In the Asterix the Gaul cartoons, the audience is meant to root for the 'small village of indomitable Gauls' against the Romans. How common is this positive cultural depiction of barbarians in the West (specifically France and Britain), and how/why did our views of the barbarians change?

Any reading recommendations on perceptions of barbarians (especially in France, 19th century) would be greatly appreciated, I'm considering the topic for a masters dissertation.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Any high quality in depth historical books about the Boxer Rebellion?

Hello I am just looking for some recommendations on some deeply in depth books about the boxer rebellion. I enjoyed reading and looking through The Pivotal Conflict a comprehensive chronology of the First World War 1914-1919 by Gerald Herman. Is there any books that like that for the Boxer Rebellion? I am not looking for single accounts I would like many accounts with very technical descriptions of troop movements and numbers. I do not know the correct terms so I hope you can understand, thanks!

1 Answers 2021-02-24

In Mexico plenty of places and cities have native names, but in South America, particularly Colombia, Venezuela and Ecuador, it seems native names are much rarer, why is this?

I'm basing this simply on my own perception, perhaps there are as many native names in South America as in Mexico, but given what I've seen it seems native names are extremely rare in some South American countries

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Why didn't East Asia or South Asia saw complex infantry formations like in Europe during early modern period. I mean like Spanish Tercio, Swiss Pikes, Dutch infantry during 80 years war etc.

It seems that these complex infantry formations started to came in part in response to Cavalry but similarly in South Asia Mughals, and in China Qing were a cavalry based armies, so why didn't something unique appeared on the battlefield to challenge that even though these regions did have access to gunpowder weapons.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Did Joseph Smith use Judaism as a partial inspiration for the doctrine of the LDS church or are the similarities between them accidental/incidental?

I recently finished reading the Complete idiots guide to Judaism and coming from a Mormon background I couldn't help but see certain similarities between the two faiths. The similarities I saw included;

  • The mandatory 10% tithe.
  • The similarities between the LDS doctrine of service and the Jewish concept of tzedakah
  • The Mormon belief in creating an American Zion and reviving the 12 tribes of Israel.
  • The shared belief that followers have a direct connection to god and that there is continues revaluation.
  • The Mormon belief in a lay ministry (with each man past 18 being a priest) and the Jewish belief that all Jews should act as priests for the gentile population
  • The word of wisdom (and its extensive dietary restrictions) is comparable to Kashruth.
  • Mormon holy garments are comperable to the tzniut.

Are these similarities insignificant? Can you draw similar comparisons between other protestant denominations and Judaism? And are these type of protestant enough to say that Joseph Smith was inspired by Judaism?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Roman emperors often had idealized statues of their physique made, but Nero let it all hang out. His coinage and statues feature a fleshy face and double chin. Do we know why he didn't have artists "photoshop" his appearance? Was this fidelity to reality unusual in emperors?

Nero coin one.

Nero coin two.

Nero coin three.

Nero statue head.

Compare to Augustus.

I also wonder if allowing the overweight depictions of himself to circulate was itself a message. The empire wasn't involved in major wars during his reign. The economy was doing fine. Maybe he was using his weight to show that it was a time of peace and plenty?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

How was the Empire of Ethiopia perceived by European countries in the age of colonialism and after WW2? Did they consider Ethiopia in a negative connotation or did they treat the Emperor and the country itself in a positive light considering the time period of how Europeans may have viewed Africans?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Career Options for Studying History with a Focus on Pre-Christian civilizations?

I am interested in switching my current major to history. I am apprehensive, as I'd like to know that I will be able to have a stable career and live comfortably. I love school and am ready to buckle in for the long haul - masters, doctorate. I am leaning towards a career in academia because that seems the most obvious and I think I would be very happy in a scholarly setting as it is what I enjoy now.

My issue is, I am bored of modern history. I loved U.S. history in high school, but I am now fascinated with the things we don't know. Ancient civilizations, pre-Christian religions and civilizations. I might even consider a career in archaeology, but I have a 6 month old and my fiancé has a great job specific to our region, so I need to stay relatively stable in terms of location.

My question is - is there a future in this specific focus? I am hopeful that we will always continue to learn about these mysterious cultures and so there must still be room for the study of them.

Any insight would be greatly appreciated!

1 Answers 2021-02-24

For Musicologists - Where to find music of William F. Hanson

I’ve recently learned of a work called the Sun Dance Opera written by American composer William F. Hanson with Gertrude Simmons Bonnin. I’m interested to hear this but can’t find a recording or video of a performance, at least not in a morning of googling (but lots on the boy band Hanson). Turns out, the poor guy doesn’t seem to merit a Wikipedia entry.

So I thought this might be the place to ask if anyone knows how I can obtain more information, especially recordings and scores. I understand he was a specialist in Native American music and I’m curious to hear his work.

Thank you all in advance for any direction.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

In the early 19th century warfare, how big a deal was it for a soldier to lose his country's flag on the battlefield?

