How did Western racist ideas come to become so widely applied to people all across the world during the imperial age?

I've been thinking about this a good deal recently-I've always found it strange that common racist tropes of non-whites as being somehow childlike, primitive, "ape-like" lacking moral character, or otherwise inferior in some way have been remarkably consistent across the world and across the centuries' worth of European colonial rule, from 1492 all the way through to the 20th century, and in more understated forms ever since. I can sort of understand how, from a twisted point of view, these sorts of stereotypes could stick to peoples who lived a completely different mode of living to Europeans, such as in the Americas or sub-Saharan Africa when viewed from a European perspective unfamiliar with those cultures, but how did identical, or very similar ideas, come to be attached to places such as the Middle East, the Indian subcontinent, or East Asia, settled societies with very old intellectual traditions and political modes that would've at least been somewhat recognizable to a European observer?

1 Answers 2021-03-25

Historians of Reddit: how did you pick your concentration?

I’m about halfway through my undergrad, with a declare history major

The trouble is I don’t want to concentrate in anything, I don’t really like focusing on any one time period and region for too long

I’m very interested in fields like economic history which look at multiple times periods and regions; however my professor told me that it is a dwindling field and all but said to pursue something else

3 Answers 2021-03-25

Black muslim fighters in the crusade

In the book "The Crusades" by Thomas Asbridge, its briefly mentioned that in the battle of Arsuf the crusaders faced for the first time black fighters (in the book it makes it sound that they are from sub sahara africa). What do we know about these fighters? Where they african muslims who came to help Saladin?

1 Answers 2021-03-25

What legal ramification would someone face for killing someone in a duel?

Howdy yall, I have been doing some quick google searches on this but I cannot find anything on what happens to the duelist that killed another duelist. Is it manslaughter? What if both parties are aware of possible accidents and witnesses were present? I do not mean modern times fyi

1 Answers 2021-03-25

How credible are Marxist explanations for World War 1?

A Marxist understanding of First World War is that it was a competition between capitalist states that seek to expand their own Empires as such imperialism which is caused by capitalism is a major reason for war between European powers. Additionally war is extremely profitable for many capitalists especially armaments manufacturers and thus defense companies would advocate for war to increase their profits.

My question is there any evidence that capitalists in Europe advocated for European wide war to increase their own profits?

1 Answers 2021-03-25

How to know if I should major in History

Hello I hope this kind of post is allowed first off. I was basically wondering how you knew history was the right major and how it’s come in handy since? I’m also thinking if I do I’d pair it with anthropology or possibly archeology and wondered what sort of job future I could look forward to that actually utilizes my degree especially if I decide to get my masters in it. Thank you for any help you can give!!

1 Answers 2021-03-25

Why did the Nazis prevent Jews from leaving countries under their control considering that they wanted to be rid of Jews?

1 Answers 2021-03-25

How was the life for a crusader's wife in and outside the Holyland?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

What kind of roles might women have had aboard naval vessels during the Napoleonic Wars?

I ask this question because I have recently learned that my fourth great-grandfather was born aboard the HMS Thunderer during the Dardanelles Operation of 1807. I wondered - why would his mother have been aboard the ship, especially during a combat operation? His father appears to have been a carpenter, which may explain his presence (though I do not know for certain if he was aboard), but I don't see why he should have brought his wife with him.

Enough about my family history: I am not asking specifically for insight about that. It merely got me thinking more generally about why women may have been aboard these ships during this period, and what roles they might have served on them. That is what I am asking about now.

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Was pulling on really long string ever used to communicate?

Was pulling on string ever used as a long distance method of communication? I would imagine that if you could bury a string underground in a tube for instance for long distances and then pull on that string in coded ways or in patterns (similar to morse code) you could transmit information over vast distances. I'm wondering if this was ever used throughout history pre-telegraph?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

The UK Criminal Justice Act 1988 (Offensive Weapons): 7 of the 14 weapons banned in this act are stereotypically carried by ninjas. Was the UK plagued by fears of ninja invasions? Were gangs adopting the sickle-on-a-chain into their repertoire? Why did lawmakers care about these specific weapons?

In 1988 the UK passed "The Criminal Justice Act 1988 (Offensive Weapons) Order 1988." It lists 14 classifications of weapon, some of them I can understand the reasoning for, like various types of concealed blade or baton, but 7 of those 14 weapons I can only describe as "ninja" weapons.

Those weapons are the "handclaw," the "hollow kubotan," the "footclaw," shurikens, kusari gama (specifically a sickle on a cord), kyoketsu shoge (a hooked knife on a cord), and the manrikigusari (a weight on a cord). Fully half of their 14 weapon list are items that are straight out of a B ninja movie.

Do we have any of the reasoning behind these rules? Were there actual plagues of ruffians using ninja weapons? If it's fearmongering why specifically these weapons?

2 Answers 2021-03-24

How much time did premodern agriculture workers and peasants spend working and how did it compare to today?

I have seen things that says medieval pedants work far less than modern people do, and also things that say that peasant life is so filled with drudgery that people would take any opportunity to leave it and do something else.

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Why does "and" have a symbol (ampersand &) but other conjunctions like "or" and "but" do not?

