Building a list of "Dictators who Accidentally Undid their own Legacies." Stuck on the last one.

1 Answers 2014-01-06

How is the Romani situation in Eastern European so bad despite having gone through the Communist Era? (Full explanation in description)

Background

After coming to university and meeting many Eastern European friends, I became aware of apparent issues relating to the Romani community in Eastern Europeans countries. My friends tell me they often live in ghettos, suffer from poverty and generally don't have good levels of education. Basic research I've done on this seems to back this up, and also mentions many other social issues which affect the Romani group.

Strikingly, I found that many (although not all, still a majority) of them are quite openly critical of the Romani population, bordering on what in the West we'd define as racism. I mention this to them, but usually get a response along the lines of "if you lived where I lived, you'd understand". In any case, I realise this attitude towards Romani is purely anecdotal on my part, and quite possibly not at all representative, just thought it was interesting to mention.

I got to thinking as to why there may be many issues relating to the Romani, and got a bit bewildered that this situation exists in many newly democratic Eastern European countries despite having gone through Communism. My reasoning was as follows - despite the flaws in Communism countries which existed, they generally put a high emphasis on education, and I doubt they would have been fond of allowing ghettos or any sort of pseudo-segregation to exist. These two factors combined with the fact these countries had the Totalitarian power to enforce these beliefs led to my confusion about the Romani's current predicament.

Question

How is the Romani situation in Eastern European so bad despite having lived in Communist countries which place value on education, place value on the equality of peoples, and have the power to enforce these last two beliefs?

Side Question (which may really be part of the main question)

How were Romani (sometimes "Gypsy") people treated in Eastern European countries during the Communist Era?

5 Answers 2014-01-06

What, if any, impact did Orlando Figes anonymous reviews on Amazon.com of Robert Conquest's and Anne Applebaum's books have on the historical profession? How has it impacted Figes' reputation as a historian? Do you as historians even care if a peer takes to Amazon.com to trash your research?

I know this isn't a question about history, but rather about historians. I'm curious to get the impression of people who work in the field, also realizing this might not be the most appropriate forum to ask this question. For background on the conflict, see this article: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1268476/Historian-Orlando-Figes-admits-leaving-devastating-anonymous-reviews-savaging-rivals-books-Amazon.html

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Just finished watching "12 Years a Slave": Was life for slaves in the southern U.S. during the 1800's really as bad as these movies depict? What was the average life like for an average slave on an average plantation?

Believe me, not trying to undermine the abhorrence of slavery but these plantations in these slavery movies (Django, 12 Years...etc.) are always depicted so horribly, where the slave masters are literally the second coming of Hitler/Satan. I wonder if this done for effect because these are movies. I find it a bit hard to believe the average slave owner was so cruel, I can see being raised to think slaves are your property, just as you might oxen or horses, but people don't beat their horses to within one inch of their life. Because most people are just not that evil/sadistic and why do that to your property? Better to treat your property well and take care of it so it is a well performing asset. But maybe it really was so bad. Anyone have any idea?

13 Answers 2014-01-06

Why are the Baltic countries considered to be a differing geopolitical group from Eastern Europe?

Considering that they're geographically approximately in the same area as countries like Poland, Belarus, and Ukraine, which are considered to be Eastern European, what makes them such a differing geopolitical group from the Baltic countries? How did the concept of "Baltic" separate from the concept of "Eastern European"?

2 Answers 2014-01-06

What were guilds and how did they work?

I've never really grasped the concept. Were they consolidated organizations of a singular profession? Were they similar to modern day labor unions? And why did they constantly face opposition throughout history?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

How "woman-friendly" was early Christianity, at least for its place and time?

I've heard that very early Christianity - in its first and second century iterations, before it became more mainstream - featured women in prominent leadership roles and generally gave women a higher "status" in the religion than later versions of Christianity did. I've even heard that members of other religions in the area referred to Christianity as a "women's religion," perhaps as a way of mocking it for the religious power it gave to its female members.

The problem is that I've never really seen good sources on it. There's some analysis on the translation of the Bible that allows for women having higher status, like the argument made here by the Junia Project. There are also some women who are supposed to have leadership positions in the early church based on between-the-lines readings of the Bible, like Mary Magdelene (who was later described as a reformed prostitute, erroneously from my understanding), and more tenuously women like Phoebe and possibly Junia (who may not have been female?) who are described in language similar to other prominent disciples/apostles. I'm not sure how one is supposed to reconcile those examples with Paul's stated advice about the role of women in both homes and churches, however.

Basically, I'm wondering what the going opinions are among scholars about the place of women in early Christianity, and hoping for some scholarly (but reasonably accessible to a non-historian) sources I can look at to help me understand the issue further. I'm also curious to know how it compared to other religions of its day - and then, if there was a change at some point, where and how that came about.

Can anyone speak to this particularly?

3 Answers 2014-01-06

Was there ever a single battle that demonstrated the superiority of firearms over Mongol bows/ tactics?

From what I understand, that the Mongols/Nomadic cultures tended to dominate many civilizations militarily during the Middle Ages. However, it seems like there is hardly a mention of the Mongols themselves (not counting the various successor states) after the empire dissolved.

Was it in part due to the emergence of firearms in the following centuries? And if so, was there ever a single significant battle that demonstrated the superiority of firearms over the horse-archer based warfare of the Mongols or other nomadic peoples?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

In honor of Orthodox Christmas on January 7th, can we briefly talk about the origins of the Orthodox sect and why they celebrate holidays several weeks after the Western Christians do?

