Why hasn't the world's most fascinating monument, the Mausoleum of the First Emperor of China, been excavated?

They know where it is, why not dig?

3 Answers 2014-03-13

Were any Infantry division during WWII involved in both the Pacific Theatre of the war as well as the European Theatre?

In the midst of watching Ken Burns: The War and was just curious if any soldiers had to be through both hell's.

1 Answers 2014-03-13

[WWII] Could someone kindly give me a brief bit of context behind this French Propaganda Poster?

[WWII] Could someone kindly give me a brief bit of context behind this French Propaganda Poster? Thank you in advance.

2 Answers 2014-03-13

Why nationalization of whole industries was acceptable right after WWII in Europe, but now it's an anathema?

After the war, the British government nationalized transportation (rail, buses), utilities (electricity, gas supply, water), energy (coal, hydro, petroleum), heavy industry (iron and steel), healthcare (creating the NHS) etc.

The rest of Europe did pretty much the same and some countries nationalized large parts of their industry and natural resources; for instance, French carmaker Renault was nationalized, as were the Swedish iron mines.

Why was this acceptable back then, but now not it's completely out of the question?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

Was the Civil War necessary to end slavery, or would it have been abolished soon anyway?

Judge Andrew Napolitano recently propounded a contrarian view of President Lincoln, suggesting that other action could have been taken to end the practice. Napolitano goes so far as to suggest that the government could have bought up all the slaves for half the sum spent on the war.

I'm reminded too of an essay by Winston Churchill about half a century after the war which suggests he believed the Confederacy themselves would have ended slavery soon after defeating the North. Is this all revisionism on a grand level or is there any plausibility to their arguments?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

Why is the population of Canada so much smaller than the population of the United States?

Canada currently has only 34.88 million people, which is not only much lower than the United States (313.9 million) but smaller even than California alone (38.04 million). Canada has enough space to hold many, many more people, but doesn't seem to be as attractive to immigrants for some reason. Why is that?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

How did Islam spread so quickly?

2 Answers 2014-03-13

Why would someone be photographed holding book about the life of Admiral Dewey?

I found an old family photo that shows the mother of the family holding this book "The life and glorious deeds of Admiral Dewey". And I can find no reasonable reason why. They did have a son-in-law die about 1898-9, and he could have been part of Dewey's campaign. But rural west Tennessee is a long way from the Philippines. What does a Historian think?

2 Answers 2014-03-13

Interwar Military Theory

I've always been interested in military theory/history and recently have been digging deeper into the details of WWII. More and more I keep wondering what the theoretical and doctrinal bases for the different militaries were. I feel I have a handle on Soviet doctrine, having read a few books by David Glantz on the subject and both Strategy by Svechin and The Nature of the Operations of Modern Armies by Triandafillov, but I'm having trouble finding the core works put out by the General Staff of the other participants of the war.

Does anyone have any suggestions of works to read that would give me a sense of the theoretical and doctrinal thought of France, Germany, Britain and/or the US? Works on how that theory was applied in specific instances would also be excellent (for example, I loved Glantz's very detailed The Soviet Strategic Offensive in Manchuria and Soviet Operational and Tactical Combat in Manchuria, that showed in many ways the 'ideal' application of Soviet doctrine on the ground).

This is sort of a followup to this question I asked a few months ago

1 Answers 2014-03-13

What is the earliest society or civilization that we know of to name itself? What's the earliest name that is still in common use today?

It seems a lot of groups are given names after the fact (I'm thinking of posts I've seen here about the the Hittites and possibly the Cathars). What is the oldest society that we know how they identified themselves, and (if it's not the same) what is the oldest society that we still commonly use their own identifier to refer to them? Also, why did they chose these names for themselves?

EDIT: Also, I am called an American because I come from the land that was named after the guy who determined it was its own continent and not part of Asia. Romans were presumably named after the city that they came from. Is this pretty standard when cultures decide names for themselves? What other examples are there of people naming themselves after things other than where they dwell?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

How/Why did Rome Transition from a professional Roman army to one of barbarian 'foederati'?

