In the melee of a medieval battle, how could you tell who you were suppose to be fighting?

Just watched the King on Netflix, and whilst I'm sure that's ladened with inaccuracies on the fighting that took place within medieval battles, it has made me wonder that in the thick of a melee where all combatants are wearing fairly similar plate armour, how on earth could you tell who you were suppose to be fighting. Surely you could easily end up killing people on your own side by accident?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

UK religious historians(?) - Why in the CofE is it not possible for divorced people to marry in a CofE religious ceremony but the religion itself was "founded" by someone who did it so he could divorce and remarry?

I've been watching the crown (season 1) and the bit where Margaret can't marry a divorcee. Wasn't the CofE founded by Henry the 8th so he could divorce and remarry? Have I missed something or has the rules changed since then?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Where can I find issues of Confidential magazine (American gossip magazine from the 1950s)?

I am a university student currently studying history, and I am doing a research project about American pop culture during the early years of the Cold War. I am taking a look at how the politically-fostered culture of exposure and paranoia permeated into American popular culture. A primary source that I would like to use for my research is an early American gossip magazine, Confidential, which will serve as an example of this culture of paranoia and exposure. Even though the magazine was in print until the 1970s, I would like to look at issues from 1952 to 1958, its most successful years.

I was wondering if anyone knows where I could find these issues of Confidential, either physically in a repository or in scans online. I am having trouble finding them through my university’s library services, and I wanted to see if I could find them another way. I know there are some on eBay, but I would prefer not to pay for this if possible. I attend a pretty big university in the US, so I should be able to gain access through interlibrary loan if they’re held at a different institution.

Also, if you are aware of any similar publications or other secondary sources that would be helpful to my research, please let me know! Thanks!

1 Answers 2019-11-01

I'm the ghost of John Flagstaff. Have any ghosts from the battle Agincourt seen "the King"?

Since it is Halloween weekend and the magical powers of the mods have brought me back to life I have a question; I just watched the new tale of Henry V on a magical netflix window and since I'm mostly a figment of imagination of Billy Shakespear I'm asking other ghosts from 1415 what you thought of it. I was annoyed that it was a bit too simplified (where were my military scouts?) but alas, it only a tale for folks without deep knowledge so I gave them a pass. A true tale would take days to tell and scare the soft bellied youth ;)

I appologize if I spoke out of turn, 800 years of being dead makes the mind a bit fuzzy, I only seek information of ancient deeds.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Did accounts of the battle of Osowiec (aka "The attack of the dead men") have any effect on zombie lore in pop-culture?

This was just a curiosity that occured to me while listening to Sabaton's "Attack of the Dead Men", which is about the battle of Osowiec Fortress, where 7000 Germans, repeatedly unable to eliminate the Russian forces within, deployed mustard gas. However, when the Germans advanced on the fortress, under the belief they killed everyone, it turns out 100 Russians survived the mustard gas, and the surprise of so many surviving defenders whose faces were mangled horribly from the gas caused the 7000 Germans to rout.

This made me wonder, did an experience so horrifying have any effect on George Romero when he introduced the zombie into pop-culture? I don't know of any specific people before Romero who wrote about zombies, hence why I put his name in the text, but if there is a lesser known individual before Romero who created Zombie stories (even if they didn't use the Z-word) that were inspired by the events of Osowiec, I would love to hear about them.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Hey, did you hear about Marquis Yiyong? He's only got one wife! You'd think a man of his stature in the Qing court would at least keep a few concubines around, everyone else is doing it. Why d'ya think he keeps himself to one?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Hey, Lincoln, what were you planning or hoping to do regarding slavery as president?

Obviously, the civil war must have thrown most of your plans out the window, but it seems like you must have had some idea of what you were going to do if you got a regular term in office.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Why did the British not provide a high explosive shell for their 2 pounder guns in World War II?

So I know that in early British tanks that were equipped with 2 pounder (40mm) guns not having a high explosive round for anti infantry use was considered a huge setback for early British forces. One of the reasons the British liked the Grant tank so much was the high explosive 75mm gun it had. I am curious to why though the original 40mm guns were not provided with it. There were 40mm anti aircraft guns that had HE shells so what prevented the British from designing a similar shell for their tanks.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

What rank was my grandfather?

Hello AskHistorians! All I know about this portrait of my grandfather is that the picture was taken in 1973 Francoist Spain, he most likely served within the armed forces or the Guardia civil. It is very hard to find any information about ranks back then and the closest thing I found was a rank table on wikipedia but the shoulder patch is very hard to identify, hence I came here seeking for help.

https://imgur.com/a/leCR7WV

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Is there any evidence to want music was played during roll call at concentration camps?

What music*

Had an argument with a friend. Is there any documentation of this?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Tomorrow is Día de muertos, but how did it get so popular? Also, what's up with all the sexy skeletons?

I didn't hear about it so much before but seems to be pretty popular nowadays.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Why did Russia and America care about the korean war?

I looked this up but i can't find a satisfying answer. Considering the enormous tension from cold war and the giant stockpiles of nukes, it could have ended really badly. What was there to gain from Korea that justified risking the end of the world to get it?

2 Answers 2019-11-01

Kangxi Emperor, can you tell us how you practiced and what you thought of the Yijing?

