Are there probable borrowings of Zoroastrian themes in early Islamic writings?

Or, to be a bit more precise: direct borrowings, without an intermediary stage within the Jewish tradition. I am completely ready to accept, of course, that it may be hard to tell in many cases. I am interested in all types of texts—the Qu'ran, early exegesis, sirat, poetry…

2 Answers 2014-03-03

I've seen this come up a bit in unreliable TIL links, but did the city of Troy really exist/what do we actually know about the Trojan War?

2 Answers 2014-03-03

What is the oldest Biblical story that is also mentioned by non-Jewish primary sources?

For example: if there are any Egyptian or Assyrian writings that talk about a warlord named Abraham and his two sons Isaac/Ishmael, or something. Or maybe if some pagan sources talk about a great warrior named Goliath.

6 Answers 2014-03-03

How did Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan end up with such a complicated border?

Uzbekistan extends a tendril into Kyrgyzstan, while Tajikistan curls around a spur of the same; additionally there are a bunch of small exclaves in Kyrgyzstan as well.

Is there a geographic or (I'm sure) ethnic basis for this division? How were these borders worked out and agreed to, especially after the dissolution of the USSR?

If any of it happened within twenty years, I don't mean to break the rule, but I'm not even sure where to start on this!

2 Answers 2014-03-03

Augustine's 'Earthly City': did he mean Rome?

I'm not asking from a philosophical perspective but a historical one... was Rome actually like what he describes as an Earthly City?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

Monday Mysteries | Lost Skills

Previously on Monday Mysteries

Today we'll be taking a look at skills that were once quite common, but have fallen into disuse.

Throughout history, many different people have had to use many different skills to keep up in society - and due to more modern methods or technology, those skills have fallen into disuse or have been completely forgotten altogether. So tell us, what are some jobs that were once popular, but no longer exist? What skills used to be common, but are now lost to the sands of time?

Remember, moderation in these threads will be light - however, please remember that politeness, as always, is mandatory.

11 Answers 2014-03-03

Were there any significant protests against the Spanish-American War?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

What happened in the year 1000 celebration wise?

The year 2000 was celebrated by humanity, but what about the year 1000? Obviously it would have been limited to the Christian world, but how aware were people/society and was it of any significance to people back then?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

What were the military advantages and disadvantages of the Welsh/English Longbow?

I've heard that they had the ability to punch through some plate armour, and I'm wondering if there are other qualities that made it so widely used by the English.

1 Answers 2014-03-03

When I was growing up in the Philippines, there seems to a belief where they used to own Okinawa from a very very long time ago but I can't seem to find any evidence of this at all.

Inspired by the question about the Latvian government .

1 Answers 2014-03-03

Why didn't Islam develop any monastic traditions as are found in other faiths?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

How factually correct is the Cracked video "6 Myths You Probably Believe About the American Revolution?" Link in text.

http://www.cracked.com/video_18793_6-myths-you-probably-believe-about-american-revolution.html

6 Answers 2014-03-03

Did ancient coastal cultures distinguish between the types of fish they ate?

When I go to the supermarket I can buy different varieties of fish: cod, mackerel, tuna, salmon. Did ancient Mediterraneans (or any highly populated coastal civilizations) know what type of fish they were eating?

Follow-up: I've also heard that shellfish like lobster and crab used to be considered low-class food, now they are luxury cuisine. Has any other seafood experienced a major swing like this?

There have been a few fish questions on the front page recently. Does anyone know of good sources for fishing history?

4 Answers 2014-03-03

Are there recorded cases of intentionally baiting a camp with booty and then ambushing the plundering enemy?

I'm familiar with battles where a undisciplined army, after winning a partial victory and stopping to plunder, gets attacked by reformed or held-back enemies (Tagliacozzo 1268, Mezőkeresztes 1596), but are there any cases where the prospect of plunder was used to intentionally lull an enemy into dispersing and plundering, and then springing the trap?

2 Answers 2014-03-03

Why did empire like Roman break apart and never return to its former glory but China manage to hold onto its territory for thousand of years?

