Why was Karl Marx so harsh on his writings about Simón Bolívar?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 04, 2019

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history

  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read

  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now

  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes

  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

11 Answers 2019-07-04

"A newly unearthed archive letter has told the story of how an early 18th century Dutchman kept an elephant in an upstairs flat in Edinburgh". I have... questions.

Namely:

  1. What on earth is this madness? How do you even get an elephant into a flat in a city notorious for its cramped buildings? How common were elephants in this period that some random Dutchman shoving one up a staircase wouldn't have been immediate cause for concern?
  2. More seriously, I'm interested in the kind of neighbourly dispute resolution that might have taken place, either specific to Edinburgh or in other cities in this period. What sort of obligations did neighbours have towards one another? What options for redress were there for patently disruptive or damaging behaviour (like KEEPING AN ELEPHANT IN YOUR FLAT)? Why would local authorities, as they seem to have done in this case, find in favour of the pachydermophile in question?

Link.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

How did the scholars interpret ancient/extinct language?

To be more specific, George Smith in his epic translation of ancient akkadian language that references the biblical deluge. How did they do it when this language was thought to be extinct?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

What country and century would these knights most likely be from?

Can anyone identify, through the armour and helmets of these knights, if they are an accurate depiction of a particular place and time in history?

​

https://imgur.com/a/uuxvCnU

​

Thank you

1 Answers 2019-07-04

If we could poll US Colonials in 1776 what percent would have been in favor of the Declaration of Independence?

I have always been curious about the extent of support there was in Colonial America at the Continental Congress. I assume there would be many who wanted independence but no a bloody war, some who would fight, some who were happy to stay part of the UK, and those who did not care one way or the other. How would these groups break down as a percentages of the colonial population?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Debt forgiveness in Rome

So I've recently I've been looking into the practice of a general debt forgiveness. From my understanding on occasion the state ,during the late republic period at least, just forgave all personal debt. How well did this work? I'd imagine it'd have some interesting consequences on inflation rates around election time if there was a high level of personal debt going around and perhaps a more radical populares was high in the running. The video I was watching implied it helped to boost the productivity of some of Rome's poorest as debt rose too high. Was this the case?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

We know that many of the founding fathers owned slaves. How many *actually* freed their's once independence from Britain was gained?

- Also taking into account any laws/regulations that prohibited the freeing of slaves, giving anyone the benefit of the doubt about their willingness to free their slaves.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Were any spears able do be easily disassembled and reassembled at any time in history?

Coming from the point that the first (and as I know the great majority ) spearheads were firmly attached to the shaft and not supposed to be unattached casually, were any of them different? Was it a point where the spearheads (or even the whole shaft) were able to be disassembled for any reason? Like ease of travelling or shapening on the go.

2 Answers 2019-07-04

How was German reunification received in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland? Did it have any significant effect on the public opinion concerning Irish reunification in either country?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Best Chernobyl history books in Spanish

My friends and I were discussing HBO's Chernobyl and I suggested some of the history books I have read about here. However, I didn't find any of them translated into Spanish. My friends do not feel comfortable reading in English, so I came here to ask for your help in finding some Spanish language sources.

Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Why did Pre-Islamic Syriac sources keep mentioning the Medes even 800 years after the fall of their empire?

As a Kurd I think majority of Kurds are convinced that the Medes are their ancestors but majority of historian reject that claim, this made me to search a little bit about this topic.

Lately I've found some Syriac Aramic sources that kept mentioning the Medes as a people till Islamic invasions, even in Bible the Medes aren't extinct people as mentioned in Acts 2: 8-11 Then how is it that each of us hears them in our native language?  Parthians, Medes and Elamites; residents of Mesopotamia, Judea and Cappadocia, Pontus and Asia

  • Isaac complex in 410 AD mentioned Diocese of the Medes.
  • Aqaq complex in 486 AD mentioned Abraham the Med. It's believed name of the town of Batnaya in Nineveh plain came from Beth Madaya which means home of the Medes.
  • Babi complex in 497 AD mentioned Median bishop.
  • Grigor Complex in 605 AD mentioned Median bishop.
  • Joseph complex in 554 AD mentioned that Aqaq is Bishop of the Medes.
  • And finally Tertullian an early Christian author in 2nd century mentioned that The Medes are believer of Jesus.

I have more sources that mentioned The Medes, mostly mentioned them in the geography that Kurds live in today, another confusion thing all these Syriac sources above have mentioned Kurds too, so The Medes and the Kurds were living at same time, a Kurdish historian Soran Hamarash believes that The Medes were elite ruling family of the empire, so even after the fall of their empire they kept ruling small kingdoms for centuries later, it's just like today as we mention Ottomans but in fact Ottomans were only elite ruling family and the rest of people were Turks, Kurds, Armenians, Arabs.. etc.

