What was classical-era Chinese understanding of the far west like? What sorts of knowledge/myths did they have of places west of Persia, such as Egypt, Greece, Scythia or Rome?

3 Answers 2019-05-03

Did there Armenian genocide really happen?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-05-03

How accurate is the number of deaths in the holocaust?

The number 6,000,000 typically comes to mind when thinking about the number of Jews killed in the holocaust. But with rising conspirators and holocaust deniers, how accurate is this number? Does 6,000,000 refer to all of the Jews killed both directly and indirectly from the holocaust, or just directly. Where does this number come from? How was it calculated? Is it accurate?

PS: No I am not an advocate for holocaust deniers, I just consider myself an open-minded person and like to hear both perspectives before labeling one side as 'ridiculous' or 'outrageous'. Any answers are appreciated :)

2 Answers 2019-05-03

What was at the location of "al Aqsa" mosque during Mohammed's lifetime?

The Qur'an (17:1) states that Allah took his servant to the al aqsa mosque over a single night. Muslims take this servant to be Mohammed.

However, to me at least, it's odd to imagine a "mosque' being at the location before Islam. My understanding is that the Temple was destroyed much earlier and attempts by people like Julian to rebuild it failed. But that's where my shallow knowledge bottoms out.

So, what was at the location at Al Aqsa and what were the Muslims referring to? Was there some sort of Jewish temple there (assuming that Muslims at the time felt enough kinship with Jews to consider it a "mosque")? Do we have any records on this? What happened to said temple ?

1 Answers 2019-05-03

Amateur Historians vs. Professional Historians

There seems to be an opinion in the historical fields that there is a divide, or snobbery between Academic historians (those that hold university degrees), and “amateurs” who don’t, and are just enthusiastic.

Is there any evidence of this (e.g. a written paper)? I cannot seem to locate any sources from either side of this supposed argument.

2 Answers 2019-05-03

Was Hitler openly anti-semitic in public speeches before gaining power?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

You often hear that the ancient Egyptians brewed beer. Any accounts of what it may have tasted like, or how it was made?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

What did people do before modern medicine when they tore a major ligament such as an ACL or Achilles tendon? Was life over or did they attempt a rudimentary fix?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Do present day latin americans have iberian jewish and morish ancestry?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Why didn't Germany experience a culture and ethnic clash following the fall of the Berlin wall, following decades of isolation and political influence from both superpowers?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Holocaust Whataboutism

There seems to be a trend these days of other groups showing their history in the Holocaust and how their group was persecuted.

While these events are also horrible and inexcusable it has come to a point where if the Holocaust is brought up it turns into a sort of whataboutism.

Some examples from my life recently, a Jehovah's Witness, trying to come into my house and preach to me, in an attempt at solidarity I assume tells me "Well you know Jehovah's Witnesses were locked up as well", and again this is true some 2,500-5,000 were put in camps died mainly for resisting Nazi authority, and resisting national army service.

A co-worker told me when I mentioned that this day was coming up, that "Catholics were killed too". Again this is true, there was persecution of Catholics and the attempt to eliminate Christianity overall by Hitler.

The large one that gets brought up, especially online, is the persecution of LBTQAI members under the Nazis, and yes again there were some 50,000 overall convicted with 5,000-15,000 of those going into work camps with an unknown number killed.

There are is also the History of the Poles and Slavic Peoples, which others have brought up.

What I would like to know is then, why was it different for the Jews. I know for example that anyone with one Jewish grandparent was taken to the death camps; and the even church registers were looked at for Jews that had converted to Christianity, as the predominant form of Anti-Semitism then was racial against Jews.

But I have a hard time explaining other than those few examples why it was different, or maybe I'm wrong and it wasn't different at all. While I find many items in the FAQ related to the Holocaust I don't see this question addressed specifically.

Thanks, Ummmbacon

1 Answers 2019-05-02

How, if at all, did contact with the West influence 19th and 20th century historiography in East Asia (esp. Qing and post-Revolution China, Japan)? What independent schools of formal historical study existed in these places before extensive Western contact? And are they still relevant today?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

I'm a young Scottish solider riled up by the independence wars and am ready to leave my village and join Robert the Bruce. What can I expect?

