What was the Roman conceptualization of nationhood? Was Rome the nation and the empire its subjugated allies? Or was the empire a holistic entity on its own? Or was it something else entirely?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Considering the numerous and very brutal aztec sacrifices done on top of their pyramids, how did they prevent or deal with the massive infections and diseases caused by so much blood drained through the city and into the surrounding lake Texcoco, considering 200k inhabitants?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Did European ball and chain flails actually exist in premodern china?

i read this blog about ming dynasty weapons which begged this question as agricultural flails were used all throughout Eurasia (in africa, i do not know). baed on my knowledge of weaponry, ball and chain flails from asia only existed in india via the kabasteen and binnol

​

the blog http://greatmingmilitary.blogspot.com/2016/04/flails-of-ming-dynasty.html

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Why has Israel seen a increase in GDP per capita much higher than the surrounding nations (especially during the years 1970 - 1990)?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Why are the faces of many people in medieval art seemingly expressionless and disinterested even while being killed?

This seems to have been a very common trend among the artists of the day.

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Did the Huns actually practice ritual cranial deformation or is this a lie spread by their enemies?

If true, what did it look like and did it cause any psychological issues?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Professional opinions on Nicholas “The_Chieftan” Moran

I’ve been developing my own knowledge in more contemporary military theory and one individual I’ve been enjoying is Nicholas Moran, an advisor for the video game “World of Tanks”. He’s done many videos for them on tanks and has his own YT channel. From watching him, he seems to know his stuff, speaks frequently about information from archival sources, emphasizes how video games and history never match up, and dismisses his own personal experience as a tank commander as a source.

What is the professional view of him? I’ve seen him give many presentations connected to historical groups (Tankfest with the Bovington Tank Museum is rather frequent) and this video on the developmental history of the M4 Sherman that aired on CSPAN. He seems to be professional; acts likes a professional, sounds like a professional, but is he considered one?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Did the Romans apply for jobs (such as working at a thermopolium) or were they more family-owned/family-ran businesses?

2 Answers 2019-04-15

I’ve been told from Christian religious leaders that when Muhammad(peace be upon him) had his first revelation he believed he was possessed by a demon. Are there any historical documents to support this assertion or is this simply Christian propaganda?

I’m an agnostic theist, formerly baptist but my girlfriend is Muslim. I want to understand her faith and learn about it objectively.

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Why did the Military stop using Pineapple-like Grenades in favor of smooth ones?

1 Answers 2019-04-15

Wars based upon opposing buddhist beliefs?

Have wars been caused by, or sustained by, opposing Buddhist beliefs or sects? We see religious based wars being fought in the western world but I'm wondering if this happens within a non-violent belief system like Buddhism.

Are there more non-violent Buddhist traditions when compared to others? (A scale or range of non-violence according to the school) Can I assume that zen, and perhaps pureland, is the most "non violent" traditions because of their emphasis on individualized practices and enlightenment processes?

Edit: spelling and clarity

2 Answers 2019-04-15

How did people cut their toe nails before nail clippers?

Fingernails yeah you can just bite off but toe nails...

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Why was it Ancient Rome that adopted the first ever recorded case of democracy?

So from what I heard, Ancient Rome / The Roman Republic:

  • Had a system of election for their leaders
  • Gave the vote to both patricians and plebians (upper and lower class)
  • Managed to get this to work for hundreds of years.

There may be no specific reason that it was the Romans in particular but I was just wondering if there was something that caused it

1 Answers 2019-04-14

What is the connection between Galicia in Spain and the former Galician Kingdom in modern Poland/Ukraine? Do either have any connections to Gaelic heritage?

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Are there really an uncommon number of similarities/overlaps between Hindu and Greek Mythology as we know it today? If so, is there any any historical reason for this?

Here's some from a quick google search:

  • Three main Gods (though their roles are different).
  • Krishna and Achilles being vulnerable at the heel.
  • Indra = Zeus, with lightning and stories of their romantic conquests.
  • Manmadha = Cupid
  • Hades = Yama

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Did your typical medieval peasant own his own oxen/horse to drive his plow or did they have to rent animals for the work?

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Why didn't the Middle east adopt plate armour?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Were there ever any attempt by the Romans to bury the remains of the people of Pompeii?

Would they even have been able to? Was there a "humanitarian" aid program for survivors?

1 Answers 2019-04-14

How do historians make sense of hitler's vegetarianism and animal rights policies?

I am a vegetarian and despite recognition that one must be very careful not to trivialise the holocaust and sensitive to the subject in general, came to the conclusion some time ago that there is some comparison to be drawn between the systematic murder of 56 billion animals (annually) and those who were murdered in the holocaust (I understand that is controversial but at least note that I said 'some' not 'a direct')

This is why it came as such a surprise to learn about hitlers policy regarding animal rights. According to wikipedia, hitler was a strong antivivisectionist and later on a vegetarian. Also "In his private diaries, Nazi Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels described Hitler as a vegetarian whose hatred of the Jewish and Christian religions in large part stemmed from the ethical distinction these faiths drew between the value of humans and the value of other animals; Goebbels also mentions that Hitler planned to ban slaughterhouses in the German Reich following the conclusion of World War II". The nazi party proposed an all out ban on vivisection in 1931 which was voted down - clearly this was not simply a popular sentiment which the nazis adopted as populists.

How do historians make sense of this? was there any acknowledgement by nazi leaders of the hypocrisy of at once supporting the innate value of animal life and the subjugation and eventual murder of the jews? What is the basis in nazi ideology for these seemingly conflicting ideas

Thank you

2 Answers 2019-04-14

Request for help identifying WW2 German tracked vehicle

I recently saw a restored model of a WW2 German tracked vehicle but was not able to identify it. It was about the size of the Kubelwagon but entirely track driven. It most closely resembles the Kettenkrad from what I have seen but did not have the front wheel. It was only armed with a MG in front and had bench seating in the back, enough to carry 1 or 2 people and was entirely open topped. I'm curious if anyone knows the vehicle and if so, what its purpose was during the war.

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Would the study of Caveman paintings be considered as History?

Or would it still be Pre-History?

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Why aren't America and Canada always invading each other like everyone else does?

The last war the US and Canada had was over 200 years ago. But then two countries like France and Germany have been at war 4 times in the same period.

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Everyone’s seen the famous Soviet anti-alcoholism posters. Were these campaigns successful? How did the Soviet Union deal with excess drinking? Did any govt. measures actually help reduce the consumption of hard alcohol and its consequences?

1 Answers 2019-04-14

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | April 08, 2019–April 14, 2019

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2019-04-14

In British public schools, the Empire’s suppression of the slave trade is taught as essentially the greatest act of magnanimity in world history. Did the Empire have some kind of material interest in stopping the slave trade?

2 Answers 2019-04-14

⯇ 2016 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start