I want to know why they kept mentioning the Medes although their empire fall centuries ago, did the Medes survived or they just referred everyone who lived in Ancient Media as Median?

Sorry for my English, it isn't my first language.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Why wren’t other german speaking areas included in german unification?

Austria (just austria not the whole empire), Switzerland, Luxembourg, etc.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Everyone knows the american natives struggled with european disease - but did the europeans face any american disease their immune systems couldnt cope with? And if so, why didnt they all die like the natives?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

How "English" was the American Revolution?

Aside from the more obvious associations with english writings like that of John Locke and Thomas Paine, I've seen 18th century woodcuts connecting Magna Carta to the contemporary grievances of the American war. The language used by English radical groups like the Levellers and the Diggers seem strongly related to the rhetoric of revolutionary american politics. I've even seen connections made to the 1381 revolt and the legal reforms of Alfred the Great.

How far was the American War of Independence and Revolution a continuation of (actualisation, even?) of a tradition of English dissidence and radicalism?

2 Answers 2019-07-04

In September 1992, Nine Network aired Australia's Naughtiest Home Videos, a programme so apparently objectionable that it was pulled off the air 24 minutes into its 60 minute run. Why was it ever made in the first place, and why was the plug pulled after they'd already made it?

2 Answers 2019-07-04

Before photographs, were Presidents and other celebrities recognized when out in public?

While watching the John Adams miniseries, I noticed that he did things that would be unthinkable to Presidents today, such as stumbling around a dirty slum with no security protection. Wouldn't somebody notice and say "Hey, that's the President! Let's mug him!" or something?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

How does the king communicate orders to his army, in the medieval times?

I'm writing a story and I would like to know how does the King pass on orders to his army. I want to walk readers through the process along which the King's orders leave his mouth and reach the ears of the soldiers who would be actually carrying over the order. How does this order pass through and finally get executed?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Source about the Declaration of Independence

I just read the entire Declaration of Independence (for the first) and realized that I have no idea what most of the complaints are about. E.g.,

He has plundered our seas, ravaged our coasts, burnt our towns, and destroyed the lives of our people.

I have not heard any stories of seas getting plundered by the Crown or towns getting burned.

Is there a good book that goes through each claim and details what motivated it?

Looking at the book list "The Constitutional Origins of the American Revolution" is somewhat close, but its Table of Contents is off.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

What were the major differences between the Parthians and the Persians during the time period of the Roman Empire?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

What were the major differences between the Persian Empire and the Sassanid Empire?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

At what point did civil war seem inevitable to Americans in the 1800s?

As in, when was such a state reached where people acknowledged that only a spark was needed to ignite an inevitable war?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Fur Traders Hauling Keel Boats on Land

Had a question about the fur traders hauling keelboats on land as seen in movies and books. Why and when did they do this? How far could they be traveling on land like this?

Really appreciate it.

1 Answers 2019-07-04

What exactly was the "salt meat" given to sailors before the 1900's?

Every time there is a question about sailors' diets one of the food items noted is always "salt meat" without much elaboration. I've never heard someone use that term outside of these questions, and when I google it none of the meat products listed are things that seem like they would survive long without refrigeration.

What exactly is salt meat? How long would last? Is there an equivalent product to it that is still available?

1 Answers 2019-07-04

Why did the Mali empire, being one of the, if not the richest empire of its time use mud for so many of its constructions?

So I have become interested in the history of the Mali empire, and know little about it. I was surprised learning that it was one of the richest empires in history, yet had many buildings made with mud, although it also had buildings made with stone and other materials.

Without much knowledge these are the potential explanations I came up with:

  1. Heat: Stone and even wood probably are good at retaining heat, which in an equatorial region could make living quarters an oven without some additional engineering. On the other hand, mud allowed for better heat transmission from the inside towards the outside, making mud a more desirable material for building.
  2. Unnavailability of materials: Maybe wood and stone were not abundant in the region and were a hassle to transport. Why bother moving tonnes of stone when you have a perfectly good and maleable construction material right next to you.
  3. Lack of military incentive to use stone and other sturdier materials: In europe, it was usually just town walls and castles that were made of stone (with the exception of cathedrals), because they served a military purpose. The rest of the constructions (houses, storage...) where often made of a combination of other materials like cow dung, timber, mud... Depending on the military situation of the Mali empire (number of enemies and whatnot) there would have been little economic incentive to build constructions in stone over mud.
  4. Religious/cultural: Maybe they liked the way mud looks more than other materials, kind of like "Our father's and the father's of our father's built this way and we are not here to break traditions".
  5. I am actually uniformed about the prevalence of mud based architecture in the Mali empire and as a matter of fact each construction was made of solid gold and the Mali empire is, in fact, El Dorado.

Am I right about any of these? I would like to be educated on the subject.

2 Answers 2019-07-04

⯇ 1890 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start