Was Lincoln a convinced anti-slavery man?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Just how accurate are facial reconstructions of historic people?

Even people who have lived apparently 200 years ago don't look remotely like we'd imagine people to look, not even considering different standards of beauty influencing renaissance paintings or idealized sculptures. Flat or bulky faces, enormous jaws and foreheads worthy of cartoon Martians. Strangest of all is that some reconstructions seem to vary in different periods while others stay the same over millennia.

I might trust that people 7000 years ago looked a bit weird, even 2000 years ago but 200 years ago?

If so the greatest achievement of the past 200 years would have been the development of modern beauty standards haha.

Jokes aside. It's rather confusion especially because these people are supposedly experts and their reconstructions are hailed as expert works.

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How Much Say Did an Individual in deciding who/what they were going to be apprenticed to?

I am reading a biography of Benjamin Rush (“Rush” by Stephen Fried) and I am intrigued that he was apprenticed to a physician before becoming one himself. I have a vague understanding that most vocations were not formalized but instead training was done through apprenticeship which made me wonder; In 17th century United States and Europe, what, if any, say did an individual have in the profession they were apprenticed to? Did the family choose? The individual? The Master? What, if any, legal protections were in place to prevent abuse and was there an option for say, a bookbinder’s apprentice to say, “Nah, this isn’t for me, think I might try my hand at apothecary instead.” Was that even an option or where you stuck with whatever apprenticeship you started with? Thanks for any responses!

1 Answers 2020-05-03

The homicide rate in Italy doubled between 1785 and 1812, while the other major European nations saw a steady drop. Why?

I found this graph and I'm fascinated. I have searched online and haven't found anything specific to Italy, although I'm not a skilled history researcher. The end of the Kingdom of Italy is one possible cause I've found, political turmoil perhaps, but I would've thought the various positive social changes of The Enlightenment would've outweighed this. Thank you for your time.

1 Answers 2020-05-03

I am an ethnically English person, born and raised in India, in the late 1940's, and it's clear that Indian independence is imminent. I've spent my whole life here and I want to stay. Realistically, is this an option?

Moreover, do we know of any examples of Anglo-Indians staying after independence? Did any achieve prominence in post-colonial society?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Why did Barbarossa falter and fail?

I know this must be a very frequently asked question, but how exactly did Operation Barbarossa fail? When I looked into the battle myself, I was surprised to see the Germans overall had sent a larger force to crush the Russians, and at Stalingrad, they had artillery supremacy. However, one thing that always confused me was what the Russians did to force the Germans back. What tactics did they use, and what key battles turned the lightning war into a lightning retreat?

2 Answers 2020-05-03

How was Islam viewed in the medieval Europe? Was it considered like any other religion or was it respected, given that Christ is held in high esteem in Islam and a whole chapter in Quran narrates the story of the virgin Mary.

1 Answers 2020-05-03

The dictators Franco (Spain) and Salazar (Portugal) seem to have had similar views on many things, and both gained power after the defeat of Republics which had overthrown their respective monarchies. Why then did Franco restore the Spanish Kingdom, but Salazar kept Portugal as a Republic?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Today arable farmers buy all/most of their yearly crop seed instead of practicing seed saving. Why did this switch happen and when did it start?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | April 27, 2020–May 03, 2020

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2020-05-03

Henry III of England died in 1272 but his son and heir Edward I "Longshanks" didn't return from his Crusade until 1274. Who was running the country in his absence, and how did they do so?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Best history books about the legend of King Arthur?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Did anyone oppose the union of Scotland and England?

Did anyone rebel? What did Scottish and England people think of it?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Best of April Voting Thread

13 Answers 2020-05-03

Are the old Roman patrician families such as the Julii or the Ancii still around to this day?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How did Christianity/religion influence Anglo-Saxon crime and punishment?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

What is the British equivalent to USA's civil rights and South Africa's apparteid?

There was a similar transition here, right?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

I'm a 16 year-old Roman citizen, the child of a middle-income Plebeian family. My hormone-driven teen angst is pushing me to rebel from my parents (and society) in any way I can. Given this, is my religious devotion to/belief in the gods likely to waver? Would I be punished for questioning?