All the coordinating conjunctions from Wikipedia:

  • For – an illative (i.e. inferential), presents rationale ("They do not gamble or smoke, for they are ascetics.")
  • And – a cumulative, adds non-contrasting item(s) or idea(s) ("They gamble, and they smoke.")
  • Nor – presents an alternative non-contrasting (also negative) idea ("They do not gamble, nor do they smoke.")
  • But – an adversative, presents a contrast or exception ("They gamble, but they don't smoke.")
  • Or – presents an alternative non-contrasting item or idea ("Every day they gamble, or they smoke.")
  • Yet – an adversative, presents a strong contrast or exception ("They gamble, yet they don't smoke.")
  • So – an illative (i.e. inferential), presents a consequence ("He gambled well last night, so he smoked a cigar to celebrate.")

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Was there really a Communist community in the Sasanian Empire?

I was reading on Wikipedia about Persian history, and I saw that one of the religions practiced in the Sasanian empire was Mazdakism, which Wikipedia describes as a "noteworthy example of pre-modern communism." The article on Mazdakism is very short and offers no explanation of this.

What was the story behind Mazdakism, and why would historians describe it as communistic?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Come Read about Women for Women's History Month! The AskHistorians Flairs Have Put Together a Collection of Writings on the Exciting History of Women!

Howdy y'all!

As March and Women’s History Month comes to a close, the AskHistorians flairs would like to present a collection of new and previous writings on women through history!

This diverse collection brings you on a globe-spanning journey—from noblewomen in Three Kingdoms China, to indigenous translators in Mexico during the Spanish conquests, to women in the Knights Hospitaller, and many more—revealing the fascinating and often overshadowed lives of women. It is my hope that everyone reading this will be as enchanted by these stories as I am.

I’d like to thank everyone who submitted a piece for this mosaic of stories. This has truly been wonderful and I have loved reading everything that everyone has put together. And finally, a big thank you to the entire AskHistorians community, who without we’d simply be yelling into the void.

Anyways, without further ado, here are the pieces. I truly do feel that there is something for everyone here, regardless of where your interests lie, so please do look through them!

I have put together these pieces in a PDF, for your viewing pleasure, so you may be interested in checking that out as well!

I'd also like to take a moment to recognize some of the great answers from the recent "Women's History" weekly theme.

If you really enjoyed any of these writings, please let the person know in the comments section below!

7 Answers 2021-03-24

Were there enough of the famous ancient Roman public toilets for everyone? Or were they a rare public amenity, with most people crapping in chamber pots and dumping them in the street?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

What is a 'Non-Movable' Castle?

Wikipedia has 38 castles designated as having type=Non-Movable. For example, Bellver Castle, Barxell Castle and Alcázar of Jerez de la Frontera. All of them are located in Spain. When you search Wikipedia, and the web, for a definition, nothing comes up.

I'm sure somebody wants to respond "'it's because the castles can't be moved"; thanks, please don't bother to post that. All castles are potentially movable (remember, they moved the London Bridge), but there must be something different about these particular castles.

I suspect it is either a mistranslation from the original Spanish, or else a very, very specialized term. Do historians have an answer?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

What was used to differentiate years before the common use of AD and BC was "established"?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

How common were specialized stores or craftsmen in Medieval cities?

By “specialized” I mean anything that would take skill, time, or resources to produce that the average citizen would not be capable of. Referring to things such as jewelry, glass makers, skilled smiths, etc. Would you expect to find, for example, one skilled smith in a moderately sized city, would there be multiple with each specializing in a different thing, etc?

For context, I am trying to figure out what the closest real-world equivalent would be to a magic shop in a fantasy world, how common they would likely be, and what sorts of goods they would sell.

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Were the Viet Cong and the Communist Party of Vietnam supported by the majority of the Vietnamese (in South and North Vietnam respectively)? How widespread was support for the leadership of the South Vietnam in comparison?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

How did pre-darwin atheist explian human existence and life in general?

I caught a post from 2 years ago on the subject but jt wasn't really in depth and I would love to know more

1 Answers 2021-03-24

Why did the U.S. government loosen immigration restrictions in the 40's/50's, particularly for Asian immigrants?

Before the Civil Rights movement, with Jim Crow in full force, I am surprised that the federal government would allow non-white immigrants beyond the smallest token amount.

1 Answers 2021-03-24

During the Suez crisis in 1956, why was the position of the US in contrast to that of Britain and France?

I was wondering why was the position of the US from the crisis opposing to those of Britain and France, what were actually the pressure points that the US had over both Britain and France to withdraw, finally was the Suez crisis the opportunity for the US to declare that it is the new world leader?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

During a US Senate meeting today, a Senator said that people used to have to guess the number of jellybeans in a jar to vote. Was this an actual voting test? Was it widespread?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

How did Christianity spread throughout the Roman Empire?

I watched some documentaries and they answered some of my questions but I couldn't talk with them so I had to ask here.

  1. Why did the Romans even accepted the faith?
  2. Out of all the religions that the many ethnicities in the Roman Empire embraced, why was Christianity adopted?
  3. Why didn't the Roman Empire embrace Judaism but rather Christianity?
  4. How did Christianity split from Judaism?
  5. What made the followers of Jesus so motivated to spread their religion around while the other tribes and people of the Roman Empire weren't so willing to?

1 Answers 2021-03-24

786 / 7255

Back to start