One explanation I was exposed to was that after the battle of Adrianople there simply weren't enough professional roman soldiers to field an adequate army. But wouldn't that problem be more temporary than it turned out?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

How is it we don't know what the ancient pronunciation of Latin sounded like, but we do know what Ancient Greek sounds like?

What about the Catholic church? Do they just try and recreate the language too?

2 Answers 2014-03-13

Suppose you were sent back in time to New Jersey (or where New Jersey is now) in AD50 and then AD1050. Could you easily tell which was which by observing the native Americans?

If it was Europe I imagine it would be easy to tell

6 Answers 2014-03-13

How did pirate communities of the 17th century or the "Golden Age of piracy" work?

I know that pirates had port cities like Nassau and Tortuga to flock to, but how did those communities operate? Did they elect their own governors and have laws in place to keep the peace, or was it anarchy? How did these communities sustain themselves? Did pirates bring back loot and share it with the community to keep it running, or work together to generate more profit from their pirating?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

Was the second bomb on Japan necessary?

I've heard conflicting reports on this. Some say that after the first bomb, Japan would have surrendered anyway, and the second bomb was unnecessary. Others say that Japan were unwilling to surrender even after the first bomb, which is why the second was dropped. What was it really like?

3 Answers 2014-03-13

Did the European Baroque and Classical composers know of other cultures' music and music theories? If so what did they think of them? Did they ever incorporate foreign styles/scales/etc. into their own music?

This question came up because I was curious if the likes of Bach and Beethoven had heard Middle Eastern or Indian scales. Specifically, I noticed the use of a major third to a phrygian second, which is often used in Middle Eastern music, in Beethoven's Sonata Op. 28. Am I making false connections or were some composers occasionally influenced by other cultures' music?

2 Answers 2014-03-13

I heard a fast fact recently that stated Charlemagne, though illiterate, kept writing supplies under his bed and was tutored by his school age children. Is that true, and if so, how did his desire to be literate affect his rule and policy as king?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

Have people always been interested in seeking social status?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

After 90% of Berlin was flattened during WWII, it was discovered that the massive building that served as the Luftwaffe headquarters was almost virtually untouched. Its location is in central Berlin. Why was it barely effected by bombing raids?

6 Answers 2014-03-13

What was the name of the famous battle in the Gulf war where 100 Abrams tanks took on 400 Iraqi ones

2 Answers 2014-03-13

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in March 13th, 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

6 Answers 2014-03-13

Anyone else watch Cosmos with Neil Degrasse Tyson? How did you feel about the potrayal of Giordano Bruno?

Hey all,

I'm actually a Renaissance History historian who focuses on mysticism and Bruno is actually one of my research subjects. The Christ like fashion in which Bruno was represented (a martyr for science) both cracked me up and made me sad they failed to put him in his mystical religious context. His memory belongs with Pico and Ficino, not Gallieleo and Newton. Am I wrong?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

What would Mjolnir actually look like? (How did the norse warhammers looked at the time)

We all know Marvel's Mjolnir and even the Mjolnir pendants that are all over the place. However what kind of weapon did the norsemen imagined that Thor had?

5 Answers 2014-03-13

WW2 Planes Kill Death Ratios

At the moment in university I am making a series of infographics about different planes in the second world war. I pretty much have them all done but I am struggling to get certain information about them and that is their K/D. The planes that I need this information for are:

Hawker Hurricane Supermarine Spitfire Messerschmitt Bf 109 Focke Wulf Fw 190A Mitsubishi A6M Zero Nakajima Ki-43

If anyone could help get me this information that would be fantastic.

1 Answers 2014-03-13

Why, when so much of Erich Kästner's work was both banned and burnt, was Emil and the Detectives not banned?

I have a source claiming that this book wasn't banned, and that it was the most common of books confiscated from children when they arrived at concentration camps. Yet, the Nazis banned Kästner from publishing any other books in Germany. So why did Emil and the Detectives survive? Surely they would have assumed that all of his work would fall under the same category, having being written by a 'morally decadent' author?

1 Answers 2014-03-13

6989 / 7255

Back to start