Is it considered relatively normal for my friends and I to question the gods' existence? Do my parents likely genuinely believe in the gods? Lastly, do any of these answers change if I come from an elite Patrician family?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Is there evidence of archers using shields strapped to arms while firing?

I have been playing Medieval 2 lately and they seem to have many archer units that have shields on while firing. Is that a made up or is there evidence of archers using both at same time?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

What did internationals/expats do in times of mobilization?

Hi all,

Recently, thanks to this amazing reddit, I found about Dan Carlin’s podcast.

I am currently listening to his WWI podcast and he has a nice segment around the history of war, importance of mobilization and conscription evolution.

I was wondering, what did able-bodied people who were living abroad do when there was mobilization of a country? If I send myself back during WWI/II and there would be a nationwide mobilization what do I do as I am an expat?

Could one join the country of residence’s army? Were you re-called back to your homeland? How would you even be held responsible if you were recalled but you didnt go?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Was the Thirteen Colonies an actual British subdivision of territory at the time of colonial America, or did the term only become used in the post-revolution world to talk about the colonies that would become the United States separately from the ones that would become Canada?

I've heard the term Thirteen Colonies used before, as a description of the thirteen colonies of the British Empire that would eventually declare independence and for the United States of America. But these colonies weren't the only British possessions in North America. There were also other colonies, like Quebec, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Rupert's Land. To elaborate on my question, was there some kind of British administration/law/common opinion at the time that separated the colonies that would become the United States from the colonies that would become Canada? If I had asked somebody from the time before the American Revolution what the Thirteen Colonies were, would they though some means identify the colonies that would become the United States or would they just have considered these colonies as no different to the colonies that would become Canada?

In short, was "The Thirteen Colonies" a term used at the time or was it retroactively applied to talk about the ones that formed the United States.

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Japanese Battleships Nagato and Mutsu, were they really fundraised by children?

So in context why I'm asking this, in a game I play named Azur Lane, her design is of a little girl with HUGE riggings, showing off her four 410mm cannons, and the pagoda superstructure.

Now, the company, Manjuu, that designs the characters is rather more or less faithful to references of all ships. From what they'll look like, the riggings, to small details. For example, USS Enterprise's Anniversary skin have lots of references, including Vulcan salutation from Star Trek. One more example: an equipment named "Unfulfilled Promise" references to U-556's promise to protect KMS Bismarck no matter where they are. (tearjerking cutscene, too)

Now, why I am asking? Because out of all the Big Seven battleships (USS Colorado, West Virginia, and Maryland; HMS Nelson, and Rodney) IJN Nagato and Mutsu are little girls compare to the other five who are mature-bodied women.

Few comments long ago said it's because they were fundraised by children, thus that's the reference of them being little girls, but it's kinda unbelievable to me even today. So I'm asking this sub how true is it?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How “official” was Britain’s control over Egypt?

Egypt is often depicted as a colony of the British Empire, especially in maps of the British Empire at its height. Yet from what I understand, Britain’s control over Egypt seemed to have stemmed mostly for its strong economic power over the country rather than any direct military force. A different set-up from the Empire’s presence in much of India for example.

Still, while they had control over it, was Egypt “officially” an independent nation that just so happened to have very close ties to Britain, or was it legally under British authority in some way? Is it de jure accurate to put Egypt in the British empire on a map, or is that more of a de facto acknowledgement of the political situation in Egypt?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

Did the Royal Navy Really Attempt to Train Seagulls to Poop on U-Boat Periscopes in WW1?

In Dreadnought, Massie claims that an early attempt to combat u-boats was to train Seagulls to defecate on periscopes. Is this true, and what do we know about it?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

How did the Chimu Empire establish control over its territories?

We hear an awful lot about the infrastructure created by the Inca, but what about the Chimu? Did they also build fortifications, roadways, and other features classically associated with empire?

1 Answers 2020-05-03

1361 / 7255

Back to start