Do historians speaking in English for people/places with culturally accepted pronunciations that are different from the original use the original or the English?

Like I'm sure if a historian is speaking in Latin they'd pronounce Julius Caesar as Yulius Kaezar but would they do that in English classes/lectures, or use the commonly accepted pronunciation in English? How about more modern people like Charles De Gaulle, would he be pronounced Sharu Degah?

2 Answers 2019-11-19

What do you think about These Truths by Jill Lepore?

I was listening to the BBC History Extra podcast and they interviewed Ms. Lepore about her new book. The interview was pretty engaging and the book sounds (from her perspective) really interesting. On Goodreads it’s well reviewed right now but Goodreads reviewers basically never review poorly.

Anybody here read this book and have thoughts? I’ve been interested in American history as of late but haven’t really known where to best start reading and this sounded like a good starter candidate.

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Having trouble finding primary sources about Helots/Spartan slaves

I've been researching for a term paper that requires me to have at least 2 primary sources and I was hoping to write 'about what life was like for Helots' but I've been having trouble; does anyone know an archive I can use to find those sources?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

When was the Roman Republic “restored” (or, rather, when did the City of Rome first get its modern government)?

The question is slightly cheeky, but I was curious about this aspect of Rome’s history as a city. Rome today now has a democratic government like almost all cities in democratic countries. For years, however, it was ruled by the Roman Emperors and then the Pope, before becoming the capital of modern Italy. When in the city’s history did it become democratically run “again,” and what was the context for this “restoration”? Was there any acknowledgement of it as a historic moment, or was Rome’s modern city government created with relatively little fanfare?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Good books for a undergraduate writing an essay on the causes of WW1

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Why did 20th amendment required 3/4 of the states to be ratified?

My understanding is that for an amendment to be ratified, it is required that 2/3 of the states have to approve the said amendment through their legislative process.

However, the section 6 of the 20th amendment sets the limit at 3/4 of the states:

Section 6. This article shall be inoperative unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by the legislatures of three-fourths of the several States within seven years from the date of its submission.

Was there any reason for this exception? Why wasn’t the 2/3 threshold good enough for the 20th amendment?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

What happened to the old patrician families after the fall of the western Roman Empire?

I know some Roman families in the Middle Ages and renaissance claimed descent from the ancient Romans, but as a class were they able to survive the transition of Europe into warring feudal states or were they superseded by the new military nobility?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

I am a citizen of the Byzantine Empire in c. 1000 AD. I have just stolen a cow from my neighbor. What is the legal punishment? Does is involve compensation? (Alternatively, I have killed the neighbor! What is the legal punishment?Does is involve compensation?)

I've been trying to find some information on legal punishments within Byzantium from 900-1200 (specifically, if the Byzantine state utilized compensation in cases such as those outlined in the title). Any response would be greatly appreciated, particularly if you can refer me to the relevant law codes.

1 Answers 2019-11-19

When did the ancient Egyptian Gods religion end? Is there any religion that has continued to worship them?

2 Answers 2019-11-19

Was there a plan to drop nuclear bombs on Germany if they hadn't surrendered by the time the weapons were ready?

2 Answers 2019-11-19

Was John Ivan Demjanjuk - Ivan The Terrible?

I have just finished watching the devil next door. Such strong cases on both sides, with I think the emotional bias being against John.

So I guess I just really don’t know and would love to hear if anyone has any further thoughts. I know it’s been out for a bit (1970-2012) but would love to hear some thoughts.

Cheers

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Did the Allies knew about extermination camps?

We usually hear that the allies didn't go to war agains't germany because of the shoah. And peoples didn't know what was going on for jews in nazi germany.

But I feel like Allies's intelligence agencies would have probably knew what was going on from the very beginning. But choose to not disclose this. Am I just a fool thinking this? Or is there some truth behind my thoughts?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

I'm a sophomore in high school and I've been interested in becoming a historian, but admittedly I don't know a whole lot. Do you guys have any advice?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Why are there so few forts in England for its size compared to Spain, France, Germany and the Netherlands?