I watched this video from the 90s TV show Sharpe (set in 1800 during the Napoleonic Wars):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nuQhvoHXcys

In this clip, a British general chews out a colonel for his failings on the battlefield. The worst failing of all is that the colonel lost the King's Colours (ie the British flag). The general loses his cool over this one. He thinks it worse than all the casualties the unit suffered. I get that losing the flag could be embarrassing, but worse than the loss of human life? Is this scene realistic? How was this sort of thing viewed in the real world?

2 Answers 2021-02-24

Short Answers to Simple Questions | February 24, 2021

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

50 Answers 2021-02-24

Was Britain really composed of Roman Ruins in the past as portrayed in Assassins Creed Valhalla? If so, why didn't they rebuild the ruins or tear them down as opposed to living along side them?

2 Answers 2021-02-24

80% of Men Born In the Soviet Union In 1923 would be dead by 1946. How True Is This Statement?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Why did the Nazis have such interest in the Basque people?

Yesterday I was watching a documental from the 1940s called "In Lande Der Basken" which was a Nazi documentary about the Basque people and their customs. My question comes to why did they have that interest and why did they praise Basque culture so much?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

What was medieval combat really like?

I’ve always been curious as to what medieval combat was really like during battles etc, things movies don’t cover such as the smell, the noise. What would it really have been like? Archers shooting arrows near you I can imagine the noises were haunting as people get stabbed etc

Just hoping someone can give me some info on it all

2 Answers 2021-02-24

A strange thing I noticed about US states is that usually, the capital of the state is not the largest city in it. Why is that?

5 Answers 2021-02-24

Information about the Jômon and Yayoi periods?

I've read a book about the history of Japan and I found that there is almost no information about people that existed during those 2 periods and instead of that you find a list of emperors that didn't exist in real life. I'd like to know more about that two periods and not only general information about the whole place. I'd like more specific information for understanding more. Any book or YouTube channel would be great.

And also I want to know who was the first real emperor of Japan and why is it so difficult to know details about the past of Japan before 7th century.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

What were the most stable 'international' currencies during the cataclysms of the past (World Wars, 1918 Pandemic, Great Depression etc.) – and were there any recurring reasons for their stability?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

What were the duties of a new member of the Knights Templar?

Upon being accepted to the Knights Templar order, what was expected of a knight, what duties was he to perform and how, if at all, could he be promoted to a higher status?

I have recently found out that my city has a legit Knights Templar order and I wish to join in the future. I'm completely serious. And so I would like to be as authentic as possible and get some starting information. Thank you very much for reading.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

PTSD is nowadays well documented, but in the past it wasn’t so much. What was the attitude towards the disorder before it got large-scale attention following World War One?

I‘m not well versed in this topic so apologies for any misconceptions put forth in my title, but I was wondering how PTSD was perceived and dealt with throughout history. I don’t know of any examples from antiquity, and I am also curious about examples as recent as the Napoleonic wars.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

20th Century American Physicians/Surgeons and Eugenic Sterilization

I'm hoping that maybe some folks here might be able to help point me in the right direction on this. I am doing work on early to mid 20th Century Eugenics in the United States, specifically looking at the role of physicians who were the ones to actually physically carry out the surgeries for reproductive sterilization of those deemed "socially unfit" or otherwise. I am having no trouble finding primary and secondary sources detailing the overall ideology undergirding eugenic thinking, but as mentioned, I am really quite interested in the physicians who actually carried out the procedures that the intellectual eugenicists called for: what did they think about these ideas and the medical procedures associated with them? Was there any significant organized opposition to forcible reproductive sterilization among physicians and healthcare workers of the time, or was there general acceptance of the procedures as being ethically permissible among most physicians? I guess I am wondering essentially whether these procedures were considered controversial (specifically) among doctors (perhaps akin to controversy that might surround things like physician-assisted suicide (as an example) today), or not. Any direction regarding possible primary and secondary literature on this would be much appreciated. Thank you!

2 Answers 2021-02-24

What was considered the most leisurely country in the mid-late 1800s?

I like to immerse myself in certain periods, one way I do that is by watching colorized videos of life in the old days on YouTube. I notice in pretty much all of them that the French people look the most well dressed, that their popular city’s look the most attractive and well cared for, and that they generally seem to be the most leisurely.

Does anyone know if this was considered a truism even by the people of the time? Or did everyone think whatever nation they lived in was the most leisurely?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

Were survivors of the Holocaust able to recoup any of their lost assets?

2 Answers 2021-02-24

Found a Privateer Ships log written from 1812 to 1813. Now what?

It was in a batch with some really old family pictures.No idea what to do with this. Its really cool, is it something I should show to a local ship museum? Is it worth anything & what is best way to store it safely? I'd post pic but sub wont let me.

1 Answers 2021-02-24

What were the economic and political reasons that lead to the abolition of the Gold Standard in the early 20th century?

1 Answers 2021-02-24

833 / 7255

Back to start