/u/ElheTaifin_KangXi, Professor Richard J. Smith has written in both of his histories of the Yijing that you were an avid student and practitioner of this Classic. He said you used to study it by meditating on a single gua for three days at a time. Was this true? How did you practice this way? Are there writings where you later shared your thoughts about this ancient work? How long would you practice this way (i.e. would you study each gua for three day increments until finishing all 64 and then restart?)?

Sincerely, u/JimeDorje

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Did the U.S. Army fought in the Pacific during WW2 or it was just the Marines/Navy?

If so, who did most of the fighting? The Army or the Marines?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

My plays are over-full of jests bawdy and foul, and oft attended by the basest rascals, yet of late are reckon'd most exquisite art. How came this to be so?

2 Answers 2019-11-01

Dear Qianlong Emperor, did you have a preference for Buddhistic schools? And what prompted your intense interest in the Dharma?

/u/AbkaiWehiyehe, your eminence, it is no secret that you were best friends with His Holiness the Panchen Lama. And of course, I have been using the Tenjur you commissioned for my own academic work and I thank you for your interest commitment to the propagation of the Buddhadharma. But I have always wondered what prompted such an intense interest and focus into your study of Buddhism and why you gravitated further and further towards an intensive study of the Tibetan variant?

Was your interest in the Dharma always geared towards the Tibetan variety, or did you also study and have an interest in other forms, i.e. Chinese or otherwise?

Sincerely, u/JimeDorje

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Hannibal, Scipio, Maharbal, and Fabius I ask yo now. When considering how good a commander is, surely a general ought know how to use a victory, and not merely gain one?

I ought say, that I'm curious as to their views.

1 Answers 2019-11-01

General Count Alfred von Schlieffen... What was I supposed to do?! Belgium is resisting, Russia was staged, waiting to beef with us... HALP!

I would like to ask General Count Alfred von Schlieffen a question about the implementation of his famous plan because this is really bumming me out rn.

At what point/deviation were you the most pissed about? The Belgians resisted and the Russians were staged to mobilize almost immediately. Should either of those issues cause the plan to be scrapped and a more thorough improvisation to happen?

Do you blame me? :(

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Why, why, why PM Meir did you not act on intelligence before the Egyptians and Syrians struck on Yom Kippur?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Why did Allied command cover up the fact that Mustard gas was spilled into Bari during a German air raid?

I'm reading through Rick Atkinson's The Day of Battle and he talks about the German air raid on Bari. One thing that isn't clear is why the Allied command kept it hidden from medical personnel and then buried the story for another 15 years. Was it fear of German reprisal should they learn the allies stored several tons of gas ready to use or was allied command ashamed of what happened?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

"all answers accepted" tag

[deleted]

2 Answers 2019-11-01

When did governments start taking on considerable debt instead of matching expenditures with income? Did the city states of Greece, the Roman emperors, and the leaders of the Quin Dynasty take on state debt to bankroll their projects?

1 Answers 2019-11-01

Frauen of AskHistorians, do you love your husbands?

I ask this question after many years of reflection, as I think back on my life as I write its story for my children and their children after them. I myself loved my first husband, Chayim Hameln, a pious and worthy Jew who walked in the paths of the righteous, beloved by all his fellows. We were betrothed when I was twelve years of age and married two years later, as is the age-old custom among the Jews of Germany in our day, and always shall I be grateful to my beloved parents for their fortuitous choice of mate. In our business my good husband always trusted my opinion and was guided by my advice, and together we arranged fortuitous matches for the eldest four of our twelve children. Alas! that he should have passed before we, side by side, could have led all of our children beneath the wedding canopy! Yet it was not to be; far too young, he died, and I could not even touch him as I was in a state of impurity. The whole of the community of Hamburg was in a state of shock and grief. But God gives and God takes away, may the name of God be blessed.

After his death I maintained his affairs best I could, with little of the help that one might expect be given to a widow with eight children yet to marry off. I never thought of marrying once more- there could never be another Chayim Hameln- but when I agreed after fourteen years to marry Hirz Levy, I believed that at the least I should have comfort and companionship for the rest of my days. Alas!- he was a good man, but he lost his money and mine with which I had entrusted him, and soon he died. I now live out my last days with my daughter and her husband, and they shower me with honor, yet I shall never be as happy as I was with my dear husband, may he rest in peace. Now my diary shall be the evidence of the depth of the love and esteem in which we were fortunate for all too short a time to regard each other.

Fellow women, do you love your husbands? Were they chosen for you in the age-old custom, or did you meet them by some other means? Do they treat you as a true helpmeet or are you cast aside and disregarded?

3 Answers 2019-11-01

Día de Muertos on AskHistorians! Ever wanted to sit down with a historical figure for a beer or coffee? Now's your chance! Ask and/or answer questions in character, 11/1 1pm GMT to 11/2 7pm GMT!

ETA: If you want to play, please post new threads rather than replying to this one!

Truly, what holiday is better worth celebrating in a history community than a día de los muertos?

From:

  • 8 AM Central Time, Nov 1 (1 PM GMT)

to

  • 2 PM Central Time, Nov 2 (7 PM, GMT)

AskHistorians goes to the ghosts as "r/AskHistoricalFigures"!

We encourage you to post AND answer questions as people of the past. Novelty accounts welcome! (Or you can just post with your main account, and tell us in the post whether you are asking/answering in character).

A few guidelines:

And thus...bring out your dead! Bring out your dead!

10 Answers 2019-11-01

Friday Free-for-All | November 01, 2019

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

9 Answers 2019-11-01

⯇ 1687 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start