Is there any concept in music theory that was introduced by modern pop music (1950s onwards) instead of classical music?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

In US history, how long did it typically take for a presidential election decision to be announced? What was the longest time between the election and final results?

I assume that the time allotted between the election and the elector vote is due to it taking longer to get a decision. Is this correct?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

What role did collaborationist Soviet deserters and POWs play during the Holocaust?

I was reading Life and Fate by Vasily Grossman and in it he mentions that Soviet POWs served as attendants and guards in the extermination camps? How did this happen?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

TUESDAY TRIVIA: "I have to write because if I don't get something down, then after a while I feel it's going to bang the side of my head off" (Terry Pratchett)- are you similarly compelled to write about the history of WORKS OF LITERATURE?

Welcome to Tuesday Trivia!

If you are:

this thread is for you ALL!

Come share the cool stuff you love about the past! Please don’t just write a phrase or a sentence—explain the thing, get us interested in it! Include sources especially if you think other people might be interested in them.

AskHistorians requires that answers be supported by published research. We do not allow posts based on personal or relatives' anecdotes. All other rules also apply—no bigotry, current events, and so forth.

For this round, let’s look at: WORKS OF LITERATURE! Are there any really interesting works of literature that were written in your era? What about about your era? Who were some particularly notable authors, or perhaps illustrators? Answer any of these or spin off into whatever you want!

Next time: MARRIAGE!

3 Answers 2020-09-22

How was it living in Rome during the middle ages?

I know that the population of Rome during the height of the empire was unprecedently big at around 1 million people. However after the fall of the western empire and being sacked and invaded multiple times the population shrunk to just a few thousand people. Do we have any accounts on how was it like living in the city after its fall? Was it like a ghost town where everybody could see the ruins of the empire or was much of it burned or destroyed?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Why did the Americans and south Vietnamese never invade north Vietnam?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

In 1074, Pope Gregory VII called on Latin Christendom to assemble an army in support of the Byzantines in the wake of the Battle of Manzikert in 1071, but was unsuccessful. Why did Gregory's call to arms fail, compared to Urban II's in 1095, which led to the First Crusade?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

I recently read a claim on reddit which stated that red army infantry (later on in the cold war) were only equipped with three ak mags each because ir was thought that on average they wouldnt live long enough to need more than that. Is this true? If so how come?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Did Jesus Walk the Earth?

I recently started becoming curious about religion and started with Christianity since it's the major religion around where I live. I saw this video that talked about Jesus' teachings but I have questions about his existence in general. Here are a few questions I hope someone has the answers to:

Was he a really person? How do we know?

What records are their of him outside of the bible?

Are their any records of his miracles outside of the bible

Why do we record all of human history by his birth and death?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Did the Bretton Woods system make it so that when the US experienced a financial issue, the rest of the world did as well, due to having their currency pegged to the dollar?

As the above question asks.

1 Answers 2020-09-22

How common was small scale warfare during the High/Late Middle Ages?

I was looking it this list of wars involving England and noticed that there was often 25 years or more between major wars. Would lesser vassals have fought each other? Or would soldiers go long periods of time without fighting? This goes against what I used to think of the Middle Ages - as a time of constant warfare and violence.

I only mentioned England but I’m interested in other European countries as well.

1 Answers 2020-09-22

In the USA, there is a widespread (if short of universal) stigma against selling and eating veal, with cruelty to young animals often cited as the reasoning. Why doesn't this stigma/controversy exist the same way for lamb?

The fact that I've heard several people now say that they didn't realize "lamb" meant "baby sheep" (as opposed to it referring to a meat type, a la "pork" and "pig") notwithstanding.

1 Answers 2020-09-22

When did the idea of life on other planets come up?

Who was the first person to think that we're not alone in the universe? When did it happen? Did they just see a flying saucer and come up with that or something?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Context about the B-29

So, I’m pretty sure we all know that the B-29 had turrets that could be remotely controlled from “fire stations” inside the bomber. But my question revolves around how exactly the gunner would see and fire at the target. I will try to break it up into sections for easy reference:

  1. How would the gunner even see the target. I know that there are windows on the side of the bomber that you can look out of, but would those even be effective? And God forbid that the target is well... above the bomber. (Yes I know that it would fly higher than a Japanese zero, but say the enemy somehow was above the bomber). Was there a sort of monitor inside of the gunner’s position? If so, how clear was the picture, was it in color, and were the “sights” of the turret relative to the monitor feed, or another sensory device, given that you would have to account for ballistics, but you would probably want to see your target at the same time? This seems like it would be rather out of place though, even considering that the project was crazy expensive.

  2. How would the gunner fire? This is of less importance, but I am still curious. Would they just press a button? Or would there be some sort of trigger integrated into their console?

  3. How would the turrets rotate? Since the guns aren’t operated manually, I don’t expect that the rotation of the turret would either. Would they have a joystick that moved it? That would seem the most logical to me.

Explanations are great but so are pictures, but I’ve not been able to find any good quality, up close pictures of the gunner’s fire station, so any links towards good pictures would be just as appreciated.