For example:

What to expect at Bannockburn? What would life for me be like? How would we fight against the known superior English army?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

How did the assassination of JFK influence more conspiracy and change how Americans viewed events?

I am currently writing a paper on how the JFK assassination changed American culture, but I am having a hard time finding reliable sources that show either an increase of conspiracies, or how it directly affects current events. If you could leave sources or information/life experience, I'd really appreciate it!

1 Answers 2019-05-02

what ethnicities were aztecs? are there people who can track down their family down to aztec empire and pre-discovery of america?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Is a flat helmet or a pointed helmet better for representing the crusades?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

A famous medieval knight called Bertrand du Guesclin was ransomed for 100,000 Francs. What could you buy in 14th-century France for 100,000 francs? And was it considered to be a large ransom or quite the opposite?

I'm reading the chronicles by Froissart and there's this bit about a ransom that confuses me. It's not immediately clear for me whether or not the ransom was high or rather too low but politically inopportune. Because both the Prince of Wales as well as his counsel regret the decision to ransom the knight for 100,000 Francs (or rather, regret ransoming him at all - since he would raise 2000 men at arms). Also, it took Bertrand a month to raise the money from the King of France and the Duke of Anjou. Would this be a long period or were they amazed at how fast his ransom was paid?

The text is kind of ambiguous.

So, what could you buy in 14th-century France for 100,000 francs, the ransom of Betrand du Guesclin? Was it considered large for a ransom? If so, how did the French during the Hundred Years' War pay a large ransom like that?

2 Answers 2019-05-02

What was Italian food like before tomatoes were brought from South America?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

What did Gorbachev hope to achieve through his Glasnost reforms?

I'm currently studying New Thinking in Soviet Foreign Policy and can't quite place the primary motivation for Glasnost?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

For Holocaust Remberrance Day Can someone Help Me Explain Why Jews Were Different Than Other Groups

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Pre-Bronze age Greek religion; why did Robert Graves speak of Pelasgians?

For extra context, I'm a fan of the Iliad and the Olympians gods and recently looked into Robert Graves' "The Greek Myths," which I understand is widely recommended. I was fascinated by his introduction in which he speaks of the native peoples before the Mycenaeans. A people he calls the Pelasgians who worshipped the "Mother Goddess." He goes into some detail about how she was a trinity, even multiple trinities. Nymph, maiden, and crone, or spring, summer, and winter. She was linked with the moon phase due to the female period having a similar time frame and that she led a matriarchal society over all early Greece.

What's more, Graves goes on to suppose that Ionians, Dorians, Acheans (I may forget the particular tribe but I believe he mentions at least three) arrived from the north in waves and slowly influenced the existing matriarchal religion with their patriarchal Olympians. Perseus and the Gorgon, Hercules vs the Amazons, Zeus vs Hera: all subtle clues to the shift in power as the cultures battled.

He's very compelling, especially in his historical fiction where he presents characters living during the culture clash (Hercules My Shipmate, 1944). Mary Renault's "The King Must Die" (1958) also had Theseus living amongst Pelasgian style religion.

I'm told there's little in the way of evidence for much of these ideas. So, long story short, where did they come from?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

In feudal Europe and the Middle Ages, Jews were generally prohibited from owning weapons and armor. Where were the exceptions and when?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

What are the origins of gun sizing measurements? Such as caliber, inch, etc?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-05-02

How long did English resistance to the Normans last following the Battle of Hastings, and what forms did it take?

As a follow-up, was there any form of resistance that lasted past the 1070s?

1 Answers 2019-05-02

Classics or History?

Hello, I'm a new member here. I was wondering if any of you could advice me about whether I should take Classics or History. I'm interested in Ancient History mainly like Ancient Greece to Rome, mythology etc., not the whole of it. Please help me out! :)

1 Answers 2019-05-02

⯇ 1987 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start