3 Answers 2014-03-03

How did Russia expand so successfully in the eighteenth and ninetheenth centuries, given its relative lack of industrial capacity and feudal organization? By contrast, other non-Western powers (Ottoman Empire, Persia, China, etc.) were more easily dominated by other European powers.

I have a Wikipedia-level knowledge of Russian history in the 18th and 19th centuries. My sense is the Peter the Great and his successors tried to modernize Russia economically and militarily and met with mixed success at best.

Nevertheless, Russia seemed quite successful in imposing its will on the Ottoman Empire, which was also trying to modernize with mixed results. In addition, Russia was able to serve as "Europe's policeman" and go toe-to-toe with modern European military powers in a way that other less-modernized entities around the world (the Turks, Persians, Indians, Chinese, etc.) could not. Yet, by World War I Russia was in bad enough shape that it couldn't arm all of its own troops.

This is admittedly a broad question, but to summarize: Russia seemed to be in the same boat as a lot of other non-Western powers in the 18th and 19th centuries, in terms of modernity (and the power that comes with it). However, Russia seems to have been a lot more powerful militarily than the other non-Western powers.

Why is this? Are one of my premises wrong?

3 Answers 2014-03-03

I've been lead to believe that warfare was more romanticized before the world war. How much truth is there to this statement?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

What was life typically like for Africans living under colonial rule?

I need some information for an essay I'm attempting on the "Scramble for Africa". I have tried to find information on this but my searches are always overwhelmed with books and articles on the life of African Americans. Can anybody help me out? Did Africans feel subjugated by their European intruders or did life go on generally unhindered? I'd also welcome any information on the Boers in South Africa and how colonial domination by the British affected their way of life as well? Thanks guys.

2 Answers 2014-03-03

What has typically happened in the embassy of a country immediately after a successful revolution or coup at home?

Do they shred documents? Run for the doors with the silverware and beg for political asylum? Hope for rapprochement with the new regime?

2 Answers 2014-03-03

How Did Prostitutes Deal with Birth Control Issues?

I just started watching the pirate TV show "Black Sails" and they show the whore house quite a lot. So that got me thinking, how did prostitutes in those times (and other times) not get pregnant? I understand the "pull out" method and they probably drank a lot, so conditions for pregnancies weren't perfect. But with the amount of sex they had, it seems it's just a matter of time before they did get pregnant. Was there some kind of "industry-wide standard" so to say, on dealing with this "occupational hazard"?

Also, surely at some point they did get pregnant and surely at some point attempts at abortions failed. So how did they deal with being pregnant and then having a child? Did they try to figure out who the father was? Did they somehow try to get money from the father (if the father was rich)? Did they try to get the father to care for her and the child in some way? How was their standing in the whore house affected by being pregnant and then being a mother? Surely there was no "maternity leave" for them. How did their reputation and attractiveness suffer, if at all, during and after pregnancy? What happened to the kid? etc etc etc

2 Answers 2014-03-03

Did the Aztecs bake contaminated blood into bread made for the conquistadors?

It has been a few years since I had AP U.S. History, but I recall reading in my textbook that the Aztecs, as a way of getting back at the Spanish, baked blood that was contaminated with diseases (most notably syphilis) into bread they made for the Spaniards. I was trying to find some evidence of this online, but I was not able to do so. Is this something the authors just made up, or is this just something that doesn't exist on the Internet for whatever reason?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

What caused the rift between the People's Republic of China and the U.S.S.R?

1 Answers 2014-03-03

How Different was Isaac Newton from his time? Compared to what was happening at that time, how significant was his work?

Basically I want to understand a little better really how much ahead he was from his time if he was at all.

1 Answers 2014-03-03

Were there every Christian heresies that ran something the lines of: "God was so terrible in the Old Testament, especially to Job, maybe Satan over-through Him and Satan sent his only son, Jesus to set things right."

Any heresies where Satan is the good guy, not the quasi-libertarian teen angst good guy, but an actual good guy.

1 Answers 2014-03-03

Can you recommend a book of similar quality to "the guns of August" which describes the rest of WW1?

I just finished that book and I wish it didn't end before the battle of the Marne!

2 Answers 2014-03-03

7031 / 7255

Back to start