Why didn't states recruit/conscript women into their armed forces? Wouldn't that have been an easy way to double troop numbers?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

How much Prussian was Prussia?

How much Prussian was Prussia? did the leaders speak prussian? was Prussia more German than Prussian? were prussians able to understand german and vice versa?

I'm talking Around 1800, long time after the formation of Prussia, but 70 years before the German Empire

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Do you know any ancient or medieval recipes that you've cooked/might be worth cooking or maybe a list/book of recipes or general food and food preparation?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Why did Britain support the French in Indochina immediately after World War II, but pressure the French to pull out at the same time?

Shortly after World War II, the French were trying to reestablish their rule in their colonies/mandates. From what I've read, the British lobbied the US to support the French in the French's desire to take back Indochina, in part because the British Foreign Office didn't want the US to undermine European colonial empires since they were afraid of blowback on their own empire. During the same period, though, I've read that they pressured the French to pull out of their mandate in Syria.

What was the difference between these two situations that made the British act in such different ways?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

In the “response of the zhaporovian cossacks” the Cossacks refer to sultan mehmed IV as “the wheelwright” of macedonia. Given the nature of the text this seems to be meant as an insult, why would being referred to as a wheelwright in the 17th century be seen as an insult?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Good books on Mughal Empire?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Saturday Showcase | September 28, 2019

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2019-09-28

In 1979 Wales voted by 79% to 20% against having their own national parliament in a referendum. Why were they so hostile to devolution?

2 Answers 2019-09-28

Why was Julius Ceaser not the first emperor of rome?

After crossing the Rubicon and becoming the dictator of Rome, Ceasar amassed a huge amount of political power/control. Some amongst the populace even referred to him as 'King' on one ocassion (which he admittedly rebutted). So why is it that we refer to Augustus as the first Emperor of Rome? Was Julius Ceasar not an Emperor in all but name?

On from this, what changes did Augustus bring to Rome which differentiates his power to his uncle that grants him the title?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

How have facists historically seized power?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Why do Russian Tsarinas mostly seem to be chosen from (relatively) minor royal families?

For the purpose of this question, I'd like to confine the period to that of the Romanov dynasty.

I've always thought it curious why the royal brides for future czars were chosen from seemingly minor royal families. For example, Catherine the Great's father was the ruler of a small principality and her family was by and large, impecunious.

The last Empress of Russia, Alexandra Feodorovna, came from a princely cadet branch.

Was there any particular reason for choosing brides from minor royal families? I can't imagine they would bring in much wealth or prestige marrying into Russian Royal Family.

Why weren't they chosen from the great European royal families at that time, such as England, France, Spain, etc?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

How can we read super ancient Egyptian hieroglyphs if the Rosetta stone was created in 196BC?

I mean, languages change pretty dramatically over time, and the Egyptians were around for an incredibly long period. Most of us couldn't understand English from just a few hundred years ago. Aren't the hieroglyphs on the Rosetta stone different from hieroglyphs from those made thousands of years earlier?

2 Answers 2019-09-28

Flint knives

Surprisingly hard to google those simple questions:

  1. What was the reason why man changed material from flint to metal in weapons?
  2. How long could a flint knife be?
  3. What are the advantages of metal weapon over stone weapon?
  4. Is it true that flint weapons couldn't get as long as metal ones, because they would break?

I 'know' most of the answers from a general knowledge, but I'm writing a quasi-historical book and I'd like to look into some serious sources, but the one I've got only talk about the specifics of the found knives, but don't explain why people transitioned and why people didn't use 'stone swords'. The purpose of the book is to explain the philosophy of arms and armour to people working in entertainment industry (games, movies, etc.)

​

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2019-09-28

How important was the library of Alexandria

I’ve heard about this library but don’t know too much about it hoping someone could tell me more

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Limpieza de sangre: Confused. How was this both a Racial purity but also a Religious one if Religion and Race are two different things?

Reading up on this event in Spain during the time of the defeat of the Moors. Limpieza de sangre which was a Blood Purity ruleset similar to the One Drop Rule in the United States, but based on Religious groups. But how could they tell what Religion a person was from their genetics? Unless Religion and Race were synonymous terms back then.