I was raised Russian Orthodox, but never really understood the technical differences between this type of Christianity and its counterparts, primarily the differences in the calendar that Orthodox Christians use. The origins of Orthodox Christianity would also be interesting.

2 Answers 2014-01-06

Why was the Russian Empire the only European power to be outwardly pro-Union during the US Civil War?

I've gathered that there was some affinity for/between Alexander II and Lincoln (and they have somewhat similar legacies in their countries). But I've never read anything that explained the reasoning for Alexander's blatant Union boosterism, especially compared to the hedging, neutrality, and outright Confederate sympathizing from other European governments.

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Hitler glorified blonde hair and blue eyes, yet he himself didn't look stereotypically "Aryan". Did he consider himself and the other Austrians to be "lower quality Aryans" and the Scandinavians "higher quality Aryans"? I.e did he consider himself "pure"?

Prevalence of light hair: http://i.imgur.com/D6QG6X6.jpg

Prevalence of light eyes: http://i.imgur.com/T8qFFgE.png

3 Answers 2014-01-06

How prevalent/successful was the use of ramming in naval warfare after the 16th century? Specifically in the late 18th and early 19th centuries?

In the age of the galley, it seems to have been a primary tactic. I know later in the monitor/steamship era it was used as well. I understand that reinforcing a hull specifically for ramming would slow down a sailing ship, and the broadsides of larger ships would certainly make it hazardous if not suicidal. But is there any record of ramming being used successfully in the midst of a major battle during this time? Or of any ship taking or sinking another via ramming?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

How big of an impact did socialist realism have upon the people of russia at the time?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

How close was WW1 and WW2? Did both sides hold potential for victory at almost all time?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Why is contemporary Celticity so much more prominent than Germanicity?

At least in my view, I should explain I'm from Scotland where there seems to be a constant desire to re-connect to our Celtic past. In various festivals and trying to reinvigorate the Gaelic language. Yet I never hear of Norwegians dressing up as Vikings or Germans trying to connect with their distant past

2 Answers 2014-01-06

I'm interested in the history of US Labour. What are the essential reads?

I looked into the sidebar book recommendations but no sure what books would address my interests most succinctly. I have read elsewhere that the US labor movement can be identified by 'periods' with specific trends and that post WWII some claim there was a concerted effort by business and government to reign in US labor. Is this claim accurate? Please give me lots to read, I'm interested in Labor from its earliest years to the present so bring it on!

Thanks so much!

2 Answers 2014-01-06

What Factors led to the Great Depression, not just in America, but globally?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Why didn't the Soviets mass produce the Tsar Bomba?

4 Answers 2014-01-06

What exactly was Drang nach Osten? Before the Nazis, how did it occur?

  • Why did Germans migrate towards the East?

  • Why, for example in this photo, were they refered to as colonists? Surely in 19th century Europe the government of (in this case Russia) would have been able to stop an influx of Germans?

  • To what extent was it still going on in the 19th century and, if left unhindered, what effect would it have had? (I apologise for the what if, but I feel it is relevant to this question.)

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Why did the Vikings raid?

It's widely known that Vikings would frequently raid other nearby peoples. However, I've never heard it discussed why they did and how it became such a large part of their culture. So, why?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

I want to learn all that I can about the USSR. What resources would you, as a historian, recommend I look at to start?

I've got a deep interest in the history of the USSR, but I've never really tried to learn more about it than what comes up in general history books. I'm specifically interested in the early years of the Soviet Union and the Cold War. Any books, internet resources, or video series would be appreciated.

5 Answers 2014-01-06

How did countries like Switzerland or Sweden manage to stay "untouched" during WWII?

Why did no party invade/conquer those countires, while they were surrounded and supposed to be "easy targets"?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

Have the Mounties ever been in the habit of picking up random people to fight forest fires?

I realize this is a very vague and very odd question, but it's about all I have to go on. I was chatting with a guy at work one day a few years ago and he claimed he was picked up by the RCMP in the 1960s, along with a bunch of Cree men, for being indigent and dropped off in rural B.C to fight fires with minimal equipment. Google gives me nothing, but my mother, who is from that area, insists it did happen and was common. However, she's not really a great person to ask about history.

So does this odd tale have any basis in reality?

2 Answers 2014-01-06

What foods are no longer eaten?

3 Answers 2014-01-06

How rich was ancient Greece?

Okay, so I guess my question is how influential, wealthy, populous, etc. ancient Greece really was. Because I grew up in Western culture, I always sort of idolized the Greeks, and tended to think of ancient Greece as somehow uniquely civil, philosophically minded, wealthy, and powerful in the ancient world.

Obviously that wasn't completely the case - Athenians and Spartans had slaves/helots, and Persians had philosophers and mathematicians (so the whole 300 "A NEW AGE OF FREEDOM!" thing is kind of bs), but how exactly did ancient Greece compare to other societies in terms of development? I realize that this may change during different time eras, but were the Greeks really spectacular in any regard (apart from Alexandrian Macedon, were the Greeks really influential on the world stage, and was there any reason for it)? Because I've gotten the impression recently from some readings that Greece was actually kind of a small backwater, and that it was basically just Eastern empires (Persia et al) that were the civilized hegemons.

So... how was Ancient Greece in terms of development standards? Standards of living, culture, amount of global influence (in terms of hard power projection and actual diplomatic soft power), etc.?

1 Answers 2014-01-06

7235 / 7255

Back to start