It’s just something I’ve noticed. I thought it could be due to there being fewer foreign invasions, but then there should be many, many forts from the times of the Anglo-Saxons and Viking invasions?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

The conquistadors used indigenous allies to help topple the empires in Central and South America during their conquest. Do we know at what point the conquistadors' indigenous allies realized they made a horrible mistake?

The Spanish conquistadors were small in number and thus used divide and conquer tactics to gain indigenous allies to even the playing field numerically during their conquest of the Americas. Even though they assisted the Spanish, they would eventually turn on them. Do we have any record of any former indigenous allies to the Spanish realizing they made a mistake or regretting supporting the Spanish? Once the indigenous allies realized the Spaniards couldn't be trusted, why weren't there widespread revolts to push them out? With their small numbers and no indigenous allies this time, shouldn't it be relatively easy to defeat the Conquistadors?

2 Answers 2019-11-19

When Henry VIII was looking for his fourth wife he had already abandoned one, executed another and lost his third due to childbirth. Did his marital history hinder his search for his fourth wife? How would fathers (or brothers) feel about a suit from Henry VIII?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

What drugs did they use in roman times

I was writing a short story about a soldier in the battle of trebia (gave up ain't planning to finish it) and i wanted to include something about what drugs they used, how they used it and what the latin name would be

2 Answers 2019-11-19

Could the royal navy have prevented a successful invasion by the Nazis if Britain had lost the Battle of Britain?

I have always heard that once Nazi Germany lost the Battle of Britain, it became impossible for them to successfully invade.

However, the Royal Navy was the largest naval force in the world and I am wondering if the RN could have prevented a successful invasion by the Nazi's, even if Britain had lost the Battle of Britain?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Book suggestions for Communism in China

I was wondering if anyone had any suggestions for books relating to the history of communism in China? Generally interested in an overview from its beginnings and throughout the 20th century, but books on specific events are also welcome

2 Answers 2019-11-19

What are some Chinese sauce thickness before corn starch and potato starch

I like to cook Chinese food; however, when it comes to thickening the sauce, it inevitably calls for either corn starch or, on rare occasions, potato starch. These were introduced, I believe, during the Qing dynasty. How were sauces thickened before then?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

How did capturing enemies in battle actually work?

Beware who comes here, for English is not my first language.

I was reading a post here about late medieval Europe and while I'm familiar with the fact that highborn enemies could be captured for ransom rather than killed, I wonder how did that actually work. In the aforementioned post, a contributor states that

If soldiers were able to identify a particularly important individual, there would probably have been a mad scramble to capture him rather than kill him outright, both for political purposes and for the potential for ransom profits. This happened to the French king Jean II at Poitiers, who was taken prisoner in a furious melee where other high-ranking French aristocrats, who ordinarily would have made excellent ransoms, were killed (possibly by accident as English troops swarmed to grab Jean specifically)

It seems there was competition to be the one to capture an important enemy. How were those claims disputed in the middle of a battle? Were there any 'claiming rights', or were they shared among different individuals?

Another post tackled this issue slightly different. How did the 'capturing' work in the middle of a battle, or was it done after the whole thing?

1 Answers 2019-11-19

1492 Spanish Map: What are the Wind Names Referred to on this Compass Rose?

The Wikipedia page says the letters refer to traditional wind names. I did some googling and couldn't find the names of any winds that match the letters (or what I guess the letters to be since the writing is unusual to me)

Link

Thank you!

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Readings which discuss Ancient Greek and Roman Mythology?

I checked the excellent list on this reddit, but couldn’t find much in the way of specifically the mythology these peoples subscribed to. I want to read from their perspective, and actually learn the stories I’m just vaguely aware of. All this talk about “Zeus, don’t do that” and the repercussions, I must learn more.

Stories from those who lived then or “summaries” from more recent sources are cool, I just want to learn more about the mythology. Thanks.

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Why has America always been an attractive country for immigrants?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-11-19

Why did German-Americans flock to the Union banner during the US Civil War?

German Americans filled a large part of the Union Army. Is it a 48’er thing? Were there any German confederates?

2 Answers 2019-11-19

⯇ 1657 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start