If so, what genetic characteristics defined a Christian from a Jew from a Muslim? Because they all come from the same region of origin and same root religion, so I am confused how they would been racially different back then.

1 Answers 2019-09-28

In old novels from the 18th and 19th centuries, opera singers and actresses are seen as disreputable: at one point did the reverse become the case?

I've been reading 'Vanity Fair', and I have the impression that if one of the upper class fops were to bring home an opera singer, it would be like his modern day counterpart bringing home a porn actress. (If his parents also liked watching the same porn.)

Today, the reverse would be the case. I'm imagining some cultural writer with the 'New Yorker' fawning over a renowned opera singer and her blueblooded Knickerbocker husband in their Manhattan townhouse.

So how did we get from A to B?

Edit: typo. Meant to ask "At what point...?"

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Germanic Frankish to Romance French - How, When and Why?

I'm aware the Franks were a Germanic people who predominantly migrated into northern Gaul, and who, with Christianisation, founded a kingdom in the 5th century that would come to encompass a very large proportion of Western Europe by the early 9th century.

What I've never quite understood is their transformation from a Germanic-speaking people to a Romance-speaking people. How did a people shift languages like this? What prompted it? When did the change begin and when was it complete? Did some of the Carolingian realms remain Frankish, or at least for a longer period than they did in Francia/West Francia?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Did any noticeable number of Muslims/non-Christians fight on he side of Christian crusaders?

I was just thinking about the fact that realistically speaking the crusader kingdom of Jerusalem/other crusader states likely had majority non-Christian majorities. Or at least had non Catholic majorities. During the various crusades/religion based fights did Muslims/Jews/Non-Christians/Catholics make up a noticeable amount of the Christian led armies? Would this kind of thing even be recorded in history. I mean I know that non-upper class history has way less written primary sources so I can imagine scribes not really care about things like the ethnic and religious compositions of armies.

Secondary question that probably deserves a different thread: Did Catholic occupation of sizeable parts of the Middle East have a noticeable impact on the religion and ethnic make up? Did the number of Christian increase? Did the western Europeans who settled leave any lasting religious or cultural impact on the region?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

I found a map of the world today but I can not figure out what year is is supposed to represent. Help please!

Here is the image of europe: https://imgur.com/a/5ire5RT

From what i can tell, we are looking at a pre WWII map but there is no information regarding the year.

There is no East Prussia which is confusing me. Any help would be appreciated.

This image includes North Africa and Asia: https://imgur.com/a/1U59GZ4

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Why Japanese, Italian and German ex-colonies don't use their colonist's language as their official language, unlike Portugese, Spainsh, English, French, Belgium ex-colonies?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

Did the Soviet army intentionally encourage the Warsaw Uprising, just to let it get destroyed by the Germans?

The common narrative I heard was that the Soviet army encouraged the poles to rise up in Warsaw to fight the Germans. with the expectation that the majority of the poles that fought were nationalists. The Soviets denied the allies the right to airborne drop supplies into the city, and they moved a mostly polish armored division away from the city.

This seems to hold water. especially when you consider the fact that it was not the first time they were cruel towards the poles. i.e. the Katyn Massacre. Also when you consider what happened after the war. The Polish nationalists were now outnumbered the polish communists and Poland became a satellite state under the Soviet Union.

2 Answers 2019-09-28

How significant an advantage would it be for Late Bronze Age soldiers with iron weapons fighting against soldiers with bronze weapons, if respective skill and experience are the same for both sides?

How much stronger/sharper/tougher of a metal is iron over bronze weaponry?

Were there significant events documented or attesting to big battles between iron and bronze weapons?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

How varied were people’s diets in the late 1800’s/early 1900’s?

I’m mostly curious about meals eaten at home - did families tend to eat the same thing every day, or was it more varied like we are now? Did they each 3 meals a day or was it different?

1 Answers 2019-09-28

The year is 1000AD. Where are the wealthy areas in Europe, Middle East and Asia? And why are those areas rich?

3 Answers 2019-09-28

The Young Samurai Series is a series of young-adult books set in Japan in 1611 to ~1616. In the series, women are apparently considered complete equals in fighting and warfare by both the Samurai and the ninjas. How accurate is this depiction? What role (if any) did women have in battle in that era?

2 Answers 2019-09-28

⯇ 1742 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start