The reason I’m asking this is because people always talk about the remote systems, but quickly gloss-over the mechanics behind it. After all, we were still using wood landing decks on aircraft carriers, so it’s hard to imagine that the gunner inside a WWII bomber would have an Alien Ware monitor inside his fire station. I look forward to reading your answers!

1 Answers 2020-09-22

What is meant when historians get classified as modernist? Is it modernist because of the years they were writing in? Or the goals they have in their writing? or both?

Ive been going down a rabbit hole of looking at readings about contemporary american political issues all the way to to the idea of nationalism on a grand scale.

Through my google searches i keep coming back to this subredddit and learning about writers from Hobsbawm, to Gat to Immerwahr. And through these posts ive noticed some writers being labeled as "modern". For example Hobsbawm VS Azar Gat.

Im curious what is exactly meant by this. As stated in the question, are they modern because of the year that they are writing? Or is it an idea about these ideas (i.e nationalism) that they are writing about. And does their modernity apply to a newer set of politics that they position themselves against?

I apologize if the question is awkward. im kinda learning all this stuff on my own, and im not a historian nor did i go to school for this stuff.

1 Answers 2020-09-22

How much stock should I put into Caeser's description of the Nervii's strength?

The implicit bias of Caeser in describing his skirmishes in Gaul is obvious of course, but, interesting to me is if that is the case shouldn't he downplay how close the battle against them at Sabis was? I'd love recommend reading regarding the subject as well. His regard for them after the battle going so far as to call them heroic is also interesting. Was that mostly to paint himself in a more heroic light?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Can the Aztec and Incan empires be linked to the Babylonian empire?

Question sounds ridiculous, I know. My mother is a Jehovah's witness, and she listened to a talk earlier tonight. Apparently the speaker claimed that a lot of Aztec and Incan mythology or beliefs, that kind of stuff can be linked straight back to the Babylonian empire. Supposedly Babylonia was extremely important and a birthplace to much of ancient history and religions. Is there any truth to this? Will be happy to clarify any other questions.

2 Answers 2020-09-22

Did romans have street names and street addresses? What was their mail system like in general? How would I mail a letter from Capua to Ephasis?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Has there been a recognizable increase in the amount of skin cancer that has been documented since western society stopped wearing multilayered, extremely modest clothing about a century or so ago?

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Were Christian churches already beginning to emerge around 30 CE? If not, what is the earliest church we have record of?

David Fitzgerald is a historian that argues against there being a historical Jesus. One of his claims is that around the time Jesus died, churches were beginning to sprout up in Judea, Damascus, Greece, and even Rome itself.

1 Answers 2020-09-22

Self-Determination in WWI

Hey y'all,

Does anyone happen to have any resources they wouldn't mind sharing regarding self-determination and/or the arbitrariness of sovereignty in WWI? Any resources for any intended audience would do—I don't mind examining whatever y'all share.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2020-09-21

How much credit does Napoleon actually deserve for his victories?

I'm been reading up on him and as I understand it, before Napoleon generals had more direct control of their army. For example, Frederick the Great used very intricate tactics and plans to defeat all of Europe, which required him to have a detailed idea of what was going on at a small scale. As I understand it, Napoleon won battles with simple plans (or no plans at all) and left the details to lower levels.

Example:

At Leuthen, Frederick the Great tricked the Austrians in thinking he was retreating. Then he deployed in four columns and hid his army behind hills. He kept the farthest cavalry column in view to make the Austrians think he was going to move on their right, actually he piled the other three columns together behind the hills to hit the Austrian left. Then he marched the three columns around the Austrian left, using the hills to cover. He prepared an infantry attack at a perfect angle on the weakest part and hid his artillery on the hills. Then he attacked! When the Austrians tried to counter the infantry, his artillery fired down on their right as his cavalry hit their left. The Austrians got completely destroyed.

At Austerlitz, Napoleon let the Russians weaken their center to attack his right. Then he had his generals attack the center, and march around to his right. Very simple plan, just a hammer and anvil. Napoleon's only responsibility was sending in reinforcements while his marshals did the real work. He didn't personally give instructions on what formations or feigned retreats or angle of attack. His plan relied on only one trick: the Russians attack his right. Frederick tricked the Austrians into with the retreat, tricked them with the cavalry, tricked them with the hills, tricked them with the artillery. Napoleon's poorly thought-out plan could have easily gone wrong without his subordinates filling in the details. Frederick's detailed plan meant he always had another great trick up his sleeve if any one part failed.

1 Answers 2020-09-21

Why other colonial powers did not end up with a significant presence in South America

I know that Spain and Portugal had a 100 years start ahead the other colonial powers but I still find it hard to believe that the influence of the rest of the colonial powers was limited to some caribbean islands and the Guyana region.

Were all the hospitable regions already taken, did anyone tried to take spanish or portuguese colonies by force, I just want to know.

1 Answers 2020-09-21

Did ancient people really talk in a boring way?

If you read literature from several thousand years ago, the dialogue is super dry. As I read through he Bible and the Odyssey, the plot is great, the characters are good, but the dialogue is so dry and unnatural. Did people actually talk like that 2-3 thousand years ago, or did that boring dialogue come from somewhere else?

1 Answers 2020-09-21

How did painters capture fleeting moments and fast action before the invention of photography?

1 Answers 2020-09-21

1085 / 7255

Back to start