's the history of the occult / esotericism / mysticism like for Africa? Are there any major resources to turn to for information about the occult in Africa?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

My family believes that some of our heritage is Irish royalty, but I can't find evidence of the story ever existing. Are we actually just boring regular Irish?

The story goes that there was a high king of Ireland who had two sons. The older one went on to rule Ireland and the younger (my alleged ancestor) was jealous and staged a revolution. The revolution was unsuccessful and my ancestor had to flee to England. Was there ever a failed revolution like this that took place in Ireland or is this just family folklore?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Would WW2 have happened if the US stayed out of WW1.

1 Answers 2014-03-15

What were the equivalents of elementary school, middle school, and high school like in Ancient Rome? What may have been an average day?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

I am a convicted murderer in pre-Modern England. How does my sentence differ from if I was convicted today?

I am struggling to find resources about pre-Enlightenment murder trials and I'm hoping your comments might inspire some fresh search terms because I'm out of ideas.

2 Answers 2014-03-15

What was World War II like on the eve of Normandy? That is, on which fronts/where were battles being fought before the Allies invaded France?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Help me fill in the gap in my education about China

My knowledge of China is nearly nonexistant. I'm particularly interested in learning about Ancient China. Any recommendation of podcasts, documentaries, books, etc would be appreciated. I recently picked up a copy of The Three Kingdoms, but i don't know how factual it is.

1 Answers 2014-03-15

6982 / 7255

Back to start